I've not seen Shameless.
Mad Men hooked me right away.
It transported me back the when I was very young and my dad would drag me to the office after school for one reason or another, and it recalled the neighbors, the cocktail parties etc.
I was watching my early years. The clothes, the cars, the miracle that was the Xerox machine, the settings and the decor are all so spot on that it's erieee sometimes.
They talk about the same topics my parents and their friends talked about and in the same manner.
The dialogue and the attitudes the characters show towards things like race, civil rights, women, popular culture etc are so spot on. And they're evolving nicely as the show moved forward in timeline.