New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Gated Communities

Arkady

President
On occasion, I get accused of living in a gated community. Not only is it untrue, but the truth is I don't even know where to find a gated community. I'd only even heard of one, at an Ipswich country club. They appear to be very rare in Massachusetts, where I live. I'd assumed they were rare everywhere, until I started reading up about them. Apparently 40% of all new homes in California are built behind gates. Nationally, over 6% of all homes are now in gated communities. They appear to be very common in the South, and especially Florida, Southern California, Arizona, Arkansas, and Texas. The Chicago and New York suburbs also seem to have a few.

A Google Search for "Massachusetts gated community" comes up with just eight results, versus 16,400 for "Florida gated community." Even Arkansas, half the size of Massachusetts, comes back with 11,200 Google hits. Ironically, two of the eight results for "Massachusetts gated community" were a snarky reference to John Kerry supposedly living in a Massachusetts gated community, when, in fact, he did not, at the time -- he lived on Beacon Hill, where there are no gated communities... anyone can stroll right up to his house there.

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news...president/2004-07-26-kerry-neighborhood_x.htm

Most people in this state, even very wealthy people, just live in plain old traditional open communities. The Massachusetts elite mostly lives on Beacon Hill, or in suburbs like Newton, Wellesley, Weston, Brookline, Milton, Lexington, Concord, Lincoln, and Sudbury. These are wealthy places, no doubt -- in 2013, the median home in Weston went for $1.1724 million. But these are just regular neighborhoods, with most or all areas having no access controls. This is the type of state where you can be out for a jog and just randomly spot David Ortiz or Mike Dukakis walking to or from their homes. Few seem to feel the need to wall themselves off from the general community. I wonder why that is.

I guess one possibility is simply that Massachusetts was mostly already "built out" before the idea of gated communities took off, so there wasn't the same opportunity to make new developments that way. But New York, Chicago, southern Florida, southern California, etc., were also built out prior to the gated community boom, yet have retrofitted plenty of those communities, so I don't think that's it. I suspect it's largely about race. With the end of legal segregation, I think white people tried to recreate that sense of protective isolation with gated communities. In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population, there wasn't the desire for cloistering.
 
Go to Florida...The land of gated communities.....Where white people go to hide behind big walls protected by their private security force
 
Go to Florida...The land of gated communities.....Where white people go to hide behind big walls protected by their private security force
I guess, in a sense, I really have been sheltered, in that I wasn't even aware of gated communities as being a thing until I watched the TV show "Weeds" -- the first two seasons of which were set in southern California gated communities. I guess that's not entirely true: growing up, I lived in some "gated communities," if you include military bases. And I was aware there were some gated communities for retirees. But otherwise, I thought they were just something that existed in two or three places in the country, where people like movie stars and Howard Hughes type billionaires demanded that the rabble be kept out of their sight lines. I had no idea it had become a thing for the upper-middle class.
 
Don't worry Ark, you'll get there someday...
I hope not. I like the idea of maintaining a liveable community on a much broader basis, so that people don't feel the need to wall themselves off. Overall, I think Massachusetts does a pretty good job of that. Despite being densely populated and heavily urbanized, Massachusetts has a murder rate of just 2.0 -- ninth lowest in the nation. It is almost always on the low end of various other rankings of indicators of social dysfunction, and it has the best public schools in the country. In this state, you can live a "gated community lifestyle," without needing to live in a gated community. I think that's something we can preserve, if we stick with the public investment policies that have worked well for us in the past, rather than making the mistake of getting into a race to the bottom with the dysfunctional states.
 
I hope not. I like the idea of maintaining a liveable community on a much broader basis, so that people don't feel the need to wall themselves off. Overall, I think Massachusetts does a pretty good job of that. Despite being densely populated and heavily urbanized, Massachusetts has a murder rate of just 2.0 -- ninth lowest in the nation. It is almost always on the low end of various other rankings of indicators of social dysfunction, and it has the best public schools in the country. In this state, you can live a "gated community lifestyle," without needing to live in a gated community. I think that's something we can preserve, if we stick with the public investment policies that have worked well for us in the past, rather than making the mistake of getting into a race to the bottom with the dysfunctional states.

Mr. Arkady,

I think you hit the nail on the head with your first post as to why there is such a good standard of living where you are:

"In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population..."
 
