New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Humiliating

Don't think anybody is suggesting that there was a clean way to get out of there. What is under discussion is the shitty way that we exited, thereby allowing for the collapse of the Afghani government, and not to mention the abandoning of our allies and supporters in the area, oh and not to mention American citizens left to live in terror of the Taliban while awaiting extraction
You see/hear anyone providing specific details for a bloodless withdrawal?
 
You see/hear anyone providing specific details for a bloodless withdrawal?

no, were there supposed to be?

the details we have involve an abrupt withdrawal, coupled with a collapse that left American and ally lives imperiled. does the president wield powers that could have mitigated that?
 
Why did they do that?
Because they intended to do that all along. Taking what we offered them while we there was the easy way out. The easy way out is gone. We shoulda been outta there long ago. GWB, Obama and Trump didn't have the political courage to do it.
 
These righties have some FALSE belief the greatest loser would have done better........ yeah...........that is why he left it for Biden and ignored it for 4 years after all those ego speech applause lines !
Everybody knows the greatest loser was Jimmah Cahtah. Todays loser is Biden's handlers. Clearly if Biden is being instructed (as Biden says) on he can and can't say then he Biden didn't win.
 
Because they intended to do that all along. Taking what we offered them while we there was the easy way out. The easy way out is gone. We shoulda been outta there long ago. GWB, Obama and Trump didn't have the political courage to do it.
Are you affirming that we did indeed know that? If so why did we abandon The Afghani government and our allies, not to mention contractors and American citizens left to suffer the terror of not knowing whether they would make it out or not?
 
Everybody knows the greatest loser was Jimmah Cahtah. Todays loser is Biden's handlers. Clearly if Biden is being instructed (as Biden says) on he can and can't say then he Biden didn't win.

The most powerful man in America said he has to have permission to answer questions!
 
Are you affirming that we did indeed know that?
I think some military people knew it.

If so why did we abandon The Afghani government and our allies, not to mention contractors and American citizens left to suffer the terror of not knowing whether they would make it out or not?
How many of those you think could've been quietly pulled out before everyone knew what was happening? You think we should've sent more troops in to make withdrawal more orderly?


What was your plan for an orderly, clean withdrawal from Afghanistan? I'd love to hear it.
 
I think some military people knew it.


How many of those you think could've been quietly pulled out before everyone knew what was happening? You think we should've sent more troops in to make withdrawal more orderly?


What was your plan for an orderly, clean withdrawal from Afghanistan? I'd love to hear it.
I don't follow.. we've built up a massive military apparatus there. You and I both know, having experienced it over the years, that we're capable of executing massive airstrikes across the entirety of the region. I would imagine that some small flexing of that might, but a temporary increase in force, and or coupled with an increase in airstrikes such that they might forestall the advance of the Taliban long enough for us to exit..

Is it or is it not true that the media, posters here, and others have regaled our efforts to date to remove our people and others as one of the most massive mobilizations... I think I read somewhere since Dunkirk..

PS I didn't say anything about clean or orderly... But something above a shit show probably could have been achieved.
 
I would imagine that some small flexing of that might, but a temporary increase in force, and or coupled with an increase in airstrikes such that they might forestall the advance of the Taliban long enough for us to exit..
You think that could've been achieved without civilian casualties? Who do you think would've been reamed for those casualties?
 
You think that could've been achieved without civilian casualties? Who do you think would've been reamed for those casualties?
No I don't think it could have been achieved without civilian casualties.

Do you think we could have done better than we did?
 
Do you think we could have done better than we did?
I don't know. I'm not a military adviser. Anyone who thinks we could have done better but can't say specifically how in detail is just a Monday morning quarterback whose opinion means no more than mine.
 
I don't know. I'm not a military adviser. Anyone who thinks we could have done better but can't say specifically how in detail is just a Monday morning quarterback whose opinion means no more than mine.
Really? Well...that's odd...we've witnessed what American military and air superiority have done in the past to at the very least keep the Taliban at bay. Surely you can concede that that has occurred?

And, having all witnessed that's such a thing is indeed possible, it's not much of a stretch to surmise that it could have been achieved yet again... At least to the degree that it would have kept the Taliban at Bay long enough for us to affect an orderly exit.

Don't you think? Or would you rather pretend that somebody needs to provide some exquisite level of detail such that they may avoid being branded and Monday morning quarterback, in light of the facts of the past 20 years.....
?
 
no, were there supposed to be?

the details we have involve an abrupt withdrawal, coupled with a collapse that left American and ally lives imperiled. does the president wield powers that could have mitigated that?

Abrupt? You mean the one announced in Trump's surrender document in February 2020? The one with a deadline of May 1st 2021? Oh, and then extended to August 31st?

Yeah, that was abrupt.
 
Really? Well...that's odd...we've witnessed what American military and air superiority have done in the past to at the very least keep the Taliban at bay. Surely you can concede that that has occurred?

And, having all witnessed that's such a thing is indeed possible, it's not much of a stretch to surmise that it could have been achieved yet again... At least to the degree that it would have kept the Taliban at Bay long enough for us to affect an orderly exit.

Don't you think? Or would you rather pretend that somebody needs to provide some exquisite level of detail such that they may avoid being branded and Monday morning quarterback, in light of the facts of the past 20 years.....
?
air support alone could not keep the Taliban at bay....anymore than it did in Vietnam with far more resources applied to the war.

The US stopped providing air support in March 2020.

The US was able to use air support in Iraq, because there was still a functioning Iraqi army sufficient to stand against ISIS.
 
Back
Top