New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Moderator elections?

HA, why would someone agree to come to a political blog...never participate in it...but merely Moderate other posters' posts.....without pay or compensation? Not exactly FUN...I can tell you.

I doubt anyone would become a bonafide moderator without some sort of compensation. Unless someone is into that sort of thing as a hobby of sorts.

But, from what I have seen, what you and this group of alleged moderators do is not actually moderating. Why would anyone assume a title/position for something that they are not actually doing?

The whole thing is just a little ridiculous - everyone pretending that everyone else is something that they actually aren't for the benefit of, what, keeping up appearances? It's more than a little silly and just plain ol' stupid.
 
couple that with the fact that we're all anonymous and unknown to one another, and yet somehow seem bent on outlining every gradation of what is or is not moderating, who is beholden to whom, aligned to whom, owes who what, and or what 'side' and therefore your actions should dictate this that n the other..

well then the whole lot gets ever ridiculous-er..um..er.
 
couple that with the fact that we're all anonymous and unknown to one another, and yet somehow seem bent on outlining every gradation of what is or is not moderating, who is beholden to whom, aligned to whom, owes who what, and or what 'side' and therefore your actions should dictate this that n the other..

well then the whole lot gets ever ridiculous-er..um..er.

Actually, we're not all anonymous and unknown to each other, but that's beside the point.

When in doubt, I always go by the traditional dictionary definition as a means of clarifying what something means. (I am not one of these people who holds to the notion that words mean whatever we want them to mean whenever we need them to mean something other than what they actually mean.)

For example:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moderator

And, in case you can't find the additional link yourself (I do realize very few people are familiar with the dictionary):

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moderate

The moderator is meant to be impartial and not a taker of sides, beholden or aligned with anyone. That's what makes a moderator a moderator. That is sort of the point.
 
surely some will find your dictionary references illuminating.


as we are not, any of us, impartial..as it stands... it seemed most beneficial, and I believe the intent of the owners of this site, to institute a moderating-by-committee model...

Apparently, not so much, seemingly....to many

Anyhoo...until such time as the owners elect to offer remuneration, or perhaps our denizens here agree to contribute to the hiring of same... what we have here is a 'make the best of what is' scenario...

great? nah. horrible? nah. trying? yes. a best effort kind of deal..given the voluntary nature of the whole thing... inclusive of participation..


best,
PF.
 
The moderator is meant to be impartial and not a taker of sides, beholden or aligned with anyone. That's what makes a moderator a moderator. That is sort of the point.


So, we could call them cheerleaders instead. The Lead Moderators shall heretofore be known as Head Cheerleaders. Sound like a plan?
 
HA,

In fact, neither of the online definitions that you provided indicated that being impartial/impartiality was an "essential" part of being a moderator. The most appropriate definitions that I saw on your online links were:

Moderator: A person who moderates

Moderate: kept or keeping within reasonable or proper limits; not extreme, excessive, or intense

To me, the purpose of the moderators are - as a group - to keep PJ from "boiling over" and descending into a "Ballot Box-like" state of discourse. The structure of the group of moderators - a fair balance between ROC and LOC - with discipline for ROC being primarily in the hands of ROC mods and discipline for LOC being primarily in the hands of LOC mods works pretty well. The moderators - as individuals - are not meant to be "impartial." Personally, I think that this system of checks and balances seems to work OK.

That said, this system is meant to help Dave and the Administrators "moderate" PJ. Dave has the final say. Dave is IMO impartial. And Dave's impartiality is reflected in the overall evenhandedness of the moderators as a group. Everyone is going to have a moderator that they don't particularly like. But all individual mods are constrained by the system that they work in.

In sum, though individual moderators may not be impartial, I think that the system works in an impartial way on balance.




Actually, we're not all anonymous and unknown to each other, but that's beside the point.

When in doubt, I always go by the traditional dictionary definition as a means of clarifying what something means. (I am not one of these people who holds to the notion that words mean whatever we want them to mean whenever we need them to mean something other than what they actually mean.)

