Arkady
President
A number of years ago I made a serious study of Roman history. Many historians have focused on what killed the Roman Empire. But arguably even more interesting is the question of what killed the Roman Republic. Between the overthrow of the Roman monarchy, around 509 BCE, and when Caesar crossed the Rubicon, in 49 BCE, the Republic survived for almost half a millennium.... over twice as long as our own Republic has been around. It was an astoundingly successful era. Rome went from being a tiny city state, subservient to the Etruscans, to controlling the Mediterranean world, and having direct or indirect control of most of Spain, France, Egypt, and areas around the Black Sea. What was it that caused that great Republic to fall into a permanent state of dictatorship?
One of the things that happened was that people started to use their offices to the maximum of their theoretical limits, rather than within the constraints of tradition. This led to a dysfunctional government, which made dictators seem increasingly attractive. That worries me, because the U.S. is apparently going through a similar process now. Take, for instance, the filibuster. Traditionally, the filibuster was rarely used, so that most things that had majority support passed through the Senate, without the minority using that exceptional power. That has changed. These days, anything remotely controversial is subject to a filibuster in the Senate so that, in practice, there's a 60-vote requirement to get anything done. Reconciliation can be used to get around that, but it has its limits.
The refusal to approve federal judges is another example. Both parties have used the filibuster to keep unwanted judges off the bench, but the frequency of these Republican efforts is astounding. There is now a full-bl9wn vacancy crisis in the federal district and appellate courts -- 88 vacancies, which is over 10%. This has resulted in 31 courts being so overburdened that they've been officially designated "judicial emergencies." The Congressional Research Service has confirmed that never before in American history has there been a period of such historically high vacancy rates. The Republicans are essentially trying to block the Obama presidency having any lasting judicial impact, by either leaving those slots vacant permanently, or forcing him to nominate conservative judges to fill them.
To take a specific example, look at Caitlin Halligan. She was an Obama nominee for the Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit. There was no serious question about her qualifications. She made it past the Judiciary Committee, then got a majority vote to bring the nomination forward, but forty-one Republican Senators voted to prevent her from even getting an up-or-down vote, and that was it for her chances. Eventually she withdrew. Obama has now failed to place a single judge on the DC Circuit (which is considered the second-most important court in the nation, after the Supreme Court). That's not because he has insisted on nominating ideologues. But any sign of even moderate liberalism, like Halligan's history on gun control, is enough to trigger absolute right-wing obstructionism.
Eventually the Republicans will again take the White House and the Senate, and the shoe will be on the other foot. When it is, the Democrats will have a choice. They can go back to the tradition of only using the filibuster as an extreme measure, once in a long while, or they can retaliate by using the Republican tactic of hair-trigger filibusters against them. Game theory says you have to retaliate, because otherwise there are no negative repercussions for the GOP for their bad behavior, and it will continue. Besides, if Democrats have to appoint conservatives and Republicans don't have to appoint liberals, it will continue the extreme rightward tilt of the federal judiciary. But, there's little real limit on how badly these powers can be abused, and each side can up the ante. That puts us in a death-spiral similar to the Roman Republic.
The Democrats tried to play nice once, already. In the Bush years, they were using the filibuster to block conservative judges more than was historically normal (in retaliation for the Republicans having blocked an historically abnormal number of Clinton appointees). The so-called Gang of Fourteen Senators recognized that we were in a death spiral, and negotiated a compromise to get out of it -- an agreement that Democrats would only filibuster in extraordinary cases, in exchange for the Republicans agreeing not to change the filibuster rules. Democrats kept to it, allowing Bush's second-term appointees proceed without obstruction. Republicans have essentially decided to ignore that compromise now that Obama is the one doing the nominating. So, a further compromise is going to be tough to reach. How do you convince Democrats to compromise again, when they've seen how Republicans will ignore a compromise the moment it's politically inconvenient?
These are the kinds of things that happened in the Roman Republic. Factions started putting their narrow interests ahead of the Republic, and eventually the Republic crumbled, as people came to prefer dictatorship to paralysis.
One of the things that happened was that people started to use their offices to the maximum of their theoretical limits, rather than within the constraints of tradition. This led to a dysfunctional government, which made dictators seem increasingly attractive. That worries me, because the U.S. is apparently going through a similar process now. Take, for instance, the filibuster. Traditionally, the filibuster was rarely used, so that most things that had majority support passed through the Senate, without the minority using that exceptional power. That has changed. These days, anything remotely controversial is subject to a filibuster in the Senate so that, in practice, there's a 60-vote requirement to get anything done. Reconciliation can be used to get around that, but it has its limits.
The refusal to approve federal judges is another example. Both parties have used the filibuster to keep unwanted judges off the bench, but the frequency of these Republican efforts is astounding. There is now a full-bl9wn vacancy crisis in the federal district and appellate courts -- 88 vacancies, which is over 10%. This has resulted in 31 courts being so overburdened that they've been officially designated "judicial emergencies." The Congressional Research Service has confirmed that never before in American history has there been a period of such historically high vacancy rates. The Republicans are essentially trying to block the Obama presidency having any lasting judicial impact, by either leaving those slots vacant permanently, or forcing him to nominate conservative judges to fill them.
To take a specific example, look at Caitlin Halligan. She was an Obama nominee for the Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit. There was no serious question about her qualifications. She made it past the Judiciary Committee, then got a majority vote to bring the nomination forward, but forty-one Republican Senators voted to prevent her from even getting an up-or-down vote, and that was it for her chances. Eventually she withdrew. Obama has now failed to place a single judge on the DC Circuit (which is considered the second-most important court in the nation, after the Supreme Court). That's not because he has insisted on nominating ideologues. But any sign of even moderate liberalism, like Halligan's history on gun control, is enough to trigger absolute right-wing obstructionism.
Eventually the Republicans will again take the White House and the Senate, and the shoe will be on the other foot. When it is, the Democrats will have a choice. They can go back to the tradition of only using the filibuster as an extreme measure, once in a long while, or they can retaliate by using the Republican tactic of hair-trigger filibusters against them. Game theory says you have to retaliate, because otherwise there are no negative repercussions for the GOP for their bad behavior, and it will continue. Besides, if Democrats have to appoint conservatives and Republicans don't have to appoint liberals, it will continue the extreme rightward tilt of the federal judiciary. But, there's little real limit on how badly these powers can be abused, and each side can up the ante. That puts us in a death-spiral similar to the Roman Republic.
The Democrats tried to play nice once, already. In the Bush years, they were using the filibuster to block conservative judges more than was historically normal (in retaliation for the Republicans having blocked an historically abnormal number of Clinton appointees). The so-called Gang of Fourteen Senators recognized that we were in a death spiral, and negotiated a compromise to get out of it -- an agreement that Democrats would only filibuster in extraordinary cases, in exchange for the Republicans agreeing not to change the filibuster rules. Democrats kept to it, allowing Bush's second-term appointees proceed without obstruction. Republicans have essentially decided to ignore that compromise now that Obama is the one doing the nominating. So, a further compromise is going to be tough to reach. How do you convince Democrats to compromise again, when they've seen how Republicans will ignore a compromise the moment it's politically inconvenient?
These are the kinds of things that happened in the Roman Republic. Factions started putting their narrow interests ahead of the Republic, and eventually the Republic crumbled, as people came to prefer dictatorship to paralysis.