1) Disagreed. I pointed out my disagreement. If you don't like my reasons, point out those.
Arkady's analogy was in post #46 in this thread. Since then, you have submitted SEVEN posts to the thread, numbering #47, #53, #54, #55, #57, #59, and #78.
In NONE of those did you explain your disagreement with Arkady's analogy. You simply say you disagree with it, but have not bothered to explain why. I am calling on you to do so. In fact, I am not even convinced that you bothered to READ Arkady's analogy. So here it is again:
Arkady: Here, maybe this will help you understand your error of reasoning. Imagine you're the parent of a ten-year-old who has been growing. However, he's been growing more slowly than the vast majority of first-world children in his age cohort, such that he's dwarfed by most of his contemporaries, and would look more at home in a crowd of second- or third-world kids, where poor nutrition is stunting growth generally. So, can we rule out the idea that your kid isn't getting good enough nutrition? Is the fact he's growing at all proof that his nutrition has been "adequate and effective"?
Hopefully that makes your illogic plain to you. Clearly, someone doesn't need to be shrinking for us to worry about nutrition. Even if he's growing, he could be doing a lot better if he were better nourished. In the same way, the US population can be getting smarter and better educated, while still falling short of our peers, due to problems with how education or other factors are being managed here. Right now, we're the equivalent of that kid who is a head shorter than nearly all his peers, despite having grown a bit. Only, in this case, the population groups are too large for genetics to be a good explanation for the difference.