For example:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moderator

And, in case you can't find the additional link yourself (I do realize very few people are familiar with the dictionary):

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moderate

The moderator is meant to be impartial and not a taker of sides, beholden or aligned with anyone. That's what makes a moderator a moderator. That is sort of the point.
 
surely some will find your dictionary references illuminating.


as we are not, any of us, impartial..as it stands... it seemed most beneficial, and I believe the intent of the owners of this site, to institute a moderating-by-committee model...

Apparently, not so much, seemingly....to many

Anyhoo...until such time as the owners elect to offer remuneration, or perhaps our denizens here agree to contribute to the hiring of same... what we have here is a 'make the best of what is' scenario...

great? nah. horrible? nah. trying? yes. a best effort kind of deal..given the voluntary nature of the whole thing... inclusive of participation..


best,
PF.

Trying? Really? I hardly think so. It's not that difficult to maintain impartiality with respect to the rules and regulations and to conduct oneself in a manner that is fair and unbiased.

No, none of you are impartial, and therefore, none of you qualify as moderators.

If we are to be a moderating-by-committee model, then why not open up the committe to everyone? Any time a problem arises, then, say within 15 minutes of the problem arising, anyone on the board can toss in their vote and all votes get counted, not just those few who can't seem to be any more impartial than any other idiot roaming the web at any given moment.

Either that or just chuck the whole thing and let the place be a free-for-all.

I mean, seriously, how useful are moderators who don't actually moderate and who feel free to break the rules while simultaneously chastising others for breaking the rules?

The whole thing seems rather pointless.
 
HA,

In fact, neither of the online definitions that you provided indicated that being impartial/impartiality was an "essential" part of being a moderator. The most appropriate definitions that I saw on your online links were:

Moderator: A person who moderates

Moderate: kept or keeping within reasonable or proper limits; not extreme, excessive, or intense

To me, the purpose of the moderators are - as a group - to keep PJ from "boiling over" and descending into a "Ballot Box-like" state of discourse. The structure of the group of moderators - a fair balance between ROC and LOC - with discipline for ROC being primarily in the hands of ROC mods and discipline for LOC being primarily in the hands of LOC mods works pretty well. The moderators - as individuals - are not meant to be "impartial." Personally, I think that this system of checks and balances seems to work OK.

That said, this system is meant to help Dave and the Administrators "moderate" PJ. Dave has the final say. Dave is IMO impartial. And Dave's impartiality is reflected in the overall evenhandedness of the moderators as a group. Everyone is going to have a moderator that they don't particularly like. But all individual mods are constrained by the system that they work in.

In sum, though individual moderators may not be impartial, I think that the system works in an impartial way on balance.

Read on - a moderator acts as a referee, umpire, arbiter, judge- all things that require impartiality. Without impartiality, the job of the moderator is reduced to nothing but playing favourites. And, really, the people of like mind police the people people of like mind? You think that works - should Sandusky's jury have been made up of nothing but pedophiles?

I think Dave was/is impartial because he didn't know any of us and had no baggage, but anyone who has carried over baggage from someplace else and brings that baggage up constantly here cannot realistically be considered someone who is going to be a fair and reasonable moderator. :censored:

I don't want to read that endlessly and I find it an inconvenience to have to maneuver around it. On top of that, apparently it is against the rules both to bring up crap from prior forums and to go at each other constantly with the personal attacks. Yet not a single moderator has actually done anything about it...

What's the point of pretending to have moderators if they don't actually do anything useful, like moderating according to the rules of the board?

The whole thing is a joke and I don't see why we should continue the pretense.
 
seemingly far from pointless... given that we're knee deep in the subject across several posts.

maybe you come show us how its done... you have my vote...
 
I say that we institute a weekly contest along the line of "Where's Waldo" except it will be "What do Moderator do?" You can fill in the blanks with dictionary finds and guesses and solve the puzzle.

I think the solution is that we adults all stop trying to figure out how we want to be policed perfectly and just start posting interesting subjects with a novel idea of not breaking rules. Maybe stop worrying so much about someone else? Maybe finally give into the most important concept and that is how we ourselves want to be seen, not how a Moderator or a named poster is seen by yourself but how you yourself is seen by all.

