New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Is Inflation Overstated?

Arkady

President
The Austrian and Chicago schools of economics were certain that loose Fed policy, starting in mid-2008, would cause sky-rocketing inflation. Now, seven years along, we continue to have some of the lowest inflation rates in American history. So far this year, annualized rates, by month, have ranged between -0.2 and 0.2, all of which is far below the Fed's (overly conservative) inflation target.

It takes a perverse intelligence to be wrong the way right-wing economists are. If they'd predicted normal inflation rates, that would have been wrong, since inflation rates actually plunged far below normal. But their special kind of wrong involved predicting soaring inflation rates-- it takes talent to be exactly wrong that way.

Now, of course, they try to insist that official inflation is understated -- after all, if reality doesn't line up with the economic theories they embrace with a religious zeal, then reality must be at fault. Yet, if you check the Billion-Price Project, we're actually running deflation right now. No matter, they have their theories for why inflation is understated, such as the way the "basket of goods" gets adjusted based on actual buying habits, which tends to reduce the buy of things that are getting more expensive (e.g., steak) in favor of cheaper options, (e.g., chicken).

But, since these right-wing economists have such an amazing talent for being exactly wrong, perhaps we should consider the opposite possibility: that, as low as inflation is today, it is actually being OVER-stated.

The case in that direction is easy to make when you think about electronics. For example, for $580 today, you can get an all-in-one desktop computer, with 8 Gig of Ram, 1 TB hard drive, a 23-inch touchscreen, and a 1.7 GHz processor. What would that have cost you twenty years ago? The answer is you probably couldn't have bought it at any price, since some of the technologies, like the touchscreen didn't exist or were in much worse forms. Consider the hard drive alone. Twenty years ago, you could get a 2 Gig hard drive for $280. You'd have needed 500 of those to match a single terabyte drive. So, just to have the storage capacity of that $580 computer, you'd have paid $140,000. Similarly, the CPU included in that computer would have been a supercomputer by the standards of earlier eras. For example, it would run circles around a 1980s-era Cray Y-MP $20 million super computer. So, if you did straight price comparisons based on capabilities, we'd be talking about MASSIVE price deflation. Instead, we compare normal computers from 20 years ago to normal computers today, and thus ignore that deflation, by way of an apples-to-oranges comparison.

Let's say you're a car guy who doesn't care about computers. Well, the same principle is in play. The way we calculate inflation ignores improvements in car technologies. The price comparison treats a worse old car as equivalent to a better new one. A car bought in the 1980s would have worse fuel efficiency, lack of air bags, lack of anti-lock breaking, lack of traction control, worse crash-test performance, worse emissions, and none of the bells and whistles like GPS and satellite radio. Yet, it would be treated as equivalent to a modern car when computing inflation.

Take the 1985 Lamborhini Countach. It was an exotic sportscar that did 0-60 mph in 5.7 s, the 1/4 mile drag in 14.4 s, and had fuel consumption of 12/18 mpg. Now, compare that to a 2015 Ford Mustang GT. 0-60 4.4 s, 1/4 mile 12.8 s, mileage 15/25 mpg. The 1985 Countach cost about four times what the Mustang costs today, in nominal dollars, and yet today's Mustang would make mincemeat out if it. In terms of track performance, the $110,000 Countach, the super-car that graced the posters of boys in the 80s, was basically on-par with an entry-level Honda Civic of today.

Again and again, you find similar stories when comparing supposedly similar consumer products over time. For example, the refrigerator/freezer combo of the 1980s was generally smaller, less fuel efficient, didn't have built-in ice makers and filtered water dispensers, self-defrosting freezers, etc. A 50-inch TV was unheard of a decade ago, yet is commonplace now. We've got bag-less vacuum cleaners, wall outlets with ground fault interrupters, wrinkle-free, stain-resistant chinos, etc. Inflation calculations tend to compare the old and new products as if they were the same, and show inflation in prices from one to the next, without considering the added value of those technological upgrades. Buying the equivalent of today's products, in the past may, have been like buying an 80s Lamborghini to get the performance of a modern Civic. If the inflation calculation linked products based on performance, rather than market position, we'd likely be seeing much lower inflation rates in the modern era than the official stats.

