Arkady
President
I want to like Jill Stein. I like the fact the Green Party highlights environmental issues, for example. But when I dig into her policies, she seems to embody some of the most woolly-headed aspects of lefty thinking. Her flirtation with the anti-vaxxers is dangerous. Granted, she has no chance of becoming president, but if she did, and humored the anti-vaccine movement, it would cost the lives of kids. Her maneuvering on the topic reminds me a bit of the way Trump tries to have it both ways with racist groups -- not wanting to be associated with them, but also not wanting to alienate them with a clear denunciation.
She has also thrown in her lot with the anti-GMO types, despite the fact the anti-GMO science is just shy of the lunatic fringe. And she has a history with quack medicine (homeopathy, etc.) Moreover, she wants us to shut down nuclear power in this country. I'm not as strongly pro-nuclear as I used to be, since solar has recently bridged so much of the affordability gap with other forms of generation, but I still think any realistic low-carbon strategy for the short- and medium-term is going to need to include nuclear, if only as a grid complement to intermittent low-carbon options like solar and wind.
I know more than a few lefties of the "new age" variety, and I'm not sure if Stein is one of them or whether she just sees them as her meal ticket, but she's definitely peering from the same chakras. What she's calling for is not quite like embracing the healing power of crystals or (to borrow Jordan Weissman's brilliant comparison), like trying to levitate the Pentagon, but it's more than enough to be disturbing.
I'm also enough of an economic realistic to question some of her economics. Although I'm definitely more of a lefty than most people here, I just can't get behind the idea of canceling all student loan debt, for example. There are a lot of people who took on student loan debt as an investment in their future, and a lot of people for whom that investment is paying off big. There's no reason to let them off the hook for the cost of that investment.
For example, I once had $120,000 of student loan debt at 7-12% interest, which was terrifying. But that debt opened up high-paying jobs to me and I paid back every cent in under ten years without any help. Why should people in similar situations be given a windfall at the cost of the ordinary taxpayer (who'd effectively foot the bill for that debt forgiveness, one way or the other)? By all means, we can reform student loan policies (e.g., make student loan debt, not just interest, deductible, and reform bankruptcy laws so that the legitimately screwed can get themselves unscrewed, with various limits to prevent abuse). But mostly I'd focus on slowing future college cost growth. Bailing out doctors, lawyers, and other high-earning professionals from the cost of investments that are already paying off just doesn't make sense, other than as a simple political sales pitch.
Since I'm in Massachusetts, which is a dead lock for Clinton, I plan to use my vote as a protest, since Clinton's neoconservative tendencies disgust me. I'd been tempted to give Stein my vote, but I just can't stomach the idea of my vote looking like an endorsement of dizzy economics and new age bull-crap. So, I think it'll end up a write-in for Sanders, whose policies are pretty damned good.
She has also thrown in her lot with the anti-GMO types, despite the fact the anti-GMO science is just shy of the lunatic fringe. And she has a history with quack medicine (homeopathy, etc.) Moreover, she wants us to shut down nuclear power in this country. I'm not as strongly pro-nuclear as I used to be, since solar has recently bridged so much of the affordability gap with other forms of generation, but I still think any realistic low-carbon strategy for the short- and medium-term is going to need to include nuclear, if only as a grid complement to intermittent low-carbon options like solar and wind.
I know more than a few lefties of the "new age" variety, and I'm not sure if Stein is one of them or whether she just sees them as her meal ticket, but she's definitely peering from the same chakras. What she's calling for is not quite like embracing the healing power of crystals or (to borrow Jordan Weissman's brilliant comparison), like trying to levitate the Pentagon, but it's more than enough to be disturbing.
I'm also enough of an economic realistic to question some of her economics. Although I'm definitely more of a lefty than most people here, I just can't get behind the idea of canceling all student loan debt, for example. There are a lot of people who took on student loan debt as an investment in their future, and a lot of people for whom that investment is paying off big. There's no reason to let them off the hook for the cost of that investment.
For example, I once had $120,000 of student loan debt at 7-12% interest, which was terrifying. But that debt opened up high-paying jobs to me and I paid back every cent in under ten years without any help. Why should people in similar situations be given a windfall at the cost of the ordinary taxpayer (who'd effectively foot the bill for that debt forgiveness, one way or the other)? By all means, we can reform student loan policies (e.g., make student loan debt, not just interest, deductible, and reform bankruptcy laws so that the legitimately screwed can get themselves unscrewed, with various limits to prevent abuse). But mostly I'd focus on slowing future college cost growth. Bailing out doctors, lawyers, and other high-earning professionals from the cost of investments that are already paying off just doesn't make sense, other than as a simple political sales pitch.
Since I'm in Massachusetts, which is a dead lock for Clinton, I plan to use my vote as a protest, since Clinton's neoconservative tendencies disgust me. I'd been tempted to give Stein my vote, but I just can't stomach the idea of my vote looking like an endorsement of dizzy economics and new age bull-crap. So, I think it'll end up a write-in for Sanders, whose policies are pretty damned good.