New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking for Moderators

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've never seen a cross word from either of them. Hmm....

I never saw Dave or Chris get into a heated debate but I have seen them compliment and such. I haven't been here long though so please correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Personally, if moderators from posting members are chosen, I will probably spend my time posting somewhere else. Chris, Dave, et al, you guys have no idea how deep the bad blood runs regarding former members of Slate that decided to make PJ their new political discussion home. Alliances formed among each and every one of us at some level and many of those allegiance remain in one form or the other. I don't trust anyone being able to leave personal bias out of the decision making process regarding moderating among that group. I feel it's only fair to require that anyone selected to do this refrain from posting as to remove even the slightest appearance of a "conflict of interest" accusation. If a moderator can remain a posting member of the forum, I feel it is only human nature to concentrate on possible rules violations from opposing viewpoints.

Wanna ruin a good thing here at PJ and run off the transferred members...by all means, pick moderators from the current posters.
 
Uh.....uh oh.

I hate to say it .....but......

that may be EXACTLY what their aim and goal here is...LOL!


(for 'some' unknown reason...hehe)


Wanna ruin a good thing here at PJ and run off the transferred members...by all means, pick moderators from the current posters.
 
Number58,

I agree with your analysis.

Personally, if moderators from posting members are chosen, I will probably spend my time posting somewhere else. Chris, Dave, et al, you guys have no idea how deep the bad blood runs regarding former members of Slate that decided to make PJ their new political discussion home. Alliances formed among each and every one of us at some level and many of those allegiance remain in one form or the other. I don't trust anyone being able to leave personal bias out of the decision making process regarding moderating among that group. I feel it's only fair to require that anyone selected to do this refrain from posting as to remove even the slightest appearance of a "conflict of interest" accusation. If a moderator can remain a posting member of the forum, I feel it is only human nature to concentrate on possible rules violations from opposing viewpoints.

Wanna ruin a good thing here at PJ and run off the transferred members...by all means, pick moderators from the current posters.
 
Excellent ideas there, PACE. What is needed (and I hope wanted) on this board is for those who are reading but not posting to come in and post. I am sure that some are scared away by the current strife that the Fray posters have brought to the board. But I don't think those people were posting much to begin with.

Those of us who came from the Fray aren't afraid to post, to be ridiculed, to be argued with...... we've done that for years. But to others, that might be an intimidating thing to put themselves out there to experience.

I don't know what the trick would be to get those "just reading" people to post. Obviously Jack Bucks and posting contests haven't worked. And some very good Polls haven't worked either. Right now I am showing 91 members online and 2251 people (not logged in) watching. While I am certain that some of those 2251 are members viewing before they log in............ not all could possibly be. If many of them came in and could bring themselves to post, that would diffuse the few (and there are really only a few) posters who seem bent on ruining this place would be diluted.

That would probably be too much of a job for a couple of monitors, but it could be a goal to work for.

I believe that I could successfully separate myself from partisan posts and being objective in the reporting of miscreants. I've had experience irl in doing that and did it well. But of course, that is my opinion.

Star for you on this one Pace.

Hi Chris:

Why not post the responsibilities, and the deliverables clearly, create your short list from the recommendations here, and then set up a macro to monitor posts until you make a decision?

I mean to say if those that are recommended can contain their postings enough so that other posters are encouraged to post, and by that I mean those new posters who are "reading" and not engaging. that's clear from the members list, maybe then you can pick posters from the boards that can be interviewed for the responsibilities of the job.

Or, you can find independents who have no affliliation with either the previous home for a lot of these posters, or Political Jack, that might be the best path.

But again, my opinion

Regards
Pace
 
Thank you Jen, but I would still encourage the enlistment of independents, at this point, the moderating could degrade down to a singular defense of the moderators actions, of course, no one would be totally happy, but I have never shyed away from a good debate, but to be honest? some of the debates here especially the political discussions degrade so quickly into WWF's, that I am looking at other forums, it's not a matter of kitchen heat, it's a matter of useful time and understanding the views of others.

I will be relentless in attacking the politicians, they put themselves in the public forum under the guise of "serving the people" and defending unalienable rights, but the third person attacks here are tiresome, hopefully you agree,

I think the bar should be raised and those that are "observing" should be encouraged to post, maybe a new rubic for new posters, and the rules there are much more strigent than the other boards; sort of like ski slopes; beginners, intermediates, and then experts.

Regards
Pace
 
Oh, I definitely agree that the third person attacks here are tiresome. But the problem is that whenever we talk about a candidate, that candidate's supporters are also implicated and if said supporters group together and launch untruths about the opposing candidates, then here come the third person attacks because we really should not be expected to turn a blind eye to such antics. And it seems that the "if the shoe fits" thing is ignored and if someone here says "Democrats say..." or "Republicans say..." people (and I've been guilty of this) take it personally. It's one thing to point out that "I don't say that so not all Dems/Reps say it" and quite another to attack the writer for some ambiguous attack.

We've been conditioned to see an attack everywhere so we respond to just about everything as if it is an attack. And there are those here whose repetitive attacks (posting the same words/ same pictures to everything) actually are attacks. And that compounds the problem.

The rules are stringent because some of us came from a battered and abusive place and rules are needed at this point. There are still bullies here. But hopefully that will change. I do have hope.

Thank you Jen, but I would still encourage the enlistment of independents, at this point, the moderating could degrade down to a singular defense of the moderators actions, of course, no one would be totally happy, but I have never shyed away from a good debate, but to be honest? some of the debates here especially the political discussions degrade so quickly into WWF's, that I am looking at other forums, it's not a matter of kitchen heat, it's a matter of useful time and understanding the views of others.

