New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Inheritance Taxes

Arkady

President
Since Trump wants wealthy heirs like himself to get that income without taxation, I thought it was worth trotting out a parable I've used in the past.

Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.

You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.

There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?
 
Since Trump wants wealthy heirs like himself to get that income without taxation, I thought it was worth trotting out a parable I've used in the past.

Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.

You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.

There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?

It's not your money. You didn't earn it. Shut the [Unwelcome language removed] up. If I want my child to have what I worked for rather than some useless piece of shit BLM animal, it's none of your [Unwelcome language removed] business.

Get a job and shut the [Unwelcome language removed] up.
 
The inheritance tax is just guise for the redistribution of wealth.
 
It's not your money. You didn't earn it.

It's nobody's money. We're talking about fortunes that have been left behind when someone dies. The question is what to do about them.

If I want my child to have what I worked for rather than some useless piece of shit BLM animal, it's none of your [Unwelcome language removed] business.

Yet, setting aside your seething racism, wouldn't the same argument hold true for ANY taxes? If I hire someone to work as my nanny, the transfer of wealth from me to her, in the form of her income, is taxed. I could whine that if I want her to have my money it shouldn't be the government's business to tax it, but as a matter of simple fact it IS taxed. So, if that kind of EARNED money gets taxed, why should money that isn't earned be tax-free?
 
Last edited:
The inheritance tax is just guise for the redistribution of wealth.
It's a revenue collection mechanism. The wealth gets redistributed one way or the other -- from the dead person to one or more other people and entities. It's up to us to decide how it gets redistributed. We can, of course, choose to redistribute it to whoever's name happens to appear in the will -- or in accordance with whatever rules we choose for intestate inheritance. But we can also choose to redistribute it in more productive, fairer, and more sensible ways.
 
It's a revenue collection mechanism. The wealth gets redistributed one way or the other -- from the dead person to one or more other people and entities. It's up to us to decide how it gets redistributed. We can, of course, choose to redistribute it to whoever's name happens to appear in the will -- or in accordance with whatever rules we choose for intestate inheritance. But we can also choose to redistribute it in more productive, fairer, and more sensible ways.

Righto_O.....who gets to decide the "can also choose to redistribute it in more productive, fairer, and more sensible ways" ?.

Who gets to determine who is more worthy of family wealth if not the family itself?

Fascist is as fascist does.
 
Don't sweat it - you commies are winning:

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/arti...h-tax-looks-like-it-can-make-a-country-richer

Look, I think Noah Smith is a pinko (like you). But if a wealth tax proposal was offered by the left that eliminated corporate, capital gains and dividend taxes altogether, you might find me willing to make that deal.

An estate tax increase, as Smith is suggesting, is probably a no go because to make it work you have to eliminate the charitable deduction. And the education & social welfare industrial complex is a very powerful political beast. Maybe if you just disallowed it on estate returns and give people the incentive to give it away before they die, it might be workable. But what do you do if too many decide to die poor rather than fork over most of their wealth to the government?
 

The American people, obviously, by way of the usual mechanisms of representative democracy.... the same way as we decide every other tax issue.

Good boy.

You can stop pretending any time that is actually what you and your cohorts have in mind.
 
Don't sweat it - you commies are winning:

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/arti...h-tax-looks-like-it-can-make-a-country-richer

Look, I think Noah Smith is a pinko (like you). But if a wealth tax proposal was offered by the left that eliminated corporate, capital gains and dividend taxes altogether, you might find me willing to make that deal.

I'm skeptical of simplistic tax schemes built around just a single revenue source, for obvious reasons. The greater the share of the revenues that come through a single calculation, the greater the incentive to game that calculation, and the greater the distortions it causes. For example, in some old cities you can find huge houses with an absurdly small number of windows, for no reason other than that the primary mode of revenue collection was a wealth tax based on how many windows your house has, incentivizing the creation of cavernous, dismal mansions. When there's one big bite, people have lots of reason to distort their behavior to dodge that one bite. When there are lots over little bites, the incentives to dodge each are smaller, and people are more likely to behave in minimally distorted ways.

