Arkady
President
The Austrian and Chicago schools of economics were certain that loose Fed policy, starting in mid-2008, would cause sky-rocketing inflation. Now, seven years along, we continue to have some of the lowest inflation rates in American history. So far this year, annualized rates, by month, have ranged between -0.2 and 0.2, all of which is far below the Fed's (overly conservative) inflation target.
It takes a perverse intelligence to be wrong the way right-wing economists are. If they'd predicted normal inflation rates, that would have been wrong, since inflation rates actually plunged far below normal. But their special kind of wrong involved predicting soaring inflation rates-- it takes talent to be exactly wrong that way.
Now, of course, they try to insist that official inflation is understated -- after all, if reality doesn't line up with the economic theories they embrace with a religious zeal, then reality must be at fault. Yet, if you check the Billion-Price Project, we're actually running deflation right now. No matter, they have their theories for why inflation is understated, such as the way the "basket of goods" gets adjusted based on actual buying habits, which tends to reduce the buy of things that are getting more expensive (e.g., steak) in favor of cheaper options, (e.g., chicken).
But, since these right-wing economists have such an amazing talent for being exactly wrong, perhaps we should consider the opposite possibility: that, as low as inflation is today, it is actually being OVER-stated.
The case in that direction is easy to make when you think about electronics. For example, for $580 today, you can get an all-in-one desktop computer, with 8 Gig of Ram, 1 TB hard drive, a 23-inch touchscreen, and a 1.7 GHz processor. What would that have cost you twenty years ago? The answer is you probably couldn't have bought it at any price, since some of the technologies, like the touchscreen didn't exist or were in much worse forms. Consider the hard drive alone. Twenty years ago, you could get a 2 Gig hard drive for $280. You'd have needed 500 of those to match a single terabyte drive. So, just to have the storage capacity of that $580 computer, you'd have paid $140,000. Similarly, the CPU included in that computer would have been a supercomputer by the standards of earlier eras. For example, it would run circles around a 1980s-era Cray Y-MP $20 million super computer. So, if you did straight price comparisons based on capabilities, we'd be talking about MASSIVE price deflation. Instead, we compare normal computers from 20 years ago to normal computers today, and thus ignore that deflation, by way of an apples-to-oranges comparison.
Let's say you're a car guy who doesn't care about computers. Well, the same principle is in play. The way we calculate inflation ignores improvements in car technologies. The price comparison treats a worse old car as equivalent to a better new one. A car bought in the 1980s would have worse fuel efficiency, lack of air bags, lack of anti-lock breaking, lack of traction control, worse crash-test performance, worse emissions, and none of the bells and whistles like GPS and satellite radio. Yet, it would be treated as equivalent to a modern car when computing inflation.
Take the 1985 Lamborhini Countach. It was an exotic sportscar that did 0-60 mph in 5.7 s, the 1/4 mile drag in 14.4 s, and had fuel consumption of 12/18 mpg. Now, compare that to a 2015 Ford Mustang GT. 0-60 4.4 s, 1/4 mile 12.8 s, mileage 15/25 mpg. The 1985 Countach cost about four times what the Mustang costs today, in nominal dollars, and yet today's Mustang would make mincemeat out if it. In terms of track performance, the $110,000 Countach, the super-car that graced the posters of boys in the 80s, was basically on-par with an entry-level Honda Civic of today.
Again and again, you find similar stories when comparing supposedly similar consumer products over time. For example, the refrigerator/freezer combo of the 1980s was generally smaller, less fuel efficient, didn't have built-in ice makers and filtered water dispensers, self-defrosting freezers, etc. A 50-inch TV was unheard of a decade ago, yet is commonplace now. We've got bag-less vacuum cleaners, wall outlets with ground fault interrupters, wrinkle-free, stain-resistant chinos, etc. Inflation calculations tend to compare the old and new products as if they were the same, and show inflation in prices from one to the next, without considering the added value of those technological upgrades. Buying the equivalent of today's products, in the past may, have been like buying an 80s Lamborghini to get the performance of a modern Civic. If the inflation calculation linked products based on performance, rather than market position, we'd likely be seeing much lower inflation rates in the modern era than the official stats.