I will be relentless in attacking the politicians, they put themselves in the public forum under the guise of "serving the people" and defending unalienable rights, but the third person attacks here are tiresome, hopefully you agree,

I think the bar should be raised and those that are "observing" should be encouraged to post, maybe a new rubic for new posters, and the rules there are much more strigent than the other boards; sort of like ski slopes; beginners, intermediates, and then experts.

Regards
Pace
 
Please run this by me before you make any decisions as to whom you might choose. I don't relish the idea of getting into a pissing match with a new Liberal moderator and a runaway ego.

We have been discussing bringing on 2 people to be moderators to assist with some admin functions on Political Jack. We would like to open the discussion to help us decide who would be best. We would prefer to have people from both sides (left and right) to keep it balanced. Let's get some ideas together and vote on the matter.

Thanks all!
 
Jen,

FWIW, I do not consider an attack on President Obama to be a personal attack on me as someone who supports Obama. Presumably, BRU does not consider an attack on Mitt Romney to be a personal attack on her. Now, if someone claims that President Obama is not a leader or Mitt Romney is not a leader, I am sure that some folks will strongly disagree and will express that disagreement. But they will not feel insulted. All of us see this sort of thing around the clock on the news channels and the blogs.

On the other hand, attacks that label ALL conservatives to be racists or ALL liberals to be "baby-killers" are - in my opinion - the moral equivalent of a personal attack. I think that people fall into those habits because throwing out generalizations is easy to do and it provides a sense of emotional satisfaction. Stereotypes are powerful for a reason. But a culture of throwing out stereotypes is also potentially destructive in my opinion. It is the "gross" generalizations and the "gross" personal attacks that I think are particularly destructive. (BTW, if Dave and Chris wanted to create a "no holds barred" zone where people could be as gross as they felt like being and restricted that behavior to that zone, that might make sense but that is a somewhat different structure from what we currently have.)

Oh, I definitely agree that the third person attacks here are tiresome. But the problem is that whenever we talk about a candidate, that candidate's supporters are also implicated and if said supporters group together and launch untruths about the opposing candidates, then here come the third person attacks because we really should not be expected to turn a blind eye to such antics. And it seems that the "if the shoe fits" thing is ignored and if someone here says "Democrats say..." or "Republicans say..." people (and I've been guilty of this) take it personally. It's one thing to point out that "I don't say that so not all Dems/Reps say it" and quite another to attack the writer for some ambiguous attack.

We've been conditioned to see an attack everywhere so we respond to just about everything as if it is an attack. And there are those here whose repetitive attacks (posting the same words/ same pictures to everything) actually are attacks. And that compounds the problem.

The rules are stringent because some of us came from a battered and abusive place and rules are needed at this point. There are still bullies here. But hopefully that will change. I do have hope.
 
Given what has already been written on this thread, I think that it is a safe bet that someone like Degsme might write:

"Please run this by me before you make any decisions as to who you might choose. I don't relish the idea of getting into a pissing match with a new Conservative moderator and a runaway ego."

At least you recognized earlier that if you were a Moderator that you might have to ban yourself.

Please run this by me before you make any decisions as to whom you might choose. I don't relish the idea of getting into a pissing match with a new Liberal moderator and a runaway ego.
 
I would not take the job, even if I did have the time. I would not take the job because I could not resist the temptation to ban every damned Liberal on the board (except for MaryAnne and Marylb) take their Jack Bucks away from them and call them the most vile and venemous names I could think of to let them know just how I feel about their opinions, their lack of understanding and common fairness, the sorry way they live their lives and the way they exist immersed in lies and bullshit with absolutely no respect or acknowledgment of right and good and truth.

Then I'd have no one to argue with.
 
you have no one to argue with now jack. we just post to you to encourage you to write more stuff like u just posted. its hilarious
 
I actually wouldn't do any of that stuff. What I WOULD do is open up the forum and make it a free for all, so I could take off the gloves call you what I relly think you are.
 
and that would matter to me exactly how? youre hardly in the same league with guys like whizzer and blammie, little fella.
 
I am not sure I totally agree Jen, I've seen posts started wtih "Hey Lefties!", or someother salutation of similar stellar fashion :)
Or how about commies, leftists, etc.? does that engage useful debate?

Or how about introductions for a new poster here where their mental health was "announced" to the whole board? glad the poster was banned, no one should have to endure that.

There's a thread degrading right now, and it's got a lot of views; let's face it, most people would rather post "facebook style sublimial posts" than discuss issues, and if baiting were a job, many here would be gainfully employed, I can see why they are not employed.

It's unfortunate, but that's the truth, and yes, you are correct that some try to parse their words into focused retorts to a subject line, while others just practice the politics of personal destruction; that's an easy game, it takes real talent, drive and intelligence to debate and try to convince someone of an opposing view that there may be a modicum of consensus. I would argue that many here don't have that kind of talent, so the politics of personal destruction suit the dialogue well for them.

That's why I think indies should moderate, it's hard to drop the "conditioning" of the past, and surely it's evident here, that some don't even try to.

Regards
Pace
 
and that would matter to me exactly how? youre hardly in the same league with guys like whizzer and blammie, little fella.

You've already proven that you can't take criticism. You have an overinflated opinion of your own importance. My guess is that you are not very well endowed. You sound like a man with some deep-seated emotional hang-ups.
You don't play well with others and it's apparent that you get your feelings hurt very easily.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top