I like the concept of a wealth tax, since that doesn't disincentivize productive behavior, and would tend to result in society's assets flowing from those who use them least productively to those who use them most productively. But I worry that if that were the only tax, there'd be a big incentive to game the wealth calculation, with distorting effects.

But what do you do if too many decide to die poor rather than fork over most of their wealth to the government?

If they give it away to worthy causes, the need for government social spending would decline. But I'd rather go the other way and eliminate the charity tax deduction (and the deduction for religious giving, as well).

By the way, the Bloomberg article makes a great point about the lucky rich -- the investors and entrepreneurs who get rich with one big score or being in the right place at the right time. There are some business people who are unquestionably business geniuses -- scoring big time and again in independent ways (e.g., Steve Jobs starting up Apple, then turning Pixar into a powerhouse, then coming back and rescuing Apple from the brink of ruin and turning it into the most successful company in the world). But, there are a lot of others who stumble into one good idea, or make a random investment that just happens to pay off big, etc. Buying a lottery ticket isn't a sound investment decision, even if it winds up paying off huge. A wealth tax would tend to erode the value of that one big score, while helping out those who have multiple smaller scores of the same cumulative value.
 
I'm skeptical of simplistic tax schemes built around just a single revenue source, for obvious reasons. The greater the share of the revenues that come through a single calculation, the greater the incentive to game that calculation, and the greater the distortions it causes. For example, in some old cities you can find huge houses with an absurdly small number of windows, for no reason other than that the primary mode of revenue collection was a wealth tax based on how many windows your house has, incentivizing the creation of cavernous, dismal mansions. When there's one big bite, people have lots of reason to distort their behavior to dodge that one bite. When there are lots over little bites, the incentives to dodge each are smaller, and people are more likely to behave in minimally distorted ways.

I like the concept of a wealth tax, since that doesn't disincentivize productive behavior, and would tend to result in society's assets flowing from those who use them least productively to those who use them most productively. But I worry that if that were the only tax, there'd be a big incentive to game the wealth calculation, with distorting effects.



If they give it away to worthy causes, the need for government social spending would decline. But I'd rather go the other way and eliminate the charity tax deduction (and the deduction for religious giving, as well).

I understand your position here completely. Of course you aren't in favor of replacing any taxation, just adding more. No surprise there. It's how you grow government, which, as a kard karrying Keynesian, is your only goal.

As for the "many small bite" approach, what you end up with is a completely unworkable economy (like the European ones you so love) because there are disincentives in every nook and cranny. Eventually they simply grind (almost) to a halt like Greece. But of course, you have superior intellect so I'm sure I'm completely missing some progressive nuance that makes none of those real world outcomes applicable for your purposes here.

But think about this for a minute, would you be surprised to find that Scandinavians tend to do better here in America than they do in their home countries? It's true:

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2016-08-16/denmark-s-nice-yes-but-danes-live-better-in-u-s

Just throwing another log on the fire I'm using to burn away your complete bullshit social justice agenda. Have a nice day!
 
I understand your position here completely. Of course you aren't in favor of replacing any taxation, just adding more.

That's not what I'm suggesting. I'm happy to offset increased revenues from inheritance taxes with decreased revenues from other taxes. For example, the poor and middle class have been losing ground in recent decades, in terms of real income, and we could offset that by lowering their tax burden commensurate with the added revenues from estate taxes. I'm just saying that even at a certain total flow of revenues, I foresee fewer problems if the flow is coming through a lot of smaller spigots than one big one.

As for the "many small bite" approach, what you end up with is a completely unworkable economy (like the European ones you so love) because there are disincentives in every nook and cranny.

No. As you're aware, every major wealthy economy in the world takes the "small bite" approach -- with some combination of VAT, sales tax, income tax, real estate tax, estate tax, tariffs, use fees, luxury taxes, sin taxes, excise taxes, carbon taxes, corporate taxes, TV taxes, payroll taxes, leases of public property, etc. I'm not aware of any major wealthy nation that goes with the "one big bite" approach.
 
Since Trump wants wealthy heirs like himself to get that income without taxation, I thought it was worth trotting out a parable I've used in the past.

Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.

You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.

There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?


