New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Guns, Mass Murder

Zam-Zam

Senator
This is one of the most thoughtful reads I've seen on the matter. Those who advocate for an easy-fix will likely disagree:



WASHINGTON — Every mass shooting has three elements: the killer, the weapon and the cultural climate. As soon as the shooting stops, partisans immediately pick their preferred root cause with corresponding pet panacea. Names are hurled, scapegoats paraded, prejudices vented. The argument goes nowhere.......


......If we’re serious about curtailing future Columbines and Newtowns, everything — guns, commitment, culture — must be on the table. It’s not hard for President Obama to call out the NRA. But will he call out the ACLU? And will he call out his Hollywood friends?

The irony is that over the last 30 years, the U.S. homicide rate has declined by 50 percent. Gun murders as well. We’re living not through an epidemic of gun violence but through a historic decline.

Except for these unfathomable mass murders. But these are infinitely more difficult to prevent. While law deters the rational, it has far less effect on the psychotic. The best we can do is to try to detain them, disarm them and discourage “entertainment” that can intensify already murderous impulses.

But there’s a cost. Gun control impinges upon the Second Amendment; involuntary commitment impinges upon the liberty clause of the Fifth Amendment; curbing “entertainment” violence impinges upon First Amendment free speech.

That’s a lot of impingement, a lot of amendments. But there’s no free lunch. Increasing public safety almost always means restricting liberties.

We made that trade after 9/11. We make it every time the TSA invades your body at an airport. How much are we prepared to trade away after Newtown?



Complete text: http://www.humanevents.com/2012/12/20/krauthammer-the-roots-of-mass-murder/
 
Hollywood movies stars and producers, rappers, and gamers created the cultural cimate and trained all the killers at Columbine, Aurora, Tucson, and Newtown -- all the killers were deranged kids either in school or older kids still living at home with mom or dad.

Here is how warped, sanctiminous, and hypocritical the libs are: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBruXAEK1zY

That is my open and shut case that hyper rich Hollywood stars, dripping rich rappers, and super rich video game maker have trained the kids to kill and have cashed in on kid deaths,)
 
Guys like Gordy would restrict your rights so they can feel SAFER, even though they are not any SAFER than before they restricted your rights. Typical of the dunderheads of the left.

ORR
 
Let's face it the arguement over gun ownership in the United States is strictly an opinion based arguement. For every fact that the anti gun crowd finds, there is an equal fact from the pro gun crowd to counter it, and vice versa. If we are having a discussion about facts we will find a stalemate on the issue, with each side getting further and further entrenched in the matter. The ONLY way to solve anything, and to have both sides "get what they want" (which will never happen) a compromise through debate, and sacrifice (from both sides) will need to be had.


Until then the arguements will be the same as they have been in the past few weeks, and will continue to be for the foreseable future.
 
This is one of the most thoughtful reads I've seen on the matter. Those who advocate for an easy-fix will likely disagree:



WASHINGTON — Every mass shooting has three elements: the killer, the weapon and the cultural climate. As soon as the shooting stops, partisans immediately pick their preferred root cause with corresponding pet panacea. Names are hurled, scapegoats paraded, prejudices vented. The argument goes nowhere.......


......If we’re serious about curtailing future Columbines and Newtowns, everything — guns, commitment, culture — must be on the table. It’s not hard for President Obama to call out the NRA. But will he call out the ACLU? And will he call out his Hollywood friends?

The irony is that over the last 30 years, the U.S. homicide rate has declined by 50 percent. Gun murders as well. We’re living not through an epidemic of gun violence but through a historic decline.

Except for these unfathomable mass murders. But these are infinitely more difficult to prevent. While law deters the rational, it has far less effect on the psychotic. The best we can do is to try to detain them, disarm them and discourage “entertainment” that can intensify already murderous impulses.

But there’s a cost. Gun control impinges upon the Second Amendment; involuntary commitment impinges upon the liberty clause of the Fifth Amendment; curbing “entertainment” violence impinges upon First Amendment free speech.

