New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

for rational humans

IN the rancorous debate over how to get the sluggish economy moving, we have forgotten the wisdom of Henry Ford. In 1914, not long after the Ford Motor Company came out with the Model T, Ford made the startling announcement that he would pay his workers the unheard-of wage of $5 a day.
Not only was it a matter of social justice, Ford wrote, but paying high wages was also smart business. When wages are low, uncertainty dogs the marketplace and growth is weak. But when pay is high and steady, Ford asserted, business is more secure because workers earn enough to become good customers. They can afford to buy Model Ts.

This is not to suggest that Ford single-handedly created the American middle class. But he was one of the first business leaders to articulate what economists call “the virtuous circle of growth”: well-paid workers generating consumer demand that in turn promotes business expansion and hiring. Other executives bought his logic, and just as important, strong unions fought for rising pay and good benefits in contracts like the 1950 “Treaty of Detroit” between General Motors and the United Auto Workers.
Riding the dynamics of the virtuous circle, America enjoyed its best period of sustained growth in the decades after World War II, from 1945 to 1973, even though income tax rates were far higher than today. It created not only unprecedented middle-class prosperity but also far greater economic equality than today.

The chief executives of the long postwar boom believed that business success and workers’ well-being ran in tandem.
Frank W. Abrams, chairman of Standard Oil of New Jersey, voiced the corporate mantra of “stakeholder capitalism”: the need to balance the interests of all the stakeholders in the corporate family. “The job of management,” he wrote, “is to maintain an equitable and working balance among the claims of the various directly affected interest groups,” which he defined as “stockholders, employees, customers and the public at large.”

Earl S. Willis, a manager of employee benefits at General Electric, declared that “the employee who can plan his economic future with reasonable certainty is an employer’s most productive asset.”
From 1948 to 1973, the productivity of all nonfarm workers nearly doubled, as did average hourly compensation. But things changed dramatically starting in the late 1970s. Although productivity increased by 80.1 percent from 1973 to 2011, average wages rose only 4.2 percent and hourly compensation (wages plus benefits) rose only 10 percent over that time, according to government data analyzed by the Economic Policy Institute.

At the same time, corporate profits were booming. In 2006, the year before the Great Recession began, corporate profits garnered the largest share of national income since 1942, while the share going to wages and salaries sank to the lowest level since 1929. In the recession’s aftermath, corporate profits have bounced back while middle-class incomes have stagnated.

Today the prevailing cut-to-the-bone business ethos means that a company like Caterpillar demands a wage freeze and lower health benefits from its workers, while posting record profits.

Globalization, including the rise of Asia, and technological innovation can’t explain all or even most of today’s gaping inequality; if they did, we would see in other advanced economies the same hyperconcentration of wealth and the same stagnation of middle-class wages as in the United States. But we don’t.

In Germany, still a manufacturing and export powerhouse, average hourly pay has risen five times faster since 1985 than in the United States. The secret of Germany’s success, says Klaus Kleinfeld, who ran the German electrical giant Siemens before taking over the American aluminum company Alcoa in 2008, is “the social contract: the willingness of business, labor and political leaders to put aside some of their differences and make agreements in the national interests.”

In short, German leaders have practiced stakeholder capitalism and followed the century-old wisdom of Henry Ford, while American business and political leaders have dismantled the dynamics of the “virtuous circle” in pursuit of downsizing, offshoring and short-term profit and big dividends for their investors.

Today, we are all paying the price for this shift. As Ford recognized, if average Americans do not have secure jobs with steady and rising pay, the economy will be sluggish. Since the early 1990s, we have been mired three times in “jobless recoveries.” It’s time for America’s business elites to step beyond political rhetoric about protecting wealthy “job creators” and grasp Ford’s insight: Give the middle class a better share of the nation’s economic gains, and the economy will grow faster. Our history shows that.





Hedrick Smith, a former correspondent and Washington bureau chief of The New York Times, is the author of “Who Stole the American Dream?”
 
Henry Ford was a SOCIALIST!! :D

Great piece Yuri, we need to read more like it, and Wouldn't it be Nice if DNC could create a bit for their big show featuring Henry's obviously successful concept of expanding the middle class?

[video=youtube;h6jOMn_KPCU]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6jOMn_KPCU[/video]
 
Henry Ford was a SOCIALIST!! :D

Great piece Yuri, we need to read more like it, and Wouldn't it be Nice if DNC could create a bit for their big show featuring Henry's obviously successful concept of expanding the middle class?

[video=youtube;h6jOMn_KPCU]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6jOMn_KPCU[/video]

the thing, Bo, you are not going to change gone and lost to humanity mao-like brains, but there are still quite a few people around on the fence and who are not familiar with history and actual facts
 
the thing, Bo, you are not going to change gone and lost to humanity mao-like brains, but there are still quite a few people around on the fence and who are not familiar with history and actual facts

True True.. and Bumpety Bump ;-)
 
Every once in a while someone writes a post that deserves to be bumped... consider this a five star bump.
 