You may disagree and want to talk about the really boring subject of Moderators. I can tell you that Phil does pull hair and Dave has been known to shake a can of coke on us - but those two things are really the only perks.
 
Read on - a moderator acts as a referee, umpire, arbiter, judge- all things that require impartiality. Without impartiality, the job of the moderator is reduced to nothing but playing favourites. And, really, the people of like mind police the people people of like mind? You think that works - should Sandusky's jury have been made up of nothing but pedophiles?

A moderator does not have to be a judge. I think that you are dead wrong. The Sandusky analogy is just plain insulting to all the moderators whether they are ROC or LOC.

I think Dave was/is impartial because he didn't know any of us and had no baggage, but anyone who has carried over baggage from someplace else and brings that baggage up constantly here cannot realistically be considered someone who is going to be a fair and reasonable moderator. I mean, seriously, if any moderator here was doing their job, then BRU and NinaS would have been banned long ago because all those two do is go at each other over some old crap that they got into with each other over at Ballot Box.

I think that you underestimate Dave. BTW, do you think that YOU could be a fair and reasonable moderator?

I don't want to read that endlessly and I find it an inconvenience to have to maneuver around it. On top of that, apparently it is against the rules both to bring up crap from prior forums and to go at each other constantly with the personal attacks. Yet not a single moderator has actually done anything about it...

I take it that you don't want to read back and forths between BRU and Nina. It sounds like you want both of them to be banned. I take it that you think that they both repeatedly what you understand to be the rules. Personally, I don't find it that inconvenient to avoid posts that I am not particularly interested in. I am mostly concerned with how folks interact with me. I find the general posting environment to be improved from what it was before the moderator system was established. Is it perfect? No. Is it improved? In my opinion, it is.

What's the point of pretending to have moderators if they don't actually do anything useful, like moderating according to the rules of the board?

If I understand things correctly, moderators - for the most part - evaluate infraction reports from posters and occassionally take action if they notice stuff themselves. As I suggested above, I do think that the moderators have done some useful things.

The whole thing is a joke and I don't see why we should continue the pretense.
[

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. I do not think that the moderating system is a joke or has been an abject failure. But that is just my POV.
 
seemingly far from pointless... given that we're knee deep in the subject across several posts.

maybe you come show us how its done... you have my vote...

I prefer to self moderate - in that I can exercise enough self control so as not to make this forum a worthless place to visit for anyone looking for interesting and amicable conversation on a wide range of topics.

Obviously, the vast majority of people around here have a fair amount of trouble with self control.
 
i would not go so far as to throw the 'vast majority' under the lack of self control bus..

but I would tend to agree..there are several that have their issues..further, some that are wholly without merit.

and there's the rub...if we, each of us would self moderate..just enough..this modding thing would be a non starter..

(and secretly...just twixt you and I...i've long advocated for the ole heave ho for a handful of our..more colorful..denizens. but shh, don tell no one..)
 
A moderator does not have to be a judge. I think that you are dead wrong. The Sandusky analogy is just plain insulting to all the moderators whether they are ROC or LOC.



I think that you underestimate Dave. BTW, do you think that YOU could be a fair and reasonable moderator?



I take it that you don't want to read back and forths between BRU and Nina. It sounds like you want both of them to be banned. I take it that you think that they both repeatedly what you understand to be the rules. Personally, I don't find it that inconvenient to avoid posts that I am not particularly interested in. I am mostly concerned with how folks interact with me. I find the general posting environment to be improved from what it was before the moderator system was established. Is it perfect? No. Is it improved? In my opinion, it is.



If I understand things correctly, moderators - for the most part - evaluate infraction reports from posters and occassionally take action if they notice stuff themselves. As I suggested above, I do think that the moderators have done some useful things.

[

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. I do not think that the moderating system is a joke or has been an abject failure. But that is just my POV.

Yes, the moderator does have to be a judge. They have to, in fact, judge whether or not any given poster is acting within the appropriate guidelines of the forum...exactly what their decisions to give warnings, infractions etc. have to be based upon. Unless you are suggesting that their job is to hand out kudos or condemnation based on nothing other than their personal whim???