Our current way of calculating inflation does nothing to account for how somebody with an entry level job can now afford a car with performance that only Wall Street tycoons could afford in the 80s. So, maybe we're badly over-estimating inflation these days.
 
Last edited:
The Austrian and Chicago schools of Economics were certain that loose Fed policy, starting in mid-2008, would cause sky-rocketing inflation. The smarter economists of the so-called salt-water school (mostly neo-Keynesians) knew better, but if you were listening to those on the right, you'd have pictured an era of soaring prices. Now, seven years along, we continue to have some of the lowest inflation rates in American history. So far this year, annualized rates, by month, have ranged between -0.2 and 0.2, all of which is far below the Fed's (overly conservative) inflation target.

That's the thing about the right-wing economists. They don't just tend to be wrong. Any moron can be wrong much of the time. But it takes a special kind of perverse intelligence to be wrong the way right-wing economists are -- not just wrong, but exactly opposite of the truth. If they'd predicted normal inflation rates, that would have been wrong, since inflation rates actually plunged far below normal. But their special kind of wrong involved predicting soaring inflation rates, which is exactly opposite of what happened.

Now, of course, they try to insist that official inflation is understated -- after all, if reality doesn't line up with the economic theories they embrace with a religious zeal, then reality must be at fault. Yet, if you check the Billion-Price Project, we're actually running deflation right now. No matter, they have their theories for why inflation is understated, such as the way the "basket of goods" gets adjusted based on actual buying habits, which tends to reduce the buy of things that are getting more expensive (e.g., steak) in favor of cheaper options, (e.g., chicken).

But, since these right-wing economists have such an amazing talent for being exactly wrong, perhaps we should consider the opposite possibility: that, as low as inflation is today, it is actually being OVER-stated.

The case in that direction is easy to make when you think about electronics. For example, for $580 today, you can get an all-in-one desktop computer, with 8 Gig of Ram, 1 TB hard drive, a 23-inch touchscreen, and a 1.7 GHz processor. What would that have cost you twenty years ago? The answer is you probably couldn't have bought it at any price, since some of the technologies, like the touchscreen didn't exist or were in much worse forms. But consider the hard drive alone. Twenty years ago, you could get a 2 Gig hard drive for $280. You'd have needed 500 of those to match a single terabyte drive. So, just to have the storage capacity of that $580 computer, you'd have paid $140,000. Similarly, the CPU included in that computer would have been a supercomputer by the standards of earlier eras. For example, it would run circles around a 1980s-era Cray Y-MP $20 million super computer. So, if you did straight price comparisons based on capabilities, we'd be talking about MASSIVE price deflation. Instead, we compare normal computers from 20 years ago to normal computers today, and thus ignore that deflation, by way of an apples-to-oranges comparison.

But, let's say you don't care about computers. Let's say you're a car guy. Well, in the same way, the way we calculate inflation ignores improvements in car technologies. The price comparison treats a worse old car as equivalent to a better new one. A car bought in the 1980s would have worse fuel efficiency, lack of air bags, lack of anti-lock breaking, lack of traction control, worse crash-test performance, worse emissions, and none of the bells and whistles like GPS and satellite radio. Yet, it would be treated as equivalent to a modern car when computing inflation.

Take the 1985 Lamborhini Countach. It was an exotic sportscar that did 0-60 mph in 5.7 s, the 1/4 mile drag in 14.4 s, and had fuel consumption of 12/18 mpg. Now, compare that to a 2015 Ford Mustang GT. 0-60 4.4 s, 1/4 mile 12.8 s, mileage 15/25 mpg. The Countach cost in 1985 about four times what the Mustang costs today, in nominal dollars, and yet today's Mustang would make mincemeat out if it. In terms of track performance, the $110,000 Countach, the super-car that graced the posters of boys in the 80s, was basically on-par with an entry-level Honda Civic of today.