That’s a lot of impingement, a lot of amendments. But there’s no free lunch. Increasing public safety almost always means restricting liberties.

We made that trade after 9/11. We make it every time the TSA invades your body at an airport. How much are we prepared to trade away after Newtown?



Complete text: http://www.humanevents.com/2012/12/20/krauthammer-the-roots-of-mass-murder/

I get "invaded" every time we fly and don't bitch about it. YOU PEOPLE are so afraid you will have to give up your stupid assault weapons that you start talking about shit like that? Would you rather be "invaded" at an airport or run head-on into a sky scraper? Would you rather your chidren and grandchildren face an assault rifle held by some gun crazed lunatic or help to make it so they are not so easily available to nuts like that. As I have stated umpteen times since the CT shootings. 3/4 of the guns used in mass shootings in the past 30 yrs have been by guns owed by "RESPONSIBLE" gun owner...(as though) They are guns that are bought legally and licensed. And WTH use are they to the average person?? Unless you are not in law enforcement and/or military why do you need a gun like that which could end up in some lunatic's hands? That moron from the NRA is a cold blooded [Unwelcome language removed].
 
Guys like Gordy would restrict your rights so they can feel SAFER, even though they are not any SAFER than before they restricted your rights. Typical of the dunderheads of the left.

ORR

Tell the parents of those dead CT kids about your [Unwelcome language removed] RIGHTS. Tell me ORR...what use is a rifle like the one that lunatic used on those kids other than to do what he did?? What good is it for anyone to be able to have a gun like that in their home where some lunatic can get hold of them?? Why do you think you NEED such a weapon?? Talk about scared...YOU PEOPLE are not only scared, you're PARANOID.

We have no accessible weapons in our home except a service revolver that is LOCKED UP in a place that is not accessible. My husband knows more about safety than you ever will and has seen first hand what weapons can do in the wrong hands.

Do YOU PEOPLE give a shit at all about those children or any in the future who may have it happen to them because of your stupid "RIGHTS"> Did y ou even know that until 2008 the 2nd Amendment did not give you the right "PERSONALLY" to bear arms? It was only for a militia. Look it up.
 
Tell the parents of those dead CT kids about your <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif>ing RIGHTS. Tell me ORR...what use is a rifle like the one that lunatic used on those kids other than to do what he did?? What good is it for anyone to be able to have a gun like that in their home where some lunatic can get hold of them?? Why do you think you NEED such a weapon?? Talk about scared...YOU PEOPLE are not only scared, you're PARANOID.

We have no accessible weapons in our home except a service revolver that is LOCKED UP in a place that is not accessible. My husband knows more about safety than you ever will and has seen first hand what weapons can do in the wrong hands.

Do YOU PEOPLE give a shit at all about those children or any in the future who may have it happen to them because of your stupid "RIGHTS"> Did y ou even know that until 2008 the 2nd Amendment did not give you the right "PERSONALLY" to bear arms? It was only for a militia. Look it up.

There can't be militias any more. They pose a danger to the government and are terrorists. The national guard are now federalized troops who can act on US territory.


I worry more about my children growing up with very limited and ever more restricted rights then I ever will about them being shot. Considering .00003 percent of the US population dies from guns every year, including suicide which provides the bulk of the deaths, I don't see how I can be reasonbly concerned about the guns when the NDAA and Patriot Act have already restricted our freedoms as US citizens. Those are the things I am afraid of. Funny isn't it, I am more likely to die by thousands of other means (or my children) than I am terrorism or a gun, yet they are the most prevalent issues in the US today all in the name of our "safety".
 
There can't be militias any more. They pose a danger to the government and are terrorists. The national guard are now federalized troops who can act on US territory.


