New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Hillary & Pneumonia

Zam-Zam

Senator
I'm not going to pretend I know Hillary's health situation, in part because she guards her health records the way Donald Trump guards his tax returns in this era of transparency. Then story at present is that it's pneumonia. So here are a few facts about pneumonia in the elderly (Hillary will be 69 before election day), make of it what you will:

The elderly are more susceptible to pneumonia than younger populations. The prevalence of both disability and comorbid diseases increase with age and are associated with increased risk of pneumonia. Therefore, the elderly constitute a growing proportion of those at risk. The known independent risk factors for pneumonia include alcoholism, asthma, immunosuppression, heart disease, institutionalization, and age greater than 70. The strongest predictors of mortality, at least in community-acquired pneumonia, are BUN greater than 20mg/dL, respiratory rate greater than 30 per breaths minute, and diastolic blood pressure less than 60mmHg. The American Thoracic Society has published practice guidelines for the management of both community-acquired and hospital-acquired pneumonia. These guidelines suggest evaluation, therapy, and work-up of pneumonia patients based upon patient- specific risk factors, age and site of treatment. Pneumococcal species are the most common causative pathogens for pneumonia in the elderly, and the development and utilization of the pneumococcal vaccine was a major public health milestone. However, too few individuals are being vaccinated, perhaps, because pneumococcal pneumonia is more likely to be prevented in low-risk patients who receive the vaccine, (those without risk factors for pneumonia), than in high-risk patients. It appears that overall health status is the most significant factor in determining the risk of morbidity and mortality associated with onset of pneumonia in the elderly.

A number of studies have confirmed that there is a high rate of morbidity and mortality associated with pneumonia in the elderly (Fig. 1).[1-5] These high rates have continued to impede the efforts of healthcare professionals, despite significant improvements in therapeutic options and public health practices. One-sixth of the six million pneumonia cases that are reported each year occur primarily in those individuals 65 years and older requiring hospitalization for pneumonia.[6] Over 90% of all deaths from pneumonia occur in this older population.[7] Currently, individuals over 65 comprise 12% of the population, and by the year 2050 this will increase to 25 percent. By 2020, there will be 65 million individuals over the age of 65 years, all at high risk for pneumonia.


Complete text: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/722306_1
 
If the campaign says she has pneumonia, that's probably the only thing we can say with confidence that she DOESN'T have. They have proven themselves incapable of leveling with the American people.

"Walking pneumonia" is the current narrative because it's just (basically) a bad cold. But she's been coughing bad for nine months, and you don't have "walking pneumonia" for nine months. Whatever she has, it's more than "just" pneumonia.
 
If the campaign says she has pneumonia, that's probably the only thing we can say with confidence that she DOESN'T have. They have proven themselves incapable of leveling with the American people.

"Walking pneumonia" is the current narrative because it's just (basically) a bad cold. But she's been coughing bad for nine months, and you don't have "walking pneumonia" for nine months. Whatever she has, it's more than "just" pneumonia.


I don't know what she has, I can only know what their story is. If you're 68 years old, however, there is no such thing as "just pneumonia"........

Singer James Brown died of congestive heart failure on Monday, a day after being admitted to a Georgia hospital with pneumonia. President Gerald Ford died the day after; he had battled pneumonia earlier this year, and his health then rapidly declined. What makes pneumonia so dangerous for old people?


It makes them more vulnerable to other problems. Because of its rapid onset and ability to spread to other parts of the body (as opposed to a stroke or heart attack), pneumonia can be lethal. Even a milder case deals a severe blow to your immune system, which can turn an underlying condition like heart disease into a life-threatening malady. Since older people often have these additional problems, any sort of pneumonia can have dangerous complications. James Brown's cause of death was officially listed as congestive heart failure, but his pneumonia had likelyweakened his immune system and either aggravated an underlying condition or caused his heart to fail on its own. In general, the more health problems someone has, the more likely it is that a case of pneumonia will turn out to be deadly.




