New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Improper Threats

What Congressional approval did George Walker Bush get for invading Iraq??? What approval has any US president gotten in 4o years for missile strikes on many countries by many presidents??? Answer: NONE.

EXACTLY
While they were still digging bodies out of those barracks in Lebanon. Ronnie saddled up and went it alone. He put troops on the ground and overthrew a govt as the world decried his actions.

appears the blown to hell barracks was a Threat On America........
 
What Congressional approval did George Walker Bush get for invading Iraq??? What approval has any US president gotten in 4o years for missile strikes on many countries by many presidents??? Answer: NONE.


Ahem:

On Oct. 10 and 11, 2002, the US House of Representatives and the US Senate, respectively, voted on HJRes 114, the "Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution of 2002" (58 KB) ausiraq.procon.org_files_usiraq_pdf_logo.gif. This legislation, authorizing President George W. Bush to "use the Armed Forces of the United States as he determines to be necessary and appropriate" against Iraq, was passed by 70% of the House and Senate.

http://usiraq.procon.org/view.additional-resource.php?resourceID=001987
 
No. But only in the US is participation in an anti-chemical weapons treaty seen as a de facto promise to launch a military attack against any country that uses them (or at least any country that we don't like that uses them).

Not really. Every signatory to such a treaty holds responsibility for enforcement. Without enforcement, such treaties don't mean jack-shit, do they? America is most likely to take a leadership role in any such endeavor. It looks like some of our partners have cold feet. Maybe the evidence isn't convincing enough to sway them? Maybe they have ulterior motives? I don't know. I don't think that the US should act alone, but I don't have a problem with the US showing international diplomatic leadership.

I'd prefer world peace, but this isn't a beauty pageant.
 
appears the blown to hell barracks was a Threat On America........

Maybe so ? But Ronnie hightailed it out of Lebanon where that threat was. Grenada on the other hand had nothing to do with an attack half a world away from their tiny island in the Caribbean
 
Why do some continue to fixate on the actions of past Presidents? If they violated the Constitution, impeach them.

Why do you people wish to deflect the decisions to be made and actions that might be made now by saying "well, 10, 20, 30 years ago this guy violated it...why can't Obama?"

For those of you who want to bring up Reagan, Bush, etc...do you support or oppose what Obama has said and is proposing we should do? What say you Gordo, Zoar, Spam?

FYI, I'm not going to play the answering a question with another question...if you want me to answer a question; answer mine first...if you have the integrity to do so.
 
The top-poster's certitude around the "War Powers Resolution", begs the question of why if he's SO certain that this law is inviolate, he's never put together a legal team to challenge what he must feel are its multiple violations. Either he's not so sure of himself, OR...he prefers to bloviate his feelings under his cloak of anonymity and hasn't the nuggets to put his feelings to the actual test.
 
Why do some continue to fixate on the actions of past Presidents? If they violated the Constitution, impeach them.

Why do you people wish to deflect the decisions to be made and actions that might be made now by saying "well, 10, 20, 30 years ago this guy violated it...why can't Obama?"

For those of you who want to bring up Reagan, Bush, etc...do you support or oppose what Obama has said and is proposing we should do? What say you Gordo, Zoar, Spam?

FYI, I'm not going to play the answering a question with another question...if you want me to answer a question; answer mine first...if you have the integrity to do so.

Even as you didn't ask, I'm not sure that this one's the best "test case" for this argument - at least at this point, since Obama has specifically asked for Congressional approval! Nevertheless, I think we Americans gotta suck it up and accept the decisions that our elected Commander-in-Chiefs make - whether it be Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush, or Obama. If we don't like their calls, we can do as we did back in '68 and refuse to reelect them.
 
There's been a very healthy debate going on about whether it's legal for Obama to use US forces in Syria without Congressional authorization (or even in the face of clear Congressional opposition). But the truth is, there's no honest controversy on the subject. There's a federal law, which has survived on the books for 40 years, and for which there's no plausible Constitutional objection, that says the president can't send armed forces into hostilities unless there's been a declaration of war by Congress, or a statutory authorization for that use of force, or a national emergency created by attack on the US, its territories or possession, or its armed forces.

