New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Jill Stein

Arkady

President
I want to like Jill Stein. I like the fact the Green Party highlights environmental issues, for example. But when I dig into her policies, she seems to embody some of the most woolly-headed aspects of lefty thinking. Her flirtation with the anti-vaxxers is dangerous. Granted, she has no chance of becoming president, but if she did, and humored the anti-vaccine movement, it would cost the lives of kids. Her maneuvering on the topic reminds me a bit of the way Trump tries to have it both ways with racist groups -- not wanting to be associated with them, but also not wanting to alienate them with a clear denunciation.

She has also thrown in her lot with the anti-GMO types, despite the fact the anti-GMO science is just shy of the lunatic fringe. And she has a history with quack medicine (homeopathy, etc.) Moreover, she wants us to shut down nuclear power in this country. I'm not as strongly pro-nuclear as I used to be, since solar has recently bridged so much of the affordability gap with other forms of generation, but I still think any realistic low-carbon strategy for the short- and medium-term is going to need to include nuclear, if only as a grid complement to intermittent low-carbon options like solar and wind.

I know more than a few lefties of the "new age" variety, and I'm not sure if Stein is one of them or whether she just sees them as her meal ticket, but she's definitely peering from the same chakras. What she's calling for is not quite like embracing the healing power of crystals or (to borrow Jordan Weissman's brilliant comparison), like trying to levitate the Pentagon, but it's more than enough to be disturbing.

I'm also enough of an economic realistic to question some of her economics. Although I'm definitely more of a lefty than most people here, I just can't get behind the idea of canceling all student loan debt, for example. There are a lot of people who took on student loan debt as an investment in their future, and a lot of people for whom that investment is paying off big. There's no reason to let them off the hook for the cost of that investment.

For example, I once had $120,000 of student loan debt at 7-12% interest, which was terrifying. But that debt opened up high-paying jobs to me and I paid back every cent in under ten years without any help. Why should people in similar situations be given a windfall at the cost of the ordinary taxpayer (who'd effectively foot the bill for that debt forgiveness, one way or the other)? By all means, we can reform student loan policies (e.g., make student loan debt, not just interest, deductible, and reform bankruptcy laws so that the legitimately screwed can get themselves unscrewed, with various limits to prevent abuse). But mostly I'd focus on slowing future college cost growth. Bailing out doctors, lawyers, and other high-earning professionals from the cost of investments that are already paying off just doesn't make sense, other than as a simple political sales pitch.

Since I'm in Massachusetts, which is a dead lock for Clinton, I plan to use my vote as a protest, since Clinton's neoconservative tendencies disgust me. I'd been tempted to give Stein my vote, but I just can't stomach the idea of my vote looking like an endorsement of dizzy economics and new age bull-crap. So, I think it'll end up a write-in for Sanders, whose policies are pretty damned good.
 
I want to like Jill Stein. I like the fact the Green Party highlights environmental issues, for example. But when I dig into her policies, she seems to embody some of the most woolly-headed aspects of lefty thinking. Her flirtation with the anti-vaxxers is dangerous. Granted, she has no chance of becoming president, but if she did, and humored the anti-vaccine movement, it would cost the lives of kids. Her maneuvering on the topic reminds me a bit of the way Trump tries to have it both ways with racist groups -- not wanting to be associated with them, but also not wanting to alienate them with a clear denunciation.

She has also thrown in her lot with the anti-GMO types, despite the fact the anti-GMO science is just shy of the lunatic fringe. And she has a history with quack medicine (homeopathy, etc.) Moreover, she wants us to shut down nuclear power in this country. I'm not as strongly pro-nuclear as I used to be, since solar has recently bridged so much of the affordability gap with other forms of generation, but I still think any realistic low-carbon strategy for the short- and medium-term is going to need to include nuclear, if only as a grid complement to intermittent low-carbon options like solar and wind.

I know more than a few lefties of the "new age" variety, and I'm not sure if Stein is one of them or whether she just sees them as her meal ticket, but she's definitely peering from the same chakras. What she's calling for is not quite like embracing the healing power of crystals or (to borrow Jordan Weissman's brilliant comparison), like trying to levitate the Pentagon, but it's more than enough to be disturbing.

I'm also enough of an economic realistic to question some of her economics. Although I'm definitely more of a lefty than most people here, I just can't get behind the idea of canceling all student loan debt, for example. There are a lot of people who took on student loan debt as an investment in their future, and a lot of people for whom that investment is paying off big. There's no reason to let them off the hook for the cost of that investment.

For example, I once had $120,000 of student loan debt at 7-12% interest, which was terrifying. But that debt opened up high-paying jobs to me and I paid back every cent in under ten years without any help. Why should people in similar situations be given a windfall at the cost of the ordinary taxpayer (who'd effectively foot the bill for that debt forgiveness, one way or the other)? By all means, we can reform student loan policies (e.g., make student loan debt, not just interest, deductible, and reform bankruptcy laws so that the legitimately screwed can get themselves unscrewed, with various limits to prevent abuse). But mostly I'd focus on slowing future college cost growth. Bailing out doctors, lawyers, and other high-earning professionals from the cost of investments that are already paying off just doesn't make sense, other than as a simple political sales pitch.

Since I'm in Massachusetts, which is a dead lock for Clinton, I plan to use my vote as a protest, since Clinton's neoconservative tendencies disgust me. I'd been tempted to give Stein my vote, but I just can't stomach the idea of my vote looking like an endorsement of dizzy economics and new age bull-crap. So, I think it'll end up a write-in for Sanders, whose policies are pretty damned good.

I respect any candidate to an extent who supports anti-GMO standards, and your claim that it's "lunatic fringe" is ridiculous.

There's a ton of evidence to the contrary, and even looking at the GMO itself, it's not safe for human consumption.

1. Multiple Toxins From GMOs Detected In Maternal and Fetal Blood

2. DNA From Genetically Modified Crops Can Be Transferred Into Humans Who Eat Them

3. New Study Links GMOs To Gluten Disorders That Affect 18 Million Americans

4. Study Links Genetically Modified Corn to Rat Tumors

5. Glyphosate Induces Human Breast Cancer Cells Growth via Estrogen Receptors

6. Glyphosate Linked To Birth Defects

7. Study Links Glyphosate To Autism, Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s

8. Chronically Ill Humans Have Higher Glyphosate Levels Than Healthy Humans

9. Studies Link GMO Animal Feed to Severe Stomach Inflammation and Enlarged Uteri in Pigs

http://www.collective-evolution.com...-proving-gmos-can-be-harmful-to-human-health/

The amount of money used, bully law, deception, and cover up to keep the GMO use alive or hidden is enough to raise suspicion itself, IMO.

We aren't even allowed to know if GMO's are in our food, and coincidentally, Monsanto owns both parties, including your own, beloved Democrat party.
 
I respect any candidate to an extent who supports anti-GMO standards, and your claim that it's "lunatic fringe" is ridiculous.

There's a ton of evidence to the contrary, and even looking at the GMO itself, it's not safe for human consumption.

1. Multiple Toxins From GMOs Detected In Maternal and Fetal Blood

2. DNA From Genetically Modified Crops Can Be Transferred Into Humans Who Eat Them

3. New Study Links GMOs To Gluten Disorders That Affect 18 Million Americans

4. Study Links Genetically Modified Corn to Rat Tumors

5. Glyphosate Induces Human Breast Cancer Cells Growth via Estrogen Receptors

6. Glyphosate Linked To Birth Defects

7. Study Links Glyphosate To Autism, Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s

8. Chronically Ill Humans Have Higher Glyphosate Levels Than Healthy Humans

9. Studies Link GMO Animal Feed to Severe Stomach Inflammation and Enlarged Uteri in Pigs

http://www.collective-evolution.com...-proving-gmos-can-be-harmful-to-human-health/

The amount of money used, bully law, deception, and cover up to keep the GMO use alive or hidden is enough to raise suspicion itself, IMO.

We aren't even allowed to know if GMO's are in our food, and coincidentally, Monsanto owns both parties, including your own, beloved Democrat party.


I love how Europe is great, we should follow everything the Europeans do.....

except -they ban GMO's... I never see that being praised for positive, forward thinking....

But, not liking GMO's is on the "lunatic fringe".... but yet whole countries of knowing, thinking well educated people - disallow them in their products....

Ah.. contradiction.. thy name is lefty...

connie
 
I love how Europe is great, we should follow everything the Europeans do.....

except -they ban GMO's... I never see that being praised for positive, forward thinking....

But, not liking GMO's is on the "lunatic fringe".... but yet whole countries of knowing, thinking well educated people - disallow them in their products....

Ah.. contradiction.. they name is lefty...

connie

Typical lefty. All they really want is to see Americans stripped of their civil rights, as European regimes have done to their subjects for centuries. This is why the Democrats, especially the current radical wing of the party (Clinton, Obama, etc.), have always been the attractive option for this type of authoritarian collectivist.
 
Typical lefty. All they really want is to see Americans stripped of their civil rights, as European regimes have done to their subjects for centuries. This is why the Democrats, especially the current radical wing of the party (Clinton, Obama, etc.), have always been the attractive option for this type of authoritarian collectivist.

Well look at Arkady's objections to Stein...

She doesn't submit to the "settled science " of GMO's. Of course, how anyone who is an environmentalist can support them is beyond me. GMO's are the antithesis of natural, wholesome, unity with the land. Environmentalists don't want any form of man-made or artificial chemical used in farming. - thus why would they support a product designed to withstand an obscene level of onslaught of man-made chemical. They expect that lower yields, is the result. They think that is the best.

She doesn't submit to the "settled science" of nuclear energy.

She doesn't submit to the settled science brought to us by Big Pharma.

Hell, she is a freaking heretic of all that is sacred to lefty - being owned by big corporatism and submitting to the authority of their betters, and individual freedom and choice ( anti-vax). No wonder he can't stand her. She is actually a better candidate for libertarians who feel strongly about environmental issues - than the libertarian candidate.
 
I want to like Jill Stein. I like the fact the Green Party highlights environmental issues, for example. But when I dig into her policies, she seems to embody some of the most woolly-headed aspects of lefty thinking. Her flirtation with the anti-vaxxers is dangerous. Granted, she has no chance of becoming president, but if she did, and humored the anti-vaccine movement, it would cost the lives of kids. Her maneuvering on the topic reminds me a bit of the way Trump tries to have it both ways with racist groups -- not wanting to be associated with them, but also not wanting to alienate them with a clear denunciation.

She has also thrown in her lot with the anti-GMO types, despite the fact the anti-GMO science is just shy of the lunatic fringe. And she has a history with quack medicine (homeopathy, etc.) Moreover, she wants us to shut down nuclear power in this country. I'm not as strongly pro-nuclear as I used to be, since solar has recently bridged so much of the affordability gap with other forms of generation, but I still think any realistic low-carbon strategy for the short- and medium-term is going to need to include nuclear, if only as a grid complement to intermittent low-carbon options like solar and wind.

I know more than a few lefties of the "new age" variety, and I'm not sure if Stein is one of them or whether she just sees them as her meal ticket, but she's definitely peering from the same chakras. What she's calling for is not quite like embracing the healing power of crystals or (to borrow Jordan Weissman's brilliant comparison), like trying to levitate the Pentagon, but it's more than enough to be disturbing.

I'm also enough of an economic realistic to question some of her economics. Although I'm definitely more of a lefty than most people here, I just can't get behind the idea of canceling all student loan debt, for example. There are a lot of people who took on student loan debt as an investment in their future, and a lot of people for whom that investment is paying off big. There's no reason to let them off the hook for the cost of that investment.