The elderly are also less likely to notice they have pneumonia until it's too late. Younger patients will visit their doctor with symptoms like chills, shortness of breath, and chest pain, but elderly sufferers are often asymptomatic. This is because their immune response is already in a somewhat weakened state. For instance, younger people cough up sputum when congested, the body's natural way of clearing out the lungs. (It's unpleasant, but it is also a healthy response.) People tend to lose lung capacity as they age, which makes it harder for them to cough productively. As a result, they might build up a large amount of sputum without becoming symptomatic. Similarly, elderly patients are less likely to notice the symptoms they do have, since they're so used to feeling ill.



http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2006/12/pneumonia_vs_the_elderly.html
 
I'm not going to pretend I know Hillary's health situation, in part because she guards her health records the way Donald Trump guards his tax returns in this era of transparency. Then story at present is that it's pneumonia. So here are a few facts about pneumonia in the elderly (Hillary will be 69 before election day), make of it what you will:

The elderly are more susceptible to pneumonia than younger populations. The prevalence of both disability and comorbid diseases increase with age and are associated with increased risk of pneumonia. Therefore, the elderly constitute a growing proportion of those at risk. The known independent risk factors for pneumonia include alcoholism, asthma, immunosuppression, heart disease, institutionalization, and age greater than 70. The strongest predictors of mortality, at least in community-acquired pneumonia, are BUN greater than 20mg/dL, respiratory rate greater than 30 per breaths minute, and diastolic blood pressure less than 60mmHg. The American Thoracic Society has published practice guidelines for the management of both community-acquired and hospital-acquired pneumonia. These guidelines suggest evaluation, therapy, and work-up of pneumonia patients based upon patient- specific risk factors, age and site of treatment. Pneumococcal species are the most common causative pathogens for pneumonia in the elderly, and the development and utilization of the pneumococcal vaccine was a major public health milestone. However, too few individuals are being vaccinated, perhaps, because pneumococcal pneumonia is more likely to be prevented in low-risk patients who receive the vaccine, (those without risk factors for pneumonia), than in high-risk patients. It appears that overall health status is the most significant factor in determining the risk of morbidity and mortality associated with onset of pneumonia in the elderly.

A number of studies have confirmed that there is a high rate of morbidity and mortality associated with pneumonia in the elderly (Fig. 1).[1-5] These high rates have continued to impede the efforts of healthcare professionals, despite significant improvements in therapeutic options and public health practices. One-sixth of the six million pneumonia cases that are reported each year occur primarily in those individuals 65 years and older requiring hospitalization for pneumonia.[6] Over 90% of all deaths from pneumonia occur in this older population.[7] Currently, individuals over 65 comprise 12% of the population, and by the year 2050 this will increase to 25 percent. By 2020, there will be 65 million individuals over the age of 65 years, all at high risk for pneumonia.


Complete text: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/722306_1
It's fair to be worried about her health. Pneumonia is no joke in the elderly. But neither is it a death sentence. In the US, there are about 3 million cases of pneumonia reported each year, with about 60,000 dying of it. Since the cases that get reported are going to be disproportionately the most serious cases, including pretty much all those that end in death, that probably overestimates the mortality risk, but even then, the vast majority recover from it. About a third of pneumonia cases occur in those over age 65. There are about 46 million Americans over 65, so pneumonia is hitting about one and a half percent of them per year.

Anyway, logically this shouldn't make a significant difference in the election, since the only people it should really matter to are those who prefer Clinton to Trump, but who also prefer Trump to Kaine, such that their preference of ticket were to change if the top of the Democratic ticket was incapacitated. I'd imagine that's a meaningless percentage of Americans... probably just confined to a few conservative personal friends of the Clintons and a few personal enemies of Kaine. That said, people aren't logical, so it could hit the polling numbers all the same.
 
there are actually 20 different types of germs which cause "pneumonia like" symptoms. most are encountered ONLY in a hospital setting, and have developed a frightening resistance to modern antiobiotics.

what specific strain of pneumonia does Hillary have? where did she likely get it? is it antibiotic resistant? what medicines is she taking?
 