There are situations where an honest debate can be had about whether that law's conditions are satisfied. For example, if one of our allies is attacked or believes it's under imminent threat of attack, and calls for our help, then if there's a ratified mutual defense treaty with that ally, you can argue that the treaty amounts to the Congressional authorization required by the War Powers Resolution, so using force that way would be permissible, even without express Congressional authorization related to that particular incident. You could make similar arguments for attacks waged under the auspices of NATO (in relation to a threat against NATO nations), or under the UN, since those international organizations have treaties ratifying them under US law -- you can at least argue that Congress meant to allow for that kind of indirect authorization by way of an approved multi-national body. But, when it comes to something like bombing Libya or Syria, there's really no honest debate to be had. If Obama were to order such an attack, without Congressional authorization, he'd be violating federal law. And if ordering American service men to do something illegal with a very high probability of resulting in the deaths of human beings isn't a "high crime or misdemeanor," then what is?

That said, a more honest debate could be had about whether Obama's initial threat against Syria (the "red line" comment) was also criminal. The War Powers Resolution doesn't deal with that. Anyway, as you'll recall, Obama referred to the possibility of Syria using poison gas as a "red line" that would trigger "enormous consequences." Many pro-war politicians have argued that we're basically compelled to invade now, to maintain any national credibility. But if that kind of threat can really, in a de facto sense, commit us to war, then even uttering that comment is effectively the same as attacking.... and the president who made the threat without Congressional authorization has already crossed a "red line" of his own, that should have enormous legal consequences for him.

Ultimately, I don't think Obama committed an impeachable offense when he made that threat, but that's because I disagree with the pro-war people who think we're effectively compelled to invade now. Obama's comments were ill-advised, but he didn't specify what kind of consequences there would be -- at most, it was a strong hint. If Syria were to attack us on the basis of that threat, they'd be the one in the wrong -- Obama didn't really force their hand. You could at least argue that he was warning of intensified sanctions or arming Syria's neighbors or calling for something in the UN, etc. It's the difference between telling someone "insult me again and you're not going to like the results" and telling him "insult me again and I'm going to come to your house and put a bullet in your head."

Obama should rightly be faulted for the looseness of his "red line" rhetoric, which implicitly promised consequences he has no lawful authority to deliver on. But he kept things vague enough that I don't think that, in itself, should be regarded as a crime. He won't have committed an impeachable offense, in relation to Syria, unless he actually engages our forces in hostilities without Congressional authorization.


Well, it could be argued that it's illegal (or at least a violation of the UN Charter) under international law to be making threats to begin with.

All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter1.shtml
​
I'd also add that a broad interpretation of the WPA of 1973 wouldn't make it necessarily illegal under US law if he did it without congressional authorization.

I would question too, whether or not it would be impeachable, in theory and practice.