IN the rancorous debate over how to get the sluggish economy moving, we have forgotten the wisdom of Henry Ford. In 1914, not long after the Ford Motor Company came out with the Model T, Ford made the startling announcement that he would pay his workers the unheard-of wage of $5 a day.
Not only was it a matter of social justice, Ford wrote, but paying high wages was also smart business. When wages are low, uncertainty dogs the marketplace and growth is weak. But when pay is high and steady, Ford asserted, business is more secure because workers earn enough to become good customers. They can afford to buy Model Ts.

This is not to suggest that Ford single-handedly created the American middle class. But he was one of the first business leaders to articulate what economists call “the virtuous circle of growth”: well-paid workers generating consumer demand that in turn promotes business expansion and hiring. Other executives bought his logic, and just as important, strong unions fought for rising pay and good benefits in contracts like the 1950 “Treaty of Detroit” between General Motors and the United Auto Workers.
Riding the dynamics of the virtuous circle, America enjoyed its best period of sustained growth in the decades after World War II, from 1945 to 1973, even though income tax rates were far higher than today. It created not only unprecedented middle-class prosperity but also far greater economic equality than today.

The chief executives of the long postwar boom believed that business success and workers’ well-being ran in tandem.
Frank W. Abrams, chairman of Standard Oil of New Jersey, voiced the corporate mantra of “stakeholder capitalism”: the need to balance the interests of all the stakeholders in the corporate family. “The job of management,” he wrote, “is to maintain an equitable and working balance among the claims of the various directly affected interest groups,” which he defined as “stockholders, employees, customers and the public at large.”

Earl S. Willis, a manager of employee benefits at General Electric, declared that “the employee who can plan his economic future with reasonable certainty is an employer’s most productive asset.”
From 1948 to 1973, the productivity of all nonfarm workers nearly doubled, as did average hourly compensation. But things changed dramatically starting in the late 1970s. Although productivity increased by 80.1 percent from 1973 to 2011, average wages rose only 4.2 percent and hourly compensation (wages plus benefits) rose only 10 percent over that time, according to government data analyzed by the Economic Policy Institute.

At the same time, corporate profits were booming. In 2006, the year before the Great Recession began, corporate profits garnered the largest share of national income since 1942, while the share going to wages and salaries sank to the lowest level since 1929. In the recession’s aftermath, corporate profits have bounced back while middle-class incomes have stagnated.

Today the prevailing cut-to-the-bone business ethos means that a company like Caterpillar demands a wage freeze and lower health benefits from its workers, while posting record profits.

Globalization, including the rise of Asia, and technological innovation can’t explain all or even most of today’s gaping inequality; if they did, we would see in other advanced economies the same hyperconcentration of wealth and the same stagnation of middle-class wages as in the United States. But we don’t.

In Germany, still a manufacturing and export powerhouse, average hourly pay has risen five times faster since 1985 than in the United States. The secret of Germany’s success, says Klaus Kleinfeld, who ran the German electrical giant Siemens before taking over the American aluminum company Alcoa in 2008, is “the social contract: the willingness of business, labor and political leaders to put aside some of their differences and make agreements in the national interests.”

In short, German leaders have practiced stakeholder capitalism and followed the century-old wisdom of Henry Ford, while American business and political leaders have dismantled the dynamics of the “virtuous circle” in pursuit of downsizing, offshoring and short-term profit and big dividends for their investors.

Today, we are all paying the price for this shift. As Ford recognized, if average Americans do not have secure jobs with steady and rising pay, the economy will be sluggish. Since the early 1990s, we have been mired three times in “jobless recoveries.” It’s time for America’s business elites to step beyond political rhetoric about protecting wealthy “job creators” and grasp Ford’s insight: Give the middle class a better share of the nation’s economic gains, and the economy will grow faster. Our history shows that.





Hedrick Smith, a former correspondent and Washington bureau chief of The New York Times, is the author of “Who Stole the American Dream?”

It's interesting that posts of this type generate few responses. But bring up a short phrase from a 45 minute speech and the place goes bananas.

Tom Peters was a management guru for a short period. Based on the TQM system, he considered the receptionist one of the most important people in the company. The first contact set the tone. Do we even have receptionists anymore?
 
It remains to be seen what would have happened if Ford had the opportunity for reliable off-shore manufacturing. That wasn't an issue in American 100 years ago when Ford offered that $5 per hour, a scale his parts suppliers and other resources didn't match at the time. At that time, America WAS the reliable off-shore manufacturing giant, and England was the world-power running mostly on momentum.

You figure yout how to get those jobs back on shore, and then we can talk about what to pay for the people doing them.
 
