New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Keynes 1923:

"No man of spirit will consent to remain poor if he believes his betters to have gained their goods by lucky gambling. To convert the business man into the profiteer is to strike a blow at capitalism, because it destroys the psychological equilibrium which permits the perpetuance of unequal rewards. The economic doctrine of normal profits, vaguely apprehended by every one, is a necessary condition for the justification of capitalism. The business man is only tolerable so long as his gains can be held to bear some relation to what, roughly and in some sense, his activities have contributed to Society."

Does anyone disagree that this paragraph describes the very essence of the bargain everyone makes in a capitalist economy? Has a more perfect statement about capitalism ever been stated?
 
I prefer, "It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages." Adam Smith, 1776
 
Ever read about Smith? He is not what the popular media portray him as by a far stretch. I bought a little book a while back on him that is a must read for folks like you and me who spend so much time thinking about economics. It's called "The authentic Adam Smith, his life and ideas" by Buchan. If you find it, get it. Smith cared a lot more about fairness than he did wealth. Do you not accept the central tenet of Keynes point here though? As long as the game is fair and the spoils are attributed due to hard work and some sense of added value that has a broader function than just greed and personal wealth, we all buy into the deal of unequal returns. When we feel it is unfair or ill gotten, we get mad. In essence, this is at the core of both the Tea Party and the OWS movements. In the robber baron days, people understood the game was rigged and monopolies ruled unfairly. Since then, we have managed to create a nation that raised all ships up until the last 30 years when we moved from making profits the old fashioned way to making them as casino owners skimming games of chance. Wall street today serves no legitimate function other than to make itself money. This is what Keynes is talking about here trap, surely you can admit this essential truth.
 
Ever read about Smith? He is not what the popular media portray him as by a far stretch. I bought a little book a while back on him that is a must read for folks like you and me who spend so much time thinking about economics. It's called "The authentic Adam Smith, his life and ideas" by Buchan. If you find it, get it. Smith cared a lot more about fairness than he did wealth. Do you not accept the central tenet of Keynes point here though? As long as the game is fair and the spoils are attributed due to hard work and some sense of added value that has a broader function than just greed and personal wealth, we all buy into the deal of unequal returns. When we feel it is unfair or ill gotten, we get mad. In essence, this is at the core of both the Tea Party and the OWS movements. In the robber baron days, people understood the game was rigged and monopolies ruled unfairly. Since then, we have managed to create a nation that raised all ships up until the last 30 years when we moved from making profits the old fashioned way to making them as casino owners skimming games of chance. Wall street today serves no legitimate function other than to make itself money. This is what Keynes is talking about here trap, surely you can admit this essential truth.

Yes, but the early American puritan and protestant focus on "fairness" was almost exclusively directed at "transactional" fairness, or both sides of a capitalist transaction getting a good deal. Those that weren't were directed mostly at the obligation for charitable giving. NEVER those with wealth being systematically fleeced via the government for the benefit of the "disadvantaged." You guys have sought to misappropriate their words in the furtherance of Marxism (and frankly probably has them spinning in their graves).
 
Yes, but the early American puritan and protestant focus on "fairness" was almost exclusively directed at "transactional" fairness,

Not true. The Puritans - when they first arrived, sought to live according to ACTS 4 and 5. And thus their ag. production was largely held in common like a COMMUNe.

And the same applied to tools on the Frontier
And the tradition of Barn Raising
And the tradition of mutual self defense where families would gather into the largest farmhouse
And the tradition of "hospitality of the table"

Etc. etc. So Smith actually is incorrect in his appeal to the "self-interest" of the butcher etc. IN fact he comes long after those initial traditions and hence shares none of them.


But your point about transactional fairness is an interesting one. It is one that STRONGLY argues for interventionism by The Government in markets, for Strong Unions and labor laws. Because absent

  • Informational symmetry
  • Risk symmetry
  • Adequate substituted products
  • No externalization of costs

"transactional fairness" cannot exist.
 
On another note...the statement is perfectly logical.....but hardly understood by the majority of people who live under the mis-impresion that society owes them a living. I would say that it is a good maxim for any CEO to hang on his office wall and read on a daily basis though.

JO
 
On another note...the statement is perfectly logical.....but hardly understood by the majority of people who live under the mis-impresion that society owes them a living.

how is this a "misunderstanding"? Why be a member of society if it does not benefit you?
 
Well....the business man could easily ask the same question.... and many are lately.

To clear the air I will clue you into the fact that I do have socialist leanings....a society simply cannot survive without some form and some measure of it....that's just honest thinking. Unfortunately however many who see the soft landing prefer it to the work ethic....clever yes....useful no.
 
In 1923 there was no social welfare safetny net so your comments had absolutely nothing to do with Keynes intent or statement. Is it possible for any of you to think critically outside of ideology? It's as if you look through everything using a glass filter.
 
they did? So why did they leave England? You are making shit up.

