A moderator does not have to be a judge. I think that you are dead wrong. The Sandusky analogy is just plain insulting to all the moderators whether they are ROC or LOC.
I think that you underestimate Dave. BTW, do you think that YOU could be a fair and reasonable moderator?
I take it that you don't want to read back and forths between BRU and Nina. It sounds like you want both of them to be banned. I take it that you think that they both repeatedly what you understand to be the rules. Personally, I don't find it that inconvenient to avoid posts that I am not particularly interested in. I am mostly concerned with how folks interact with me. I find the general posting environment to be improved from what it was before the moderator system was established. Is it perfect? No. Is it improved? In my opinion, it is.
If I understand things correctly, moderators - for the most part - evaluate infraction reports from posters and occassionally take action if they notice stuff themselves. As I suggested above, I do think that the moderators have done some useful things.
[
You are certainly entitled to your opinion. I do not think that the moderating system is a joke or has been an abject failure. But that is just my POV.
Yes, the moderator does have to be a judge. They have to, in fact,
judge whether or not any given poster is acting within the appropriate guidelines of the forum...exactly what their decisions to give warnings, infractions etc.
have to be based upon. Unless you are suggesting that their job is to hand out kudos or condemnation based on nothing other than their personal whim???
The Sandusky analogy is completely appropriate - if the fact is that the the place is moderated by one group of "moderators" who deal only with the posters of a similar mindset to their own and another group of "moderators" who only deal with the posters who are of their own similar mindset, then you have admitted that the place is not actually being
moderated at all.
I don't know Dave well enough to estimate anything other than what I did - that he seemed to be an impartial moderator.
Yes, I know I could be a fair and reasonable moderator. However, I do not have the time to volunteer for the job because I actually have a job that I have to work because that's how I pay my bills - which is why I am not here very often. An absentee moderator wouldn't be any more useful than the current system. As I said, the moderator position isn't really all that hard. You have a set of rules, you apply the rules fairly and impartially to all and judge whether or not anyone has broken them, how often, how severely and what action may be appropriate when infractions arise. (The best way to get to that point, if the forum insists on having these lay moderators, is to reduce the position of moderator to a 2-4 week period and while moderating, moderators cannot join the open fray. Perhaps even make the position mandatory for those who log in consistent, regular hours.)
I've been here since Sept. 2011 and there does not seem to be any difference from then to now except that now some people can see the swear words instead of the "censored" icons...and, apparently some of the rules have changed.