New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Here's one...

What's the matter @EatTheRich ? Truth blows? Ukranian Nazis to this day resent communist Jews. And Ukranians Nazis exist for a reason. Rational or not.
 
Last edited:
What is your point? A few Jews remained in positions of power even after Stalin’s anti-Semitic purges and Russian-chauvinist retrenchments. And centuries-old anti-Jewish prejudices were of course encouraged by the enemies of communism (Hitler etc.) to undermine working-class solidarity and build fascism. Enemies of Stalin who lacked confidence in the left opposition’s fight against his regime also opportunistically looked to Hitler’s invasion for salvation, at least until they saw what it looked like in practice. Yes, perhaps 1 in 50 Ukrainians were Nazi sympathizers/collaborators … the cruelty of a few people like Kaganovich hardly justifies that.
 
What is your point? A few Jews remained in positions of power even after Stalin’s anti-Semitic purges and Russian-chauvinist retrenchments. And centuries-old anti-Jewish prejudices were of course encouraged by the enemies of communism (Hitler etc.) to undermine working-class solidarity and build fascism. Enemies of Stalin who lacked confidence in the left opposition’s fight against his regime also opportunistically looked to Hitler’s invasion for salvation, at least until they saw what it looked like in practice. Yes, perhaps 1 in 50 Ukrainians were Nazi sympathizers/collaborators … the cruelty of a few people like Kaganovich hardly justifies that.
IF YOU DON'T RESPOND TO A POST I'M NOT TOLD YOU POSTED UNLESS YOU INCLUDE @Halo.

No, my point is there are Nazis in Ukraine to this day and their motivation is ancestral. So you and middler can admit there is a Nazi Azov element to the ruling government. Zelensky being Jewish isn't exculpatory any more than saying an estimated 180,000 Jews (both hidden and Aryanized) fought in the military for Germany during WW2. The real world is more complicated.

And my point is also that antisemitism didn't come from a vacuum. A people who hold themselves separate and chosen, unwilling to share their God, will invariably suffer collective retribution as their outsized influence is perceived detrimental to the larger part of society.

Karl Marx being Jewish doesn't help on the antisemitism issue among the agnostic and atheist. Maybe that is why atheist Stalin purged Jews but after Holodomor.
 
IF YOU DON'T RESPOND TO A POST I'M NOT TOLD YOU POSTED UNLESS YOU INCLUDE @Halo.

No, my point is there are Nazis in Ukraine to this day and their motivation is ancestral. So you and middler can admit there is a Nazi Azov element to the ruling government. Zelensky being Jewish isn't exculpatory any more than saying an estimated 180,000 Jews (both hidden and Aryanized) fought in the military for Germany during WW2. The real world is more complicated.

And my point is also that antisemitism didn't come from a vacuum. A people who hold themselves separate and chosen, unwilling to share their God, will invariably suffer collective retribution as their outsized influence is perceived detrimental to the larger part of society.

Karl Marx being Jewish doesn't help on the antisemitism issue among the agnostic and atheist. Maybe that is why atheist Stalin purged Jews but after Holodomor.
@Halo I suggest reading Marx “On the Jewish Question,” where he makes the case that anti-Semitism is fundamentally rooted in actual exploitation suffered by ancient and medieval people at the hands of Jews who represented the incipient capitalist element in their society, and also explains that capitalism’s destruction of social differentiation and its class polarization of the Jewish people as all other people has made that motive obsolete, except in the minds of people trapped in medieval modes of thought and those who take advantage of their muddle-headedness to intensify their own exploitation.

Azov started out with a far-right, Hitler-inspired, anti-Semitic ideology, although it functioned more as a rightist than a strictly fascist movement. It had no formal government power, but exerted influence over the government via its military power. That power has been substantially reduced and the rightist nature of Azov diluted since the government subordinated Azov to the regular National Guard and split up and dispersed its units.

Anyway, it seems to me that far-right sympathy in Ukraine is motivated less by “ancestral” sympathy for the Nazis who have been abhorred for generations than by the present-day bourgeoisie’s promotion of right-wing nationalism, national division to roll back working-class conquests and stave off the return of socialism. In particular it owes much to the influence of Russian ultrarightists Zhirinovsky, Dugin, etc., and their elevation to influence by Russia’s burgeoning secret-police dictatorship.
 