Again and again, you find similar stories when comparing supposedly similar consumer products over time. For example, the refrigerator/freezer combo of the 1980s was generally smaller, less fuel efficient, didn't have built-in ice makers and filtered water dispensers, self-defrosting freezers, etc. A 50-inch TV was unheard of a decade ago, yet is commonplace now. We've got bag-less vacuum cleaners, wall outlets with ground fault interrupters, wrinkle-free, stain-resistant chinos, etc. Inflation calculations tend to compare the old and new products as if they were the same, and show inflation in prices from one to the next, without considering that buying the equivalent of the new product in the past may have been like buying an 80s Lamborghini to get the performance of a modern Civic. If they linked products based on performance, rather than market position, we'd likely be seeing much lower inflation rates in the modern era.
I'm bumping once. I hate to see something I put time on scroll away without comment.
 
thanks for self promoting your top post so I would see it - here's your reward (my comment)

yeah- I don't think lamborghis and computers go into the "market basket" of how the government analyzes inflation. last time I checked it was groceries, energy (gasoline, electricity, heating oil, natural gas); clothing; and housing.

if you canvas people who want to live in San Francisco and NYC - they believe a $15 minimum wage is laughably inadequate because rent and food are so high.

yet some people live comfortably at "below poverty level" income away from the overheated coastal areas.

we don't use high end PCs in the marketbasket for inflation for the same reason we don't compare a 2015 $750 iPhone 6 to a $19.99 rotary dial phone from 30 years ago.

we don't compare Evian bottled water sold in stores to tap water which was all that was available in 1960. or compare "tv reception" (free in 1960) with sky high cable bills today; or top line fighter aircraft in 1945 (the P51 mustang - $51,000 then, $600,000 inflation adjusted today) with an F35 jet fighter ($150 million, before accessories); or compare . . .

Ark, you really astonish, much of the time.
 
Last edited:
The Austrian and Chicago schools of economics were certain that loose Fed policy, starting in mid-2008, would cause sky-rocketing inflation. Now, seven years along, we continue to have some of the lowest inflation rates in American history. So far this year, annualized rates, by month, have ranged between -0.2 and 0.2, all of which is far below the Fed's (overly conservative) inflation target.

It takes a perverse intelligence to be wrong the way right-wing economists are. If they'd predicted normal inflation rates, that would have been wrong, since inflation rates actually plunged far below normal. But their special kind of wrong involved predicting soaring inflation rates-- it takes talent to be exactly wrong that way.

Now, of course, they try to insist that official inflation is understated -- after all, if reality doesn't line up with the economic theories they embrace with a religious zeal, then reality must be at fault. Yet, if you check the Billion-Price Project, we're actually running deflation right now. No matter, they have their theories for why inflation is understated, such as the way the "basket of goods" gets adjusted based on actual buying habits, which tends to reduce the buy of things that are getting more expensive (e.g., steak) in favor of cheaper options, (e.g., chicken).

But, since these right-wing economists have such an amazing talent for being exactly wrong, perhaps we should consider the opposite possibility: that, as low as inflation is today, it is actually being OVER-stated.

The case in that direction is easy to make when you think about electronics. For example, for $580 today, you can get an all-in-one desktop computer, with 8 Gig of Ram, 1 TB hard drive, a 23-inch touchscreen, and a 1.7 GHz processor. What would that have cost you twenty years ago? The answer is you probably couldn't have bought it at any price, since some of the technologies, like the touchscreen didn't exist or were in much worse forms. Consider the hard drive alone. Twenty years ago, you could get a 2 Gig hard drive for $280. You'd have needed 500 of those to match a single terabyte drive. So, just to have the storage capacity of that $580 computer, you'd have paid $140,000. Similarly, the CPU included in that computer would have been a supercomputer by the standards of earlier eras. For example, it would run circles around a 1980s-era Cray Y-MP $20 million super computer. So, if you did straight price comparisons based on capabilities, we'd be talking about MASSIVE price deflation. Instead, we compare normal computers from 20 years ago to normal computers today, and thus ignore that deflation, by way of an apples-to-oranges comparison.

