New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hi, Dave

My post was first just a question about features of PM, and if i can block unwanted spam.
Was not i even supposed to ever mention who sends me the spam?

[edit]
 
I did not Moderate that post but I have edited this post Yuri. You guessed correctly that you cannot use another posters name in a Toppost or it is a Callout. You did get the answer to that first question and no doubt some who may not have known are glad you asked.

As an FYI: Moderators are required to edit out names on all Topposts where a name appears with an insult or not.
 
I did not Moderate that post but I have edited this post Yuri. You guessed correctly that you cannot use another posters name in a Toppost or it is a Callout. You did get the answer to that first question and no doubt some who may not have known are glad you asked.

As an FYI: Moderators are required to edit out names on all Topposts where a name appears with an insult or not.
how about in the thread, when i was communicating to jen and told her about someone spamming my PM. Am I not supposed to do that on "General discussions" board either?

[edit]
 
I edited the name out in this too if it is a complaint. Probably the best way to look at it is to avoid negatively using names anywhere unless directly speaking to that person. That way you know it won't be edited. Glad you asked. ;)

What I'd do if someone bugged me is PM a Moderator and ask for help if you want them to address the person you can name to them via PM. In any case its all good. Now ya know.

I think Jen said she'd check further but BRU and Nightswimmer gave the only fix I am aware of.
 
As an FYI: Moderators are required to edit out names on all Topposts where a name appears with an insult or not.

That makes no sense, Min. I can see it if there's an insult, but, as I asked before, what about 'happy birthday' posts, or posts of special interest to on person? A few rotten apples have been allowed to spoil things for everyone.
 
That makes no sense, Min. I can see it if there's an insult, but, as I asked before, what about 'happy birthday' posts, or posts of special interest to on person? A few rotten apples have been allowed to spoil things for everyone.

Make no sense is correct, Friday.
There were no personal call outs, just a question and complain to jen in the subsequent discussion.
Are some people like Jesus and their names are not supposed to be mentioned at all in any context?
Now, I mentioned conversation with jen to you , will name "jen" be edited out from this post?
Is it me or something became crazier in this place?
 
That makes no sense, Min. I can see it if there's an insult, but, as I asked before, what about 'happy birthday' posts, or posts of special interest to on person? A few rotten apples have been allowed to spoil things for everyone.

it makes perfect sense, the rules are clear


-No Toppost Callouts: No starting threads about other members to bash them, hate on them whether name is used in title or body of thread. Do not personalize Toppost bashing. These will be deleted and infractions may be issued.

-No Poster Named Topposts are allowed, not even created to illustrate a point, or induce further political discussion of an issue being discussed in another thread, or for any reason. Moderators may merge continued discussions with Toppost names back into original conversation or work with posters to repost without names.



His top post call out including an insult to the named poster. Please refer to the rules above https://www.politicaljack.com/forums/showthread.php?29902-Political-Jack-Rules
 
Make no sense is correct, Friday.
There were no personal call outs, just a question and complain to jen in the subsequent discussion.
Are some people like Jesus and their names are not supposed to be mentioned at all in any context?
Now, I mentioned conversation with jen to you , will name "jen" be edited out from this post?
Is it me or something became crazier in this place?

Please refer to the rules page

-No Toppost Callouts: No starting threads about other members to bash them, hate on them whether name is used in title or body of thread. Do not personalize Toppost bashing. These will be deleted and infractions may be issued.

-No Poster Named Topposts are allowed, not even created to illustrate a point, or induce further political discussion of an issue being discussed in another thread, or for any reason. Moderators may merge continued discussions with Toppost names back into original conversation or work with posters to repost without names.



Your top post call out included an insult to the named poster. Please refer to the rules above https://www.politicaljack.com/forums/...cal-Jack-Rules
 
The General Board would seem to be an exception for the "Naming rule" as we have always known it for any positive Well Wishing. Note also the No Name rule is separate from Callout Rule now. This is the only board I am aware of where sincere well wishing doesn't get moved. The rule stands but the exception of the General Board could be noted if it causes confusion. I'll check into it. The biggest issue I can see is someone abusing removing it from the No Naming Rule in some way but thus far that has not been an issue on this board where we move any "Happy Birthday" or "Get Well" to from other boards.

In any case naming with no negative intent has been taken out of the Callout rule. Callouts with insults, or reporting publically, or any negative with a name is much easier as that Callout rule is consistantly handled the same way - remove name or more.
 
I've never really understood all the righteousness around "top post call outs". But then.....I've never really understood a lotta shit that most others do.

I guess if I were boss of everything, I'd make say....a "24 hour rule". Folks should be allowed to "top post call out" at their whim, BUT....of the target of the "call out" either declines or is unable to respond within 24 hours, then it's vanished.
 
Thanx, Min. Your answer actually addressed my question. I would post birthday, info, etc to the general board. I have also posted pictures of particular interest to certain people (example: Marilyn Monroe, century old pics of a country) with a top post noting that. I would hope that this would still be permitted, and it sounds as tho you agree.
 
No, it does not make perfect sense...I specified 'without insult'. You did not address my question.

yes I did (at the time) the rules I pasted to you covered it... see "or for any reason" .
A recent exception has now been made and posted on the rules page. At the time; I did address your question.
 
That was the wording so the revision was overdue for this board being the known exception but not noted in the rule. It worked out great. ;)

Dave wrote the rule wording but no well wishing names were edited out on this board to the point this is where Happy Birthday and Get Well Soon posts were always moved to. Nice to have it reflected now to end the confusion. Ah the fun of revisions. LOL
 
Back
Top