It remains to be seen what would have happened if Ford had the opportunity for reliable off-shore manufacturing. That wasn't an issue in American 100 years ago when Ford offered that $5 per hour, a scale his parts suppliers and other resources didn't match at the time. At that time, America WAS the reliable off-shore manufacturing giant, and England was the world-power running mostly on momentum.

You figure yout how to get those jobs back on shore, and then we can talk about what to pay for the people doing them.

did you miss the part about Germany? Nowadays, not 100 years ago...
 
did you miss the part about Germany? Nowadays, not 100 years ago...

I didn't miss it, I merely think it's irrelevant. We have a universe of democratic-socialist republics we can look at in Europe as examples, and Germany is the only one that stands out as any kind of success story. France, Spain, Italy and England are all practicing austerity plans because they are unable to support the benefits they've paid out over the past 60 years. Prior to the advent of the Euro, they all had a means of dealing with this problem -- they could inflate their way out of debt. After more than a decade of the euro, which takes the currency out of the hands of the politicians of Europe, the issues have finally become to obvious to ignore. The system of cradle-to-grave benefits that worked for the second half of the 20th century in Europe has become too expensive to support. The fact that Germany is a counter example means little, given that it is basically the sole counter example.
 
I didn't miss it, I merely think it's irrelevant. We have a universe of democratic-socialist republics we can look at in Europe as examples, and Germany is the only one that stands out as any kind of success story. France, Spain, Italy and England are all practicing austerity plans because they are unable to support the benefits they've paid out over the past 60 years

First off you are factually wrong on the "austerity plans".... Particularly now that Hollande is President of The Republic.

Secondly the UK was perfectly ABLE to support its benefits - but CHOSE not to... and it created a double dip recession that is doing more harm than good to the economy.

Thirdly, Spain and Italy are VERY VERY different economies than France and/or Germany. And alot of it has to do with fairly endemic corruption and tax avoidance

And its not just Germany that outperformed the USA's GDP growth, it is Finland, Norway, Denmark to name a few. IN fact the USA mirrored the growth rate of the only EU country to match its low tax rate: Switzerland. with an ANEMIC 2.6% GDP growth rate.

http://www.tradingeconomics.com/

Inconvenient facts (btw they are Social Democracies, not "socialist" democracies)...
 
In Winger World, all of the European Democracies have to be demonized, they all have universal health care, a much wider safety net and much better GINI scores, so they must be evil to a Rand Cultist. And they absolutely refuse to ever acknowledge the better growth rate of Germany over the US in the last decade with a much more progresssive tax rate, its all about the 1% to these ideologues.
 
In Winger World, all of the European Democracies have to be demonized, they all have universal health care, a much wider safety net and much better GINI scores, so they must be evil to a Rand Cultist. And they absolutely refuse to ever acknowledge the better growth rate of Germany over the US in the last decade with a much more progresssive tax rate, its all about the 1% to these ideologues.
Funny, OG, when they want to criticize Obama they say that he wants Europe here, what that's even supposed to mean? they use "Europe" as a four letter word.
On the other hand most of Europe embraced cons' voodoo ideas about austerity in the times of crisis and look where this landed some of them....
 
First off you are factually wrong on the "austerity plans".... Particularly now that Hollande is President of The Republic.

Hollande hasn't been in office very long -- and it remains to be seen if he can afford to pay for his promises. What is clear is that over the entire time of the Sarkozy presidency, France cut back on programs because it couldn't afford all that it had offered in the past.

Secondly the UK was perfectly ABLE to support its benefits - but CHOSE not to... and it created a double dip recession that is doing more harm than good to the economy.

No, Degs, if the UK had been able to support its programs, which were popular with its public, it wouldn't have had to cut back on them. And attributing the double dip recession there to the cutbacks rather than to other factors, is merely an opinion of some economists -- and yes, I can provide data from others who don't agree.
Thirdly, Spain and Italy are VERY VERY different economies than France and/or Germany. And alot of it has to do with fairly endemic corruption and tax avoidance

Sorry, the idea that you can cross an imaginary line near San Sebastian and all of a sudden you're in a nation of thieves and tax avoiders is just your way of denying that Spain (and Italy) have exactly the problem I ascribed to them. They can't afford their programs. It doesn't matter if this is because of the expense of the programs or because they have successful tax evasion -- at the end of the day, they can't afford them.

And its not just Germany that outperformed the USA's GDP growth, it is Finland, Norway, Denmark to name a few. IN fact the USA mirrored the growth rate of the only EU country to match its low tax rate: Switzerland. with an ANEMIC 2.6% GDP growth rate.