When I pass..when you pass..I would hope to have an effective plan in place that would minimize the exposure of my estate to taxation, and pass on as much of it as possible to my survivors. Is that not what you're working for?
 
When I pass..when you pass..I would hope to have an effective plan in place that would minimize the exposure of my estate to taxation, and pass on as much of it as possible to my survivors. Is that not what you're working for?
That depends on how big my estate is. If my estate were so large that it would enable my daughter to live luxuriously without labor for life, I absolutely wouldn't want to pass it all on to her. I've worked hard to raise her well and I don't want to ruin that by turning her into a spoiled, lazy rich brat. I plan to leave her enough that she never has to worry about the bare necessities, as long as she's frugal, but she will have to earn the comforts and luxuries from her own efforts. I'll set her up to make those efforts as productive as I can, by giving her a good education (formal and informal), but then she'll go only as far as her wits and her diligence will take her.

An estate of even $1 million, after taxes, is more than enough to set an heir up that way. A $1 million fortune, if simply stuck in a diversified index fund, will tend to outperform inflation by about 5 points per year. That would produce $50,000 of income per year (adjusting up for inflation), or more than twice as much as the median adult in this country earns. Even if I had two kids, that would be enough to let each of them afford the basic necessities without labor for life, without even drawing down the principal. Yet, right now, a married couple can shield $10.9 million from any federal estate taxation, and Trump thinks even that is insufficient.
 
Since Trump wants wealthy heirs like himself to get that income without taxation, I thought it was worth trotting out a parable I've used in the past.

Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.

You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.

There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?

The question is, who gets to decide who is lazy and who isn't?

It'd be great if there was an honest and all knowledgeable deity who could judge us all and pay us accordingly for our efforts.

However, that's impractical. It's impossible to do.

The "judging" would actually be far more dangerous than the "injustice".
 
That depends on how big my estate is. If my estate were so large that it would enable my daughter to live luxuriously without labor for life, I absolutely wouldn't want to pass it all on to her. I've worked hard to raise her well and I don't want to ruin that by turning her into a spoiled, lazy rich brat. I plan to leave her enough that she never has to worry about the bare necessities, as long as she's frugal, but she will have to earn the comforts and luxuries from her own efforts. I'll set her up to make those efforts as productive as I can, by giving her a good education (formal and informal), but then she'll go only as far as her wits and her diligence will take her.

An estate of even $1 million, after taxes, is more than enough to set an heir up that way. A $1 million fortune, if simply stuck in a diversified index fund, will tend to outperform inflation by about 5 points per year. That would produce $50,000 of income per year (adjusting up for inflation), or more than twice as much as the median adult in this country earns. Even if I had two kids, that would be enough to let each of them afford the basic necessities without labor for life, without even drawing down the principal. Yet, right now, a married couple can shield $10.9 million from any federal estate taxation, and Trump thinks even that is insufficient.


No offense intended, but if you raised her well, why would she be spoiled or devolve into a lazy rich brat?

If I'm so luck to leave a substantive sum to my son, I'll pass content in the notion that he wont become a douche bag just because I left him money, otherwise, arent I assuming the worst?
 
The question is, who gets to decide who is lazy and who isn't?

We don't need to decide that, in this case. We simply need to tax wealth transfers the same regardless of whether they're earned through labor, or received through having one's name appear in the right will. If I pay an average effective rate of 30% on the $6 million I earn through three decades of productive labor, then shouldn't you pay the same 30% on the $6 million you are handed for having originated with a certain sperm?
 
We don't need to decide that, in this case. We simply need to tax wealth transfers the same regardless of whether they're earned through labor, or received through having one's name appear in the right will. If I pay an average effective rate of 30% on the $6 million I earn through three decades of productive labor, then shouldn't you pay the same 30% on the $6 million you are handed for having originated with a certain sperm?

This is dangerous ground.

Once the government starts stripping families from their built up wealth, it'll gut the middle class entirely..

In the real world, people are just born into privilege. Look at Will Smith's son, he's black (gasp!), and yet, gets more privilege than any white person I've ever known.

Tall people are proven to be more successful, do you advocate a "tall tax"?

How about people who are in shape? They are more successful.. a "fit tax"?
 
Back
Top