Arkady
President
Sorry if I missed an earlier post on this.
The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.
A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.
What's going on?
Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.
The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.
So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.
The latest jobs report came out and it's a mixed bag. The unemployment rate fell, but job creation was unimpressive. Economists expected 185,000 jobs to be created, and the figure came in at 138,000. We also suffered significant downward revisions of job numbers for the prior two months, erasing 66,000 jobs we thought we'd created in March and April. The final March figure was just 50,000 jobs, which is considerably less than needed to keep up with population growth.
A figure that low would be no big deal in a single month, but we now see it's becoming part of a pattern. So far, on Trump's watch, we've averaged just 149,000 jobs created per month. That's the worst average for a period of this length since mid-2012.
What's going on?
Well, there are two ways of looking at it. The mainstream way is to simply to think of it in terms of being close to full employment. The closer you are to full employment, the more job creation will be restricted by labor supply problems: businesses are creating openings, but those openings are hard to fill because there are fewer and fewer motivated and qualified workers available. With the unemployment rate now just at 4.3%, it's going to mean that there will be many local areas where it's well under 4%, (e.g., 2.3% in Colorado, or 2.7% in Hawaii, or 3.9% in my own state of Massachusetts). Such rates are so low that there's little more than "frictional unemployment" there -- people briefly between jobs. The more places get into that situation, the harder it will be to produce large job creation numbers.
The one thing calling that explanation into question is that the average workweek has been unchanged at 34.4 hours, where you'd expect workweeks to be climbing if companies were dealing with a shortage of available workers. Still, even with workweeks steady, I think the idea that we're just running up against "full employment" is a fairly satisfying explanation, from a mainstream economic outlook. It is not, however, satisfying if, like so many right-wingers in the Obama years, you take the view that our "real unemployment rate" is vastly higher. If you think there are secretly tens of millions of extra unemployed people who aren't being counted, it's a lot harder to explain why job creation would have slowed down to a relative trickle, based on labor-supply considerations. There should be plenty of people available to fill new slots, so there just aren't as many slots being created these days. From that perspective, there must be something else going wrong in the last few months.
So, is this a sign we're going into a recession? Tough to say. It's encouraging that we went through a similar rough spot in mid-2012 and bounced back strongly. Hopefully that happens again. In 2012, we went nine straight months with sub-200k job creation, before bouncing back strongly. Currently we've been sub-200k every month since the election, but that's still only seven straight months, so we still have some time to bounce back based on the 2012 pattern.
