New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

If Israel Attacks

BitterPill

The Shoe Cometh
Supporting Member
I've been thinking, regarding the presidency, who would benefit if Israel attacked Iran this spring.

The stock market would fritz, oil prices would skyrocket, and our building recovery would likely be short-circuited, so I'd have to say Romney.

Now, the Obama Administration probably figured that out, and it probably went to the Israelis and asked, "If you are going to attack Iran, please wait until after the election," but would the current Israeli leadership listen?

The current Israeli leadership is in a unique position to affect our upcoming election to its benefit. The Likud government could attack Iran before the election knowing that whatever the repercussions from an Obama Administration, they would likely be over with a Romney presidency.

Romney's foreign policy team is chock-full of neocons who, presumably, would welcome war with Iran even if it were due to an Israeli manipulation.
 
...if Israel attacks Iran, they are on their F'IN own - good luck with that...

...we all somehow act as though if Iran gets the bomb we are all doomed. Are we that out of touch to believe that if any terrorist group wanted to get nuclear materials/weapons to use against us they could only get them from Iran and couldn't get them from Pakistan, India, DPRK or Russia?

...ugh
 
In the long slide down the banister of life Israel is a big splinter up the arse, imho!
 
Yes, Wulk - that sentiment rings loud and clear in all of your posts. You fly to the issue in multiple forum categories here and are unwavering in your support of Iran. So it goes.
 
I'd agree that it benefits a GOP challenger to an extent. However the electorate can be wary of switching horses in dire times as well. Tough to plot out a finicky public.
 
I continue to believe that Iran/nukes is but one of many "political tools" being employed by umpteen different entities, from the Iranians themselves, to the U.S., to Israel, to the EU, to Russia, China, and pan-Islam.

So, I continue to believe we're naive to expect that the Israelis would "attack" Iran, as a purely practical matter. They would only do so, if their plan had all their political ducks in a row, and stars aligned. Even in my well-fertilized imagination, I'm having a hard time seeing how they do that right now. SO....I don't see them attacking Iran.

And for what it's worth...I have no problem with the world playing this political game, so my above ramble shouldn't be interpreted as being the least bit dismissive of the Israelis.
 
Again...advantage Republican nominee. If Israel attacks Iran and we don't offer aid and support to Israel...Obama loses a huge voting block from the Jewish Community. And, in my opinion, he's going to need everything he had last time to show the same loyalty this time.
 
...I could give a rats a$$ about political support. What I do care about is American soldiers and citizens. Fact - Iran does NOT pose a threat to the US - or at least any more of a threat than DPRK, Pakistan, China or Russia for that matter...
 
Why is it that those states that have nuclear capability feel it is their right to declare/insist that Iran not be so equipped? Israel will not even allow their nuclear arsenal (they say 260 nuclear weapons) to be inspected, yet don't want Iran to be able to defend themselves against those? Is there anyone who actually believes that a nuclear war will happen? Who would be stupid enuf to anihilate the entire world? Israel attacking Iran would be as insane as invading Iraq...
 
I really prefer not to think of an Israeli attack on Iran in terms of how it would benefit US politics. It would, in general, be a very bad thing that could have world-wide repercussions and none of those repercussions would be good ones as far as I can tell.
 
...I do not support nuclear proliferation but if a country has the collective will and resources there really is no way to stop the development of that or worse down the road...

...if Israel were to attack Iran, it indeed would be insanity and quite possibly/regrettably an end to Israel
 
...here is an interesting perspective:

"Ken Pollack, a former White House and CIA official with expertise on the Gulf, said the sudden rise in public discussion of an Israeli strike on Iran's known nuclear sites -- including increasingly dire warnings from leaders in Jerusalem -- were misleading.

"If Israel has a good military option, they just take it, they don't talk about it, they don't give warnings," said Pollack, director of the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at the Brookings Institution. "So the fact that they are talking about it, to me, is one tip-off that they don't have a good military option.

"We should never rule out the possibility of an Israeli strike and the odds have probably increased in recent months as a result of a number of different factors. But ... there are a lot of disincentives that have prevented Israel from launching a strike for 10 years," Pollack said."

http://www.jpost.com/IranianThreat/News/Article.aspx?id=256376
 
...here is an interesting perspective:

"Ken Pollack, a former White House and CIA official with expertise on the Gulf, said the sudden rise in public discussion of an Israeli strike on Iran's known nuclear sites -- including increasingly dire warnings from leaders in Jerusalem -- were misleading.

"If Israel has a good military option, they just take it, they don't talk about it, they don't give warnings," said Pollack, director of the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at the Brookings Institution. "So the fact that they are talking about it, to me, is one tip-off that they don't have a good military option.

"We should never rule out the possibility of an Israeli strike and the odds have probably increased in recent months as a result of a number of different factors. But ... there are a lot of disincentives that have prevented Israel from launching a strike for 10 years," Pollack said."

http://www.jpost.com/IranianThreat/News/Article.aspx?id=256376

On this note, it's just as likely (if not considerably more), that the Israeli politic planted this news leakage in order to get everyone shouting about what they will do, can do, or might do.....with the express intention of scoring points by NOT doing it.

It will be very interesting to watch how the politico-shouting around this one, goes down over the next 6 months.
 
I'm not arguing that whatsoever and not making a political jab or statement, just an observation or offering an opinion to your initial post...I wasn't happy regarding Iraq and the extension of Afghanistan (should have been limited to find bin Laden), either. Just adding to the conversation...sorry if you took it otherwise.
 
I really prefer not to think of an Israeli attack on Iran in terms of how it would benefit US politics. It would, in general, be a very bad thing that could have world-wide repercussions and none of those repercussions would be good ones as far as I can tell.

I totally agree.
 
Exorbitantly high gas price spikes. Muslim extremist retaliations on US soil. Forced to spend more money that we don't have to spend. Not to mention damaged (permanently?) relations with one of our previously best allies. And the list goes on and on....
 
good point Gabe. the oil corps need this to raise the price of crude for a long enough period of time to make it worth their heavy investment in the tar sands... IOW, there's the real reason for this war.
 
Back
Top