New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Jobs

Arkady

President
Sorry if I missed an earlier post on this.

The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.

A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.

What's going on?

Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.

The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.

So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.
 
Interesting, though that isn't enough information to really know what that means. For example, how many jobs are filled per week? If there are 5.1 million unfilled jobs at a given moment, but most of those will be filled in the next few weeks, with all new jobs coming online, that's just "frictional unemployment" -- the snapshot you'll have in even the best of markets from the delay time between listing and filling a job. It would also be helpful to have more history on that -- where the number of unfilled jobs are today versus at other periods in recent history.

My own personal guess is we're not quite to "full employment" yet. My reasoning is that inflation remains quite low, so there's no sign unemployment is yet so low as to be driving a problem in that area. In fact, we got down to and below the current unemployment level from around the start of 1999 until March of 2001, and yet in all that time inflation never became a problem. That suggests that "full employment" would involve an unemployment rate in the mid-to-high-threes, or lower, not the low fours. And the LFPR is still off from from its highs even if you adjust for demographic aging, suggesting there are still some people on the sidelines who could be coaxed back in the game with a stronger job market.

Anyway, if we can keep going at roughly this rate (say 150,000 jobs per month, average), I'll be content. That's enough to outpace population growth and gets slowly closer to full employment. I am a little worried, though, that what we're seeing are the early signs of a coming recession. The trend with recent recessions is for them to have been preceded by periods of spotty and weakening job creation, and right now we have such a period. Maybe we'll bounce back strong like in 2012, but maybe, instead, this is like what we saw in 2007, leading up to the last recession's start, or what we was in mid 2001, leading into the first of Bush's two recessions.
 
Interesting, though that isn't enough information to really know what that means. For example, how many jobs are filled per week? If there are 5.1 million unfilled jobs at a given moment, but most of those will be filled in the next few weeks, with all new jobs coming online, that's just "frictional unemployment" -- the snapshot you'll have in even the best of markets from the delay time between listing and filling a job. It would also be helpful to have more history on that -- where the number of unfilled jobs are today versus at other periods in recent history.

My own personal guess is we're not quite to "full employment" yet. My reasoning is that inflation remains quite low, so there's no sign unemployment is yet so low as to be driving a problem in that area. In fact, we got down to and below the current unemployment level from around the start of 1999 until March of 2001, and yet in all that time inflation never became a problem. That suggests that "full employment" would involve an unemployment rate in the mid-to-high-threes, or lower, not the low fours. And the LFPR is still off from from its highs even if you adjust for demographic aging, suggesting there are still some people on the sidelines who could be coaxed back in the game with a stronger job market.

Anyway, if we can keep going at roughly this rate (say 150,000 jobs per month, average), I'll be content. That's enough to outpace population growth and gets slowly closer to full employment. I am a little worried, though, that what we're seeing are the early signs of a coming recession. The trend with recent recessions is for them to have been preceded by periods of spotty and weakening job creation, and right now we have such a period. Maybe we'll bounce back strong like in 2012, but maybe, instead, this is like what we saw in 2007, leading up to the last recession's start, or what we was in mid 2001, leading into the first of Bush's two recessions.
If we had a recession what would you blame it on?
 
Last edited:
Sorry if I missed an earlier post on this.

The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.

A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.

What's going on?

Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.

The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.

So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.

WTF? What part of companies aren't hiring so people aren't looking is so hard for you to understand? This isn't rocket science:

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/...ctly-the-same-rate-as-it-did-during-the-1930s
 
If we had a recession what would you blame it on?
At this point, I'd just blame it on the dynamics of the business cycle, which make runs of growth this long extremely rare. The average growth cycle, historically, has only been 38.7 months, and even in more recent times, since the New Deal helped to lengthen growth cycles, the average has been only 59 months. We're now 96 months into this growth cycle, which is the third-longest in history. The longest --the Clinton Boom-- was 120 months long, so we could have another two years on this cycle before entering unprecedented territory, but we're already far past what we typically see. For example, if we haven't gone into recession by next month, we will have blown past the length of the last growth cycle by two full years.

What I'll be more interested in is how long and deep the coming recession is, and how long and strong the subsequent growth cycle is. Back when we fell into the first of Bush's two recessions, I didn't hold that against him, because we were long overdue for a correction. People had gone for so long only seeing improvements, that it was inevitable that they would have over-extended in some places, and an adjustment was going to happen. But though I didn't blame Bush for that, I did blame him for the subsequent growth cycle being so pathetic. Not only was it shorter than the prior two cycles, it was also shockingly bad at actually producing decent results for most Americans. Even at the peak of the Bush economy, before the second (and vastly worse) of his two recessions, things were going poorly for the country relative to where we'd been before Bush oozed his way into the Oval Office. Deficits were vastly higher than he'd inherited, the unemployment rate still hadn't gotten back to pre-Bush levels, and incomes were down and poverty was up relative to what Bush had inherited. The murder rate was also higher than Bush inherited. So, when that second recession started, we were falling from what was already a disappointingly poor position.

Hopefully we wouldn't see the same kind of disappointing performance from a Trump economy, following a correction, but since socioeconomic disappointment is a pretty reliable state for America when Republicans are in the White House, it's the wise bet this time, as well.
 
WTF? What part of companies aren't hiring so people aren't looking is so hard for you to understand? This isn't rocket science:

http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/...ctly-the-same-rate-as-it-did-during-the-1930s
Your blogs are so cute! I love how he lumps the decade of the 1930s together for no better reason that the number, when it was so clearly two different eras. There was the era from 1930 through March of 1933 (the Hoover era), when the economy was an absolute disaster. Then there was the New Deal era, when we had the strongest economic growth in peace-time history, other than the single year of 1938. Take a look at a simple arithmetic average growth/shrinkage rate per year:

1930-1933 -7.3% shrinkage
1934-1939: 7.1% growth

The FDR section of the thirties was as good as the Hoover section was bad.
 
Sorry if I missed an earlier post on this.

The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.

A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.

What's going on?

Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.

The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.

So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.

No worries. The pathological liar-in-chief claims he already created a million jobs.

http://money.cnn.com/2017/06/01/new...n-private-sector-jobs-paris-speech/index.html
 
Sorry if I missed an earlier post on this.

The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.

A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.

What's going on?

Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.

The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.

So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.
you get a c-minus on this paper.

as a matter of economics, please note that:

  • unemployment is not a "cause" of a recession. its an effect
  • nobody believes the job creation or unemployment numbers any longer. not with 95 million working age people out of the workforce, and food stamp use at record levels.
  • There continues to be a huge disparity between the US department of labor job statistics, and ADP, which actually processes payrolls. ADP shows 100,000 more jobs in May 2017 than BLS. See links below.
  • millions of the unemployed are in fact NOT EMPLOYABLE. for reasons such as functional illiteracy/HS dropout; can't pass a drug test; prior convictions restrict where they could work; refuse to work because wages will be garnished for back child support; etc.
  • the number of people on "permanent disability" and medically unable to work (through court decision) more than doubled during the Obama administration
  • May/June/July are problematic for unemployment numbers, because of the large number of high school and college grads seeking work for the first time
  • Apple is sitting on more than $200 billion in foreign cash, which it refuses to repatriate to America (they don't like America's corporate tax rates) while nearly 99% of their manufacturing takes place overseas.

https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/empsit.pdf

https://www.adpemploymentreport.com/
 
unemployment is not a "cause" of a recession. its an effect

Are you under the impression I called it a cause? If so, reread. I'm simply pointing out that recessions tend to be preceded by periods of labor market weakness. That isn't asserting causation. It's just saying that if we see a period of such weakness, it may be telling us something.

nobody believes the job creation or unemployment numbers any longer. not with 95 million working age people out of the workforce, and food stamp use at record levels.

What you're really saying here is "I don't believe in numbers that tell me things that make me politically uncomfortable." We already knew that. But speak for yourself -- don't try to attribute your own feelings to everyone else.

There continues to be a huge disparity between the US department of labor job statistics, and ADP, which actually processes payrolls. ADP shows 100,000 more jobs in May 2017 than BLS.

The whole reason for ADP's numbers is to try to give business people a preview of where the BLS numbers will come out. That's why they come out right before the BLS numbers. ADP has never been perfect at that prediction games. Sometimes they come out high, sometimes low.

millions of the unemployed are in fact NOT EMPLOYABLE. for reasons such as functional illiteracy/HS dropout; can't pass a drug test; prior convictions restrict where they could work; refuse to work because wages will be garnished for back child support; etc.

Possibly. However, we have examples in recent history of considerably lower unemployment rates -- as low as 3.8% in the Clinton years, and even lower in the Johnson, Truman, and Roosevelt years. These days, a lower share of Americans are high school dropouts and/or functionally illiterate than in those earlier times. And you'd think that the convictions issue would have been at least as bad in the Clinton era, since our nation's all-time high for violent crime rates was right before he took office, at the end of the Reagan/Bush economic catastrophe.
  • May/June/July are problematic for unemployment numbers, because of the large number of high school and college grads seeking work for the first time

You should read up on this before. The numbers I quoted are seasonally adjusted, so they already take that into account
 
Stuff like that leaves me wondering whether he's really that stupid, or whether he's a smart man who simply holds his supporters in utter contempt, figuring they're stupid enough to swallow any swill he serves up.

Did you think same of boy Θ's lies and libs stupid enough to swallow:
(1) If you like your Doctor
(2) If you like your insurance
(3) $2,500 savings

His supporters swallowed that hook/line and sinker
 
Stuff like that leaves me wondering whether he's really that stupid, or whether he's a smart man who simply holds his supporters in utter contempt, figuring they're stupid enough to swallow any swill he serves up.

It's the latter. He knows his rabble know nothing, and they believe any lie he tells.
 
Back
Top