I hope not. I like the idea of maintaining a liveable community on a much broader basis, so that people don't feel the need to wall themselves off. Overall, I think Massachusetts does a pretty good job of that. Despite being densely populated and heavily urbanized, Massachusetts has a murder rate of just 2.0 -- ninth lowest in the nation. It is almost always on the low end of various other rankings of indicators of social dysfunction, and it has the best public schools in the country. In this state, you can live a "gated community lifestyle," without needing to live in a gated community. I think that's something we can preserve, if we stick with the public investment policies that have worked well for us in the past, rather than making the mistake of getting into a race to the bottom with the dysfunctional states.

Mr. Arkady,

I think you hit the nail on the head with your first post as to why there is such a good standard of living where you are:

"In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population..."


Massachussetts has clearly prioritized staying white and wealthy over being diverse. You could say the whole state is a gated community...
 
Mr. Arkady,

I think you hit the nail on the head with your first post as to why there is such a good standard of living where you are:

"In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population..."


hmmm,,,that is pecular...high standard of living, low crime rate, low percentage of minorities...

by god ark!
i think you got somthing there!
 
they dont just let anybody into those elite enclaves...
One other thing I've noticed, which is sort of along the same lines, is how much more restrictive home-ownership seems to be in other parts of the country. In many places, it seems to be standard to have homeowners associations, which have various quasi-legislative powers. There are also all sorts of restrictive covenants governing even very minor questions about what you can do with your property, like whether you can have clotheslines and what color you can paint your house. I don't know anyone in the whole state of Massachusetts who has anything like that, but when I talk with my relatives in other states, it appears to be a common thing. I live in a nice little town, and we make rules the traditional way -- with town meetings where all residents get a chance to vote directly, rather than with quasi-governmental associations just of the property owners, operating by way of a private corporation or other affiliation. And we pay for town initiatives the traditional way, with taxes, rather than through HOA assessments. It strikes me as much more democratic this way, instead of through a method that privileges those with property.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Town_meeting
 
One other thing I've noticed, which is sort of along the same lines, is how much more restrictive home-ownership seems to be in other parts of the country. In many places, it seems to be standard to have homeowners associations, which have various quasi-legislative powers. There are also all sorts of restrictive covenants governing even very minor questions about what you can do with your property, like whether you can have clotheslines and what color you can paint your house. I don't know anyone in the whole state of Massachusetts who has anything like that, but when I talk with my relatives in other states, it appears to be a common thing. I live in a nice little town, and we make rules the traditional way -- with town meetings where all residents get a chance to vote directly, rather than with quasi-governmental associations just of the property owners, operating by way of a private corporation or other affiliation. And we pay for town initiatives the traditional way, with taxes, rather than through HOA assessments. It strikes me as much more democratic this way, instead of through a method that privileges those with property.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Town_meeting


hmmm,,,that is pecular...high standard of living, low crime rate, low percentage of minorities...

by god ark!
i think you are on to something there!
 
Mr. Arkady,

I think you hit the nail on the head with your first post as to why there is such a good standard of living where you are:

"In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population..."
What is your theory on why a good standard of living doesn't happen in places with more blacks and Hispanics?

I think it's the dynamics of having the underclass have such obvious differences from the ruling class. I think that tends to result in the ruling class neglecting and trying to isolate the underclass, creating a more permanent class structure, which, in turn, invites a more dysfunctional culture among the underclass, which comes to feel they're doomed to their position simply by the nature of who they are. I think that in places where the upper class is better able to empathize with the underclass, there is greater willingness to engage in social interventions to prevent the formation of a permanent underclass. I think there's a reason you get more generous social welfare states in places where the upper and lower class is of the same ethnicity, like New England or Scandinavia. And I think those more generous social welfare states allow for more widespread prosperity, and fewer sociological problems.
 
On occasion, I get accused of living in a gated community. Not only is it untrue, but the truth is I don't even know where to find a gated community. I'd only even heard of one, at an Ipswich country club. They appear to be very rare in Massachusetts, where I live. I'd assumed they were rare everywhere, until I started reading up about them. Apparently 40% of all new homes in California are built behind gates. Nationally, over 6% of all homes are now in gated communities. They appear to be very common in the South, and especially Florida, Southern California, Arizona, Arkansas, and Texas. The Chicago and New York suburbs also seem to have a few.

