New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Know the enemy within

Really? So if I find one right winger who says Jews should be rounded up and sent to camps you'd agree that it was the view of all right wingers?

No. What on Earth gave you the impression I'd think that?
 
No you are wrong. I am simply saying a small percentage of *retired generals*, probably Democrats, isn't very impressive. Furthermore, this country is sliding further into politicizing the military, something we avoided for a very long time.

Oh you wanted to know how many oppose the deal? Here you go, so far there are 190:

http://www.haaretz.com/news/world/.premium-1.673134

Now tell me again how impressive it is when retired generals take a political position. And would you like me to come around to your way of thinking on the matter? Yes or no?

I can only post what I have read, and you should be aware that generals and admirals can be just as much Republican and beholden to Israel as they can to a Democrat president. But now we have 226 generals and admirals who are either opposed or in favor of the plan. If they are all laying out their reasons for their position, they obviously know what is in the plan. Why don't the Republicans in congress know, as per BOCA?

And let me add another little ditty here. Adm. Roy Hoffmann was politicized when he attacked Kerry's military record in Vietnam, along with O'Neill and the Swiftliars. Please do not tell me they lied, Thurmond lied about his Bronze Star, claiming he never received one because there was no incident on the river. As well they claimed there never were military personnel in Cambodia, either PBR's on the border, or ground troops, and both of those statements were a lie. Nixon and Kissinger sent them in.
 
Last edited:
Citizens United is a case about whether a corporation has a 1st Amendment right and that case was decided correctly. If you reverse the Citizens United ruling then The New York Times as a corporation that often expounds political speech needs to stop. All incorporated news entities will need to give up their 1st Amendment right to free speech. Is that what you believe? I certainly don't

You can legally control the amount of money candidates receive and from whom but you can't stop corporations from exercising their free speech rights because you say so. It would be a logically inconsistent viewpoint.

Yes! If we are going to censor the speech of corporations because there's too much money in politics, let's at least have the courage of our convictions and take the money out of the hands of the corporations by nationalizing them. In Cuba different pro-Communist points of view (revisionist, anti-revisionist, Stalinist, Maoist, Trotskyist, etc.) are allowed access to state-owned media resources in proportion to the number of Cubans formally endorsing the different tendencies. There's no reason this framework of a state-owned media couldn't/shouldn't be extended to include reasonable (not openly racist, fascist, sexist, can we agree?) pro-capitalist points of view as well.
 
1. It was about money...not speech. The case involved a pro-republican group producing a movie and pretending it was not part of a political campaign.

2. It allowed anonymous donations to political campaigns.

3. It had nothing at all to do with newspapers or media outlets.

Producing a political movie is very much about speech. And about money too. No matter whose ox is getting gored.
 
So tell me...prior to Citizens United...how many news outlets were prevented from airing stories related to political campaigns?

Are you aware that 501c4 groups can accept anonymous and unlimited donations? A lawyer buddy of Romney's set up a 501c4, rounded up a million bucks, used it for pro-Romney adds and disolved the 501c4 all in about a week.....Is that what you think of as good for the democracy?

Why did Citizens United bring the lawsuit? If it was because of "Hillary the Movie" then your attempt to dismiss what I said is silly...but feel free to wonder about what is wrong with me....

Either all speech is free or it isn't. And, again, if it isn't, then the last good argument for private ownership of the media goes out the window.
 
Clearly NYT Inc. was being treated special from USS Inc. in the past. Citizens United rectified that.

Laws can be passed that limit the money that candidates receive. That survives constitutional review. You can even make political speech from public entities like corporations transparent (i.e. not anonymous). Note that money has lost elections in the past and the internet makes for a whole new world.

YOU want to fix our system? Let every legal citizen of the U.S. vote for legislation on the floor of the house via computer vote. Kiss Big Money donors, K Street, and J Street goodbye.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/james-clr/works/1956/06/every-cook.htm

"Every Cook Can Govern," by C.L.R. James
 
Go ahead. See if you can get an amendment through to change the house of representatives to be something other than what the founders designed.

We'll definitely have to start by building up our unions. And of course to do that they'll need the right to engage in unlimited corporate speech.
 
Okay, if you two are gonna tagteam me I surrender.

But instead of chicken little diversionary talk about avatars could I ask ya both one last question on the actual topic of this thread.