Let's say you're a car guy who doesn't care about computers. Well, the same principle is in play. The way we calculate inflation ignores improvements in car technologies. The price comparison treats a worse old car as equivalent to a better new one. A car bought in the 1980s would have worse fuel efficiency, lack of air bags, lack of anti-lock breaking, lack of traction control, worse crash-test performance, worse emissions, and none of the bells and whistles like GPS and satellite radio. Yet, it would be treated as equivalent to a modern car when computing inflation.

Take the 1985 Lamborhini Countach. It was an exotic sportscar that did 0-60 mph in 5.7 s, the 1/4 mile drag in 14.4 s, and had fuel consumption of 12/18 mpg. Now, compare that to a 2015 Ford Mustang GT. 0-60 4.4 s, 1/4 mile 12.8 s, mileage 15/25 mpg. The 1985 Countach cost about four times what the Mustang costs today, in nominal dollars, and yet today's Mustang would make mincemeat out if it. In terms of track performance, the $110,000 Countach, the super-car that graced the posters of boys in the 80s, was basically on-par with an entry-level Honda Civic of today.

Again and again, you find similar stories when comparing supposedly similar consumer products over time. For example, the refrigerator/freezer combo of the 1980s was generally smaller, less fuel efficient, didn't have built-in ice makers and filtered water dispensers, self-defrosting freezers, etc. A 50-inch TV was unheard of a decade ago, yet is commonplace now. We've got bag-less vacuum cleaners, wall outlets with ground fault interrupters, wrinkle-free, stain-resistant chinos, etc. Inflation calculations tend to compare the old and new products as if they were the same, and show inflation in prices from one to the next, without considering the added value of those technological upgrades. Buying the equivalent of today's products, in the past may, have been like buying an 80s Lamborghini to get the performance of a modern Civic. If the inflation calculation linked products based on performance, rather than market position, we'd likely be seeing much lower inflation rates in the modern era than the official stats.

Our current way of calculating inflation does nothing to account for how somebody with an entry level job can now afford a car with performance that only Wall Street tycoons could afford in the 80s. So, maybe we're badly over-estimating inflation these days.
I'm not sure what you are arguing for here - is it that we should consider technological advancements as mitigating factor to cost bases?

Setting aside the usual selectivity for that which agrees with what you seek to argue, it seems to me that performance specs should be irrelevant to the consideration of inflation.

Personally, I tend to focus on relative affordability of like goods and staples. Onboarding sidebar considerations serves only to give the manipulators and bureaucrats cover to deceive.

Why do we labor so intently to enable those whom we should be holding accountable? They have far too much wiggle room as it is.
 
thanks for self promoting your top post so I would see it - here's your reward (my comment)

yeah- I don't think lamborghis and computers go into the "market basket" of how the government analyzes inflation. last time I checked it was groceries, energy (gasoline, electricity, heating oil, natural gas); clothing; and housing.

If you were right, it would make my point even more strongly -- if the government weren't even measuring whole areas of expense like computers, where costs have been falling. But, that's not the case. The "basket of goods" is very wide and detailed and contains a whole lot more than the stuff you listed (most of which is actually excluded from the "core inflation" calculation, by the way).

This gives you a feel for it:

http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t02.htm

As you'll see, new cars and computers are definitely on the list.

I think it's a fascinating list, since it lets you look into where prices are rising the most and the least. For example, the highest inflation, in the last year, was for eggs, which are now about a quarter more expensive than a year ago. The lowest is fuel oil, which is nearly 30% cheaper than this time last year.

if you canvas people who want to live in San Francisco and NYC - they believe a $15 minimum wage is laughably inadequate because rent and food are so high.

yet some people live comfortably at "below poverty level" income away from the overheated coastal areas.