@Halo I suggest reading Marx “On the Jewish Question,” where he makes the case that anti-Semitism is fundamentally rooted in actual exploitation suffered by ancient and medieval people at the hands of Jews who represented the incipient capitalist element in their society, and also explains that capitalism’s destruction of social differentiation and its class polarization of the Jewish people as all other people has made that motive obsolete, except in the minds of people trapped in medieval modes of thought and those who take advantage of their muddle-headedness to intensify their own exploitation.

Azov started out with a far-right, Hitler-inspired, anti-Semitic ideology, although it functioned more as a rightist than a strictly fascist movement. It had no formal government power, but exerted influence over the government via its military power. That power has been substantially reduced and the rightist nature of Azov diluted since the government subordinated Azov to the regular National Guard and split up and dispersed its units.

Anyway, it seems to me that far-right sympathy in Ukraine is motivated less by “ancestral” sympathy for the Nazis who have been abhorred for generations than by the present-day bourgeoisie’s promotion of right-wing nationalism, national division to roll back working-class conquests and stave off the return of socialism. In particular it owes much to the influence of Russian ultrarightists Zhirinovsky, Dugin, etc., and their elevation to influence by Russia’s burgeoning secret-police dictatorship.

What is left and right wing?

Communists killed in very large numbers people based on their class and sending them to gulags. Is that really that much better than the Nazis who killed based on their race and sending people to concentration camps?

Do you think that in the 1950's, 60's or even 70's that say the Russians didn't have strong nationalist feelings similar to Nazis? And are not communist internationalist aspirations (where communism will only succeed if everyone is communist so let us spread) in their way imperial?

Are not the collectivization party platforms of communists and Nazis at the expense of individual rights not the same?

The right wing of America believes in conserving what the founding fathers started. Individual rights and the pursuit of happiness being essentially about capitalism. Individual capitalism. Individualism versus collectivism.

To me the Nazis are far more like communists than they are American conservatives. I say Nazis are of the left.

Tell @middleview if you get the chance. ha ha
 
What is left and right wing?

Communists killed in very large numbers people based on their class and sending them to gulags. Is that really that much better than the Nazis who killed based on their race and sending people to concentration camps?

Do you think that in the 1950's, 60's or even 70's that say the Russians didn't have strong nationalist feelings similar to Nazis? And are not communist internationalist aspirations (where communism will only succeed if everyone is communist so let us spread) in their way imperial?

Are not the collectivization party platforms of communists and Nazis at the expense of individual rights not the same?

The right wing of America believes in conserving what the founding fathers started. Individual rights and the pursuit of happiness being essentially about capitalism. Individual capitalism. Individualism versus collectivism.

To me the Nazis are far more like communists than they are American conservatives. I say Nazis are of the left.

Tell @middleview if you get the chance. ha ha

Tell us what you would call members of the extreme right wing, or do you believe there is no such thing? No such thing as white Supremacists? Did you think the KKK did not show up for the Unite the Right rally? How about the people carrying Nazi flags?

I'm a fiscal conservative, but disagree with the controls Trump wishes to put on individuals and what they do with their own bodies. I do not see those controls as conservative...

What you have described in the policies of the Soviet Union are aligned with fascist policies, true. The big difference is the influence business had in fascism vs communism which nationalized industries and confiscated private property from the people.
 
Tell us what you would call members of the extreme right wing, or do you believe there is no such thing? No such thing as white Supremacists? Did you think the KKK did not show up for the Unite the Right rally? How about the people carrying Nazi flags?

I'm a fiscal conservative, but disagree with the controls Trump wishes to put on individuals and what they do with their own bodies. I do not see those controls as conservative...

What you have described in the policies of the Soviet Union are aligned with fascist policies, true. The big difference is the influence business had in fascism vs communism which nationalized industries and confiscated private property from the people.
What makes racism right wing? Leftist say so? Because there is plenty of racism on the left (think of recent antisemitism or the blocking by white union members of blacks at one point in time). Left and right wing terms came from France back in the day. You think there was racism there? Or was the right wing simply monarchists.

When you look at it the difference between the right and left it boils down to communalism versus individualism period. Nazi and communists are communalists. Why does the KKK and neoNazis vote Republican? Who says that's the actual case. They are racists and hate communists. Doesn't mean they are in their very small numbers voting for conservative individualism. They very much maintain their communalist party platform and anti-capitalism sentiments. They still want to get rid of the people who live off of interest (i.e. investor income) if you read their party platform.

