Arkady
President
There's been a very healthy debate going on about whether it's legal for Obama to use US forces in Syria without Congressional authorization (or even in the face of clear Congressional opposition). But the truth is, there's no honest controversy on the subject. There's a federal law, which has survived on the books for 40 years, and for which there's no plausible Constitutional objection, that says the president can't send armed forces into hostilities unless there's been a declaration of war by Congress, or a statutory authorization for that use of force, or a national emergency created by attack on the US, its territories or possession, or its armed forces.
There are situations where an honest debate can be had about whether that law's conditions are satisfied. For example, if one of our allies is attacked or believes it's under imminent threat of attack, and calls for our help, then if there's a ratified mutual defense treaty with that ally, you can argue that the treaty amounts to the Congressional authorization required by the War Powers Resolution, so using force that way would be permissible, even without express Congressional authorization related to that particular incident. You could make similar arguments for attacks waged under the auspices of NATO (in relation to a threat against NATO nations), or under the UN, since those international organizations have treaties ratifying them under US law -- you can at least argue that Congress meant to allow for that kind of indirect authorization by way of an approved multi-national body. But, when it comes to something like bombing Libya or Syria, there's really no honest debate to be had. If Obama were to order such an attack, without Congressional authorization, he'd be violating federal law. And if ordering American service men to do something illegal with a very high probability of resulting in the deaths of human beings isn't a "high crime or misdemeanor," then what is?
That said, a more honest debate could be had about whether Obama's initial threat against Syria (the "red line" comment) was also criminal. The War Powers Resolution doesn't deal with that. Anyway, as you'll recall, Obama referred to the possibility of Syria using poison gas as a "red line" that would trigger "enormous consequences." Many pro-war politicians have argued that we're basically compelled to invade now, to maintain any national credibility. But if that kind of threat can really, in a de facto sense, commit us to war, then even uttering that comment is effectively the same as attacking.... and the president who made the threat without Congressional authorization has already crossed a "red line" of his own, that should have enormous legal consequences for him.
Ultimately, I don't think Obama committed an impeachable offense when he made that threat, but that's because I disagree with the pro-war people who think we're effectively compelled to invade now. Obama's comments were ill-advised, but he didn't specify what kind of consequences there would be -- at most, it was a strong hint. If Syria were to attack us on the basis of that threat, they'd be the one in the wrong -- Obama didn't really force their hand. You could at least argue that he was warning of intensified sanctions or arming Syria's neighbors or calling for something in the UN, etc. It's the difference between telling someone "insult me again and you're not going to like the results" and telling him "insult me again and I'm going to come to your house and put a bullet in your head."
Obama should rightly be faulted for the looseness of his "red line" rhetoric, which implicitly promised consequences he has no lawful authority to deliver on. But he kept things vague enough that I don't think that, in itself, should be regarded as a crime. He won't have committed an impeachable offense, in relation to Syria, unless he actually engages our forces in hostilities without Congressional authorization.
There are situations where an honest debate can be had about whether that law's conditions are satisfied. For example, if one of our allies is attacked or believes it's under imminent threat of attack, and calls for our help, then if there's a ratified mutual defense treaty with that ally, you can argue that the treaty amounts to the Congressional authorization required by the War Powers Resolution, so using force that way would be permissible, even without express Congressional authorization related to that particular incident. You could make similar arguments for attacks waged under the auspices of NATO (in relation to a threat against NATO nations), or under the UN, since those international organizations have treaties ratifying them under US law -- you can at least argue that Congress meant to allow for that kind of indirect authorization by way of an approved multi-national body. But, when it comes to something like bombing Libya or Syria, there's really no honest debate to be had. If Obama were to order such an attack, without Congressional authorization, he'd be violating federal law. And if ordering American service men to do something illegal with a very high probability of resulting in the deaths of human beings isn't a "high crime or misdemeanor," then what is?
That said, a more honest debate could be had about whether Obama's initial threat against Syria (the "red line" comment) was also criminal. The War Powers Resolution doesn't deal with that. Anyway, as you'll recall, Obama referred to the possibility of Syria using poison gas as a "red line" that would trigger "enormous consequences." Many pro-war politicians have argued that we're basically compelled to invade now, to maintain any national credibility. But if that kind of threat can really, in a de facto sense, commit us to war, then even uttering that comment is effectively the same as attacking.... and the president who made the threat without Congressional authorization has already crossed a "red line" of his own, that should have enormous legal consequences for him.
Ultimately, I don't think Obama committed an impeachable offense when he made that threat, but that's because I disagree with the pro-war people who think we're effectively compelled to invade now. Obama's comments were ill-advised, but he didn't specify what kind of consequences there would be -- at most, it was a strong hint. If Syria were to attack us on the basis of that threat, they'd be the one in the wrong -- Obama didn't really force their hand. You could at least argue that he was warning of intensified sanctions or arming Syria's neighbors or calling for something in the UN, etc. It's the difference between telling someone "insult me again and you're not going to like the results" and telling him "insult me again and I'm going to come to your house and put a bullet in your head."
Obama should rightly be faulted for the looseness of his "red line" rhetoric, which implicitly promised consequences he has no lawful authority to deliver on. But he kept things vague enough that I don't think that, in itself, should be regarded as a crime. He won't have committed an impeachable offense, in relation to Syria, unless he actually engages our forces in hostilities without Congressional authorization.