A Google Search for "Massachusetts gated community" comes up with just eight results, versus 16,400 for "Florida gated community." Even Arkansas, half the size of Massachusetts, comes back with 11,200 Google hits. Ironically, two of the eight results for "Massachusetts gated community" were a snarky reference to John Kerry supposedly living in a Massachusetts gated community, when, in fact, he did not, at the time -- he lived on Beacon Hill, where there are no gated communities... anyone can stroll right up to his house there.

http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news...president/2004-07-26-kerry-neighborhood_x.htm

Most people in this state, even very wealthy people, just live in plain old traditional open communities. The Massachusetts elite mostly lives on Beacon Hill, or in suburbs like Newton, Wellesley, Weston, Brookline, Milton, Lexington, Concord, Lincoln, and Sudbury. These are wealthy places, no doubt -- in 2013, the median home in Weston went for $1.1724 million. But these are just regular neighborhoods, with most or all areas having no access controls. This is the type of state where you can be out for a jog and just randomly spot David Ortiz or Mike Dukakis walking to or from their homes. Few seem to feel the need to wall themselves off from the general community. I wonder why that is.

I guess one possibility is simply that Massachusetts was mostly already "built out" before the idea of gated communities took off, so there wasn't the same opportunity to make new developments that way. But New York, Chicago, southern Florida, southern California, etc., were also built out prior to the gated community boom, yet have retrofitted plenty of those communities, so I don't think that's it. I suspect it's largely about race. With the end of legal segregation, I think white people tried to recreate that sense of protective isolation with gated communities. In Massachusetts, with a relatively small black and Hispanic population, there wasn't the desire for cloistering.


They are quite common....

In fact this hypocritcal piece of shit right here lives in one...

images


http://truthontarget.blogspot.com/2008/04/rev-jeremiah-wright-obamas-former.html
 
What is your theory on why a good standard of living doesn't happen in places with more blacks and Hispanics?

I think it's the dynamics of having the underclass have such obvious differences from the ruling class. I think that tends to result in the ruling class neglecting and trying to isolate the underclass, creating a more permanent class structure, which, in turn, invites a more dysfunctional culture among the underclass, which comes to feel they're doomed to their position simply by the nature of who they are. I think that in places where the upper class is better able to empathize with the underclass, there is greater willingness to engage in social interventions to prevent the formation of a permanent underclass. I think there's a reason you get more generous social welfare states in places where the upper and lower class is of the same ethnicity, like New England or Scandinavia. And I think those more generous social welfare states allow for more widespread prosperity, and fewer sociological problems.



all of the above flies in the face of your own observations about your state...

the conclusion is clear..

less minorities=higher standard of living, low crime...

glad you cleared that up!
 
hmmm,,,that is pecular...high standard of living, low crime rate, low percentage of minorities...

by god ark!
i think you got somthing there!
As is the case in every single community on the planet, there are lots of minorities in Massachusetts. There are left-handers, and Jews, and bald people, and children, and the elderly, the obese, and on and on. Each is only a minority of the community. And, in some ways, Massachusetts has unusually large minority groups. For example, 15.0% of people in Massachusetts are foreign-born, compared to the US average of 12.9%, and rates down as low as 1.2% in some states. But, none of these many minority groups causes widespread social dysfunction in Massachusetts, like what we see in so many other states. So, it's not simply the presence of minorities that causes a problem. What is it, exactly?
 
all of the above flies in the face of your own observations about your state...

the conclusion is clear..

less minorities=higher standard of living, low crime...

glad you cleared that up!
No. You appear to have misunderstood what I wrote if you think it flies in the face of my observations. It's entirely consistent with those observations. Try rereading.
 
What is your theory on why a good standard of living doesn't happen in places with more blacks and Hispanics?

I think it's the dynamics of having the underclass have such obvious differences from the ruling class. I think that tends to result in the ruling class neglecting and trying to isolate the underclass, creating a more permanent class structure, which, in turn, invites a more dysfunctional culture among the underclass, which comes to feel they're doomed to their position simply by the nature of who they are. I think that in places where the upper class is better able to empathize with the underclass, there is greater willingness to engage in social interventions to prevent the formation of a permanent underclass. I think there's a reason you get more generous social welfare states in places where the upper and lower class is of the same ethnicity, like New England or Scandinavia. And I think those more generous social welfare states allow for more widespread prosperity, and fewer sociological problems.

Mr. Arkady,

I'm just saying you do have your gated communities, but while in Florida, California, Las Vagas, etc., the gates are built to keep people out, whereas, Massachucetts gated communities, such as Everett, Lynn, Brockton, Randoph, Chealsea, Springfiled, and Holyoke, are intended to keep the riff raff in.

And what is up with them Portuguese? Why do they keep causing so much trouble in new bedford and Fall River?
 
No. You appear to have misunderstood what I wrote if you think it flies in the face of my observations. It's entirely consistent with those observations. Try rereading.
Seems you've hit a nerve with the angry bigots....Many wishing no doubt they could live behind walls with their fellow bigots
 
Back
Top