Yes, the communists and Nazis have very much in common.

P.S. YOUR FISCAL CONSERVATIVISM HAS HAD TO PAY ALOT FOR THOSE LIBERAL SOCIAL VALUES ALREADY.
 
Last edited:
What makes racism right wing? Leftist say so? Because there is plenty of racism on the left (think of recent antisemitism or the blocking by white union members of blacks at one point in time). Left and right wing terms came from France back in the day. You think there was racism there? Or was the right wing simply monarchists.

When you look at it the difference between the right and left it boils down to communalism versus individualism period. Nazi and communists are communalists. Why does the KKK and neoNazis vote Republican? Who says that's the actual case. They are racists and hate communists. Doesn't mean they are in their very small numbers voting for conservative individualism. They very much maintain their communalist party platform and anti-capitalism sentiments. They still want to get rid of the people who live off of interest (i.e. investor income) if you read their party platform.

Yes, the communists and Nazis have very much in common.

P.S. YOUR FISCAL CONSERVATIVISM HAS HAD TO PAY ALOT FOR THOSE LIBERAL SOCIAL VALUES ALREADY.
Making shit up is not helping you make your case.
1. You argue that college students criticizing Israel is anti-semitic. It isn't. Any more than pro-Israel are necessarily anti-Moslem or anti-Palestinian.
2. "communalists"? Bullshit.
3. The Berlin stock market was open until 1945...
4. What you refer to as "the party platform" lasted until they had power...
 
@middleview

Don't forget that "fascists capitalism" is command economy capitalism. Capitalism when told what to do is communalism.
Inventing a new definition for communalism?
com·mu·nal·ism
allegiance to one's own ethnic group rather than to the wider society:
 
What is left and right wing?

Communists killed in very large numbers people based on their class and sending them to gulags. Is that really that much better than the Nazis who killed based on their race and sending people to concentration camps?

Do you think that in the 1950's, 60's or even 70's that say the Russians didn't have strong nationalist feelings similar to Nazis? And are not communist internationalist aspirations (where communism will only succeed if everyone is communist so let us spread) in their way imperial?

Are not the collectivization party platforms of communists and Nazis at the expense of individual rights not the same?

The right wing of America believes in conserving what the founding fathers started. Individual rights and the pursuit of happiness being essentially about capitalism. Individual capitalism. Individualism versus collectivism.

To me the Nazis are far more like communists than they are American conservatives. I say Nazis are of the left.

Tell @middleview if you get the chance. ha ha
1. Right-wing means supporting social hierarchies of oppression and left-wing means breaking them down.
2. The gulags were hardly death camps; in fact, life expectancy in the gulag system was higher than the general pre-Soviet life expectancy in Siberia.
3. Russian nationalism was something Lenin spent his whole political career opposing. Its revival under Stalinism, like much of what caused Stalinism to resemble Nazism, reflected specifically Stalin’s centrist repudiation of Lenin’s leftist course.
4. Stalin’s notorious policy of “liquidation of the kulaks as a class” was termed “ultra leftist” by his orthodox communist critics because it aimed at rapid collectivization of agriculture, but even the ultra leftist maneuver the logic of bureaucratic centrism pushed on Stalin’s regime was a typically administrative exaggeration taken in response to the weaknesses created by Stalin’s prior capitulations to the right.
5. Imperialism aims at subjugating foreign nations so they can be exploited for the benefit of the metropolis. Communist internationalism is a fight for liberation that (as shown in detail in practice under Lenin’s leadership) sacrifices narrow national interests to the general interest of the working class, and in particular subordinates the interest of powerful nations to an assurance of fair treatment of oppressed nations.
6. The whole point of the Nazi regime was to assure the continued enjoyment of private property rights by the ruling capitalists. They “collectivized” by forcing everyone into state-organized cartels in order to destroy unions and assure a profitable business climate. Communists fight to assure the individual rights of the poor and oppressed by tearing down the family, private property, and the state as loci of oppression.They “collectivize” by organizing grassroots resistance to the oppressing class and seizing its property for the enjoyment of the toiling classes.
7. The right in the U.S. has a poor record when it comes to preserving individual rights. Consider for example the decades-long effort to make Christianity a state religion at the expense of our First Amendment. Or the entire Jim Crow travesty. All of which goes hand in hand with preservation of capitalism and capitalist profits,
 
What makes racism right wing? Leftist say so? Because there is plenty of racism on the left (think of recent antisemitism or the blocking by white union members of blacks at one point in time). Left and right wing terms came from France back in the day. You think there was racism there? Or was the right wing simply monarchists.