Yes. And the BLS does regional calculations to allow for such considerations. But, for purposes of this discussion, that's largely beside the point, because SF and NYC have been high for many generations, at least, relative to the economically underheated interior of the country. In each place, inflation is measured relative to the prior prices in that area, and nationally, the main inflation index (CPI-U) measures the average impact on urban consumers generally.

we don't use high end PCs in the marketbasket for inflation for the same reason we don't compare a 2015 $750 iPhone 6 to a $19.99 rotary dial phone from 30 years ago.

Yes, I understand the concept. You want the market basket to reflect what people are actually buying, rather than reflecting some fixed basket of goods from the past. But the point I'm making is this. There are people who want to pretend inflation is actually higher than the official number, because they predicted high inflation and ended up being howlingly wrong about it, so they want to pretend the real-world data is wrong instead. To make that argument, they rely on pointing out the way the basket of goods has changed over time (e.g., more chicken, less beef). But, if we open that up to criticism, the changes to the basket of goods would result in inflation being vastly OVER-STATED, not under-stated, net. For every minor difference to the hedonic value of a substituted good (the presumably higher enjoyment from eating beef over chicken), there will be a vastly greater difference in the opposite direction from technological substitutions (an entry-level car, today, blowing the doors off an 1980s exotic super-car, or an entry-level desktop, today, blowing the doors off an 1980s Cray super-computer).

or compare "tv reception" (free in 1960)

It's free today, too -- and, thanks to the change to digital broadcasts, it's free in higher definition and with a whole hell of a lot more channels to choose from -- in some areas, you can get 40 or 50 channels for free with a roof-top antenna:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/personal/2014/04/19/cutting-the-cord-antennas/7870817/

At my address, I can get 17 channels with a strong signal, over the air (crystal-clear HD), five with a moderate signal, and three with a weak signal. All in color. Anyone in 1960 would drool over that. People opt for cable not because they can't get the kind of over-the-airwaves broadcasts they did in 1960, but because they want HUNDREDS of channels in HD, including commercial-free TV.
 
I'm not sure what you are arguing for here - is it that we should consider technological advancements as mitigating factor to cost bases?

My point is that a better case can be made that official inflation is over-stated than can be made that it's under-stated. Since we calculate inflation by comparing un-like products that filled similar consumer niches in two different periods (e.g., an average desktop computer of the past to an average desktop computer of today), without accounting for quality gains, we will measure inflation in cases where there could be argued to be deflation.

Think of it another way. I could go on Craig's List and for $100 buy a computer that is every bit as good as one that sold for $2000 ten years ago. Right now, in my basement, I have a perfectly functional 40" CRT TV. I literally can't give it away. That was a TV that in the early 1990s would have set you back thousands of dollars and it works just as well as it ever did, but at this point all it represents to me is the $20 cost to recycle it, and the back-ache from trying to carry that monster up my basement stair solo (it must weigh 200 pounds). It's not even possible to calculate a deflation rate on that TV, since right now you'd have to pay someone to take something like that off your hands.

Onboarding sidebar considerations serves only to give the manipulators and bureaucrats cover to deceive.

Why do we labor so intently to enable those whom we should be holding accountable? They have far too much wiggle room as it is.

Here I agree, but I apply it very differently. The bureaucrats have a reason to pretend inflation is higher than it is, since the threat of inflation will give them an excuse to hike interest rates prematurely. The Fed's mission is to balance concerns about unemployment and inflation. Obviously, lowering unemployment helps the masses, but it can hurt the economic elite, who are more likely to be employers, and thus want the rock-bottom labor costs that come with having a workforce that knows people are lined up outside eager to take their jobs. So, the elite has cause to pretend inflation is higher than it is, and the politicians who hob-nob with the elite (and who are enriched by them) have cause to play along. I don't want to enable that. I want to hold them accountable. When inflation is as low as it is by official numbers, and probably much lower if you consider technological impacts, it's ridiculous that anyone is talking about raising interest rates right now, especially when we remain well away from "full employment."
 
I'll take that. If you ever write something into which you put mental effort, you may find yourself being tacky, too, to prevent it from scrolling away immediately.

