New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Just one week from now

Wahbooz

Governor
is an event to remember, the anniversary of the invasion of Europe. I think this is a time to reflect on the greatest generation, and the part they played in changing the course of history.

Over 5,000 men were lost, along with some 500 ships and landing craft. One of those was LST 523, which sunk after hitting a German mine. Most of the ships company, including Capt. Elmer Reitz, and men of the 207th Engineering Battalion lost their lives.

All these men made the ultimate sacrifice.
 
my prediction - some revisionist historian is already at work trying to recast world war 2 as the outcome of bad american policy.
 
my prediction - some revisionist historian is already at work trying to recast world war 2 as the outcome of bad american policy.
In a way, historians have already implicated bad US policy in WWII. Not that the US was one of the nations most at fault. At the end of WWI, there were two schools of thought about how to treat Germany. The UK and France wanted to extract revenge and reparations, and to prevent Germany from rebuilding effectively. Wilson, on the other hand, wanted to make it easy for Germany to rebuild, and to set up a strong League of Nations to serve as a forum for resolving disputes before they became toxic. Wilson failed to convince the UK and France, and then failed to convince Congress in the US to support a strong League of Nations. As a result, Germans spent years stewing in a sense of injustice and looking for scapegoats, and when a nut-job with a weird little mustache handed them scapegoats and a dream of militaristic greatness, he found a nation that was only too ready to jump on board. The US is fairly low on the list of those to blame, but it's there. Fortunately, we learned our lesson, and after WWII the Western nations took a path that was more like what Wilson had urged. They assisted Germany in rebuilding and created a United Nations that was significantly stronger than the League of Nations. As a result, Germany became one of the most peaceable major countries in the world, and for seventy years there has never been another full war between superpowers.
 
In a way, historians have already implicated bad US policy in WWII. Not that the US was one of the nations most at fault. At the end of WWI, there were two schools of thought about how to treat Germany. The UK and France wanted to extract revenge and reparations, and to prevent Germany from rebuilding effectively. Wilson, on the other hand, wanted to make it easy for Germany to rebuild, and to set up a strong League of Nations to serve as a forum for resolving disputes before they became toxic. Wilson failed to convince the UK and France, and then failed to convince Congress in the US to support a strong League of Nations. As a result, Germans spent years stewing in a sense of injustice and looking for scapegoats, and when a nut-job with a weird little mustache handed them scapegoats and a dream of militaristic greatness, he found a nation that was only too ready to jump on board. The US is fairly low on the list of those to blame, but it's there. Fortunately, we learned our lesson, and after WWII the Western nations took a path that was more like what Wilson had urged. They assisted Germany in rebuilding and created a United Nations that was significantly stronger than the League of Nations. As a result, Germany became one of the most peaceable major countries in the world, and for seventy years there has never been another full war between superpowers.

Speaking of revisionist history...
 
my prediction - some revisionist historian is already at work trying to recast world war 2 as the outcome of bad american policy.

Oh thank you so much for [Unwelcome language removed] on my post with your bullshit. This piece of history is obviously way over your head.
 
In a way, historians have already implicated bad US policy in WWII. Not that the US was one of the nations most at fault. At the end of WWI, there were two schools of thought about how to treat Germany. The UK and France wanted to extract revenge and reparations, and to prevent Germany from rebuilding effectively. Wilson, on the other hand, wanted to make it easy for Germany to rebuild, and to set up a strong League of Nations to serve as a forum for resolving disputes before they became toxic. Wilson failed to convince the UK and France, and then failed to convince Congress in the US to support a strong League of Nations. As a result, Germans spent years stewing in a sense of injustice and looking for scapegoats, and when a nut-job with a weird little mustache handed them scapegoats and a dream of militaristic greatness, he found a nation that was only too ready to jump on board. The US is fairly low on the list of those to blame, but it's there. Fortunately, we learned our lesson, and after WWII the Western nations took a path that was more like what Wilson had urged. They assisted Germany in rebuilding and created a United Nations that was significantly stronger than the League of Nations. As a result, Germany became one of the most peaceable major countries in the world, and for seventy years there has never been another full war between superpowers.

The main cause for WW2, at least in Europe, seems to be the vindictive peace of 1918, and the US is hardly to blame for that.

.
 
The main cause for WW2, at least in Europe, seems to be the vindictive peace of 1918, and the US is hardly to blame for that.

.

And the resulting inflation in Germany. When it takes a suitcase full of Deutsche Marks to buy a loaf of bread, people are easily misled.
 
is an event to remember, the anniversary of the invasion of Europe. I think this is a time to reflect on the greatest generation, and the part they played in changing the course of history.

Over 5,000 men were lost, along with some 500 ships and landing craft. One of those was LST 523, which sunk after hitting a German mine. Most of the ships company, including Capt. Elmer Reitz, and men of the 207th Engineering Battalion lost their lives.

All these men made the ultimate sacrifice.

Great thought my good friend but as you can see the thread was hijacked before it got off the ground.. I had two brothers who landed at Normandy, both of which are now dead, but tks for taking a pause for their cause Wabbooz.

gramps
 
Great thought my good friend but as you can see the thread was hijacked before it got off the ground.. I had two brothers who landed at Normandy, both of which are now dead, but tks for taking a pause for their cause Wabbooz.

gramps

Yw, Gramps. I had an uncle whose back looked like the landscape of the moon, so I feel a special connection to what happened that day, and will always feel they deserve recognition. He's gone now, like so many he fought with.

You know, there's a cemetery there, but the waters along the coast is a cemetery as well for so many sailors and soldiers who gave all when they went down with the ships.
 
Yw, Gramps. I had an uncle whose back looked like the landscape of the moon, so I feel a special connection to what happened that day, and will always feel they deserve recognition. He's gone now, like so many he fought with.

You know, there's a cemetery there, but the waters along the coast is a cemetery as well for so many sailors and soldiers who gave all when they went down with the ships.

My father in law was with the 101st Airborne Paratroopers...landed on the beach in Normandy. He made it home...thankfully. He's passed now. But he seldom talked about this experience.
 
The main cause for WW2, at least in Europe, seems to be the vindictive peace of 1918, and the US is hardly to blame for that.

.
I would put the US pretty low on the list of those to blame for the vindictive peace, since Wilson proposed something better. But the US did, ultimately, sign off on those vindictive peace terms. I haven't read enough about the actual conference to have a strong opinion on this, but my impression is that Wilson ultimately backed down, rather than holding out for better.
 
My father in law was with the 101st Airborne Paratroopers...landed on the beach in Normandy. He made it home...thankfully. He's passed now. But he seldom talked about this experience.

Neither my father, or my uncles, talked about it, Carol. And one of my uncles was at Bataan.
 
I would put the US pretty low on the list of those to blame for the vindictive peace, since Wilson proposed something better. But the US did, ultimately, sign off on those vindictive peace terms. I haven't read enough about the actual conference to have a strong opinion on this, but my impression is that Wilson ultimately backed down, rather than holding out for better.

Wilson backed out on account of illness as far as I remember.
 
My father in law was with the 101st Airborne Paratroopers...landed on the beach in Normandy. He made it home...thankfully. He's passed now. But he seldom talked about this experience.

My uncle, David, was killed on D-Day. He was a 24 year-old Major in the Royal Marines who was previously stationed on the Norfolk while it pursued the Bismarck.
 
Wilson backed out on account of illness as far as I remember.
Perhaps. My recollection is that he gave up on decent terms for Germany before getting sick and that the illness is what drove him from trying to sell League of Nations ratification to the US.
 
Back
Top