Catholicism seems a little less "nutty and scary" than mainline Protestantism, to me, simply because of the way it's typically practiced in the US today.... Catholicism tends to be more formal and maybe even "pro-forma" than the charismatic sects of evangelical Protestantism. You'll seldom hear major Catholic figures, these days, arguing that the world is just a few thousand years old, or that God created all animals in their current forms, for example. For me, modern American Catholicism can be symbolized by Georgetown University, Boston College, Notre Dame, Fordham, etc., while modern American Protestantism can be symbolized by Liberty University, Bob Jones University, Patrick Henry College, etc. The former group are places of serious scholarship that just happen to be closely affiliated with a church, while the latter are places of propaganda and evangelism masquerading as institutions of higher learning.
But that gets to how I ultimately view religion and politics. I don't much care what the official dogmas of the religion are. I care about how those things get put into practice by a particular individual or organization. In theory, Georgetown University comes out of a "nutty and scary" dogma, but in practice it's a great school (and the alma mater of the non-Catholic Bill Clinton, by the way). If a politician, similarly, theoretically comes out of a "nutty and scary" dogma like that of Mormonism, I don't much care, if that manifests itself in rational and moral behavior by him. Unfortunately, in Romney's case, the result hasn't been either moral or rational.