New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Keystone pipeline question

SW48

Administrator
Staff member
Supporting Member
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.
Yes it does. Lefty doesn't really believe that crap. This oil will be shipped if not for this pipeline anyway. I have attached a map of the current oil pipelines in the US. This little pipeline won't even be notices once built. The only reason Lefty is against it is because conservatives want it.

pipeline+accidents+final+animation1-2.gif
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.
it isn't possible. The oil will eventually be burned, one way or the other. The pipeline is safer, and will have a smaller carbon footprint than the trucks or rail tankers otherwise needed.
 
Yes it does. Lefty doesn't really believe that crap. This oil will be shipped if not for this pipeline anyway. I have attached a map of the current oil pipelines in the US. This little pipeline won't even be notices once built. The only reason Lefty is against it is because conservatives want it.

pipeline+accidents+final+animation1-2.gif
all those existing pipelines, and THIS one will doom us all?
Please.
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.

Mr. SW,

You are correct on that accout, but more importantly, Canada has said they will be building this pipeline, either to Houston, or to Vancouver, BC. If it goes to Vancouver, the oil will be shipped to Japan and China for refining. You have the tanker ships burning bunker C oil to get it across the ocean, then refining in China with no environmental oversite to be burned in Asian cars with little polution controls. So in reality, not building it will increase global warming.
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.

No.
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.

simple

The bottom line, from a climate perspective: “oil sands crude is significantly more [greenhouse gas] intensive than other crudes, and therefore has potentially large impacts,” wrote EPA’s Cynthia Giles about the State Department’s attempts to assess the full implications of Keystone. “Lifecycle emissions from oil sands crude could be 81 percent greater than the average crude refined in the U.S.,” a difference that can grow “depending on the assumptions made.” http://blogs.scientificamerican.com...n-keystone-xl-pipeline-environmental-impacts/
 
simple

The bottom line, from a climate perspective: “oil sands crude is significantly more [greenhouse gas] intensive than other crudes, and therefore has potentially large impacts,” wrote EPA’s Cynthia Giles about the State Department’s attempts to assess the full implications of Keystone. “Lifecycle emissions from oil sands crude could be 81 percent greater than the average crude refined in the U.S.,” a difference that can grow “depending on the assumptions made.” http://blogs.scientificamerican.com...n-keystone-xl-pipeline-environmental-impacts/

Mr. Plk,

So how will this oil being shipped across the Pacific to China to be refined in an area with lax environmental regulations, then to be used in Asian cars with little pollution controls decease the impact on Climate Change?

Just asiking.
 
I am confused on the keystone pipeline.

Ed Schultz today on his show is saying that if Obama says no to the pipeline that it is a big step towards stopping climate change and reducing carbon emissions.

I am wondering how that is possible? Doesn't all of that oil currently get shipped by trucks that increase carbon emissions?

I am asking as I do not understand.


I didn't see the show, but I would consider that statement, taken without the benefit of context, to be ideological rhetoric. I don't believe that stopping construction of the XL Pipeline would literally stop the processing of the Canadian tar sands, but that tar sand processing is precisely what environmentalists oppose. Stopping construction of the pipeline would be a symbolic gesture, at best, should it actually occur. I personally doubt that it will.

We are running low on easily accessible sources of sweet crude. That's why we are mining so deep in the ocean and processing bituminous solids. Neither of those methods of oil extraction would have been economically feasible back in the 1990s, when the price of crude oil was so low. Neither would be the expense of processing such dirty crude as is produced by the tar sands.

Environmentalists believe that we should be developing other sources of energy rather than going after these hard to process oil sources. They believe that we should do so sooner, rather than later. I agree with that sentiment, but I don't believe that opposition to the XL Pipeline, in and of itself, gets us any closer to pursuing that goal.
 
Back
Top