New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

"Moscow's Calling" (The Clash)

london calling.gif

Moscow calling to the faraway towns
Now war is declared and battle come down

Moscow calling to the underworld
Come outta' the cupboard, ya' boys and girls

Moscow calling, now don't look to us
Harmony-mania has bitten the dust
Moscow calling, see we ain't got no swing
'Cept for the ring of that truncheon thing


“Knock knock”

“Who's there?”

“190,000 Russian troops. But don't worry. I promise not to invade. In fact, I've already started to withdraw some troops yesterday. Don't believe your satellite images. Sorry about that hole blasted in the Ukraine nursery school. But it wasn't me. I swear. They did it themselves to, frame us. And we didn't shoot down that airliner over Ukraine in 2015 either. It was either the USA, or the Ukranians themselves.”

“Are western stock market's yo yo-ing up and down violently yet? Sorry – that wasn't my intent. This is just a peaceful wargame. For 3 months in the middle of winter. And don't blame me that Ukrainian bank ATMs don't work, and the electricity is spotty. Perhaps Israel . . . or the Jews?”

“We don't want a war. But if it happens, it's on you. I warned you that you can't allow Ukraine to hold free elections or join NATO. I warned you many, many times. So this is on you. You've left me no choice.”

“All eyes on me. Russia is important. Anytime I want, I can shut off European gas pipelines. Hack into your banks and electrical grid. Assassinate people with deadly poisons and radioactive isotopes. Shut down your satellites. What have you got? Sanctions? We survived Hitler's
siege of Stalingrad. Two years without food. We ate our dogs and cats. Our dead. Lived without running water and electric power. No crops or harvests. Economic sanctions? Economic sanctions????”

“Better go check and see if your ATMs in London, NY, Berlin and Paris are working. And if your reservoirs are protected against contamination with poisons and isotopes?”

“If something happens, remember, you were warned, and you brought this on yourself. I didn't want to do this . . . “

Group discussion time: Is the current situation the fault of Russia or Europe? Is Trump or Biden more of a factor? Remember, Trump wanted to withdraw from NATO, and said it had no legitimate purpose now that Europe was at peace. But Biden promised not to defend Ukraine militarily within the first 15 minutes of Putin's threats. How can this be set on a course to end well. Post your suggestions below:
 
Group discussion time: Is the current situation the fault of Russia or Europe? Is Trump or Biden more of a factor? Remember, Trump wanted to withdraw from NATO, and said it had no legitimate purpose now that Europe was at peace. But Biden promised not to defend Ukraine militarily within the first 15 minutes of Putin's threats. How can this be set on a course to end well. Post your suggestions below:

You posed some very interesting questions... along with some statements from Trump and Biden.
There's just too much to be considered to have an easy answer for any of them, from my admittedly limited knowledge.
Those involved with the decision making sure have lots to consider, their ultimate decisions will be history making, There's little doubt about that.
I just finished a very interesting take on it by Fred Kaplan.
_______________________________________
George W. Bush Carries Some Blame for the Current Conflict With Putin
.
 
View attachment 68856

Moscow calling to the faraway towns
Now war is declared and battle come down

Moscow calling to the underworld
Come outta' the cupboard, ya' boys and girls

Moscow calling, now don't look to us
Harmony-mania has bitten the dust
Moscow calling, see we ain't got no swing
'Cept for the ring of that truncheon thing


“Knock knock”

“Who's there?”

“190,000 Russian troops. But don't worry. I promise not to invade. In fact, I've already started to withdraw some troops yesterday. Don't believe your satellite images. Sorry about that hole blasted in the Ukraine nursery school. But it wasn't me. I swear. They did it themselves to, frame us. And we didn't shoot down that airliner over Ukraine in 2015 either. It was either the USA, or the Ukranians themselves.”

