New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Just disgusting

Until you read the whole transcript of a case you really cannot judge it properly.

It says that the woman was questioned for four hours, answering yes or no but it doesn't say what she said.

There isn't enough in the news paper to be able to see the arguments from either side.

Judges can only go by The Law they can't go by moral judgements. popular or no.

You might be right this might be a travesty but it might not be.

I have never known of any rape that wasn't a travesty.
 
I have never known of any rape that wasn't a travesty.

Amendment ......A travesty of Justice and this wasn't a rape case, it was a sexual abuse case and PACE and I have hashed it out .....I think ...and the electricity is back on. all raping and pillaging over the road is over and the jumble sale, so I can go and make a nice cuppa and leave you lot to sort out the World without me for a couple of mins ;) welcome to PJs Daniel Webster.
 
If the crime was reported and prosecuted, and she gave testimony, and she testified that it was without consent, then it was without consent. She was unable to fight back. I have a friend with a daughter who has CP...she is not mentally disabled, but cannot speak, and would have no way to fight back. My girl worked at UCP...she worked with women who could not control their limbs or communicate. I met them.
 
If the crime was reported and prosecuted, and she gave testimony, and she testified that it was without consent, then it was without consent. She was unable to fight back. I have a friend with a daughter who has CP...she is not mentally disabled, but cannot speak, and would have no way to fight back. My girl worked at UCP...she worked with women who could not control their limbs or communicate. I met them.




Now you tell me she did testify that she testified that she did not give consent. No body mentioned that before.

All I had to go on was the newspaper article which said very little.

I have worked with mentally and physically disabled people too, long ago, as a carer and in more recent year as ............... well as ' and yes life experience, friends severely disabled in accidents and friends with children who will need care forever. Disability has touched most of our lives somehow I should imagine. especially as it is more visable now a days, people are not hidden away as they once were and as far as possible look for as much independence as they can.

Because no one could or would or did give any answers as to what the young woman in questions' testimony was I looked at it from another angle. Which, though I now realise is not applicable; because now you tell me she did testify she was forced against her will; to this case, is an important one and in many ways a difficult one


Right so I had to go and look myself since no one will tell me anything ( I shall ignore these 'public outrage' post from now on )

http://slutwalkseattle.com/post/32828262157/dont-have-severe-disabilities
 
In court, the 29-year-old handicapped woman went only by the initials L.K. She suffers from severe cerebral palsy and can only communicate by moving her right index finger.

The woman testified by passing her finger over the words “yes” and “no” as well as over the letters of the alphabet if she needed to spell something. This process lasted four days, according to the Post.

This is from PACE's original link.
 
This is from PACE's original link.


Friday it did not say what she said .............. Good God would I have gone through all this bloody nonsense if I had known what she testified ? Just saying, That she testified, tells me nothing ...What she testified does.

For heavens sake it was a half told story ...... I always look at things from different angles and I always want to know all the facts .......so I am, you should know that by now.

No matter now I know ..... Where is the young woman now ?
 
If the crime was reported and prosecuted, and she gave testimony, and she testified that it was without consent, then it was without consent. She was unable to fight back. I have a friend with a daughter who has CP...she is not mentally disabled, but cannot speak, and would have no way to fight back. My girl worked at UCP...she worked with women who could not control their limbs or communicate. I met them.

We had a girl here who starved to death because her Mother and all the Nurses she had did not take care of her. She was covered with filth and feces and weighed almost nothing when she died,although she had daily Nurses with Registered Nurses to over see her care .

All those people were paid well to take care of her and they let her die of starvation. 2 are already in prison,the others await trial. She had CP!
 
Anyone who thinks this was a fair ruling has rocks in their head.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/nat...lsy-article-1.1175342?localLinksEnabled=false

It's travesty of justice when a person with the mental capacity of a three year is not protected under the law in the case of rape, because, BECAUSE, "no evidence victim fought back".


Truly a disgusting ruling by the Connecticut Supreme Court!

From what I've read, it sounds to me as if the prosecutors dropped the ball on this one. It seems the charges were based on proving that the victim was unable to signify non-consent and would typically be applied to cases where the victim was incapacitated to the point of being unable to take action at all – e.g. extremely drunk or comatose. The very fact that she was able to testify at all served to undermine the charges.

There are a lot of questions here, to be sure. Why was the guy only charged with sexual abuse? Why wasn't he charged in such a way that the victim's lack of consent and/or inability to give truly informed consent figured into the trial, conviction, and sentence? Lots of questions...

