New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

He Said What?

Zam-Zam

Senator
Which rabid right-winger do you think said this just the other day in response to the President's budget proposal:


“The White House tells us they want to defend the middle class — that’s their mantra. If you want to defend the middle class you don’t cut Social Security, you don’t cut Medicare, and you don’t cut benefits for disabled vets.”





That would be Vermont's Bernie Sanders.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...153-11e2-82bc-511538ae90a4_story.html?hpid=z5


He's not the only one not backing the President's plan:


..... At Tuesday’s protest, I put the reverse question to participants: Could they accept a dollar of cuts in Medicare and Social Security benefits for every $10 of increased taxes on corporations and the wealthy? All those I asked said they would decline.

“Not for me, no,” said Rep. Rick Nolan (D-Minn.).

“I’m not taking your offer,” said Stephanie Taylor, co-founder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee.

“No, it’s not negotiable,” said Damon Silvers, the AFL-CIO’s policy director.

“Uh, no,” said Jim Dean, the chairman of Democracy for America.

Similar answers came from Roger Hickey of the Campaign for America’s Future, Manny Herrmann from MoveOn — and, of course, Sanders.



All of this coming from a WAPO opinion writer, not exactly a bastion of conservatism.





This thing sounds like it's DOA. If you can't convince your own party, good luck with the opposition.
 
But your fellow Wingers in Congress went for it hook, line, and sinker. Are you just now figuring out that Obama is further right than his party?
 
But your fellow Wingers in Congress went for it hook, line, and sinker. Are you just now figuring out that Obama is further right than his party?


To start with, does it not occur to you that the term "Winger" can be equally applied to both those of right-wing and left-wing persuasion? In other words, nearly everyone?

Can you name all of the Republicans in Congress who have indicated they're going to vote in favor of the President's budget proposal? Since they all 'fell for it'?
 
Yeah, it's shocking that all Congressional Democrats don't roll over and do whatever the President tells them to do.

Whodathunkit?
 
And not just elected Dems:

Max Richtman of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security called Obama’s justifications “malarkey.”

“Damned malarkey,” NOW’s Terry O’Neill amended.

Nolan, the Minnesota congressman, was particularly agitated. He got in a showdown with police for standing too close to the White House; he dared the officers to arrest him.

Another speaker on the program, a Social Security beneficiary named Phyllis Zolotorow, got personal: “Believe me, Mr. President, this is not the way to honor your mother’s memory.”

The liberal activists cheered. They were angry with Obama — and defiant.
 
I only know of one Left Winger that posts here, the rest of us on the left are main stream moderate Democrats, more in line with Eisenhower Republicans and more moderate Northeastern Republicans than the Green Party or Naderites and far left whackjobs. But that is not the case on the right on this board, the top posts routinely show the farthest fringe right views on all things politic, from abortion, to gun control, to birtherism, to any talking point that Limbaugh and his ilk put out for daily Wingerist consumption. Thus we are fed the daily dose of "darkies being bad", the latest in" Democratic racism",Cilmate change deniers, evolution deniers, Bush apologists, Reagan worshippers, hell, we even get a daily dose of "doomsday" is coming from a couple of your Winger brethren.
 
I only know of one Left Winger that posts here, the rest of us on the left are main stream moderate Democrats, more in line with Eisenhower Republicans and more moderate Northeastern Republicans than the Green Party or Naderites and far left whackjobs. But that is not the case on the right on this board, the top posts routinely show the farthest fringe right views on all things politic, from abortion, to gun control, to birtherism, to any talking point that Limbaugh and his ilk put out for daily Wingerist consumption. Thus we are fed the daily dose of "darkies being bad", the latest in" Democratic racism",Cilmate change deniers, evolution deniers, Bush apologists, Reagan worshippers, hell, we even get a daily dose of "doomsday" is coming from a couple of your Winger brethren.



You only know of one left winger who posts here. Now that's funny.
 
You only know of one left winger who posts here. Now that's funny.

There is a differnece between mainstram moderate and far left whack job, or can you not see that? You see Hillary Clinton and Ralph Nader in the same spot on the political spectrum?
 
So? You seem to think this is newsworthy. To me it's as expected as the sun coming up in the east.