All over our Front Pages too ---- God!

One has to be very very run down to get lung infections of any kind -
As pretty much anyone who follows sports knows, lung infections can hit anyone, including elite young athletes.

http://www.nfl.com/trainingcamp/sto...r-back-at-practice-after-bout-with-bronchitis

http://nypost.com/2014/01/14/knicks-chandler-felled-by-bronchitis/

http://www.detroitnews.com/story/sp...t-sanchez-still-battling-bronchitis/81578418/

I had two straight years, in my late thirties, when I got bronchitis each winter, one of which developed into pneumonia. I haven't had it since and at the time I wasn't particularly run down or unhealthy. Sometimes a bug just gets you.
 
there are actually 20 different types of germs which cause "pneumonia like" symptoms. most are encountered ONLY in a hospital setting, and have developed a frightening resistance to modern antiobiotics.

what specific strain of pneumonia does Hillary have? where did she likely get it? is it antibiotic resistant? what medicines is she taking?
There is not a single bug that is ONLY encountered in a hospital setting.... since, obviously, any bug that is encountered in a hospital setting can be taken out of a hospital setting by someone who contracts in there.
 
there are actually 20 different types of germs which cause "pneumonia like" symptoms. most are encountered ONLY in a hospital setting, and have developed a frightening resistance to modern antiobiotics.

what specific strain of pneumonia does Hillary have? where did she likely get it? is it antibiotic resistant? what medicines is she taking?


The only answers you're likely to receive from Camp Clinton is "Nothing to see here. Everything is great". That may indeed be the case, but the fact is, politicians and their handlers have been known to lie. Since they are not reliable sources of information, people will speculate, and people will be watching Hillary to see if indeed everything is just swell or not.
 
It's fair to be worried about her health. Pneumonia is no joke in the elderly. But neither is it a death sentence. In the US, there are about 3 million cases of pneumonia reported each year, with about 60,000 dying of it. Since the cases that get reported are going to be disproportionately the most serious cases, including pretty much all those that end in death, that probably overestimates the mortality risk, but even then, the vast majority recover from it. About a third of pneumonia cases occur in those over age 65. There are about 46 million Americans over 65, so pneumonia is hitting about one and a half percent of them per year.

Anyway, logically this shouldn't make a significant difference in the election, since the only people it should really matter to are those who prefer Clinton to Trump, but who also prefer Trump to Kaine, such that their preference of ticket were to change if the top of the Democratic ticket was incapacitated. I'd imagine that's a meaningless percentage of Americans... probably just confined to a few conservative personal friends of the Clintons and a few personal enemies of Kaine. That said, people aren't logical, so it could hit the polling numbers all the same.


Whether it is a legitimate concern or not is, of course, for each individual voter to decide for themselves. She'll be 69 before election day, which would qualify her in the eyes of many or possibly most as "elderly", so her health is not a given.

That said, there are multiple reasons not to vote for Hillary, this is just another possible addition to the list.
 
Whether it is a legitimate concern or not is, of course, for each individual voter to decide for themselves.

Agreed. Still, it's just hard to picture the mentality of a voter for whom this concern would make a difference in who to vote for. I mean, even if Clinton were to die tomorrow, would your planned vote change? I suppose mine might, since I'm currently planning a "protest vote" based on Clinton's vote on Iraq in 2002, and so I'd be more likely to vote Democrat in November if she weren't the top of the ticket. But I'd imagine that people like me are a rarity. How many people do you think are supporting the Democratic ticket because they really like Hillary Clinton, personally? My assumption is most people supporting Clinton are doing so out of a general preference for Democratic policies, or out of an opposition to Trump. So, nothing should change for them if she's incapacitated.
 
