New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Individual Mandate Upheld

Arkady

President
I'm surprised....both by the outcome (I didn't think Roberts would set aside his partisan policy goals) and by the reasoning (the commerce clause argument was by far stronger than the tax argument, legally, yet they went with the latter as their justification.)
 
I'm surprised....both by the outcome (I didn't think Roberts would set aside his partisan policy goals) and by the reasoning (the com Erie clause argument was by far stronger than the tax argument, legally, yet they went with the latter as their justification.)

The mandate can go through taxation and Congress has that power!
 
I'm surprised....both by the outcome (I didn't think Roberts would set aside his partisan policy goals) and by the reasoning (the commerce clause argument was by far stronger than the tax argument, legally, yet they went with the latter as their justification.)

Now watch the repub faithful here suddenly decide that the court they swore was so great when they got their way on Citizens and Bush v Gore is now so inept and leftwing....entirely in keeping with the new EtchaSketch theme of the republican party.
 
Now watch the repub faithful here suddenly decide that the court they swore was so great when they got their way on Citizens and Bush v Gore is now so inept and leftwing....entirely in keeping with the new EtchaSketch theme of the republican party.

And John Roberts joined the majority. Kennedy failed on this one.
 
Back
Top