New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking for Moderators

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, I would like to know too. But no matter,we are glad you are here with us. Most of us argue politics, but are far from enemies. Many of 12 years duration at Slate.

Well I think it's larger than here in some ways, now I know that sounds strange but I won't go any further.:nono::trustme:

Lots of nice people. They used to have a wonderful debating section and still do have one with about ten or twenty that really try hard but since a couple of the best but not necessarily the best died, I don't think it's been quite the same. They have lots of other forums that are lighter and interesting.

Needed a break! I really like it here as well and like to be among mostly Americans although I love the British.

That you MaryAnn, I just can't imagine some with you all for 12 yrs., you have to feel like family.
 
First of all....you weren't even there.

Secondly, we were a family, of sorts. And fighting and fuming is what families do. Then they get over it and go on to defend each other from 'outside' enemies.

Thirdly, do you really want to preach to ME about name calling? Really? On what basis of ""moral authority"", pray tell?



But those watching found very little humour, no enlightenment and basically saw it as a waste of electron holes.

At least you seem to admit here that your enjoyment comes from the fighting and name calling.
 
Ok...since you keep pushing the envelope AND the issue....I'll take the bait, just this once.

You really want to talk about posting track records, degs?

While you follow me around and impune MY posting habits, you might want to take a good hard look in a mirror. After all, I am not the one that has been suspended twice now. That would be YOU.

Hypocrite much?

And again the quesiton goes to you Lapcat, are you here to foster and participate in civil discussions? Or are you here to continue with the approach your posting track record indicates?
 
We have been discussing bringing on 2 people to be moderators to assist with some admin functions on Political Jack. We would like to open the discussion to help us decide who would be best. We would prefer to have people from both sides (left and right) to keep it balanced. Let's get some ideas together and vote on the matter.

Thanks all!

I would suggest Jen on the right..

Best Regards
Lobato1
 
I wouldn't want to lose them as posters. And a moderator cannot be a poster.

I disagree with you. I would encourage both sides (and the middle ground if we do 3) to fully represent their arguments etc. We would know their affiliation and they should have no problem, as adults, having an intelligent political debate with everyone here and fully follow the rules at the same time.
 
It has been difficult enough since we migrated here, with "unbiased" and non-ex-fray moderators. Just imagine what it will turn into with ex-fraysters modding the place....lol.

Actually, our hope is to have the mods work with us to help cool down some situations and make this a better place overall. I think if say our republican Mod was to see a republican forum member go off the handle they might be an easier voice to listen to for diffusion of the situation.
 
I find it significant that Pace, Lapcat, and MaryAnne all agreed about this. I think that degsme and Cicero and many others have essentially agreed. (I know that I agree.) Given this, following degsme's example, I would like to suggest an alternative solution.

I think that if Dave and Chris need some help with the volume of moderating work that needs to be done, they should follow Pace's suggestion and hire people from outside who do not have a direct stake in the arguments.

However, I have a feeling that Dave and Chris might also like to have more consistent input into setting the rules and structure of PJ so that both lefties and righties felt that the "game" was fair. I think that part of the problem is that different people not only interpret rules differently but feel that different sorts of rules are appropriate. This seems clear for Jen and degsme. I think that it holds true for Cicero and me as well. If the problem is "the rules of the game" themselves, I think that it would make more sense to set up a rules/infractions board made up of, for example, three regular posters elected by righties and three regular posters elected by lefties. Though Dave and Chris would make the ultimate decisions on the rules, the board could provide healthy discussion between left and right and provide useful perspectives to Dave and Chris. In addition, lefties could complain to one or more of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused and righties could complain to one of their three reps if they felt that they were being abused. And the reps could raise the issues with Dave and with the board. One advantage of this scheme is that I think that it would be significantly less work for the individuals. Also, you could hold elections once a year or something similar so that no one permanently filled a board position. (In other words, you put in term limits.)

My instincts tell me that something along these lines might be more workable. (I know that if I was elected to a board like this, I could probably find the time to do it where I wouldn't be able to do something that required a more open-ended and time-consuming commitment. I suspect that there are others who would feel the same.)

You are on the right track of what we are looking for. A panel essentially to go over violations with us, from all sides of politics of course to ensure fairness. The work load seems to be a concern, and really as of now we wouldn't "REQUIRE" any work, more just help us with the fighting, move a thread to the proper section if you see one and want to move it, stuff like that. The panel idea is what we want, and I think we would still start with 3 total (1 right, 1 left, 1 middle) and work from there. If the mods found themselves unable to post and engage in conversation we would make changes (either add more, or allow them to drop their moderation role of course).
 