I don't know what she has, I can only know what their story is. If you're 68 years old, however, there is no such thing as "just pneumonia"........

Singer James Brown died of congestive heart failure on Monday, a day after being admitted to a Georgia hospital with pneumonia. President Gerald Ford died the day after; he had battled pneumonia earlier this year, and his health then rapidly declined. What makes pneumonia so dangerous for old people?


It makes them more vulnerable to other problems. Because of its rapid onset and ability to spread to other parts of the body (as opposed to a stroke or heart attack), pneumonia can be lethal. Even a milder case deals a severe blow to your immune system, which can turn an underlying condition like heart disease into a life-threatening malady. Since older people often have these additional problems, any sort of pneumonia can have dangerous complications. James Brown's cause of death was officially listed as congestive heart failure, but his pneumonia had likelyweakened his immune system and either aggravated an underlying condition or caused his heart to fail on its own. In general, the more health problems someone has, the more likely it is that a case of pneumonia will turn out to be deadly.




The elderly are also less likely to notice they have pneumonia until it's too late. Younger patients will visit their doctor with symptoms like chills, shortness of breath, and chest pain, but elderly sufferers are often asymptomatic. This is because their immune response is already in a somewhat weakened state. For instance, younger people cough up sputum when congested, the body's natural way of clearing out the lungs. (It's unpleasant, but it is also a healthy response.) People tend to lose lung capacity as they age, which makes it harder for them to cough productively. As a result, they might build up a large amount of sputum without becoming symptomatic. Similarly, elderly patients are less likely to notice the symptoms they do have, since they're so used to feeling ill.



http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2006/12/pneumonia_vs_the_elderly.html

The campaign and it's surrogates (hi @Arkady!) picked the wrong condition to lie about. They should have gone with something less serious, like the flu. Covering up a terminal condition by lying about a different condition that has a high rate of fatality was a mistake. I hope their next story is better...
 
The campaign and it's surrogates (hi @Arkady!) picked the wrong condition to lie about. They should have gone with something less serious, like the flu. Covering up a terminal condition by lying about a different condition that has a high rate of fatality was a mistake. I hope their next story is better...
It would have been a mistake for them to lie about her having pneumonia. Yes, it's a fairly serious condition, especially for an older lady. But, it is what it is, and lying about it would merely have given the press something to use against them. Over 98% of people who contract pneumonia recover from it, and presumably Clinton will, as well. The timing of it sucks for her campaign, since the only way to recover is to take it easy for a couple weeks, and the first debate is in less than two weeks. But she'd be wise to just cut her losses and rest. She can read and study up for the debate, but the important thing will be to have her strength back by then, so she should get lots of bed rest. If she shows up for the first debate looking strong and without any coughing problems, the health concerns will fade fast.
 
It would have been a mistake for them to lie about her having pneumonia.

And yet, their first instinct was......

Hillary Clinton’s campaign is coming under fire for failing to disclose that she was diagnosed with pneumonia on Friday, and for saying she simply got “overheated” at the 9/11 memorial service in New York, when video showed her knees buckling as aides helped her into a waiting van.

It wasn’t until shortly after 11:00 a.m. ET Sunday that the campaign put out a terse statement saying that Clinton had “departed to go to her daughter's apartment, and is feeling much better.” There was no explicit acknowledgment that Clinton had left the ceremony earlier than planned, nor any mention of what looked to be a fainting spell.


http://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/hillary-clinton-has-pneumonia-doctor-says-228012


Politicians and their handlers lie (or at least fail to disclose the whole truth) whenever they think they might get away with it. Those who doubt this need look no further than Hillary's husband.
 
