Arkady
President
Since Trump wants wealthy heirs like himself to get that income without taxation, I thought it was worth trotting out a parable I've used in the past.
Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.
You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.
There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?
Imagine a rich man with an industrious assistant and a lazy son. The industrious assistant helps the man manage his financial affairs. He is very good at his job and so makes a damned good income in the process: $200,000 per year, average, over 30 years. The lazy son spends that same time sitting by the pool mooching off daddy. At the end of that time, the rich man dies and leaves his son his $6 million estate.
You have two examples of the same thing: in each case, the man transferred $6 million of his own money to someone else. Yet, in Trump's mind, the person who earned his $6 million through three decades of productive labor should be punished for that effort by being taxed more than the person who got his $6 million by winning the birth lottery.
There are conservative arguments to be made for lower taxes on the working rich, to incentivize effort and to encourage the accumulation of wealth into the most productive hands. Those may not be compelling arguments, but they're at least colorable ones. But what's the argument for eliminating taxes on the idle rich? That creates no positive incentives for the recipients and encourages the accumulation of wealth into the least productive hands. As between two recipients of money, why should the one who actually worked for it have to pay taxes if the one who got it as a windfall doesn't?