But whatever happened, it doesn't look to me as if the court necessarily did anything wrong. Let's not overlook the fact that the CT Supreme Court actually upheld the decision of a lower appellate court. Given the facts in hand, I don't think we should be calling for the judges who voted to uphold to be tarred and feathered.

Now the prosecutors of the original case, that may be another story...

So this case may well be a travesty of justice, but let's be careful about who we want to hang for it, eh? Maybe we need to save our outrage for the prosecutors, or even for poorly-written laws. I'll need more facts before I'm ready to break out the rope.

In my experience, courts are about enforcing laws and keeping order first and foremost. “Justice”, if it's truly attainable at all, ranks well down on the list of judicial imperatives. By and large we trust that on average “justice” will be done in our legal system, that it'll arise often enough out of our messy, adversarial, legalistic system. That assumption works tolerably well on average for average folks dealing with normal issues, I guess. It's probably the best we can do, sadly.

It's infuriating at times, I know that well enough. But even though our legal system is apt to screw over most people some of the time (and some people most of the time), it's a heck of lot more likely to produce justice than an outraged, disgusted mob, don't you think?

Cheers.
 
http://www.ctpost.com/news/article/Supreme-Court-sets-accused-rapist-free-3910077.php

Yes, I do think that. I don't think it is a mob mentality but more so why when there was evidence that the 26 year old woman could not speak or have little body movement would have to resist what he may do to her. With her mental capability she might not have had a clue as to what was going to happen.

Yes there are many questions and I am glad they are being asked however in this link I will post it looks like he can't be tried again for this......yes I will call it a crime until we know different.

Maybe if women speak up and I'm sure they will in Connecticut, laws can be changed. I would certainly hope so.
 
I agree lilly

but unless you hit the 'Reply' or 'Reply with Quote' attached to the bottom of Havelocks post he won't know you are talking to him :)

I left a good link about the case a few posts up ( to Friday I think ) please God the poor little thing is with people who love her eh ?

Sweet dreams xxxx
 
Havelock. I think he made some good points but we can't just let it go.

Well, for the record, I don't think we should just let it go either. I'm only suggesting that get as many facts as we can and weigh them, ahem, judiciously, before we pass judgment.

Not to sound like a broken record, but in my experience justice is rarely the immediate product of disgust and outrage.

Cheers.
 
We had a girl here who starved to death because her Mother and all the Nurses she had did not take care of her. She was covered with filth and feces and weighed almost nothing when she died,although she had daily Nurses with Registered Nurses to over see her care .

All those people were paid well to take care of her and they let her die of starvation. 2 are already in prison,the others await trial. She had CP!

Link??
 
Well, for the record, I don't think we should just let it go either. I'm only suggesting that get as many facts as we can and weigh them, ahem, judiciously, before we pass judgment.

Not to sound like a broken record, but in my experience justice is rarely the immediate product of disgust and outrage.

Cheers.

Well I hope you don't mind but I'm still disgusted since someone in that group of lawyers or high court made a mistake.
 
Well I hope you don't mind but I'm still disgusted since someone in that group of lawyers or high court made a mistake.

and you know that for sure even though you were not there nor have you read the transcripts of the case?? wow!!
 
I agree lilly

but unless you hit the 'Reply' or 'Reply with Quote' attached to the bottom of Havelocks post he won't know you are talking to him :)

I left a good link about the case a few posts up ( to Friday I think ) please God the poor little thing is with people who love her eh ?

Sweet dreams xxxx

Neither of us are on the threaded mode so you should be able to see I posted right after Havelock did. I always quote and you know I a stickler on that but others could have been confused but not you. You told me what mode you use. Sorry to anyone that didn't know what the hell I was talking about.
 
and you know that for sure even though you were not there nor have you read the transcripts of the case?? wow!!

Well Havelock said he thought the prosecutors dropped the ball and I tend to agree it could have been the case. Is that alright with you?
 
I have questions, Havelock. Did the "sexual abuse" take place only once, or was it repeated? Where did this happen? Why was she not protected? Why was this not an ADA case? Is there the danger that this man will repeat the offenses? Is there danger to the victim that this man will retaliate...is she safe from him? Is there a public danger to others from this man?

I am disgusted and outraged, but, if it took this woman 4 hours to testify, laboriously, with a letter board and one finger, how could she have been able to SAY NO (she is obviously non-verbal)? How could she have been able to defend herself if all she could do was "kick and groan"? There are young, strong, healthy women who are unable to defend themselves from rape/sexual abuse (both have the same meaning)?
 
Back
Top