Arkady
President
Historically, one could get complacent about the ascendence of liberalism. Over any period of more than a couple decades, the political trend within the US has tended to be growing liberalism, across almost any field of analysis. For most of American history, every generation tended to have more liberal ideas and policies than the one before it. You could see it in fashion, art, tax levels, the size of government, ideas about the role of women, relations between the sexes, etc. Whenever there was a backlash (e.g., the imposition of Prohibition), it usually got wiped away in the next surge of liberalism, less than a generation later, and the next round of liberalism took the country even farther than the last.
Yet, recently, we seem to have been living in an exception to that. In a lot of ways, if not most ways, the nation has grown more conservative since the late 1960s. Economic policies that were center-right positions in the Eisenhower through early Nixon era (Rockefeller Republicanism) are mainstream Democratic positions these days, and the mainstream Republicans sit far to the right. Starting in the mid-1970s, abortion rights began to be eroded, religiosity began to rise, most Supreme Court cases tended to be dominated by the conservative faction, tax levels fell radically, peacetime military spending spiked, and so on. There was some progress on things like gay rights, but overall you could make a strong argument we're more conservative than we were 40 years ago, which is a very rare thing in our history.
Yet, that counter-trend towards conservatism might have run its course. The Republicans have only gained one national majority in the last twenty years. Tax levels recently inched back up, at least on the very wealthy. Republicans hold onto the House only thanks to districting quirks -- they actually got fewer votes than the Dems. Obamacare is the first really major progressive reform since the Johnson years. It'll take time to tell if a new trend of liberalism is taking hold, but there's at least some sign it is.
If so, here's a theory on what might account for this strangely long conservative backlash, and the recent creeping again to the left. Maybe it's because of the rise and fall of lead-induced brain damage. As has recently been much publicized, it turns out that lead poisoning may have been a big factor in our nation's spike in violence, in the mid-to-late 20th century, and the rapid decline in violence that started in the early 1990s. Could it be that brain damage also caused the rise in conservative voting patterns, and that those patterns will now begin to fade as healthier brains become the majority again?
The trends would tend to run on different timing than violent crime. Violent crime takes off in a person's mid-teens, peaks in his twenties, then fades out, as hormone levels drop. So, we'd expect violent crime to drop more rapidly and earlier, as a result of lower lead levels, than political conservatism. As those with contaminated brains aged out of their "peak crime years," we got a very rapid violent crime decrease. But people's "peak voting years" are a lot later than "peak crime years." So, the brains that were contaminated by lead in their formative years, in the middle of the 20th century, will continue to have an impact on elections for many years to come. Some of those brain-damaged people will continue to vote Republican into their 60s, 70s, 80s, and beyond, and their die-off rate will only diminsh the impact of that brain damage, demographically, in a very slow way. But, already, an ever-larger share of eligible voters are going to have healthy, properly functioning brains, so we should begin to see the impact in exit polls.
This does appear to be showing up as a growing share of young people voting Democratic.
Here is the percent of people 18-29 who voted for the Democrat in each of the last several elections:
1992: 43%
1996: 53%
2000: 48%
2004: 54%
2008: 66%
2012: 60%
Age 30-44:
1992: 41%
1996: 48%
2000: 48%
2004: 46%
2008: 52%
2012: 52%
This rising tide of Democratic support doesn't show up with those in the "Diseased Mind" age demographic, whose support for the Democrat hasn't increased:
Age 40-59:
1992: 41%
1996: 48%
2000: 48%
2004: 48%
2008: 49%
2012: (I don't have that data)
Among the oldest Americans (in other words, those with the highest rate of lead-induced brain damage), this has been an era of growing Republican strength.
http://elections.nytimes.com/2008/results/president/national-exit-polls.html
http://elections.nytimes.com/2012/results/president/exit-polls
Yet, recently, we seem to have been living in an exception to that. In a lot of ways, if not most ways, the nation has grown more conservative since the late 1960s. Economic policies that were center-right positions in the Eisenhower through early Nixon era (Rockefeller Republicanism) are mainstream Democratic positions these days, and the mainstream Republicans sit far to the right. Starting in the mid-1970s, abortion rights began to be eroded, religiosity began to rise, most Supreme Court cases tended to be dominated by the conservative faction, tax levels fell radically, peacetime military spending spiked, and so on. There was some progress on things like gay rights, but overall you could make a strong argument we're more conservative than we were 40 years ago, which is a very rare thing in our history.
Yet, that counter-trend towards conservatism might have run its course. The Republicans have only gained one national majority in the last twenty years. Tax levels recently inched back up, at least on the very wealthy. Republicans hold onto the House only thanks to districting quirks -- they actually got fewer votes than the Dems. Obamacare is the first really major progressive reform since the Johnson years. It'll take time to tell if a new trend of liberalism is taking hold, but there's at least some sign it is.
If so, here's a theory on what might account for this strangely long conservative backlash, and the recent creeping again to the left. Maybe it's because of the rise and fall of lead-induced brain damage. As has recently been much publicized, it turns out that lead poisoning may have been a big factor in our nation's spike in violence, in the mid-to-late 20th century, and the rapid decline in violence that started in the early 1990s. Could it be that brain damage also caused the rise in conservative voting patterns, and that those patterns will now begin to fade as healthier brains become the majority again?
The trends would tend to run on different timing than violent crime. Violent crime takes off in a person's mid-teens, peaks in his twenties, then fades out, as hormone levels drop. So, we'd expect violent crime to drop more rapidly and earlier, as a result of lower lead levels, than political conservatism. As those with contaminated brains aged out of their "peak crime years," we got a very rapid violent crime decrease. But people's "peak voting years" are a lot later than "peak crime years." So, the brains that were contaminated by lead in their formative years, in the middle of the 20th century, will continue to have an impact on elections for many years to come. Some of those brain-damaged people will continue to vote Republican into their 60s, 70s, 80s, and beyond, and their die-off rate will only diminsh the impact of that brain damage, demographically, in a very slow way. But, already, an ever-larger share of eligible voters are going to have healthy, properly functioning brains, so we should begin to see the impact in exit polls.
This does appear to be showing up as a growing share of young people voting Democratic.
Here is the percent of people 18-29 who voted for the Democrat in each of the last several elections:
1992: 43%
1996: 53%
2000: 48%
2004: 54%
2008: 66%
2012: 60%
Age 30-44:
1992: 41%
1996: 48%
2000: 48%
2004: 46%
2008: 52%
2012: 52%
This rising tide of Democratic support doesn't show up with those in the "Diseased Mind" age demographic, whose support for the Democrat hasn't increased:
Age 40-59:
1992: 41%
1996: 48%
2000: 48%
2004: 48%
2008: 49%
2012: (I don't have that data)
Among the oldest Americans (in other words, those with the highest rate of lead-induced brain damage), this has been an era of growing Republican strength.
http://elections.nytimes.com/2008/results/president/national-exit-polls.html
http://elections.nytimes.com/2012/results/president/exit-polls