New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Free College

Arkady

President
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.
 
Germany is not the only country in Europe where higher education is free. Finland and Czech Republic are among those who are capable of providing education for everyone, including foreign students. And those are not really big or rich countries. Why can they and why can't we?
I don't know, I don't even have a theory. But I really like the saying I heard in some TV show: Knowledge should not be for sale. It has something in it, doesn't it?
 
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.

How is it free? The professors and staff are all volunteers? A kindly old benefactor is paying all the costs of keeping the campus running?

Lefty pipedreams are always amusing...LOL
 
Knowledge IS free.. you can go the library and learn anything.

The problem is, our society has set a standard of college degrees, not by ability. That would be fine if you were allowed to test out of anything in college, but you can't. You have to appease middle management by wasting tens of thousands of dollars at colleges even if you can already perform the job adequately.
 
How is it free? The professors and staff are all volunteers? A kindly old benefactor is paying all the costs of keeping the campus running?

Lefty pipedreams are always amusing...LOL
It's free to the student. It's free in the same sense that, in the US, public high school is free. Of course it cost something, but, like with public high school, the taxpayer covers it rather than the student, and the overall cost per student is relatively low.
 
It's free to the student. It's free in the same sense that, in the US, public high school is free. Of course it cost something, but, like with public high school, the taxpayer covers it rather than the student, and the overall cost per student is relatively low.

It would be great to have college costs so low.

However, I've never thought college is for everybody. These days, college is largely pointless to many who take classes. The critique of a lack of real-world skills for many college majors and degrees is a legimate one IMO, seeing that so many people who enter the workforce with degrees aren't hired in their fields.

  • Only 46 percent of 2012 and 2013 grads report that they have found work in their chosen field.
  • Thirteen percent of those 2012 and 2013 graduates have been unemployed since graduation.
http://www.uticaod.com/article/20140715/News/140719763#ixzz3G3F0glFH

130624112813-grad-jobs-degrees-620xa.png



The secret is out on College. It's becoming it's own monster. Inefficient, untesting, inapplicable.

I'd say the right move is to not pump state money into these bloated, overfunded bodies and let them truly compete... we need to cut state funding from them, as they simply build new student centers, gyms, etc. on our dime to better market themselves.
 
It's free to the student. It's free in the same sense that, in the US, public high school is free. Of course it cost something, but, like with public high school, the taxpayer covers it rather than the student, and the overall cost per student is relatively low.

That's not free, that's just someone else paying for it.
 
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.

What a wonderful idea.
 
Knowledge IS free.. you can go the library and learn anything.

The problem is, our society has set a standard of college degrees, not by ability. That would be fine if you were allowed to test out of anything in college, but you can't. You have to appease middle management by wasting tens of thousands of dollars at colleges even if you can already perform the job adequately.

One can test-out in college:

http://clep.collegeboard.org/

you should get your degree.
 
It would be great to have college costs so low.

However, I've never thought college is for everybody. These days, college is largely pointless to many who take classes. The critique of a lack of real-world skills for many college majors and degrees is a legimate one IMO, seeing that so many people who enter the workforce with degrees aren't hired in their fields.

  • Only 46 percent of 2012 and 2013 grads report that they have found work in their chosen field.
  • Thirteen percent of those 2012 and 2013 graduates have been unemployed since graduation.
http://www.uticaod.com/article/20140715/News/140719763#ixzz3G3F0glFH

130624112813-grad-jobs-degrees-620xa.png



The secret is out on College. It's becoming it's own monster. Inefficient, untesting, inapplicable.

I'd say the right move is to not pump state money into these bloated, overfunded bodies and let them truly compete... we need to cut state funding from them, as they simply build new student centers, gyms, etc. on our dime to better market themselves.
If we cut funding to them, two things are likely to happen. One, income inequality in this country is likely to grow even greater, thereby increasing one of the major drags on our economy, and risking a whole lot of social problems. Two, we'll lose competitiveness with other wealthy nations that have better education for their people. I'd rather tie taxpayer assistance to colleges reducing the bloat, so that they cannot raise tuitions by more than a certain amount per year, in order to be eligible for government money. This would force them to focus more on academics. If it didn't work that way, there could even be a rule that required that X percent of all their budget must be devoted to the salaries of actual teaching professors. That would shift the focus to academics, and away from things like resort style amenities, and other frills that only help them market themselves.
 
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.