The Sandusky analogy is completely appropriate - if the fact is that the the place is moderated by one group of "moderators" who deal only with the posters of a similar mindset to their own and another group of "moderators" who only deal with the posters who are of their own similar mindset, then you have admitted that the place is not actually being moderated at all.

I don't know Dave well enough to estimate anything other than what I did - that he seemed to be an impartial moderator.

Yes, I know I could be a fair and reasonable moderator. However, I do not have the time to volunteer for the job because I actually have a job that I have to work because that's how I pay my bills - which is why I am not here very often. An absentee moderator wouldn't be any more useful than the current system. As I said, the moderator position isn't really all that hard. You have a set of rules, you apply the rules fairly and impartially to all and judge whether or not anyone has broken them, how often, how severely and what action may be appropriate when infractions arise. (The best way to get to that point, if the forum insists on having these lay moderators, is to reduce the position of moderator to a 2-4 week period and while moderating, moderators cannot join the open fray. Perhaps even make the position mandatory for those who log in consistent, regular hours.)

I've been here since Sept. 2011 and there does not seem to be any difference from then to now except that now some people can see the swear words instead of the "censored" icons...and, apparently some of the rules have changed.
 
i would not go so far as to throw the 'vast majority' under the lack of self control bus..

but I would tend to agree..there are several that have their issues..further, some that are wholly without merit.

and there's the rub...if we, each of us would self moderate..just enough..this modding thing would be a non starter..

(and secretly...just twixt you and I...i've long advocated for the ole heave ho for a handful of our..more colorful..denizens. but shh, don tell no one..)

As a person who has limited time to devote to this place, when entering here for the first time in several weeks/months, there does not seem to be much of any interest due to the incessant back and forth of the regular bitchsters stirring the shit amongst themselves.

Perhaps the place to start would be there - those who can't exercise self control should be the ones that get the attention of the moderators - who would impartially apply the rules and act accordingly.
 
time isnt necessarily a limiting factor... i'm sporadic...by and large.. at least i like to think so..

those who cannot exercise self control are precisely who are getting the attention.. some are conspicuously absent.. maybe more..
 
Yes, the moderator does have to be a judge. They have to, in fact, judge whether or not any given poster is acting within the appropriate guidelines of the forum...exactly what their decisions to give warnings, infractions etc. have to be based upon. Unless you are suggesting that their job is to hand out kudos or condemnation based on nothing other than their personal whim???

I disagree. Personally, I don't think that you really understand what moderators do. You understand what you think that they should be doing. You think that they should be impartial judges. You are entitled to your opinion. But I do not think that a "moderator" is simply a referee or rule enforcer. I doubt that we are going to agree on this point.

The Sandusky analogy is completely appropriate - if the fact is that the the place is moderated by one group of "moderators" who deal only with the posters of a similar mindset to their own and another group of "moderators" who only deal with the posters who are of their own similar mindset, then you have admitted that the place is not actually being moderated at all.

The Sandusky analogy IS insulting and inappropriate. None of the posters or the moderators engage in anything close to pedophilia. Even if I take the analogy as appropriate, you are saying that the moderators are incapable of dealing with fairly with their own members. I don't think that this is true either. A lot more goes on than simply - like a bureaucrat - handing out infractions on technicalities - which seems to be what you have in mind. Again, I think that this is simply a difference in how we view the appropriate role of a moderator. We just disagree. And I am as much a member of PJ as you are. Right? You don't speak for me. I don't speak for you.

I don't know Dave well enough to estimate anything other than what I did - that he seemed to be an impartial moderator.

Dave still administers the moderators. I suspect that Dave would tell you that the moderators make his job easier and that he does control things to insure that the moderators as a group are as impartial as he would be working by himself. Of course, I can't speak for Dave. This is my impression.