Our current way of calculating inflation does nothing to account for how somebody with an entry level job can now afford a car with performance that only Wall Street tycoons could afford in the 80s. So, maybe we're badly over-estimating inflation these days.
It takes a perverse intelligence to be wrong the way right-wing economists are. If they'd predicted normal inflation rates, that would have been wrong, since inflation rates actually plunged far below normal. But their special kind of wrong involved predicting soaring inflation rates-- it takes talent to be exactly wrong that way.
Now, of course, they try to insist that official inflation is understated -- after all, if reality doesn't line up with the economic theories they embrace with a religious zeal, then reality must be at fault. Yet, if you check the Billion-Price Project, we're actually running deflation right now. No matter, they have their theories for why inflation is understated, such as the way the "basket of goods" gets adjusted based on actual buying habits, which tends to reduce the buy of things that are getting more expensive (e.g., steak) in favor of cheaper options, (e.g., chicken).
But, since these right-wing economists have such an amazing talent for being exactly wrong, perhaps we should consider the opposite possibility: that, as low as inflation is today, it is actually being OVER-stated.
The case in that direction is easy to make when you think about electronics. For example, for $580 today, you can get an all-in-one desktop computer, with 8 Gig of Ram, 1 TB hard drive, a 23-inch touchscreen, and a 1.7 GHz processor. What would that have cost you twenty years ago? The answer is you probably couldn't have bought it at any price, since some of the technologies, like the touchscreen didn't exist or were in much worse forms. Consider the hard drive alone. Twenty years ago, you could get a 2 Gig hard drive for $280. You'd have needed 500 of those to match a single terabyte drive. So, just to have the storage capacity of that $580 computer, you'd have paid $140,000. Similarly, the CPU included in that computer would have been a supercomputer by the standards of earlier eras. For example, it would run circles around a 1980s-era Cray Y-MP $20 million super computer. So, if you did straight price comparisons based on capabilities, we'd be talking about MASSIVE price deflation. Instead, we compare normal computers from 20 years ago to normal computers today, and thus ignore that deflation, by way of an apples-to-oranges comparison.
Let's say you're a car guy who doesn't care about computers. Well, the same principle is in play. The way we calculate inflation ignores improvements in car technologies. The price comparison treats a worse old car as equivalent to a better new one. A car bought in the 1980s would have worse fuel efficiency, lack of air bags, lack of anti-lock breaking, lack of traction control, worse crash-test performance, worse emissions, and none of the bells and whistles like GPS and satellite radio. Yet, it would be treated as equivalent to a modern car when computing inflation.
Take the 1985 Lamborhini Countach. It was an exotic sportscar that did 0-60 mph in 5.7 s, the 1/4 mile drag in 14.4 s, and had fuel consumption of 12/18 mpg. Now, compare that to a 2015 Ford Mustang GT. 0-60 4.4 s, 1/4 mile 12.8 s, mileage 15/25 mpg. The 1985 Countach cost about four times what the Mustang costs today, in nominal dollars, and yet today's Mustang would make mincemeat out if it. In terms of track performance, the $110,000 Countach, the super-car that graced the posters of boys in the 80s, was basically on-par with an entry-level Honda Civic of today.
Again and again, you find similar stories when comparing supposedly similar consumer products over time. For example, the refrigerator/freezer combo of the 1980s was generally smaller, less fuel efficient, didn't have built-in ice makers and filtered water dispensers, self-defrosting freezers, etc. A 50-inch TV was unheard of a decade ago, yet is commonplace now. We've got bag-less vacuum cleaners, wall outlets with ground fault interrupters, wrinkle-free, stain-resistant chinos, etc. Inflation calculations tend to compare the old and new products as if they were the same, and show inflation in prices from one to the next, without considering the added value of those technological upgrades. Buying the equivalent of today's products, in the past may, have been like buying an 80s Lamborghini to get the performance of a modern Civic. If the inflation calculation linked products based on performance, rather than market position, we'd likely be seeing much lower inflation rates in the modern era than the official stats.
Our current way of calculating inflation does nothing to account for how somebody with an entry level job can now afford a car with performance that only Wall Street tycoons could afford in the 80s. So, maybe we're badly over-estimating inflation these days.
Last edited: