New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Lewinsky

Yup. Americans agreed. WJC has enjoyed huge approval ratings. He did a fantastic job, and sane people were not obsessed with his pecker.
ngmimage-web.jpg
 
The standard, modern, feminist view of in-office sexual behavior is that if there is a power imbalance, then exploitation took place even if both parties said it was consensual. Could there be more power imbalance than that between the POTUS and an intern?

Now, I do not share the standard modern feminist view -- but I am beyond PC and disagreed with Clinton much more for his policies than his bimbo eruptions.

As for Lewinsky -- when she was young and dumb, she was at least cute. Why I should care about a 40-year-old former scandal victim's view of Roger Ailes is beyond me.

It's just another Ailes "obituary," but one with a different angle as to how his disgraceful practices hurt people. There have been many such "obituaries."

;-)
 
It doesn't matter how she sees it NOW. She's deluded herself into thinking she was the aggressor or, at the very least, that the affair was consensual.

Her messaging on that has been consistent from the day this first came to light. She was always clear, both in her private discussions (later leaked to the media) and in her public statements, that it was consensual. If, at 22 years old, you were still mentally a child, incapable of deciding what you want to do with your own genitals, that's fine, but don't try to project that on another woman. Lewinsky is the best authority on the state of her mind at the time.
 
The standard, modern, feminist view of in-office sexual behavior is that if there is a power imbalance, then exploitation took place even if both parties said it was consensual.

I am a modern feminist and do not take that view. My view is that there's a power imbalance in just about every relationship, of some sort or another. One of the parties is nearly always older, wealthier, more powerful, more experienced, etc., than the other. If we tried to treat those as exploitation, we could treat just about any relationship as exploitative. For example, did Trump exploit Melania? She was easily young enough to be his daughter and much less wealthy, experienced, and powerful than him. She also lacked citizenship, which is a power he could hold over her.

When I first hooked up with the woman who'd be my wife, someone might have thought she was taking advantage. I was still a teenager and she was in her twenties and had broader life experience, having already lived on her own abroad before we ever met. She also was much more financially independent than me. Or maybe I was taking advantage of her. She'd never had a serious romantic relationship and was a virgin, having come from a sheltered religious upbringing, whereas I'd been around the block several times.

I just don't see second-guessing adults when it comes to their own decisions about who to hook up with. I can see a few exceptions (e.g., when one is legally in custody, or mentally incapable of consent due to mental issues), but I wouldn't make a professional power imbalance in the workplace one of those. They should avoid "direct report" situations, because of the impossibility of impartially managing a person directly when you have a personal relationship, but I'd say the same of close personal friends. Indirect reporting relationships are fine -- the more senior person just needs to exclude himself from reviews, etc.

As for Lewinsky -- when she was young and dumb, she was at least cute. Why I should care about a 40-year-old former scandal victim's view of Roger Ailes is beyond me.

You should care because she wasn't the only victim of Roger Ailes's behavior. Her argument, which I think is right, is that we've all been the victim of it -- that his catering to our basest impulses worsened the national discourse in a way that has caused grave harm to our national character. We need to find a way to recover.
 
I am a modern feminist and do not take that view. My view is that there's a power imbalance in just about every relationship, of some sort or another. One of the parties is nearly always older, wealthier, more powerful, more experienced, etc., than the other. If we tried to treat those as exploitation, we could treat just about any relationship as exploitative. For example, did Trump exploit Melania? She was easily young enough to be his daughter and much less wealthy, experienced, and powerful than him. She also lacked citizenship, which is a power he could hold over her.

You have identified here as male. This means, according to feminists, you are not a feminist and cannot be one (yes, I can document this). The difference between the social imbalance and the power imbalance in the workplace matters (but do remember, I'm spouting the sort of nonsense that I heard alleged feminists say back at the time, and even earlier during the Anita Hill hearings).


You should care because she wasn't the only victim of Roger Ailes's behavior. Her argument, which I think is right, is that we've all been the victim of it -- that his catering to our basest impulses worsened the national discourse in a way that has caused grave harm to our national character. We need to find a way to recover.

Roger Ailes appears to have been a serial sexual harasser, but he didn't have the opportunity to harass Lewinsky. If you accept the feminist view, Clinton harassed Lewinsky. If you accept that Lewinsky was a consenting adult, then she could only expect the sort of coverage she received after having an affair with a president old enough to be her father, whether he was married or not. Fox was no worse to her than any number of tabloids were, and would have been, whether Fox existed or not. Ailes didn't cause that. I don't think the national discourse has become any courser than it was in 1968. Ailes didn't cause that, either.
 
Last edited:
So, she's a victim... is that the gist?

Me, I think she was a willing party to an affair, the third party in what was Clinton's marital infidelity .
 
Personally, I just don't care about the philandering, so long as it was consensual. Same with Trump. Obviously the man cheated on all three of his wives and presumably he's still doing so, but as long as the women or men involved in that cheating are adults and willing participants, I regard it as little different from the time he spends golfing. A man's free time is his own concern, not mine. I'm interested in how he does the job.

I don't honestly care much about the philandering, either. But Ailes lost his job over sexual harassment, and Clinton was clearly guilty of that sin -- if not with Lewinsky then with Paula Corbin Jones. And the real problem was never the lie, "I didn't have sex with that woman, Ms. Lewinsky..." but with his attempt to deny a pattern of such things when he lied to the prosecutors in the Jones investigation. That was perjury: It was material to the case at hand, and went to establish a pattern of behavior. It was not immaterial dissembling over and affair, bur rather an attempt to undermine the civil just process for a woman with a valid on-the-job harassment complaint.

Clinton may be popular in the polls, now, but historians will always be able to find that he settle out of court to avoid perjury charges, surrendered his license to practice law, and paid $25,000 in fines for what he did in that case.
 
Last edited:
Please bail. You never offer anything of value to the forum. You essentially post the same thing over and over without any meaningful variation to accommodate the specific topic at hand. Your one and only point is that lefty posters make you feel icky. Since you've already posted that single thought hundreds of times, you're wasting your time and ours. Find a new hobby.
Lisping lefty stooges don't map my plans. Thanks anyway.
 
You have identified here as male. This means, according to feminists, you are not a feminist and cannot be one (yes, I can document this).

I assume that given the many millions of people who identify as feminists, there must be some who think males can't be feminists. But that's definitely not a standard view. If you look at feminists symposiums and similar events, there's nearly always a token male or two among the panelists and speakers and that doesn't seem to be objectionable to those there.

even earlier during the Anita Hill hearings

Keep in mind, the Anita Hill matter was dramatically different. It didn't involve outsiders proclaiming that a relationship both members regarded as consensual was out-of-bounds because of a power dynamic, as with the Lewinsky matter. Hill complained directly about Thomas's conduct, which she regarded as predatory. She alleged that Thomas asked her out repeatedly and, after being turned down repeatedly, frequently subjected her to discussions of pornography and of his own supposed sexual prowess. She passed a polygraph test, which Thomas refused to take.

People weren't attacking him for having consensually dated a more junior person in the office, which would have more like the Clinton case, and wouldn't have been a problem unless you thought that definitionally the power imbalance made it one. He was being attacked for behavior that, if it really happened, would have made almost any woman extremely uncomfortable, and that Hill said made her very uncomfortable.

If you accept the feminist view, Clinton harassed Lewinsky

No. Only if I accept your take on what the feminist view is, would that be true. I'm a feminist and it's not my view. Many other feminists don't take that view. I haven't seen polling to indicate what the majority of self-identifying feminists would say. Have you?

If you accept that Lewinsky was a consenting adult, then she could only expect the sort of coverage she received after having an affairs with a president old enough to be her father, whether he was married or not

The kind of wall-to-wall coverage, with a tawdry focus on details and on smearing her personally, was something new, so if she had expected it, she would have been seeing the future better than most of us were able. Before Roger Ailes drove Fox News that deeply into the sewer, it's just not somewhere the US press had gone that deeply before. Certainly there were recent precedents for presidential affairs, but those mistresses had never faced anything like that (see, for example, Jennifer Fitzgerald). I think Ailes caused a very marked change in the national discourse -- taking garbage that in previous decades got only passing mention in the establishment press, while mostly being confined to the tabloids, and making it a 24-hour staple of major news coverage.

An interesting thought experiment is to think about what would change if you could go back in time and alter the timeline by killing someone -- e.g., shooting Hitler before he came to power. Often, little would change, since people were mostly just the product of wider socioeconomic changes, and if they weren't around, someone else would have filled the same basic role. Sometimes, killing a bad person would make things even worse by opening a door to a more effective bad person. But I think if you could go back to the early 1990s and kill Ailes, the world probably would be much better today, because I think his singularly horrible vision and skill made things far worse.
 
Really? 20 year old Clinton hate?

Again, he has enjoyed huge approval ratings since leaving office. Sane people look to his performance as president, including the best economy in US history, and do not obsess about his dissembling about the BJs.


Obama's poll ratings always took a turn for the better whenever he was away from Washington too.

it's hard to hold a grudge against a politician who isn't raising taxes, telling lies, or increasing the national debt.
 