I'd say you are unique on the board as far as such a massively (and undeservedly) inflated sense of self worth. The rest of us accept that not everyone hangs on our every word. I expect someday you, too, will mature to the point where you understand this. There's hope for you yet...
 
My point is that a better case can be made that official inflation is over-stated than can be made that it's under-stated. Since we calculate inflation by comparing un-like products that filled similar consumer niches in two different periods (e.g., an average desktop computer of the past to an average desktop computer of today), without accounting for quality gains, we will measure inflation in cases where there could be argued to be deflation.

Think of it another way. I could go on Craig's List and for $100 buy a computer that is every bit as good as one that sold for $2000 ten years ago. Right now, in my basement, I have a perfectly functional 40" CRT TV. I literally can't give it away. That was a TV that in the early 1990s would have set you back thousands of dollars and it works just as well as it ever did, but at this point all it represents to me is the $20 cost to recycle it, and the back-ache from trying to carry that monster up my basement stair solo (it must weigh 200 pounds). It's not even possible to calculate a deflation rate on that TV, since right now you'd have to pay someone to take something like that off your hands.



Here I agree, but I apply it very differently. The bureaucrats have a reason to pretend inflation is higher than it is, since the threat of inflation will give them an excuse to hike interest rates prematurely. The Fed's mission is to balance concerns about unemployment and inflation. Obviously, lowering unemployment helps the masses, but it can hurt the economic elite, who are more likely to be employers, and thus want the rock-bottom labor costs that come with having a workforce that knows people are lined up outside eager to take their jobs. So, the elite has cause to pretend inflation is higher than it is, and the politicians who hob-nob with the elite (and who are enriched by them) have cause to play along. I don't want to enable that. I want to hold them accountable. When inflation is as low as it is by official numbers, and probably much lower if you consider technological impacts, it's ridiculous that anyone is talking about raising interest rates right now, especially when we remain well away from "full employment."
Ok. The timing strikes me a puzzling for two reasons. First, I don't recall such a treatise when a Democrat wasn't Prez. Second, the Fed has maintained artificially low interest rates for a ridiculously long period.

I'm admittedly the wrong guy to get into discussion about proper Fed policy specifics, because I'm one of those folks who thinks it ought not exist at all. But there'll be no threadjacking here. :)
 
Ok. The timing strikes me a puzzling for two reasons. First, I don't recall such a treatise when a Democrat wasn't Prez. Second, the Fed has maintained artificially low interest rates for a ridiculously long period.

I'm admittedly the wrong guy to get into discussion about proper Fed policy specifics, because I'm one of those folks who thinks it ought not exist at all. But there'll be no threadjacking here. :)
I understand that you're used to thinking of policy matters in strictly partisan political ways, but this isn't about who is in the Oval Office, it's about the two factors the Fed is supposed to be considering when setting interest rates: Inflation and Unemployment.

Right now, inflation is essentially zero, and has stayed at incredibly low levels for seven years -- levels that are below even the ridiculously low levels that the Fed officially targets. Meanwhile, absolutely nobody is arguing we're at full employment. Although we've made enormous progress in bringing the unemployment rate down in recent years, it remains 1.2 points above the Clinton-era lows, and even farther above the Johnson- and Truman-era lows.

Plus, as conservatives are fond of pointing out, the current 5.1% unemployment rate is probably misleadingly low, given the number of workers who were discouraged from even looking for a job during the long period of much higher unemployment rates. So, with inflation below where the Fed thinks it should be, and unemployment above where just about everyone thinks it should be, we should be looking to loosen money supply further, rather than talking about tightening it.

That's why, when I hear people making methodological arguments to suggest inflation is being understated, I think it's important to point out that a much stronger case can be made that inflation is being overstated, using similar methodological arguments. I'm happy to throw out both those arguments and just accept the official numbers, but then we're back to a situation where inflation is too low, according to the Fed's own conservative targets, and unemployment is too high, and we ought not to be considering tightening money supply yet.
 
I understand that you're used to thinking of policy matters in strictly partisan political ways, but this isn't about who is in the Oval Office, it's about the two factors the Fed is supposed to be considering when setting interest rates: Inflation and Unemployment.

Right now, inflation is essentially zero, and has stayed at incredibly low levels for seven years -- levels that are below even the ridiculously low levels that the Fed officially targets. Meanwhile, absolutely nobody is arguing we're at full employment. Although we've made enormous progress in bringing the unemployment rate down in recent years, it remains 1.2 points above the Clinton-era lows, and even farther above the Johnson- and Truman-era lows.

Plus, as conservatives are fond of pointing out, the current 5.1% unemployment rate is probably misleadingly low, given the number of workers who were discouraged from even looking for a job during the long period of much higher unemployment rates. So, with inflation below where the Fed thinks it should be, and unemployment above where just about everyone thinks it should be, we should be looking to loosen money supply further, rather than talking about tightening it.

That's why, when I hear people making methodological arguments to suggest inflation is being understated, I think it's important to point out that a much stronger case can be made that inflation is being overstated, using similar methodological arguments. I'm happy to throw out both those arguments and just accept the official numbers, but then we're back to a situation where inflation is too low, according to the Fed's own conservative targets, and unemployment is too high, and we ought not to be considering tightening money supply yet.
As I watch loyalists in this forum selectively express outrage about how historic metrics are compiled (I.e. UE), offer gratuitous, never before seen reach-arounds (I.e your newfangled need to introduce technological advances as diluter of inflation), I will note that it is you who is hyper-partisan to the point of relegation to abject, integrity-bankrupt servitude.

This is fact.

Prior to Obama, there is no record of you "thinking differently" on inflation and contorting yourself publicly to introduce automobile performance capabilities into metrics of inflation. All the verbosity and painfully wandering oratory in the world will not conceal this readily observable fact.

This nonsense fools only idiots - and likeminded sycophants (pardon the redundancy).

Now then, back to your unflinching, servile posts...
 
Yes, we are experiencing deflation, after eight years and trillions in "stimulus," the Keynesians running our fiscal and monetary policies are unable to produce even the modest "inflationary goal" (2%) that they set for themselves. And yet it's the "Austrian" and "Chicago" schools that are dreadful failures, according to you. So, is this, like, rocket science for you or something?
 
Yes, we are experiencing deflation, after eight years and trillions in "stimulus," the Keynesians running our fiscal and monetary policies are unable to produce even the modest "inflationary goal" (2%) that they set for themselves. And yet it's the "Austrian" and "Chicago" schools that are dreadful failures, according to you. So, is this, like, rocket science for you or something?
It's nothing other then unrelenting fealty and PR for Democrat officeholder(s). There seems to be no end to the constant apologetics, revisionism, and public relations campaign.

It's a religion to these folks.
 
It's nothing other then unrelenting fealty and PR for Democrat officeholder(s). There seems to be no end to the constant apologetics, revisionism, and public relations campaign.

It's a religion to these folks.

It's absurd! The Keynesian economic policies he worships have produced the deflation, as David Stockman so eloquently explained, by goosing supply (structurally) to sate (cyclical) demand. All that supply is now causing deflation as nations are furiously attempting to export it to each other in an orgy of currency manipulation. Yet the "Austrians" are the morons to these psuedo intellectual central planning elitists. I would laugh at how ridiculous it is but it isn't really funny.
 
(I.e your newfangled need to introduce technological advances as diluter of inflation)

You're not grappling with the concept here. As I said, I'm content to accept the official inflation number as a guide (in which case inflation remains as historical lows, dangerously close to deflation, and well below the Fed's targets). I'm merely pointing out that if we open the official number to scrutiny, based on its methods, AS CONSERVATIVES KEEP DOING, we can criticize it even more strongly in the opposite direction.