Ok...since you keep pushing the envelope AND the issue....I'll take the bait, just this once.

You really want to talk about posting track records, degs?

While you follow me around and impune MY posting habits, you might want to take a good hard look in a mirror. After all, I am not the one that has been suspended twice now. That would be YOU.

Hypocrite much?

I fully admit to engaging in Prisoner's Dillema game response.

But I have a lot of posting content that is 100% civil, factual and cited as interesting by folks on both sides of the aisle

Your posting record is consistently 85%-95% name calling of people in the guise of 3rd person opinion

Are you here to have a civil discussion - or as you seemed to indicate above - do you just want to name call and fight because that's what you find fun?

answer the quesiton please.
 
First of all....you weren't even there.
At BB - yes I was

Secondly, we were a family, of sorts. And fighting and fuming is what families do.
No families don't call each other nasty names and then get in a huff well called on it.

and notice NO ONE is defending you here - excpet perhaps the few conservatives who also just mainly post namecalling attacks

NO ONE is defending how you post.

Thirdly, do you really want to preach to ME about name calling? Really? On what basis of ""moral authority"", pray tell?
Simple, aggregate signal to noice content.

your's is consistently 85%-95% nothing but driveby name calling. Anyone can see that by simply clicking on your "Forum posts" list and scrolling through the posts you make.
 
But...but....but.....it's only sarcasm, of course, if it's coming from a leftie. If coming from a rightie, it's racist or homophobic and/or passive 3rd person attacking....lol.
Is your goal here to engage in a civil discussion about moderation or to name call and distract the conversation?

Simple question.

Please answer.
 
Perhaps I should have said it is a defence mechanism. I know both sides are guilty.That includes me. I have found myself in the middle of some doozys,(if that is a word!)

No Mary Anne. Its quite possible to engage in spirited discussion and not name call pre-emptively. Pre-emptive name calling is neither a defense mechanism nor battle scars.

It is very much a "developed pattern". and one that requires taking personal responsibility to change... assuming the person wants to change. But as seems to have been indicated above, Lapcat has admitted that she LIKES FIGHTING.... not civil discussion, not arguing facts and ideas... just fighting.

And she has even posted that fighting is her idea of what it means to be a family. Now My 'family of origin" was pretty dysfunctional. But I atleast know that what makes a family is not the fighting. And I personally own that I engage in "Prisoners Dillema" game theory response to this sort of behaviour.

But I also don't do drive by name calling if a thread is going on that is civil and discussions are ongoing.

Now just look at Lapcat's posting history yourself. Go back connect to "forum posts". Count up how many posts per page start off with 3rd person name calling. Then divide by the number of posts on the page.

22 out of 25 was what I got when I made that count. You do it. See how many posts Lapcat leads off with civil engagement... Don't take my word for it. Count it yourself.
 
You are on the right track of what we are looking for. A panel essentially to go over violations with us, from all sides of politics of course to ensure fairness. The work load seems to be a concern, and really as of now we wouldn't "REQUIRE" any work, more just help us with the fighting, move a thread to the proper section if you see one and want to move it, stuff like that. The panel idea is what we want, and I think we would still start with 3 total (1 right, 1 left, 1 middle) and work from there. If the mods found themselves unable to post and engage in conversation we would make changes (either add more, or allow them to drop their moderation role of course).

Dave, its not that moderators cannot post.

its that moderators that post are almost never seen as fairminded. As I said, this is experience I bring from 43+ years of playing in online realms both as newbie, lurker, moderator and bad boy sockpuppet. Been there, done pretty much all of it. Giving you my historic perspective...
 
And of course, if you go back and 're-read' my words, I said no such thing as what degs is 'claiming' I said.

He is just using this, as he uses everything I say, with which to attack me.

And no, it ain't working. At least...not FOR him.

Perhaps I should have said it is a defence mechanism. I know both sides are guilty.That includes me. I have found myself in the middle of some doozys,(if that is a word!)
 
Ironic.....coming from the poster that's been suspended twice now.

Again....

hypocrite much?

At BB - yes I was


No families don't call each other nasty names and then get in a huff well called on it.

and notice NO ONE is defending you here - excpet perhaps the few conservatives who also just mainly post namecalling attacks

NO ONE is defending how you post.


Simple, aggregate signal to noice content.

your's is consistently 85%-95% nothing but driveby name calling. Anyone can see that by simply clicking on your "Forum posts" list and scrolling through the posts you make.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top