When you look at it the difference between the right and left it boils down to communalism versus individualism period. Nazi and communists are communalists. Why does the KKK and neoNazis vote Republican? Who says that's the actual case. They are racists and hate communists. Doesn't mean they are in their very small numbers voting for conservative individualism. They very much maintain their communalist party platform and anti-capitalism sentiments. They still want to get rid of the people who live off of interest (i.e. investor income) if you read their party platform.

Yes, the communists and Nazis have very much in common.

P.S. YOUR FISCAL CONSERVATIVISM HAS HAD TO PAY ALOT FOR THOSE LIBERAL SOCIAL VALUES ALREADY.
Racists have loudly proclaimed their allegiance to the right for decades (although some also take the typically fascist approach of declaring themselves “neither left nor right”). The Ku Klux Klan, for example, described itself as an organization founded to preserve traditional conservative values. If they are anti-communist that makes them pro-capitalist since there is no modern alternative.

The left in France during the revolution was the side fighting for emancipation of Jews, enfranchisement of Jews and Blacks, and abolition of slavery (all proposed by leftist leader Robespierre).

Fascism depends on resentment and cannot mobilize resentment without pretending to address the failures of capitalism that fuel that resentment. Hence the ritual denunciation of banking capital, which they pretend can be separated from industrial capital so that they can openly ally themselves with the latter, and their utter dependence on and incomparable service to the former can remain hidden until they have cemented themselves in power.
 
Racists have loudly proclaimed their allegiance to the right for decades (although some also take the typically fascist approach of declaring themselves “neither left nor right”). The Ku Klux Klan, for example, described itself as an organization founded to preserve traditional conservative values. If they are anti-communist that makes them pro-capitalist since there is no modern alternative.
And yet the KKK you speak of was a bunch of registered Democrats.

The left in France during the revolution was the side fighting for emancipation of Jews, enfranchisement of Jews and Blacks, and abolition of slavery (all proposed by leftist leader Robespierre).
So did classical liberals at the time who were more of the right than the left.

Fascism depends on resentment and cannot mobilize resentment without pretending to address the failures of capitalism that fuel that resentment.
ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha... Like the commies don't foster class resentment. ha ha ha ha ha ha ha. Yet another for the more alike column.

Hence the ritual denunciation of banking capital, which they pretend can be separated from industrial capital so that they can openly ally themselves with the latter, and their utter dependence on and incomparable service to the former can remain hidden until they have cemented themselves in power.
You're going to have make this less commie talk if you expect me to follow along. Cemented in power is when the command economy is implemented? Before the eventual state take over of private companies? Did I tell you how Benito was a card carrying commie in his day? That says a lot too. How about those black American socialists who at first praised Nazism because of the commonality with socialism/communism? Where'd they go in those history books?
 
1. Right-wing means supporting social hierarchies of oppression and left-wing means breaking them down.
In Europe before classical liberalism maybe. How about left wing oppression/killing of the middle class and upper class

2. The gulags were hardly death camps; in fact, life expectancy in the gulag system was higher than the general pre-Soviet life expectancy in Siberia.
Now the gulag is good? ha ha

3. Russian nationalism was something Lenin spent his whole political career opposing. Its revival under Stalinism, like much of what caused Stalinism to resemble Nazism, reflected specifically Stalin’s centrist repudiation of Lenin’s leftist course.
Why because Lenin was Jewish and didn't want Russian nationalism to compete with that? Ohhhh... that's right Lenin didn't know he was Jewish.

4. Stalin’s notorious policy of “liquidation of the kulaks as a class” was termed “ultra leftist” by his orthodox communist critics because it aimed at rapid collectivization of agriculture, but even the ultra leftist maneuver the logic of bureaucratic centrism pushed on Stalin’s regime was a typically administrative exaggeration taken in response to the weaknesses created by Stalin’s prior capitulations to the right.
WTF?!?!
5. Imperialism aims at subjugating foreign nations so they can be exploited for the benefit of the metropolis. Communist internationalism is a fight for liberation that (as shown in detail in practice under Lenin’s leadership) sacrifices narrow national interests to the general interest of the working class, and in particular subordinates the interest of powerful nations to an assurance of fair treatment of oppressed nations.
Conquering more populated land and putting it under your ideology is a subjugating imperialism. Something commies did.