Yep. It's great that it's free... however.... people need to drastically change their perception of what college life IS and/or SHOULD BE:

Photo by Miguel Villagran/Getty Images

Last week, Lower Saxony made itself the final state in Germany to do away with any public university tuition whatsoever. You read that right. As of now, all state-run universities in the Federal Republic—legendary institutions that put the Bildung in Bildungsroman, like the Universität Heidelberg, the Universität München, or the Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin—cost exactly nichts. (By the way, they weren’t exactly breaking the bank before, with semester fees of about EUR 500, or $630, which is often less than an American student spends on books—but even that amount was considered “unjust” by Hamburg senator Dorothee Stapelfeldt.)

Well, you might be thinking, isn’t that just wunderbar for the damn Germans, with their excellent supermarket commercials and their spectacular beach nudity and their pragmatically dressed Chancellor. Now with their free college they’re just showing off. Well, here’s the kicker: Germany didn’t just abolish tuition for Germans. The tuition ban goes for international students, too. You heard me right, parents of Amerika: You want a real higher-education bargain? Get your kids to learn German and then pack them off to the Vaterland.

Of course, while it is both uplifting and jealousy-provoking to see our Teutonic friends put so much public investment into higher education—while we do just the opposite—there are important reasons that German universities have been either inexpensive or free for their entire existence. The German university experience isn’t worse than the American one, but there are vital cultural and infrastructural differences between our systems that bargain-hungry students (and their parents) might want to consider before bidding Auf Wiedersehen to Big State U.

First of all, the concept of “campus life” differs widely between our two countries. German universities consist almost entirely of classroom buildings and libraries—no palatial gyms with rock walls and water parks; no team sports facilities (unless you count the fencing fraternities I will never understand); no billion-dollar student unions with flat-screen TVs and first-run movie theaters. And forget the resort-style dormitories. What few dorms exist are minimalistic, to put it kindly—but that’s largely irrelevant anyway, as many German students still live at home with their parents, or in independent apartment shares, none of which foster the kind of insular, summer-camp-esque experience Americans associate closely with college life (and its hefty price tag). It’s quite common for German students simply to commute in for class, then leave.


Speaking of class: Academic life is quite a bit different over there. German students are typically accepted into particular majors—none of this “expanding your horizons” and declaring halfway through your junior year. You apply to college in Germany to study law, medicine, literature, engineering, etc.—and you take that program’s requirements, the end.

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html
 
It's free to the student. It's free in the same sense that, in the US, public high school is free. Of course it cost something, but, like with public high school, the taxpayer covers it rather than the student, and the overall cost per student is relatively low.
so it's free as long as someone pays...just not you...the liberal dream.
 
Yep. It's great that it's free... however.... people need to drastically change their perception of what college life IS and/or SHOULD BE:

Photo by Miguel Villagran/Getty Images



http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html


One has to wonder what curriculums will be cut...now that the school is free
 
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.

University and College professors (except for the sports coaches) get paid a pittance now. If there was no tuition coming in from the students, I wonder how much less they would be paid. Sure, a free college education would be great. But even now many universities are sloughing off their tenured professors for more adjuncts so that they can pay them less. If the pay for professors was even lower, even the Progressive Zealots might think twice before wasting their time teaching there.
 
University and College professors (except for the sports coaches) get paid a pittance now. If there was no tuition coming in from the students, I wonder how much less they would be paid. Sure, a free college education would be great. But even now many universities are sloughing off their tenured professors for more adjuncts so that they can pay them less. If the pay for professors was even lower, even the Progressive Zealots might think twice before wasting their time teaching there.

yeah, but while they are doing that they are plowing massive funds into "student life" and administration.

Personally, I preferred being taught by the adjuncts when I was in school versus the tenured professors. For most of the professors the subjects were just theory. It wasn't stuff they had done themselves. At least for my business classes - I liked being taught by a CPA who taught a class or two on the side. It kept it real, it kept it current, and they could make the subjects really relevant.

But, yes they aren't paid well, but at the same time the admin keeps growing and growing and growing.

connie
 
But adjuncts are paid so little that they can barely survive. My daughter doesn't think she can make a living being an adjunct, with all the driving required between colleges......... She has looked into it and it's pretty bleak.
 
But adjuncts are paid so little that they can barely survive. My daughter doesn't think she can make a living being an adjunct, with all the driving required between colleges......... She has looked into it and it's pretty bleak.

No, but then they aren't really desinged to be those types of positions. they are for working professionals. The assumption is the adjunct is also still working in the field. But, yeah they are paid ridiculously low. I have looked into it myself, and it works out to something like $15 an hour which is pathetic.
 