I'm not going to pretend I know Hillary's health situation, in part because she guards her health records the way Donald Trump guards his tax returns in this era of transparency. Then story at present is that it's pneumonia. So here are a few facts about pneumonia in the elderly (Hillary will be 69 before election day), make of it what you will:

The elderly are more susceptible to pneumonia than younger populations. The prevalence of both disability and comorbid diseases increase with age and are associated with increased risk of pneumonia. Therefore, the elderly constitute a growing proportion of those at risk. The known independent risk factors for pneumonia include alcoholism, asthma, immunosuppression, heart disease, institutionalization, and age greater than 70. The strongest predictors of mortality, at least in community-acquired pneumonia, are BUN greater than 20mg/dL, respiratory rate greater than 30 per breaths minute, and diastolic blood pressure less than 60mmHg. The American Thoracic Society has published practice guidelines for the management of both community-acquired and hospital-acquired pneumonia. These guidelines suggest evaluation, therapy, and work-up of pneumonia patients based upon patient- specific risk factors, age and site of treatment. Pneumococcal species are the most common causative pathogens for pneumonia in the elderly, and the development and utilization of the pneumococcal vaccine was a major public health milestone. However, too few individuals are being vaccinated, perhaps, because pneumococcal pneumonia is more likely to be prevented in low-risk patients who receive the vaccine, (those without risk factors for pneumonia), than in high-risk patients. It appears that overall health status is the most significant factor in determining the risk of morbidity and mortality associated with onset of pneumonia in the elderly.

A number of studies have confirmed that there is a high rate of morbidity and mortality associated with pneumonia in the elderly (Fig. 1).[1-5] These high rates have continued to impede the efforts of healthcare professionals, despite significant improvements in therapeutic options and public health practices. One-sixth of the six million pneumonia cases that are reported each year occur primarily in those individuals 65 years and older requiring hospitalization for pneumonia.[6] Over 90% of all deaths from pneumonia occur in this older population.[7] Currently, individuals over 65 comprise 12% of the population, and by the year 2050 this will increase to 25 percent. By 2020, there will be 65 million individuals over the age of 65 years, all at high risk for pneumonia.


Complete text: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/722306_1
This article did NOT say pnuemonia was contagious did it? No. Because it's not.
 
The campaign and it's surrogates (hi @Arkady!) picked the wrong condition to lie about. They should have gone with something less serious, like the flu. Covering up a terminal condition by lying about a different condition that has a high rate of fatality was a mistake. I hope their next story is better...
Pneumonia is terminal? No, it isn't unless someone who is already seriously ill catches it. Hillary will be just fine.:)
 
And yet, their first instinct was......

Hillary Clinton’s campaign is coming under fire for failing to disclose that she was diagnosed with pneumonia on Friday, and for saying she simply got “overheated” at the 9/11 memorial service in New York, when video showed her knees buckling as aides helped her into a waiting van.

It wasn’t until shortly after 11:00 a.m. ET Sunday that the campaign put out a terse statement saying that Clinton had “departed to go to her daughter's apartment, and is feeling much better.” There was no explicit acknowledgment that Clinton had left the ceremony earlier than planned, nor any mention of what looked to be a fainting spell.


http://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/hillary-clinton-has-pneumonia-doctor-says-228012


Politicians and their handlers lie (or at least fail to disclose the whole truth) whenever they think they might get away with it. Those who doubt this need look no further than Hillary's husband.
It was certainly a mistake, but it's not hard to see where they were coming from. Disclosing it played into the "Clinton's dying" right-wing meme, and so they probably thought that if it was something minor that would pass shortly, there would be no point feeding the right-wing propaganda that way.... especially with her feeling well enough to attend public events. After she worsened, they felt compelled to come clean. They'd have done better to get ahead of it by reporting her condition Friday.
 
there are actually 20 different types of germs which cause "pneumonia like" symptoms. most are encountered ONLY in a hospital setting, and have developed a frightening resistance to modern antiobiotics.

what specific strain of pneumonia does Hillary have? where did she likely get it? is it antibiotic resistant? what medicines is she taking?
If what you say is true, everyone who works in hospitals should be sick all the time.:oops:
 
Back
Top