I worry more about my children growing up with very limited and ever more restricted rights then I ever will about them being shot. Considering .00003 percent of the US population dies from guns every year, including suicide which provides the bulk of the deaths, I don't see how I can be reasonbly concerned about the guns when the NDAA and Patriot Act have already restricted our freedoms as US citizens. Those are the things I am afraid of. Funny isn't it, I am more likely to die by thousands of other means (or my children) than I am terrorism or a gun, yet they are the most prevalent issues in the US today all in the name of our "safety".

Pananoid [Unwelcome language removed] are more dangerous than anything else. If you want to fit into that category have at it.
 
Pananoid <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif>s are more dangerous than anything else. If you want to fit into that category have at it.

You seem just as paranoid as myself, in regards to your stance on the gun issue. You're paranoid that others might get hurt by someone else who has a gun, they undoubtedly will. It's human nature. It is also human nature that people in power will try to obtain, and often will succeed, in getting more power. I'd say we are both equally paranoid.
 
The National Guard IS a militia.

As to the rest of it, maybe the rest of us would rather have some low cost insurance against excessive gun violence, and we don't live in fear of our government.

It's hard to miss the irony in the fact that the very people who are shouting loudest for having the government put armed guards on schools, are the same people who come on here and spew about how government is evil and doesn't work.

Wingers want the government to guard the schools out of one side of their mouths, and want less government out of the other! The hypocricy is priceless!
 
A militia fights in wars that are fought on foreign soil? The National Guard is not a militia, Iraq and Afghanistan were not a national emergencies, and I'm willing to bet you would agree with that. The national guard is a federal organization now, any way you look at it.


I don't fear our government, I fear the path that our government has taken in regards to individual liberties and the very principles that our government was founded upon. The constitution is our countries "insurance" policy, that policy has been violated with the Patriot Act and NDAA. I don't fear the government, I fear the people that are in charge of it an how far they are willing to go to make us "safe" under their ever watchful eye. Freedom certainly is chaos, not a reassurance of safety.
 
Tell the parents of those dead CT kids about your <img src=images/smilies/animated/censored.gif>ing RIGHTS. Tell me ORR...what use is a rifle like the one that lunatic used on those kids other than to do what he did?? What good is it for anyone to be able to have a gun like that in their home where some lunatic can get hold of them?? Why do you think you NEED such a weapon?? Talk about scared...YOU PEOPLE are not only scared, you're PARANOID.

We have no accessible weapons in our home except a service revolver that is LOCKED UP in a place that is not accessible. My husband knows more about safety than you ever will and has seen first hand what weapons can do in the wrong hands.

Do YOU PEOPLE give a shit at all about those children or any in the future who may have it happen to them because of your stupid "RIGHTS"> Did y ou even know that until 2008 the 2nd Amendment did not give you the right "PERSONALLY" to bear arms? It was only for a militia. Look it up.

Do you mean this "look it up?"

By Robert Barnes and Dan Eggen
Washington Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, June 29, 2010

The Second Amendment provides Americans a fundamental right to bear arms that cannot be violated by state and local governments, the Supreme Court ruled Monday in a long-sought victory for gun rights advocates.







The 5 to 4 decision does not strike down any gun-control laws, nor does it elaborate on what kind of laws would offend the Constitution. One justice predicted that an "avalanche" of lawsuits would be filed across the country asking federal judges to define the boundaries of gun ownership and government regulation.

But Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., who wrote the opinion for the court's dominant conservatives, said: "It is clear that the Framers . . . counted the right to keep and bear arms among those fundamental
 
A militia fights in wars that are fought on foreign soil? The National Guard is not a militia, Iraq and Afghanistan were not a national emergencies, and I'm willing to bet you would agree with that. The national guard is a federal organization now, any way you look at it.


I don't fear our government, I fear the path that our government has taken in regards to individual liberties and the very principles that our government was founded upon. The constitution is our countries "insurance" policy, that policy has been violated with the Patriot Act and NDAA. I don't fear the government, I fear the people that are in charge of it an how far they are willing to go to make us "safe" under their ever watchful eye. Freedom certainly is chaos, not a reassurance of safety.

