New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Looking for Moderators

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting thought/ method. Are you going for the job? Maybe justoffal (I think that's who recommended you) had a good point there.
Looks like a lot of work.


Its all censorship of some form. That's what being a moderator is about. the rest is simply determining an equitable set of guidelines and applying them in a manner that works. Frankly open and judicious moderation works more effectively than suspensions and "infractions" with stiff rules that can be worked around by the flexibility of language.

I (and the owners) know that I'm capable of writing text that can slip the dagger of an insult in between pretty much any linguistic rule you try to create.

But the dagger is going to be quite visible to any moderator worth their salt. And I would get called on it.


OTOH, doing stupid shit like going around posting pictures of cans of "troll spray" or making 3rd person insults of the form "well lefties xxx" in response to a poster that is clearly to the left of you on the spectrum may technically pass a simplistic rule like "don't attack a poster personally" but it clearly is
1) intended to attack the poster
2) basically content free
3) disrupts any sort of civil discussion (which I suspect is often the intent).

A moderator with the authority to drive civil discussion, particularly if it is structured in an appealable form (ie your post gets deleted unless you can convince Dave or Chris to undelete it) works every effectively and very quickly.

Now those posers who's content is 22 out of 25 posts nothing but 3rd person name calling, are probably here to name call. well they won't last very long since it gets kinda boring to have 80% of your posts deleted.
 
Interesting thought/ method. Are you going for the job? Maybe justoffal (I think that's who recommended you) had a good point there.
Looks like a lot of work.

Nope - like I said. I did this at two other BBSes. I don't have the time to be a moderator and I like discussing economics and political futures. to be an effective moderator you have to cut back on posting. Its essentially the same as a teacher has to cut back on their religious expression because as a teacher they are the Loco Governmentis ..
 
And again, when you post civilly you have nothing to fear. but you more often than not do not. You are not as egregious as Jen or Lapcat or Jack Dallas, or Dino or Angel of Dearth. But you do name call with no supporting basis.

Well, thank God you were able to rise above your own feelings.
 
Yes. I am quite aware that the posting of a moderator would be quite different from the posting of just a regular poster. And you are correct regarding a teacher. It appears that you would know how to do the job though.

Nope - like I said. I did this at two other BBSes. I don't have the time to be a moderator and I like discussing economics and political futures. to be an effective moderator you have to cut back on posting. Its essentially the same as a teacher has to cut back on their religious expression because as a teacher they are the Loco Governmentis ..
 
Yes. I am quite aware that the posting of a moderator would be quite different from the posting of just a regular poster. And you are correct regarding a teacher. It appears that you would know how to do the job though.

Like I said, I've done it twice before... but my commitment here is intermittent. My job currently is hours of boredom punctuated by days of crunching. So I cannot be a reliable moderator and am not interested in it - at least not ona consistent basis. But that gives me an Idea that I will post as a direct response to Chris.
 
um....did I somehow pretend that or do you just want to start some trouble on the admin thread? THAT takes some nerve.

No...I said I AS IN ME wasn't going to PRETEND otherwise. I'm not you and I have no idea what you say to the adm when you discuss stuff with them nor do I want to know. All I said is that neithr of us are qualified because I truly believe that. I'm not stupid enough to think there would be any fairness. Okay?
 
Nope - like I said. I did this at two other BBSes. I don't have the time to be a moderator and I like discussing economics and political futures. to be an effective moderator you have to cut back on posting. Its essentially the same as a teacher has to cut back on their religious expression because as a teacher they are the Loco Governmentis ..

Well that's a relief. .....I doubt someone that says things like "but them wierdo Mormons... I hear they drink the blood of North Carolina Virgins mixed with pig shit... " is hardly qualified to moderate ANY board.
 
uh.....very telling of what? That it was funny? Wow now there must have been some subliminal message in that! LOL Chill out....geeze IRP was joking, I laughed, that's it. Grow up
 
Here's an alternate thought on the moderation/appeals panels.

I sail competitively. at all levels of competition from informal fun races to world champs. Basically at everything less than the National Championships level, the way sailing deals with conflicts is to have a set of rules, that have some guiding principles but also some leeway.

These then are "called out" on the water, and if there is a mutual acknowledgement, the offending party takes an appropriate penalty (not very applicable here - we already get that with some people admitting "mea culpa")

But if the conflict is mutual it goes to an appeals process after the race. the Protest Committee then is made up of FELLOW SAILORS who are known to be experienced in the rules and who have no direct personal interest in that conflict.

They then hear a presentation from each side, deliberate identify "facts found" and "rules applied" and make a ruling. That ruling can then be appealled further up the chain for a clarification of "rules applied" but "facts found" stands.


So what might work here is to have two junior moderators (junior to Dave and Chris) who are empowered to hide/temporarily delete a post. If that is appealled, then 3 posters drawn from the pool of "regulars" who don't have a dog in the proverbial fight, act as an appeals panel. that ruling can be overruled by Chris and Dave, but otherwise it stands.

IOW, Junior Moderators who's job is a preliminary sorting, independent peer appeals review, final appeal to Chris and Dave.

reduces the workload on the Moderators, makes folks have a vested interest in the society since it is participatory AND since you have an incentive not to have everone arrayed against you.
And gives Dave and Chris more time to do what they want to do which I suspect is read the interesting threads rather than just reply to hundreds of "Reportings".
 
neither did I, but please notice the sequence of events here K?:boink: That's all I am saying. LOL ....it was still funny!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top