New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Know the enemy within

It isn't even my argument it was one made at the Supreme Court in the case.

I believe in equal protection under the law. If the NY Times corp can exercise free speech, then every other corporation should be able to. Frankly I think it's a good argument. And I say that as someone who isn't a fan of corporations when it comes to exercising power over individuals. But fair is fair.
 
Then shutdown The New York Times and shutdown The Washington Post since they are both corporations that are constantly exercising free speech.

The individual reporters are exercising free speech....and those corporations are not arguing that they should be allowed to donate money to campaigns anonymously....and in unlimited amounts.
 
I believe in equal protection under the law. If the NY Times corp can exercise free speech, then every other corporation should be able to. Frankly I think it's a good argument. And I say that as someone who isn't a fan of corporations when it comes to exercising power over individuals. But fair is fair.

1. It is only about free speech if money is speech and the corporate donations amount to expressing the opinions of the investors, employees and customers....which it doesn't. It is a loophole allowing a CEO to direct his company to put it's influence behind a candidate or party.

2. The poor corporation being treated unfairly still would not result in the CEO being unable to express his own opinions....correct?
 
But that's diiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiifferent. They're liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiberal. They're entiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiitled.

You're going to hurt yourself bending over backwards to support the fascist views supporting additional rights for corporations not available to the rest of us....
 
You should jump on AIL's thread about AIPAC, he's speaking your language. All your fellow Jew-haters are there - Lance, Queenie, Boltlady, et al. The whole e-Jihadi squad...

Running out of steam, Marvin? I said nothing that could remotely be construed as anti-Semitic....so when you are afraid of actually addressing the question, I guess the best you can manage is a completely unrelated round of insults....
 
You should jump on AIL's thread about AIPAC, he's speaking your language. All your fellow Jew-haters are there - Lance, Queenie, Boltlady, et al. The whole e-Jihadi squad...

Your racism is so blatant. I would think you would at least have the decency to try and hide it some.
 
So what should we do about the donations from AIPAC to our congressmen?

The same thing we do with any other dubious donations, without concern over whether they are Jewish, Iranian, black, blue, or purple. Why do you propose a solution that differs based on what political interest the donor(s) in question represent?
 
But that's diiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiifferent. They're liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiberal. They're entiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiitled.

We are talking about donations to campaigns....I disagree that those donations have anything to do with speech and certainly are not the same thing as corporations printing stories or broadcasting the news.
 
You're going to hurt yourself bending over backwards to support the fascist views supporting additional rights for corporations not available to the rest of us....

Someone doesn't understand the meaning of fascism. But that aside, why should the NY Times have more free speech rights than any other corporation?
 
Running out of steam, Marvin? I said nothing that could remotely be construed as anti-Semitic....so when you are afraid of actually addressing the question, I guess the best you can manage is a completely unrelated round of insults....

I never said you did. I only pointed out that the way you are trying to hijack this thread is by making a point that is identical to the one AIL is making in his latest anti-Semitic screed. Don't blame me because you and he see eye to eye on this issue.
 
The same thing we do with any other dubious donations, without concern over whether they are Jewish, Iranian, black, blue, or purple. Why do you propose a solution that differs based on what political interest the donor(s) in question represent?

What solution have I proposed? I'm saying that the Iranian-American Pac has the same rights as AIPAC does. I'm pointing out that the right wingers here are only interested in slamming one group and not the other....meanwhile AIPAC is totally focused on "persuading" congress to vote in favor of legislation they see as beneficial to Israel.
 
Someone doesn't understand the meaning of fascism. But that aside, why should the NY Times have more free speech rights than any other corporation?

I agree. You don't seem to know what fascism is.....

The NYT are not attempting to donate unlimited amounts of money anonymously to political campaigns...and that is what Citizens United was about....
 
I never said you did. I only pointed out that the way you are trying to hijack this thread is by making a point that is identical to the one AIL is making in his latest anti-Semitic screed. Don't blame me because you and he see eye to eye on this issue.

Let me remind you:
You should jump on AIL's thread about AIPAC, he's speaking your language. All your fellow Jew-haters are there - Lance, Queenie, Boltlady, et al. The whole e-Jihadi squad...

I asked a question. I blame you for running away from an answer.
 
I agree. You don't seem to know what fascism is.....

The NYT are not attempting to donate unlimited amounts of money anonymously to political campaigns...and that is what Citizens United was about....

The NY Times is using their corporation to campaign for candidates they prefer. Different tactic, same abuse of corporate power.
 
What solution have I proposed? I'm saying that the Iranian-American Pac has the same rights as AIPAC does. I'm pointing out that the right wingers here are only interested in slamming one group and not the other....meanwhile AIPAC is totally focused on "persuading" congress to vote in favor of legislation they see as beneficial to Israel.

Great! So we agree no preference should be given based on political ideology. Except you really DO think it matters. That's why you *care* about corporations making anonymous donations, but are OK with the NY Times corporation using their power to influence elections.
 
Great! So we agree no preference should be given based on political ideology. Except you really DO think it matters. That's why you *care* about corporations making anonymous donations, but are OK with the NY Times corporation using their power to influence elections.

1. The NY Times, NY Post, Fox News, the WSJ...all use their editorial pages to support candidates...but it isn't a secret. You know which side various media supports....and sometimes you may see support for both sides from different editorial writers....on the same editorial page.

2. Corporations donate a lot of different ways....though lobbyists, PACS, endorsements...etc...and much of it is anonymous. Their donations were restricted in the past, but their speech was not....why is that so hard for you to understand? They could say what they wanted. Colt could take out an add and say Hillary will take your guns....but the CEO of Colt could not direct anonymous donations from his PAC to help get someone elected....now he can.
 
Back
Top