For example, I once had $120,000 of student loan debt at 7-12% interest, which was terrifying. But that debt opened up high-paying jobs to me and I paid back every cent in under ten years without any help. Why should people in similar situations be given a windfall at the cost of the ordinary taxpayer (who'd effectively foot the bill for that debt forgiveness, one way or the other)? By all means, we can reform student loan policies (e.g., make student loan debt, not just interest, deductible, and reform bankruptcy laws so that the legitimately screwed can get themselves unscrewed, with various limits to prevent abuse). But mostly I'd focus on slowing future college cost growth. Bailing out doctors, lawyers, and other high-earning professionals from the cost of investments that are already paying off just doesn't make sense, other than as a simple political sales pitch.

Since I'm in Massachusetts, which is a dead lock for Clinton, I plan to use my vote as a protest, since Clinton's neoconservative tendencies disgust me. I'd been tempted to give Stein my vote, but I just can't stomach the idea of my vote looking like an endorsement of dizzy economics and new age bull-crap. So, I think it'll end up a write-in for Sanders, whose policies are pretty damned good.

Who you think you're fooling? (other than yourself)

sexist hater
 
I respect any candidate to an extent who supports anti-GMO standards

Yes, there are many, like you, on the lunatic fringe, and it worries me that Stein is flirting with such nonsense.

First, you've been taken in:

https://www.geneticliteracyproject....ving-gmos-are-harmful-not-if-science-matters/

Second, yes, of course, with many, many thousands of studies on the subject of GMO crops, it's inevitable that some will appear to show health problems with them. If the null hypothesis has a 5% chance of being true, based on the results, that still means you'll have quite a few individual studies showing what appear to be statistically significant negative health results just by chance, if you run enough studies. The chance of a "false positive" for any individual study will be low, but with thousands of studies, that'll mean many false positives. That's why meta-analysis is critical, rather than just doing the lunatic-fringe move of seizing on the tiny handful of studies that seemed to tell them what they want to believe. The meta analyses have been compelling.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4218791/
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0278691511006399
 
I love how Europe is great, we should follow everything the Europeans do.....

That's a straw man. I've never argued we should follow everything Europeans do. I frequently cite things we should avoid that Europeans do wrong, and the irrational fear of GMOs is one of those examples.
 
Of course, how anyone who is an environmentalist can support them is beyond me. GMO's are the antithesis of natural, wholesome, unity with the land.

You're confusing environmentalism with new-age bullcrap. A new-age cultist approaches the environment as a kind of Gaia worship, and thus what matters is the fuzzy-headed idea of whether something is natural and in unity with the land. And environmentalist thinks about real-world outcomes. And from an environmental perspective, GM crops allow greater crop yields with fewer pesticides and less overall disruption of the environment (e.g., less deforestation, less depletion of acquifers, less run-off from irrigation, etc.) I'm an environmentalist, not a new-ager.
 
What makes you think that?

Shouldn't it tell you something that you always have to rely on such straw-man attacks?
YOU are the one who posted the moronic link that said so. You used it to base criticism of Hillary as being purely from "sexism".
Don't you even pay attention to the nonsense you post?
 
You're confusing environmentalism with new-age bullcrap. A new-age cultist approaches the environment as a kind of Gaia worship, and thus what matters is the fuzzy-headed idea of whether something is natural and in unity with the land. And environmentalist thinks about real-world outcomes. And from an environmental perspective, GM crops allow greater crop yields with fewer pesticides and less overall disruption of the environment (e.g., less deforestation, less depletion of acquifers, less run-off from irrigation, etc.) I'm an environmentalist, not a new-ager.


So basically every major "green" party of most major countries in the world oppose GMO's.. but that is because they are not "real" environmentalists...

got it.
 
It pretty obvious this is the "I can't look myself in the mirror if I vote for Hillary" post
 
Back
Top