"High" in the legal and common parlance of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries of "high crimes" signifies activity by or against those who have special duties acquired by taking an oath of office that are not shared with common persons.[1] A high crime is one that can only be done by someone in a unique position of authority, which is political in character, who does things to circumvent justice. The phrase "high crimes and misdemeanors" when used together was a common phrase at the time the U.S. Constitution was written and did not mean any stringent or difficult criteria for determining guilt. It meant the opposite. The phrase was historically used to cover a very broad range of crimes.
In the Washington Post reprinting of the Judiciary Committee's review of Impeachment in 1974, the review states, ""High Crimes and Misdemeanors" has traditionally been considered a "term of art", like such other constitutional phrases as "levying war" and "due process." Chief The Supreme Court has held that such phrases must be construed, not according to modern usage, but according to what the framers meant when they adopted them. Justice Marshall wrote of another such phrase:
"It is a technical term. It is used in a very old statute of that country whose language is our language, and whose laws form the substratum of our laws. It is scarcely conceivable that the term was not employed by the framers of our constitution in the sense which had been affixed to it by those from whom we borrowed it."[citation needed]
The constitutional convention adopted “high crimes and misdemeanors” with little discussion. Most of the framers knew the phrase well.[citation needed] Since 1386, the English parliament had used the term “high crimes and misdemeanors” to describe one of the grounds to impeach officials of the crown. Officials accused of “high crimes and misdemeanors” were accused of offenses as varied as misappropriating government funds, appointing unfit subordinates, not prosecuting cases, not spending money allocated by Parliament, promoting themselves ahead of more deserving candidates, threatening a grand jury, disobeying an order from Parliament, arresting a man to keep him from running for Parliament, losing a ship by neglecting to moor it, helping “suppress petitions to the King to call a Parliament,” granting warrants without cause, and bribery.[citation needed] Some of these charges were crimes. Others were not. The one common denominator in all these accusations was that the official had somehow abused the power of his office and was unfit to serve.[citation needed]
As can be found in[2] historical references of the period, the phrase in its original meaning is interpreted as "for whatever reason whatsoever". High indicates a type of very serious crime, and misdemeanors indicates crimes that are minor. Therefore this phrase covers all or any crime that abuses office. Benjamin Franklin asserted that the power of impeachment and removal was necessary for those times when the Executive "rendered himself obnoxious," and the Constitution should provide for the "regular punishment of the Executive when his conduct should deserve it, and for his honorable acquittal when he should be unjustly accused." James Madison said, "...impeachment... was indispensable" to defend the community against "the incapacity, negligence or perfidy of the chief Magistrate." With a single executive, Madison argued, unlike a legislature whose collective nature provided security, "loss of capacity or corruption was more within the compass of probable events, and either of them might be fatal to the Republic."[3]
 
Why do some continue to fixate on the actions of past Presidents? If they violated the Constitution, impeach them.

Why do you people wish to deflect the decisions to be made and actions that might be made now by saying "well, 10, 20, 30 years ago this guy violated it...why can't Obama?"

For those of you who want to bring up Reagan, Bush, etc...do you support or oppose what Obama has said and is proposing we should do? What say you Gordo, Zoar, Spam?

FYI, I'm not going to play the answering a question with another question...if you want me to answer a question; answer mine first...if you have the integrity to do so.

I do not support attacking Syria. However it is relevant to bring up the actions of Reagan, Bush 1 and Bush 2 because righties have been practicing Double Standards: they say Obama cannot do what Reagan or Bush 1 did or he will be impeached. That is the point. And yes it is relevant.
 
Why do some continue to fixate on the actions of past Presidents? If they violated the Constitution, impeach them.

Why do you people wish to deflect the decisions to be made and actions that might be made now by saying "well, 10, 20, 30 years ago this guy violated it...why can't Obama?"

For those of you who want to bring up Reagan, Bush, etc...do you support or oppose what Obama has said and is proposing we should do? What say you Gordo, Zoar, Spam?

FYI, I'm not going to play the answering a question with another question...if you want me to answer a question; answer mine first...if you have the integrity to do so.

I do not support attacking Syria. However it is relevant to bring up the actions of Reagan, Bush 1 and Bush 2 because righties have been practicing Double Standards: they say Obama cannot do what Reagan or Bush 1 did or he will be impeached. That is the point. And yes it is relevant.
 
Ahem:

On Oct. 10 and 11, 2002, the US House of Representatives and the US Senate, respectively, voted on HJRes 114, the "Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution of 2002" (58 KB) View attachment 23479. This legislation, authorizing President George W. Bush to "use the Armed Forces of the United States as he determines to be necessary and appropriate" against Iraq, was passed by 70% of the House and Senate.

http://usiraq.procon.org/view.additional-resource.php?resourceID=001987
My typo. I meant George Hurbert Bush. Not W.
 
Well, it could be argued that it's illegal (or at least a violation of the UN Charter) under international law to be making threats to begin with.

All Members shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter1.shtml
​
I'd also add that a broad interpretation of the WPA of 1973 wouldn't make it necessarily illegal under US law if he did it without congressional authorization.

I would question too, whether or not it would be impeachable, in theory and practice.

"High" in the legal and common parlance of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries of "high crimes" signifies activity by or against those who have special duties acquired by taking an oath of office that are not shared with common persons.[1] A high crime is one that can only be done by someone in a unique position of authority, which is political in character, who does things to circumvent justice. The phrase "high crimes and misdemeanors" when used together was a common phrase at the time the U.S. Constitution was written and did not mean any stringent or difficult criteria for determining guilt. It meant the opposite. The phrase was historically used to cover a very broad range of crimes.
In the Washington Post reprinting of the Judiciary Committee's review of Impeachment in 1974, the review states, ""High Crimes and Misdemeanors" has traditionally been considered a "term of art", like such other constitutional phrases as "levying war" and "due process." Chief The Supreme Court has held that such phrases must be construed, not according to modern usage, but according to what the framers meant when they adopted them. Justice Marshall wrote of another such phrase:
"It is a technical term. It is used in a very old statute of that country whose language is our language, and whose laws form the substratum of our laws. It is scarcely conceivable that the term was not employed by the framers of our constitution in the sense which had been affixed to it by those from whom we borrowed it."[citation needed]
The constitutional convention adopted “high crimes and misdemeanors” with little discussion. Most of the framers knew the phrase well.[citation needed] Since 1386, the English parliament had used the term “high crimes and misdemeanors” to describe one of the grounds to impeach officials of the crown. Officials accused of “high crimes and misdemeanors” were accused of offenses as varied as misappropriating government funds, appointing unfit subordinates, not prosecuting cases, not spending money allocated by Parliament, promoting themselves ahead of more deserving candidates, threatening a grand jury, disobeying an order from Parliament, arresting a man to keep him from running for Parliament, losing a ship by neglecting to moor it, helping “suppress petitions to the King to call a Parliament,” granting warrants without cause, and bribery.[citation needed] Some of these charges were crimes. Others were not. The one common denominator in all these accusations was that the official had somehow abused the power of his office and was unfit to serve.[citation needed]
As can be found in[2] historical references of the period, the phrase in its original meaning is interpreted as "for whatever reason whatsoever". High indicates a type of very serious crime, and misdemeanors indicates crimes that are minor. Therefore this phrase covers all or any crime that abuses office. Benjamin Franklin asserted that the power of impeachment and removal was necessary for those times when the Executive "rendered himself obnoxious," and the Constitution should provide for the "regular punishment of the Executive when his conduct should deserve it, and for his honorable acquittal when he should be unjustly accused." James Madison said, "...impeachment... was indispensable" to defend the community against "the incapacity, negligence or perfidy of the chief Magistrate." With a single executive, Madison argued, unlike a legislature whose collective nature provided security, "loss of capacity or corruption was more within the compass of probable events, and either of them might be fatal to the Republic."[3]

I agree that, in practice, it won't be impeachable. However, I think in theory it clearly is. I can come up with no good-faith reading of the WPA, no matter how broad, that would say Obama can intervene in Syria absent a direct or indirect authorization by Congress. As such, if he orders military intervention there, he's ordering military personnel to do something illegal under federal law that will almost certainly result in human deaths. The felony murder idea is that a person can be convicted of murder for felonious actions that he knew were highly likely to result in people being killed, if people actually are killed. That would make Obama's actions fall snugly into the felony murder category. If even something that severe isn't a "high crime or misdemeanor," we may as well just strike that language from the Constitution, like so much else, because it will have been reduced to functional meaninglessness.

I'd imagine that if you could bring the Framers of the Constitution forward in time to analyze this situation, they'd say that of course the Congress would have the rightful authority, if they chose, to remove Obama from office if he ignored their will and got the US involved in a war with Syria, when the Constitution had clearly put the war-declaring power in the hands of Congress, and Congress had reestablished and clarified that restriction with the War Powers Resolution. If the president can't be removed from office for usurping Congress's rightful power in that kind of premeditated way, with such severe potential consequences for the Republic (making us a target for retaliation and possibly drawing us into a wider war), then what meaning would the Constitutional system of checks and balances even have?
 