Yes, I know I could be a fair and reasonable moderator. However, I do not have the time to volunteer for the job because I actually have a job that I have to work because that's how I pay my bills - which is why I am not here very often. An absentee moderator wouldn't be any more useful than the current system. As I said, the moderator position isn't really all that hard. You have a set of rules, you apply the rules fairly and impartially to all and judge whether or not anyone has broken them, how often, how severely and what action may be appropriate when infractions arise. (The best way to get to that point, if the forum insists on having these lay moderators, is to reduce the position of moderator to a 2-4 week period and while moderating, moderators cannot join the open fray. Perhaps even make the position mandatory for those who log in consistent, regular hours.)

Believe it or not, all of these solutions have been discussed before. Some folks disagree with your view of what a moderator is or should do. The fact of the matter is is that - to have non-participating "referees" such as you envision - would almost surely require training and pay. If you want volunteers, you are going to have to have posters and improvise a system that is workable. You yourself won't volunteer. There are plenty of other posters like you who work and have to pay their bills. What makes you feel that most other folks don't work?

I've been here since Sept. 2011 and there does not seem to be any difference from then to now except that now some people can see the swear words instead of the "censored" icons...and, apparently some of the rules have changed.

I have been here since September 2011 as well and I do see a difference. Is it perfect? Far from it. Is it improved? In my opinion, yes.
 
time isnt necessarily a limiting factor... i'm sporadic...by and large.. at least i like to think so..

those who cannot exercise self control are precisely who are getting the attention.. some are conspicuously absent.. maybe more..

Time is necessary in order to actually be here to witness infractions...not to mention apply the penalty and deal with the inevitable protest etc. If you're sporadic as in "every other day", maybe that wouldn't be a detractor, but if you're sporadic in "once every 6-10 weeks", that's not quite so useful.

I see one person conspicuously absent as of the last time I was here - Gabriel. I believe 2 others have been banned since I started here in Sept. Joe Blam and some friend of his. I have noticed other people have left since I started, but I believe a lot of them left voluntarily because the place held little of value for them.

I'd just like to see this place become a good place to sit and chat with interesting people about interesting topics without having to deal with a lot of bullshit. It's not a problem to have one or two "village idiots" to liven up the place, but when the village is full of nothing but idiots, it starts to feel like time to move to a different village...
 
Seriously? Click on "Community" in the red menu at the top of the page and look at the top 10 "Likes Received" and "Thanks Received". Electing moderators by popular vote is a setup for epic fail.
 
I disagree. Personally, I don't think that you really understand what moderators do. You understand what you think that they should be doing. You think that they should be impartial judges. You are entitled to your opinion. But I do not think that a "moderator" is simply a referee or rule enforcer. I doubt that we are going to agree on this point.



The Sandusky analogy IS insulting and inappropriate. None of the posters or the moderators engage in anything close to pedophilia. Even if I take the analogy as appropriate, you are saying that the moderators are incapable of dealing with fairly with their own members. I don't think that this is true either. A lot more goes on than simply - like a bureaucrat - handing out infractions on technicalities - which seems to be what you have in mind. Again, I think that this is simply a difference in how we view the appropriate role of a moderator. We just disagree. And I am as much a member of PJ as you are. Right? You don't speak for me. I don't speak for you.



Dave still administers the moderators. I suspect that Dave would tell you that the moderators make his job easier and that he does control things to insure that the moderators as a group are as impartial as he would be working by himself. Of course, I can't speak for Dave. This is my impression.



Believe it or not, all of these solutions have been discussed before. Some folks disagree with your view of what a moderator is or should do. The fact of the matter is is that - to have non-participating "referees" such as you envision - would almost surely require training and pay. If you want volunteers, you are going to have to have posters and improvise a system that is workable. You yourself won't volunteer. There are plenty of other posters like you who work and have to pay their bills. What makes you feel that most other folks don't work?



I have been here since September 2011 as well and I do see a difference. Is it perfect? Far from it. Is it improved? In my opinion, yes.

Yes, I know you disagree, you can have the last word on the subject.

"What makes you feel that most other folks don't work?"

The sheer amount of posts/hours they log on the forum....either they are not working, as in they don't have jobs, or they are not working, as in they are at work and not doing what they are getting paid to do...

You can't post that many posts and actually have a job at which you are effectively applying yourself.
 
Back
Top