One of the universities I attended was the LMU in Munich. There's an article here that mentions it, in the context of German university tuition, which is now free for everyone:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat...free_there_even_for_foreign_students_why.html

When I attended the LMU, the cost was absurdly low by American standards. It cost about as much for a semester as you pay on textbooks in the US. Yet, despite that, the German students went on strike while I was there to protest a tuition increase that would've been the equivalent of buying about one extra textbook. It was the kind of tuition increase that, at a U.S. University, would Have had students celebrating in the street at getting away with an increase of only that much, yet it sparked outrage in Germany, among students who thought of any tuition for university as a social injustice. Now, Germany has made the universities completely free.

Keep in mind, with a school like the LMU, we are not talking about the equivalent of a community college, or even the state university. It is one of the best universities in Germany, and one of the best in Europe. It has educated many elite scholars, including the German pope. It's not quite a Harvard, but it is equivalent to some lower level Ivies, and superior to a large number of universities in this country that would cost you over $50,000 per year. And now it's free.

The article above gives you an idea for how Germany keeps the costs for the university so low relative to ours. Sure, some if it comes from the state paying for it, but the state doesn't pay very much at all relative to what private tuition costs here in the US. By focusing on academics rather than on an expensive health club/country club/daycare/social club setting, they can provide world-class education for a small fraction of what it costs here in the US. We could do well to focus on such things, if we want to get our student loan debt problem under control.

Mr. Arkady,

I love it when someone tries that lame line "why can't we do it like they do in Europe"? The answer is, of course, because the United States is different from Europe, demographically, culturally, and geographically.

That being said, there are a lot of good things about this. One, it appears that German institutions of higher learning don't waste money on frivalous degrees (like Woman's Studies, Gender Studies, Racial Studies, etc.), or on large campus infrastructures. Rather, it looks like German Universities concentrate on degrees with practical applications, and only contain the needed amount of class rooms, and administrative facilities.

It also looks like not everybody can go to Univeristy. Strict testing requirements keep out the riff raff, such that only those with interest in actual education attend. Another advantage is that the German education systems has trades schools for those not intelligent enough to attend college, or are more interested in the trades.

The thing that would not make it work here is that many of the US Colleges and universities are actaully full employment entities for the otherwise unemployable liberal intelligencia. Keeping with the adage "Those who can do, those who can't teach," tenured professors and administrators get huge saleries for teaching meaningless or unmarketable subjects. The cost of keeping this deadwood employed is enormous.

One of the things you overlook in your comparison is that most state run US universities are practically free anyway. You are charged by the ability to pay, not the actually cost of the program. Unless you are rather well off, most students survive on scholarships, grants, and the like, paying only a pitance of the tuition. Most of the costs they actually pay are not tuitions, but rather, the costs of housing and meal programs, and the various fees.

In the case of my home state, with the lottery scholarship, tuition is free for the first 48 consecutive months if the student graduated high school with a B average or above, and attends a state run university.

I mean, look at the example of our President. How else could a poor boy from Hawaii, son of a deadbeat dad and disinterested mom who dumped him on her parents so she could travel the world, end up attending three of the most expensive Universities in the nation.
 
Mr. Arkady,

I love it when someone tries that lame line "why can't we do it like they do in Europe"? The answer is, of course, because the United States is different from Europe, demographically, culturally, and geographically.

That being said, there are a lot of good things about this. One, it appears that German institutions of higher learning don't waste money on frivalous degrees (like Woman's Studies, Gender Studies, Racial Studies, etc.), or on large campus infrastructures. Rather, it looks like German Universities concentrate on degrees with practical applications, and only contain the needed amount of class rooms, and administrative facilities.

It also looks like not everybody can go to Univeristy. Strict testing requirements keep out the riff raff, such that only those with interest in actual education attend. Another advantage is that the German education systems has trades schools for those not intelligent enough to attend college, or are more interested in the trades.

The thing that would not make it work here is that many of the US Colleges and universities are actaully full employment entities for the otherwise unemployable liberal intelligencia. Keeping with the adage "Those who can do, those who can't teach," tenured professors and administrators get huge saleries for teaching meaningless or unmarketable subjects. The cost of keeping this deadwood employed is enormous.

One of the things you overlook in your comparison is that most state run US universities are practically free anyway. You are charged by the ability to pay, not the actually cost of the program. Unless you are rather well off, most students survive on scholarships, grants, and the like, paying only a pitance of the tuition. Most of the costs they actually pay are not tuitions, but rather, the costs of housing and meal programs, and the various fees.

In the case of my home state, with the lottery scholarship, tuition is free for the first 48 consecutive months if the student graduated high school with a B average or above, and attends a state run university.

I mean, look at the example of our President. How else could a poor boy from Hawaii, son of a deadbeat dad and disinterested mom who dumped him on her parents so she could travel the world, end up attending three of the most expensive Universities in the nation.

Excellent post, Mr. Ya-ta-hey.
 
Back
Top