Anyone who thinks this was a fair ruling has rocks in their head.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/nat...lsy-article-1.1175342?localLinksEnabled=false
It's travesty of justice when a person with the mental capacity of a three year is not protected under the law in the case of rape, because, BECAUSE, "no evidence victim fought back".
Truly a disgusting ruling by the Connecticut Supreme Court!
From what I've read, it sounds to me as if the prosecutors dropped the ball on this one. It seems the charges were based on proving that the victim was unable to signify non-consent and would typically be applied to cases where the victim was incapacitated to the point of being unable to take action at all – e.g. extremely drunk or comatose. The very fact that she was able to testify at all served to undermine the charges.
There are a lot of questions here, to be sure. Why was the guy only charged with sexual abuse? Why wasn't he charged in such a way that the victim's lack of consent and/or inability to give truly informed consent figured into the trial, conviction, and sentence? Lots of questions...
But whatever happened, it doesn't look to me as if the court necessarily did anything wrong. Let's not overlook the fact that the CT Supreme Court actually upheld the decision of a lower appellate court. Given the facts in hand, I don't think we should be calling for the judges who voted to uphold to be tarred and feathered.
Now the prosecutors of the original case, that may be another story...
So this case may well be a travesty of justice, but let's be careful about who we want to hang for it, eh? Maybe we need to save our outrage for the prosecutors, or even for poorly-written laws. I'll need more facts before I'm ready to break out the rope.
In my experience, courts are about enforcing laws and keeping order first and foremost. “Justice”, if it's truly attainable at all, ranks well down on the list of judicial imperatives. By and large we trust that on average “justice” will be done in our legal system, that it'll arise often enough out of our messy, adversarial, legalistic system. That assumption works tolerably well on average for average folks dealing with normal issues, I guess. It's probably the best we can do, sadly.
It's infuriating at times, I know that well enough. But even though our legal system is apt to screw over most people some of the time (and some people most of the time), it's a heck of lot more likely to produce justice than an outraged, disgusted mob, don't you think?
Cheers.