My typo. I meant George Hurbert Bush. Not W.


Oh. In that case:



Six weeks after Iraq invaded Kuwait, President George H.W. Bush went before a joint session of Congress on this day in 1990 to lay out the administration’s response to the attack.



With a large U.S. military buildup already under way in the Middle East, the president outlined a series of goals. They included the unconditional withdrawal of Iraqi forces, the restoration of the Kuwaiti government, the promotion of security and stability in the region and the safety of U.S. citizens trapped in Kuwait and Iraq.



“Iraq will not be permitted to annex Kuwait,” Bush told the lawmakers in the presence of foreign diplomats, including the Iraqi ambassador. “And that’s not a threat, not a boast. It’s just the way it’s going to be.”



“Out of these troubled times,” Bush went on to say, “... a new world order can emerge: a new era, freer from the threat of terror, stronger in the pursuit of justice and more secure in the quest for peace.”



The president used the crisis to urge the Democratic-led Congress to approve a stalled budget agreement and to support enhanced domestic oil exploration and production.



Reflecting broad public support for the president’s Iraq policies, Rep. Dick Gephardt (D-Mo.), the majority leader, said, “Here at home, the sense of unity and the absence of widespread opposition to this action in the Persian Gulf testify to our powerful, instinctive feeling that this is a cause worth standing and fighting for.”




In early 1991, by a vote of 250-183, the House passed the Persian Gulf Resolution, authorizing Bush to use force against the Iraqi military. This soon led to a successful effort to expel the invaders from Kuwait — under the umbrella of a broad coalition based in Saudi Arabia that included Syrian and Egyptian forces.


http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0909/26997.html



I'd say try again, but I think you're out of Bush's.
 
Not really. Every signatory to such a treaty holds responsibility for enforcement. Without enforcement, such treaties don't mean jack-shit, do they? America is most likely to take a leadership role in any such endeavor. It looks like some of our partners have cold feet. Maybe the evidence isn't convincing enough to sway them? Maybe they have ulterior motives? I don't know. I don't think that the US should act alone, but I don't have a problem with the US showing international diplomatic leadership.

I'd prefer world peace, but this isn't a beauty pageant.
I'm not saying we don't enforce it. I'm saying we aren't required, any more than the scores of other nations are required, to launch military strikes based on it. As you well know, we are signatories to countless treaties that various countries are in violation of (including some allies of ours), and yet we don't typically attack them. For that matter, when we attacked Iraq, we were violating the UN Charter, which we had ratified as a treaty obligation, and yet it's not like all the other UN Charter signatories were compelled to bomb us in retaliation for that breach. We all know that unless a treaty expressly requires a country to attack another country in a specific situation, there's no implicit obligation to do so. If you want the US to show international diplomatic leadership, as you say, how about starting by not violating the UN Charter by attacking Syria without a UN Security Council authorization?
 
Last edited:
The top-poster's certitude around the "War Powers Resolution", begs the question of why if he's SO certain that this law is inviolate, he's never put together a legal team to challenge what he must feel are its multiple violations. Either he's not so sure of himself, OR...he prefers to bloviate his feelings under his cloak of anonymity and hasn't the nuggets to put his feelings to the actual test.
The courts would rule I lack standing. In this country, the courts bend over backwards to avoid getting in a position where they give private citizens any power over our leaders.
 
The courts would rule I lack standing. In this country, the courts bend over backwards to avoid getting in a position where they give private citizens any power over our leaders.


What an odd concept... Elected leaders having authority over citizens.

What's the world coming to?
 
Right... Our founding fathers sought a system of anarchy.

The founding fathers did come up with this little gem:

"Of the people, by the people for the people, for the people....."

I think you'd be happier in North Korea, where your subservience would be the norm.
 
Back
Top