New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Justice Scalia's major error

JuliefromOhio

President
Supporting Member
in regard to the recent Supreme Court ruling (6-2) on the EPA:

“Scalia’s dissent contains a hugely embarrassing mistake. He refers to the Court’s earlier decision in American Trucking as involving an effort by EPA to smuggle cost considerations into the statute. But that’s exactly backwards: it was industry that argued for cost considerations and EPA that resisted. This gaffe is doubly embarrassing because Scalia wrote the opinion in the case, so he should surely remember which side won! Either some law clerk made the mistake and Scalia failed to read his own dissent carefully enough, or he simply forgot the basics of the earlier case and his clerks failed to correct him. Either way, it’s a cringeworthy blunder.”

joined in the dissent by Justice Clarence Thomas, the man of no words simply dittoed the major error. LOL

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/04/...arrassing-blunder-in-latest-anti-epa-dissent/
 
“Scalia’s dissent contains a hugely embarrassing mistake. He refers to the Court’s earlier decision in American Trucking as involving an effort by EPA to smuggle cost considerations into the statute. But that’s exactly backwards: it was industry that argued for cost considerations and EPA that resisted. This gaffe is doubly embarrassing because Scalia wrote the opinion in the case, so he should surely remember which side won! Either some law clerk made the mistake and Scalia failed to read his own dissent carefully enough, or he simply forgot the basics of the earlier case and his clerks failed to correct him. Either way, it’s a cringeworthy blunder.”

joined in the dissent by Justice Clarence Thomas, the man of no words, simply dittoed the major error. LOL

...the only way to rectify this egregious error is for ska-lieea to resign in disgrace :D
 
in regard to the recent Supreme Court ruling (6-2) on the EPA:

“Scalia’s dissent contains a hugely embarrassing mistake. He refers to the Court’s earlier decision in American Trucking as involving an effort by EPA to smuggle cost considerations into the statute. But that’s exactly backwards: it was industry that argued for cost considerations and EPA that resisted. This gaffe is doubly embarrassing because Scalia wrote the opinion in the case, so he should surely remember which side won! Either some law clerk made the mistake and Scalia failed to read his own dissent carefully enough, or he simply forgot the basics of the earlier case and his clerks failed to correct him. Either way, it’s a cringeworthy blunder.”

joined in the dissent by Justice Clarence Thomas, the man of no words simply dittoed the major error. LOL

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/04/...arrassing-blunder-in-latest-anti-epa-dissent/
From what I've heard from someone who worked as a law clerk to the Supreme Court, most of the real work is done by them. The Justices basically decide how they're going to vote and then the clerks try to wrap a legal justification around it. It sounds like, in this case, Scalia got a bit lazy and didn't bother reading what he was signing too carefully. It's not surprising that Thomas went along for the ride, since he's almost functionally identical to just giving Scalia a second vote.
 
Scalia must have got it right because lefty disagrees.....one thing for sure...lefty always gets it wrong!
 
From what I've heard from someone who worked as a law clerk to the Supreme Court, most of the real work is done by them. The Justices basically decide how they're going to vote and then the clerks try to wrap a legal justification around it. It sounds like, in this case, Scalia got a bit lazy and didn't bother reading what he was signing too carefully. It's not surprising that Thomas went along for the ride, since he's almost functionally identical to just giving Scalia a second vote.

that's what I thought.....about the law clerks writing the opinions. wonder if he'll fire any of them?
 
that's what I thought.....about the law clerks writing the opinions. wonder if he'll fire any of them?
Probably not. He has several of them, and regardless of who made the mistake, the others should have caught it, as should he (and Thomas and his clerks, if he signed on to the dissent). When the guilt is spread that broadly, it's better just to sweep it under the rug than to call attention to it by scapegoating one unfortunate soul.
 
Nothing Scalia does could surprise me. He's the classic example of an activist judge making law from the bench. What I find amusing is Thomas getting caught blindly parroting his mistake. ;)
 
Back
Top