Obama's poll ratings always took a turn for the better whenever he was away from Washington too.

it's hard to hold a grudge against a politician who isn't raising taxes, telling lies, or increasing the national debt.

You're pretending that WJC and Obama didn't have good poll numbers when in office. They did. Trump would love to have such numbers.

;-)
 
So, she's a victim... is that the gist?

Me, I think she was a willing party to an affair, the third party in what was Clinton's marital infidelity .

having a consenting affair is not a sin for a politician.

going on national TV, staring into the cameras, and declaring "I did not have sex with that woman" is a different matter.

having the first lady describe (in the aggregate) bill's playthings as "trailer trash" simply ups the ante among people who believes that our leaders ought to stand for something positive.

this is the disconnect between the embrace of Bill Clinton, and the attacks on Trump. The left lowered the bar for behavior, then screamed like crazy when Trump managed to hop over it so easily.
 
So, she's a victim... is that the gist?
Sometimes in this forum I feel like I'm having flashbacks to my days teaching the SAT for the Princeton Review, where my students would get a short selection in the reading comprehension section of the test and somehow come away with a completely bizarre view of what the gist of the piece was, despite it seeming so clear to me.

The gist of this piece wasn't that Lewinsky was a victim. Lewinsky just uses her own story as an individual example of a much broader phenomenon, driven in large part by Ailes, of the US media descending into a (very lucrative) sewer of tawdry exploitation "journalism." As she put it, on Fox "no rumor was too unsubstantiated, no innuendo too vile and no accusation too abhorrent." Her essay argues that it was in 1998 that we really started heading down the road that leads to the world we live in today -- a culture of trolls and tweets.... a "culture of humiliation." The gist of the piece was that this has been the age of Ailes, and that it debased our nation by handsomely rewarding those who pray on the vulnerable for clicks and ratings. She hopes that we can now move beyond that. I join her in that hope.
 
having a consenting affair is not a sin for a politician.

going on national TV, staring into the cameras, and declaring "I did not have sex with that woman" is a different matter.

having the first lady describe (in the aggregate) bill's playthings as "trailer trash" simply ups the ante among people who believes that our leaders ought to stand for something positive.

this is the disconnect between the embrace of Bill Clinton, and the attacks on Trump. The left lowered the bar for behavior, then screamed like crazy when Trump managed to hop over it so easily.
Nonsense. If all Trump had done is what Clinton did, we wouldn't even be talking about it. In fact, Trump did do the stuff Clinton did, and we aren't talking about it. He had a bunch of affairs -- cheating on all three of his wives. And of course he lied about it -- a man who has decided to have an affair has decided to lie about it. But that's not what Trump has been attacked for. He has been attacked for non-consensual behavior.
 
Obama's poll ratings always took a turn for the better whenever he was away from Washington too.

it's hard to hold a grudge against a politician who isn't raising taxes, telling lies, or increasing the national debt.
What an odd outlook. I'm not sure any modern president spent more time away from Washington than GW Bush. He set modern records for vacation time, and regularly disappeared to his mansion for the whole of August. He certainly wasn't raising taxes, either -- having presided over two of the most radically reckless tax cuts in history. Yet he was wildly unpopular, averaging under 49% despite a short period of unearned high ratings after 9/11. By the end of 2008, his approval rating had fallen under 30%.

In Obama's case, he wasn't popular because he was away from Washington. He was popular because, like Clinton before him, he led the nation to nearly across-the-board improvement.
 
Sometimes in this forum I feel like I'm having flashbacks to my days teaching the SAT for the Princeton Review, where my students would get a short selection in the reading comprehension section of the test and somehow come away with a completely bizarre view of what the gist of the piece was, despite it seeming so clear to me.

The gist of this piece wasn't that Lewinsky was a victim. Lewinsky just uses her own story as an individual example of a much broader phenomenon, driven in large part by Ailes, of the US media descending into a (very lucrative) sewer of tawdry exploitation "journalism." As she put it, on Fox "no rumor was too unsubstantiated, no innuendo too vile and no accusation too abhorrent." Her essay argues that it was in 1998 that we really started heading down the road that leads to the world we live in today -- a culture of trolls and tweets.... a "culture of humiliation." The gist of the piece was that this has been the age of Ailes, and that it debased our nation by handsomely rewarding those who pray on the vulnerable for clicks and ratings. She hopes that we can now move beyond that. I join her in that hope.

sure. however, she pins it on ailes, as do you. whereas the reality is that everyone, every outlet did it, it certainly wasnt predicted on the one.
and today, it is the mainstay of media, not just the purview of Ailes or fox.
 
Back
Top