Conservatives are fond of creating false spectrums. For example, on climate change, they try to present the spectrum of opinion as if the IPCC exists on the far left -- that it is the home of the "climate alarmists". Yet, in reality, there are roughly equal numbers of expert critics of the IPCC on both sides -- those who think it is downplaying risks as well as those who think it is overstating them. Well, on inflation, right-wingers are presenting a similar false spectrum, where official inflation is the absolute minimum inflation there could be, and there could be a whole lot more. But that's not the real spectrum. There is at least as strong an argument, and I'd say much stronger, to say that official inflation is badly overstated as to claim it is understated.

Of course, right-wingers get their knickers in a terrible twist when their false spectrums are challenged by someone having the audacity to point out the other wing of the consideration. But that's a side benefit. Watching your kind twist and whine when your tiny little world gets re-balanced is a joy.

Prior to Obama, there is no record of you "thinking differently" on inflation and contorting yourself publicly to introduce automobile performance capabilities into metrics of inflation.

What makes you think that? Were you one "Rosewater"? "Damned Spot"? "Kausfiles Special"? I've been arguing this same concept for years, well before Obama.

You're stuck in your narrow mental rut, where the only political thought you're capable of having is "lefties are hypocrites." That rut is so constraining that you're utterly incapable of addressing the substance of any post. No matter what the topic is, no matter what argument is offered, you come in like some sort of badly-programmed Bot, with the single mind-numbingly repetitive post that "lefties are hypocrites."
 
Yes, we are experiencing deflation, after eight years and trillions in "stimulus," the Keynesians running our fiscal and monetary policies are unable to produce even the modest "inflationary goal" (2%) that they set for themselves. And yet it's the "Austrian" and "Chicago" schools that are dreadful failures, according to you. So, is this, like, rocket science for you or something?
The Austrian and Chicago dummies warned of soaring inflation. The Keynesians said inflation wasn't a concern and we needed a lot more stimulus. Turns out the Keynesians were right. But that came as no surprise to those of us who approach economic questions with a scientific mindset, rather than a religious one.
 
It's nothing other then unrelenting fealty and PR for Democrat officeholder(s). There seems to be no end to the constant apologetics, revisionism, and public relations campaign.

It's a religion to these folks.

It is most definitely a religion, and they are the radical fundamentalists of the denomination.
 
It's absurd! The Keynesian economic policies he worships have produced the deflation, as David Stockman so eloquently explained, by goosing supply (structurally) to sate (cyclical) demand. All that supply is now causing deflation as nations are furiously attempting to export it to each other in an orgy of currency manipulation. Yet the "Austrians" are the morons to these psuedo intellectual central planning elitists. I would laugh at how ridiculous it is but it isn't really funny.
The relative truth of inflation/deflation/stagflation - what have you - doesn't even matter. Whichever is the case in any given point in time is dutifully re-badged and fervently given absolution in service to bloody party.

There's not a subject to be discussed that will not be pretzeled into 'good outcome'.
 
It's nothing other then unrelenting fealty and PR for Democrat officeholder(s). There seems to be no end to the constant apologetics, revisionism, and public relations campaign.

It's a religion to these folks.
Nonsense. I've happily called out Obama again and again when I think he's wrong, and I do so in very harsh terms where appropriate. You know that perfectly well, though you're forced to pretend you don't in order to regurgitate your single idea over and over. My criticism of Obama and the Democrats is well-documented on foreign policy matters. But I've also criticized them harshly on economic matters. That includes when Obama's ARRA proposal was half the size leading economists had called for, when Obama twisted arms to eliminate the "public option" from healthcare reform, when Obama extended all of Bush's tax cuts, when Obama made nearly all of Bush's tax cuts permanent, when Obama floated the idea of moving SS to chained CPI, when he started talking deficit reduction prematurely, etc. You wish this were about me supporting the Democrats blindly, because it would fit into your tiny worldview. But you know I'm a frequent critic of the Democrats as well as the Republicans. And you know that, unlike you, I tend to focus not on the shallow theatrics of partisan name-calling, but instead on the POLICY SUBSTANCE. It's not enough for me to point out again and again that your kind are mentally deficient evil little trolls (though, of course, you are) -- if I point that out but take no stance on matters of policy substance, I've wasted my time and everyone else's... the way you do.
 
Back
Top