Seriously: did you think a politician attempting to navigate the third rail of politics would do so without peril?
 
There is a differnece between mainstram moderate and far left whack job, or can you not see that? You see Hillary Clinton and Ralph Nader in the same spot on the political spectrum?


So you would not describe Hillary Clinton as left wing?

Some may disagree.
 
So? You seem to think this is newsworthy. To me it's as expected as the sun coming up in the east.

Seriously: did you think a politician attempting to navigate the third rail of politics would do so without peril?



Yes. I felt it newsworthy, as did the Washington Post apparently. You at least felt it "reply worthy".
 
Which rabid right-winger do you think said this just the other day in response to the President's budget proposal:


“The White House tells us they want to defend the middle class — that’s their mantra. If you want to defend the middle class you don’t cut Social Security, you don’t cut Medicare, and you don’t cut benefits for disabled vets.”





That would be Vermont's Bernie Sanders.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...153-11e2-82bc-511538ae90a4_story.html?hpid=z5


He's not the only one not backing the President's plan:


..... At Tuesday’s protest, I put the reverse question to participants: Could they accept a dollar of cuts in Medicare and Social Security benefits for every $10 of increased taxes on corporations and the wealthy? All those I asked said they would decline.

“Not for me, no,” said Rep. Rick Nolan (D-Minn.).

“I’m not taking your offer,” said Stephanie Taylor, co-founder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee.

“No, it’s not negotiable,” said Damon Silvers, the AFL-CIO’s policy director.

“Uh, no,” said Jim Dean, the chairman of Democracy for America.

Similar answers came from Roger Hickey of the Campaign for America’s Future, Manny Herrmann from MoveOn — and, of course, Sanders.



All of this coming from a WAPO opinion writer, not exactly a bastion of conservatism.





This thing sounds like it's DOA. If you can't convince your own party, good luck with the opposition.

It should be DOA. Obama is trying to shrink Social Security, and he's trying to do so to the disproportionate detriment of young people, who had the least to do with Social Security's funding shortfall (since they never paid the lower rates or had the younger retirement ages that prior generations had). It's a terrible idea and implemented in an inequitable way. Moreover, as always, Obama's opening offer gives the Republicans 90% of what they want and then invites them to try to get most of the other 10%, too. He offers up massive cuts to the centerpiece of the New Deal, and asks for relatively small tax increases on the wealthy, in exchange... an opening offer that leans so far to the right that it would be the wet dream final negotiated outcome of a sane GOP.

If Obama won't stand up for core liberal values, someone else is going to have to. Thank goodness we have Bernie Sanders.
 
That's dumb.

The Washington Post was just reporting Democrats discontent with President Obama's proposed tinkering with Social Security and Medicare. That discontent came as a big suprise to exactly noone.

What I thought was stupid was your evaluation regarding President Obama's negotiating skills. When you consider the very things that the Democrats were complaining about would have Republicans jumping for joy puts your original criticism out in the weeds.

Hope that clears things up for you.
 
So you would not describe Hillary Clinton as left wing?

Some may disagree.

Of course Hillary Clinton isn't left wing. Her stated policy positions are in the middle or even slightly to the right relative to the norm among the leaders of the world's leading nations. Only within the deeply skewed context of the leadership of America today, with the right-wingers toppling off a cliff far to the right of the field, does Hilary Clinton look left wing.
 
Did you miss Arkady's TP 23 hours ago that drew mostly lefties disagreeing with Obama's stance? No. You were there.

Kinda late to rub our noses in anything...wouldn't you say?
 
One last point -- you suggest the WaPo opinion writer isn't exactly a bastion of conservatism. Yet Milbank's last three presidential votes were for McCain, Bloomberg, and Hagel.... three Republicans. That doesn't make him a conservative, but it does make him, at best, a centrist Republican. And that's consistent with a general disconnect between the right-wing's view of the WaPo opinion pages as a liberal haven, and the reality that they are frequently home of centrist Republicans and even neo-con right-wingers.

http://www.consortiumnews.com/2009/031509.html

The WaPo editorialized constantly in favor of conquering Iraq, for example. They also editorialized in favor of appointing a special prosecutor to look into Whitewater.
 
Back
Top