There are many cases of arrests and convictions for funding terrorist activities. For example Sami Al-Arian, the University of South Florida professor who was just recently deported to Turkey after being convicted of "Conspiracy to make or receive contributions of funds, goods or services to or for the benefit of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

The Federal Judge in the case referred to him as a "master manipulator"

My question then is why Obama who started this Iran "deal" and the Democrat Senators who accepted money from Iranian lobbyists and have publically stated they'll vote to send $150 billion to help fund a state sponsor of terrorism who's mantra is Death to America.......is there some valid reason why shouldn't they be arrested and deported? Other than the fact it's Obama's Department of Justice of course.

I mean really...is our president not the quintessential master manipulator?

Obama is the terrorist-in-chief ... just like Bush before him and Clinton before that.
 
A corporation is not capable of speech. The people who work there are. The person who runs the company PAC is working at the direction of the CEO and you think the corporation speaks? It does not. The CEO magically gets to speak both as an individual and as if he speaks for everyone working for the corporation, their customers and their investors....

Bullshit....

Corporate personhood is a long-established legal doctrine, recognized by the Supreme Court in 1819, and has long been at the foundation of freedom of the press, and important to other freedoms, in the United States. It is what allows the New York Times Corporation a 1st amendment right to publish a newspaper. Overturning it would've meant throwing out whole volumes of case law and gutting substantive first amendment protections.
 
How could they be charges with "conspiracy to make or receive contributions of funds, goods or services to or for the benefit of state sponsor of terrorism" when they took no part in the conspiracy?

That said, if when the voting takes place any Republican that has accepted Iranian lobbyist's money and then votes for the deal.... I'd hang them too.

Do you feel the same about other terror-sponsoring nations supported by the U.S. (Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Israel)? What about the members of Congress who accept money from the Cuban-American National Foundation and vote to support the interests of the terrorists they sponsor?
 
Your first sentence is irrelevant to the conversation.

As far as having a stake in the company...when was the last time you were even notified of a company PAC donations to a candidate? I've owned stock in a number of companies and have rarely known the political views supported by their lobbyists or pacs.

Your logic is bizarre. You have freedom of speech. The CEO of the company has freedom of speech. You both may donate to the candidate of your choice.

Giving some additional rights to the CEO makes no sense....those additional rights may well swing elections and you've had no say at all in the opinions expressed using the cash in the company PAC....it is that simple.

What next? Will unions not be allowed to spend their dues money to support the candidates their elected leadership sees fit to support?
 
I think home is where the heart is. For example, I know an American citizen who still refers to Panama as "my country". As far as I'm concerned, that person's loyalty is to Panama and they are still Panamanian- regardless of what passport they are holding.

"The working man has no country."-Karl Marx

Of course, that was then ... now every last billion of us is Cuban!
 
Odd... I didn't even mention Iranians or Israelis. I mentioned a Panamanian I know. The point is, I'm against anyone whose loyalty is to some country other than the United States having an influence on our future. Of course, that is one of many reasons I oppose Barack Hussein Obama.

Obama's loyalty is 100% to the United States. Get real. The United States is what makes Obama the most powerful person in the world and the center of an incipient personality cult. He probably whistles the Star-Spangled Banner to himself while he's playing mini-golf in the Oval Office.
 
You should jump on AIL's thread about AIPAC, he's speaking your language. All your fellow Jew-haters are there - Lance, Queenie, Boltlady, et al. The whole e-Jihadi squad...

Do you understand that questioning a pro-Israel Congressman's loyalty because he received money from AIPAC is literally no different from questioning a pro-Iranian Congressman's loyalty because he received money from IAPAC? And that ultimately this witch hunt ends in dictatorship?
 
The individual reporters are exercising free speech....and those corporations are not arguing that they should be allowed to donate money to campaigns anonymously....and in unlimited amounts.

New rule. Individual reporters are allowed freedom of the press. But media corporations are limited in how much money they can spend getting their message out. Sound fair?
 
1. It is only about free speech if money is speech and the corporate donations amount to expressing the opinions of the investors, employees and customers....which it doesn't. It is a loophole allowing a CEO to direct his company to put it's influence behind a candidate or party.

2. The poor corporation being treated unfairly still would not result in the CEO being unable to express his own opinions....correct?

1. Money is speech. Not speaking from a legal standpoint, just from the standpoint of material reality. Ownership of the means of communication (in a capitalist society: money) allows one to effectively transmit one's message.

Corporations DO express the point of view of their investors. Just as unions express the point of view of their ranks. If you want to start limiting how my union uses its free speech, on the pretext that some finks disagree, we're gonna have a fight.
 
2. The poor corporation being treated unfairly still would not result in the CEO being unable to express his own opinions....correct?

Does freedom of speech merely mean the right to express one's opinion privately without attempting to spend the money it would take to publicize it, and stop right before people try to take part in organized political campaigns?
 
Back
Top