So you also didn't think we should invade Iraq? So what you are saying is there are no militias, so there is no need for gun ownership, only a desire!
Do you know of anyone who was required to used their own weapon in fighting in a war over the last 100 years? Well for the USA anyway.
 
Do you mean this "look it up?"

By Robert Barnes and Dan Eggen
Washington Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, June 29, 2010

The Second Amendment provides Americans a fundamental right to bear arms that cannot be violated by state and local governments, the Supreme Court ruled Monday in a long-sought victory for gun rights advocates.







The 5 to 4 decision does not strike down any gun-control laws, nor does it elaborate on what kind of laws would offend the Constitution. One justice predicted that an "avalanche" of lawsuits would be filed across the country asking federal judges to define the boundaries of gun ownership and government regulation.

But Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr., who wrote the opinion for the court's dominant conservatives, said: "It is clear that the Framers . . . counted the right to keep and bear arms among those fundamental

Yes and this is why we need to never allow a republican to appoint another right wingnut to the SCOUS.
 
So you also didn't think we should invade Iraq? So what you are saying is there are no militias, so there is no need for gun ownership, only a desire!
Do you know of anyone who was required to used their own weapon in fighting in a war over the last 100 years? Well for the USA anyway.


I disagreed with the invasion of Iraq from the get go. It was an act of US aggresion, nothing more 9/11 had nothing to do with Iraq.


There are militias, which are being systematically dismantled due to the threat they pose the US government. Ergo if you join a militia, regardless of intent or actual purpose of said militia, you are a terrorist and the US government will dissolve it. Patriot act and NDAA come to mind. A militia is not a federally sanction military force, it never has been.


Do I know anyone that has used their personal weapon in defense of the USA? I would argue that people who have shot police officers after no knock entry warrents have done so, but that would be called a terrorist act now due to the nature of our country.
 
The National Guard most certainly IS a militia. It is the amalgamation of the various state nationa guards which all derived from state militias.

The second amendment is based on that argument.

The need for a well ordered militia. The founders didn't want the Federal government to have a large standing army, and the US didn't have a large standing army until WWII.

The US in 1789 faced little significant threat from any of the European powers, as they were six weeks away. Indians were the major threat, and they could be delt with on an ad hoc basis using local militias.
 
Let's face it the arguement over gun ownership in the United States is strictly an opinion based arguement. For every fact that the anti gun crowd finds, there is an equal fact from the pro gun crowd to counter it, and vice versa. If we are having a discussion about facts we will find a stalemate on the issue, with each side getting further and further entrenched in the matter. The ONLY way to solve anything, and to have both sides "get what they want" (which will never happen) a compromise through debate, and sacrifice (from both sides) will need to be had.


Until then the arguements will be the same as they have been in the past few weeks, and will continue to be for the foreseable future.

It is not a matter of opinion, it is a matter of fact, that the people have the right to own firearms. It's called the Second Amendment and one other thing that the left has forgotten about, or thought that the right has forgotten about, the Supreme Court incorporated it the past summer.

http://http://spectator.org/archives/2010/06/29/the-second-amendment-incorpora

ORR
 
It is not a matter of opinion, it is a matter of fact, that the people have the right to own firearms. It's called the Second Amendment and one other thing that the left has forgotten about, or thought that the right has forgotten about, the Supreme Court incorporated it the past summer.

http://http://spectator.org/archives/2010/06/29/the-second-amendment-incorpora

ORR

False. Even though I certainly do tote the 2nd amendment as a natural right of every citizen, it no longer applies. Until the repeal of the Bush administrations Patriot Act and the Obama administrations NDAA's the constitution is dead and means nothing. Republicans and democrats are going to be the death of this nations, through their ever increasing need for a vast government to support their bogus "political ideals". Neither of them actually believe what they say, and use it as a ploy to get the people of this country to vote for them. The end result will be the same regardless of who is in power. The supreme court might as well be disbanded, and their rulings are virtually mute at this point.
 
Back
Top