6. The whole point of the Nazi regime was to assure the continued enjoyment of private property rights by the ruling capitalists. They “collectivized” by forcing everyone into state-organized cartels in order to destroy unions and assure a profitable business climate. Communists fight to assure the individual rights of the poor and oppressed by tearing down the family, private property, and the state as loci of oppression.They “collectivize” by organizing grassroots resistance to the oppressing class and seizing its property for the enjoyment of the toiling classes.
I bet Nazi unions did better than USSR unions for their members..

7. The right in the U.S. has a poor record when it comes to preserving individual rights. Consider for example the decades-long effort to make Christianity a state religion at the expense of our First Amendment.
I really don't think this was a thing.

Or the entire Jim Crow travesty. All of which goes hand in hand with preservation of capitalism and capitalist profits,
Which was a southern Democrat thing. You can go back to the Civil War and see that the Democrat platform much like today was a collectivized platform.
 
And yet the KKK you speak of was a bunch of registered Democrats.
Yes, back when the party had a strong conservative wing. They were the folks who issued the “Conservative Manifesto” and joined the “Conservative Coalition” (their words).
So did classical liberals at the time who were more of the right than the left.
Classical liberals like Robespierre were leftists compared with the feudal and mercantilist power structures they opposed. Guess what, political programs that were advanced for the 18th century are sometimes antiquated when duplicated in the 21st.

ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha... Like the commies don't foster class resentment. ha ha ha ha ha ha ha. Yet another for the more alike column.

No, communist rebellion is about eliminating hierarchical oppression so that individuals can be free. Fascist resentment is about the grievances of those who believe they should be privileged in a hierarchy but feel they are not.

You're going to have make this less commie talk if you expect me to follow along. Cemented in power is when the command economy is implemented? Before the eventual state take over of private companies? Did I tell you how Benito was a card carrying commie in his day? That says a lot too. How about those black American socialists who at first praised Nazism because of the commonality with socialism/communism? Where'd they go in those history books?
The state doesn’t take over private companies (except as incidental to preserving the dictatorship of the wealthiest private individuals) following a fascist counterrevolution. On the contrary, private ownership is a fundamental underpinning of fascism, and most fascist regimes have pursued aggressive privatization of state-owned enterprises,

What do you think Mussolini’s political migration from far left to far right signifies?

Which Black American socialists?
 
In Europe before classical liberalism maybe. How about left wing oppression/killing of the middle class and upper class
And in every use of the left-right spectrum afterward. Self-defense.

Now the gulag is good? ha ha

Not good. But also not comparable with the Nazi death camps.

Why because Lenin was Jewish and didn't want Russian nationalism to compete with that? Ohhhh... that's right Lenin didn't know he was Jewish.

Lenin wasn’t Jewish. He opposed Russian chauvinism because it was a barrier to workers’ unity.

WTF?!?!

Conquering more populated land and putting it under your ideology is a subjugating imperialism. Something commies did.

You’re missing that the dictatorship of the proletariat was extended with the active agency of the workers and oppressed in the “conquered” countries.

I bet Nazi unions did better than USSR unions for their members..

The tens of millions of Soviets who fought tooth and nail to resist the Nazis say otherwise.
I really don't think this was a thing.
Dominionism? It is all around us and very influential in the Trump administration. In fact, Trump publicly pledged to make us all worship the same god.


Which was a southern Democrat thing. You can go back to the Civil War and see that the Democrat platform much like today was a collectivized platform.
Hmm. Republicans advocated massive redistribution of wealth through a powerful, largely centralized government, while Democrats advocated keeping the kind of nation set up by the Founding Fathers, with slavery and traditional conservative values. Karl Marx supported the Republicans and Abraham “vote yourself a farm and horses” Lincoln told everyone to read Marx’s newspaper columns.
 
@EatTheRich I bet those Gulags were just like summer camp. All those good memories of torture, starvation, forced labor, freezing conditions.... Just like anybody would remember. ha ha So much better than a concentration camp no moral relativism required. ha ha

Russian Gulag.

1740463250101.png

Way more gulags than death camps.

1740463218264.png
 
Back
Top