And none of those are as large as the U.S. nor do they deal with the complexities the U.S. must face in terms of issues as diverse as population, demographics, or foreign policy. When I see Finland or Norway occupy a place on the world stage as significant as that of the U.S., you're argument will carry some weight -- until them, I merely see them as benefiting from having lived under an umbrella provided by NATO that they scarcely supported financially at all. And that's setting aside that these countries have tax levels that simply wouldn't be political realities in the United States.



(btw they are Social Democracies, not "socialist" democracies)...

Give me a break, Degs, surely you know that's what I meant to type.
 
Hollande hasn't been in office very long -- and it remains to be seen if he can afford to pay for his promises. What is clear is that over the entire time of the Sarkozy presidency, France cut back on programs because it couldn't afford all that it had offered in the past.
No France did not cut back on its programs because it could not afford them. Your ignorance of EuroPolitics is broad. Sarkozy was looking to stimulate GROWTH... And like the USA, France has to rejigger retirement because people are living longer.

That's not a case of not affording existing policies per se - rather that the circumstances have changed and thus policies need to be adjusted.

No, Degs, if the UK had been able to support its programs, which were popular with its public, it wouldn't have had to cut back on them.
Simply not true. UK had a similar campaign by conservatives overblowing the issue of Debt - and the public got distracted by it. And the double dip recession was caused by that cutback.. and its not "merely the opinionn of some economists". In fact its the opinion of pretty much ALL economists other than the Von Mises wackadoodles who's own claims are internally inconsistent. Please do show other credible economists that say otherwise.

Sorry, the idea that you can cross an imaginary line near San Sebastian and all of a sudden you're in a nation of thieves and tax avoiders is just your way of denying that Spain (and Italy) have exactly the problem I ascribed to them. They can't afford their programs. It doesn't matter if this is because of the expense of the programs or because they have successful tax evasion -- at the end of the day, they can't afford them.
Oh it matters a lot. Because you EXTRAPOLATE from the Italian and Spanish experience to the USA. Furthermore unlike the USA, the Italian and Spanish economies are being held to account by the German, French and other northern Euro economies. Kinda like Alabama vs. MA or EasternWa vs. Puget Sound basin. And in such cases you do see economic dislocation.

That Italy and Spain are thus constrained is what makes their programs unaffordable in light of their corruption levels. Not the levels of the programs themselves. Yet that is the implication you take away. And its not a valid takeaway.


As for the complexities of the US in terms of population diversity - well then OK the whole of the EuroZone economics does not apply, neither Italy Greece nor Germay and Finland. See you are cherry picking your data here. The reality is that being the World Stage Currency actually MAKES IT EASIER for the USA rather than harder. And the Macro Economics that affect growth is the same in nothern, Southern Europe as well as North America.

And you can look to the differences in policies, and you can see a correlation. But its not the one you WANT to see. After all, if we were to take your logic to its consistent conclusion than Germany should never have been able to outgrow the USA in the "aughts" - after all Germany's tax rate was higher, its debt rate was higher, its labor costs were higher - and yet it OUTPERFORMED the USA by 35%.

Similarly Canada should not have been able to grow on par with the USA, and when the US housing bubble crashed, Canada's should have as well. And yet NONE of that took place.

Now what IS CONSISTENT across these outperforming economies as well as the underperforming ones is that in Canada, Germany and even France, TAX CODES make it advantageous to REINVEST IN THE COMPANY. IN places like the USA, Switzerland, Italy and Spain, THE OPPOSITE is true. Tax Codes make it advantageous to take out profits and not reinvest.

Tax codes ALSO are more closely tied to Marginal Utility of Income. Thus the least efficient segnments of the economy (the private income of the wealthy) are taxed at higher marginal rates than more efficient segments (private income of middle class and poor)

Similarly in places like Canada, and Germany - HIGHER REGULATIONS ON BANKS - reduce the kind of speculative nonsense that caused and amplified the crash.

Similarly universal healthcare, and higher labor protections AND MORE PROGRESSIVE tax rates, grow the middle class. And it is MIDDLE CLASS retirement investments that drive economic growth investment (CALPERS: 1 retirement plan, in one industry in one state, has more invested in "job creation" than the 10 wealthiest Americans COMBINED).

This is just fairly basic Macro Econ. Nothing that dramatically stunning.



And none of those are as large as the U.S. nor do they deal with the complexities the U.S. must face in terms of issues as diverse as population, demographics, or foreign policy. When I see Finland or Norway occupy a place on the world stage as significant as that of the U.S., you're argument will carry some weight -- until them, I merely see them as benefiting from having lived under an umbrella provided by NATO that they scarcely supported financially at all. And that's setting aside that these countries have tax levels that simply wouldn't be political realities in the United States.



Give me a break, Degs, surely you know that's what I meant to type.
Honestly I don't. Given how you describe so much of this in terms so close to the GOP talking points which include the boogeyman of "socialism".

But if you say so I'll take your word for it.
 
Back
Top