Tell it to your buddy Leroy:

LeRoy_Was_Here
LeRoy_Was_Here is online now
Points: 3,916, Level: 18
Level completed: 17%, Points required for next Level: 334
Overall activity: 56.0%
Achievements:
100 Experience PointsPoster250 Experience Points7 days registered1000 Experience PointsThread Viewer ExpertSocial Lite31 Days Registered LeRoy_Was_Here's Avatar

Join Date
Apr 2012
Location
Colorado
Posts
1,698
Jack Bucks
11,393
Points
3,916
Level
18
Post Thanks / Like

And Jefferson's idea came straight out of Adam Smith. The goddamned Commie!!

 
Ever read about Smith? He is not what the popular media portray him as by a far stretch. I bought a little book a while back on him that is a must read for folks like you and me who spend so much time thinking about economics. It's called "The authentic Adam Smith, his life and ideas" by Buchan. If you find it, get it. Smith cared a lot more about fairness than he did wealth. Do you not accept the central tenet of Keynes point here though? As long as the game is fair and the spoils are attributed due to hard work and some sense of added value that has a broader function than just greed and personal wealth, we all buy into the deal of unequal returns. When we feel it is unfair or ill gotten, we get mad. In essence, this is at the core of both the Tea Party and the OWS movements. In the robber baron days, people understood the game was rigged and monopolies ruled unfairly. Since then, we have managed to create a nation that raised all ships up until the last 30 years when we moved from making profits the old fashioned way to making them as casino owners skimming games of chance. Wall street today serves no legitimate function other than to make itself money. This is what Keynes is talking about here trap, surely you can admit this essential truth.

I'm aware of Smith and his outre notions on marriage, morality, etc. He was a man of his times. That doesn't make his economic philosophy wrong, any more than it would make the science of rocketry wrong because it was pursued by von Braun and a team of anti-semitics. The economics are still economics, and the rockets are still rockets.

I'm not certain I accept ALL of the Keynes quote you provided. Implicit in it is the idea that it is unfair to pursue riches on the financial market, but fair and acceptable to pursue them in other ways -- that one pursuit is honorable and the other mere greed. Who gets to judge which is which?
 
how is this a "misunderstanding"? Why be a member of society if it does not benefit you?

Why work if society will provide you a living -- do you have any duty to society not to be a mere drain on it? It is indeed a misunderstanding to think that society owes you any more of a living than you can provide for yourself while living within its structure.

You can be a contributor to that structure, or something else. There's a name for the something else, but you won't like it.
 
I'm aware of Smith and his outre notions on marriage, morality, etc. He was a man of his times. That doesn't make his economic philosophy wrong,
Either he is a "man of his times" or he is not. His economic philosophy was also "of his times". And that his "economic philosophy" required that women stay home to "recivilize the man" from the "brutality of the marketplace" cannot be separated from his "economic philosophy"....

BTW, there is plenty of "natural law" that refutes Smith's philosophy be it the Fire Ants' response to flooding or symbiotic biology http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=symbiosis&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0,48 to more advanced forms of collaborative development http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/258292

Basically Smith was enamoured with the THEN "modern" idea of Natural Selection and simply did not have a broad enough span of data to make a meaningful theory. Unlike Smith, there are no counter refutations to von Braun's ballistic trajectory calculations.


I'm not certain I accept ALL of the Keynes quote you provided. Implicit in it is the idea that it is unfair to pursue riches on the financial market, but fair and acceptable to pursue them in other ways -- that one pursuit is honorable and the other mere greed. Who gets to judge which is which?
Not at all. there are no such implications in the citation of Keynes. Rather that it is IN THE SELF INTEREST of that very very rich Baker, to forego a lot of additional wealth accumulation so that the Butcher doesn't stab him out of frustration of having no prospects.

Essentially you argue that we should all be in the story of The Scorpion and the Frog and Wooley and I point out that it is the Fire Ants that make it across the river.
 
Tell it to your buddy Leroy:

LeRoy_Was_Here
LeRoy_Was_Here is online now
Points: 3,916, Level: 18
Level completed: 17%, Points required for next Level: 334
Overall activity: 56.0%
Achievements:
100 Experience PointsPoster250 Experience Points7 days registered1000 Experience PointsThread Viewer ExpertSocial Lite31 Days Registered LeRoy_Was_Here's Avatar

Join Date
Apr 2012
Location
Colorado
Posts
1,698
Jack Bucks
11,393
Points
3,916
Level
18
Post Thanks / Like

And Jefferson's idea came straight out of Adam Smith. The goddamned Commie!!


WTF??? you are seriously losing it....

BTW, Just because Jefferson's idea comes from Adam Smith doesn't mean either is empircally demonstrable. (Hint it isn't).
 
Back
Top