New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking for Moderators

Status
Not open for further replies.
Cicero would be excellent but he's not available.
Jack Dallas is a strong right wing advocate but intelligent and capable of fair judgement....
On the other side... Gordon Gecko or Degsme. Both strong left wing advocates but capable of rising above personal feelings to do neutral observer thing I believe.
 
If degsme got it I would be banned the first day.


Cicero would be excellent but he's not available.
Jack Dallas is a strong right wing advocate but intelligent and capable of fair judgement....
On the other side... Gordon Gecko or Degsme. Both strong left wing advocates but capable of rising above personal feelings to do neutral observer thing I believe.
 
Actually I recommended you as well as Degsme...

It requires to ability to rise above your own personal opinions....I just cannot do that...I believe either of you gentlemen could
Jack Dallas is another who though he has strong convictions about certain matters could separate his feelings from the task and do the job.
 
Hmmm...maybe me too

Still I think he has the ability to rise above his own feelings...he and I have had some nasty go rounds but I see traces of good judgment in there somehwere.
 
It's a massive job...when the fray closed the posting count over here probably tripled...in fact I am sure of it.
 
Well right off the bat I would disqualify anyone who has engaged in any sort of 3rd person name calling. On whichever side (that includes myself).

Frankly I don't think any of the existing active posters qualifies.

Frankly I'd suggest looking at some of the folks who are frequently lurking and have a minor posting history like Solutions4 or TheBell. And compensate them in some manner.

Because its a thankless job and the big asshats here really have no business pretending to be qualified or nominating one of their circlejerk friends.
 
If degsme got it I would be banned the first day.

No, you would just have about 80% of your posts deleted as having no content beyond that intended to cause offense.

Now you have demonstrated an ability to post without that, so clearly that would not mean a ban of you..
 
Thanks Barb and MP (and Lapcat and GG on other posts).
I appreciate your vote of confidence.

and I can guarantee that given how circle-jerky that is, this is a formulae for disaster. two posters who have the highest insult/posting content nominating a third one with a similar ratio simply because she insults the same targets is hardly something that we should desire if the goal is a civil discussion.
 
Hmmm...maybe me too

Still I think he has the ability to rise above his own feelings...he and I have had some nasty go rounds but I see traces of good judgment in there somehwere.

And again, when you post civilly you have nothing to fear. but you more often than not do not. You are not as egregious as Jen or Lapcat or Jack Dallas, or Dino or Angel of Dearth. But you do name call with no supporting basis.


I've done this job on other BBSes... dealing with folks like you would not be hard, just a bunch of work at first and you would either choose to follow the rules or leave. And given the high rate of namecalling/content we have seen from folks like that (22 out of the last 25 posts in one case) well perhaps you would chose to leave.

Civil discussion can take place and can be enforced. But rarely by moderators who also participate.
 
Well, then, thanks for the second part.

But censorship? Hmmmmm........Not sure about that idea.

No, you would just have about 80% of your posts deleted as having no content beyond that intended to cause offense.

Now you have demonstrated an ability to post without that, so clearly that would not mean a ban of you..
 
We have been discussing bringing on 2 people to be moderators to assist with some admin functions on Political Jack. We would like to open the discussion to help us decide who would be best. We would prefer to have people from both sides (left and right) to keep it balanced. Let's get some ideas together and vote on the matter.

Thanks all!

I would recommend also that for the new moderators you change the way "infractions" and "consequences" are meted out. I don't know the technology behind this BBS, but in one of the others that I helped run, what we did was to set up an Admin Only "Deleted" forum. All posts that were deemed "infractions" did not result in suspensions, but simply were "deleted". The "deleted" post was moved to the "Deleted" forum. That way if the senior administrators/forum owners felt that the moderator had been overly zealous - and/or the violator made a persuasive enough appeal, the post could be restored.

This worked well. Lots of screaming up front as content free name calling got deleted. but then relatively civil discussions. periodically there'd be a flareup as someone would get a bug up their but.

Suspensions were only applied by the owner of the forum upon recomendation by one of the moderators. And the purpose of the suspensions was to enforce a cooling down period not as punishment. The idea being that its possible for some people to get into a Technology Loop http://www.ifc.com/portlandia/videos/portlandia-technology-loop that only Real World interaction can break.


At another BBS an "appeals forum" was tried. Where the junior moderators would move the conflicting parties into a "moderation" forum. There each would get to present their side in a post, each would get a rebuttal and the moderator would make a ruling. This forum was "read Only" for all of those outside the conflict. That way they could see where the boundaries were being drawn but not actually participate in the process.

It was alot of work, but it did work. dunno if that would be enough here.
 
Well, then, thanks for the second part.

But censorship? Hmmmmm........Not sure about that idea.
Its all censorship of some form. That's what being a moderator is about. the rest is simply determining an equitable set of guidelines and applying them in a manner that works. Frankly open and judicious moderation works more effectively than suspensions and "infractions" with stiff rules that can be worked around by the flexibility of language.

I (and the owners) know that I'm capable of writing text that can slip the dagger of an insult in between pretty much any linguistic rule you try to create.

But the dagger is going to be quite visible to any moderator worth their salt. And I would get called on it.


OTOH, doing stupid shit like going around posting pictures of cans of "troll spray" or making 3rd person insults of the form "well lefties xxx" in response to a poster that is clearly to the left of you on the spectrum may technically pass a simplistic rule like "don't attack a poster personally" but it clearly is
1) intended to attack the poster
2) basically content free
3) disrupts any sort of civil discussion (which I suspect is often the intent).

A moderator with the authority to drive civil discussion, particularly if it is structured in an appealable form (ie your post gets deleted unless you can convince Dave or Chris to undelete it) works every effectively and very quickly.

Now those posers who's content is 22 out of 25 posts nothing but 3rd person name calling, are probably here to name call. well they won't last very long since it gets kinda boring to have 80% of your posts deleted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top