“Are western stock market's yo yo-ing up and down violently yet? Sorry – that wasn't my intent. This is just a peaceful wargame. For 3 months in the middle of winter. And don't blame me that Ukrainian bank ATMs don't work, and the electricity is spotty. Perhaps Israel . . . or the Jews?”

“We don't want a war. But if it happens, it's on you. I warned you that you can't allow Ukraine to hold free elections or join NATO. I warned you many, many times. So this is on you. You've left me no choice.”

“All eyes on me. Russia is important. Anytime I want, I can shut off European gas pipelines. Hack into your banks and electrical grid. Assassinate people with deadly poisons and radioactive isotopes. Shut down your satellites. What have you got? Sanctions? We survived Hitler's
siege of Stalingrad. Two years without food. We ate our dogs and cats. Our dead. Lived without running water and electric power. No crops or harvests. Economic sanctions? Economic sanctions????”

“Better go check and see if your ATMs in London, NY, Berlin and Paris are working. And if your reservoirs are protected against contamination with poisons and isotopes?”

“If something happens, remember, you were warned, and you brought this on yourself. I didn't want to do this . . . “

Group discussion time: Is the current situation the fault of Russia or Europe? Is Trump or Biden more of a factor? Remember, Trump wanted to withdraw from NATO, and said it had no legitimate purpose now that Europe was at peace. But Biden promised not to defend Ukraine militarily within the first 15 minutes of Putin's threats. How can this be set on a course to end well. Post your suggestions below:

Moskva

I Live by the river!

Group Therapy

Russia v Europe: Russia

Trump v Biden: Trump would negotiate a deal...Biden can't. 1. Biden can't negotiate, no skills. 2. The Biden's got paid from both sides and if he interferes, the truth comes out. Biden becomes non a factor.

Suggestion: Get Trump to negotiate on behalf of Biden admin.
 
You posed some very interesting questions... along with some statements from Trump and Biden.
There's just too much to be considered to have an easy answer for any of them, from my admittedly limited knowledge.
Those involved with the decision making sure have lots to consider, their ultimate decisions will be history making, There's little doubt about that.
I just finished a very interesting take on it by Fred Kaplan.
_______________________________________
George W. Bush Carries Some Blame for the Current Conflict With Putin
.
Leaves us with three questions:

1. What was Kaplan's summation? Science, climate change?

2. Does it matters who to blame outside of Russia or the Ukraine, and does putting blame on Bush fix this?

3. What will Biden do?
 
Moskva

I Live by the river!

Group Therapy

Russia v Europe: Russia

Trump v Biden: Trump would negotiate a deal...Biden can't. 1. Biden can't negotiate, no skills. 2. The Biden's got paid from both sides and if he interferes, the truth comes out. Biden becomes non a factor.

Suggestion: Get Trump to negotiate on behalf of Biden admin.

This is wag the dog stuff. Ukraine makes rockets and has Uranium reserves. They should nuke up and MAD with Russia.

 
Your post correctly puts the onus on Putin.
Your first discussion question negates that. I wonder why.
i think Putin's various public utterances put the onus on him. My question is, should Europe have approached this differently, right from the start? Or is the path they followed, to this violent confrontation, the best of all their possible choices?
 
Moskva

I Live by the river!

Group Therapy

Russia v Europe: Russia

Trump v Biden: Trump would negotiate a deal...Biden can't. 1. Biden can't negotiate, no skills. 2. The Biden's got paid from both sides and if he interferes, the truth comes out. Biden becomes non a factor.

Suggestion: Get Trump to negotiate on behalf of Biden admin.
I tend to agree that Trump would claim he could negotiate a deal, and attempt to. But the actual question is: Do Trump and Europe bear any responsibility for either making NATO seem irrelevant, or failing to admit nations seeking membership? Let's also roll back the clock, to a couple of years before the 2016 trump election. What role does Obama play for his response to Russia's shootdown of the airliner over Ukrainian airspace. Is that "measured restraint"? Or pusillanimous?
 
Moskva

I Live by the river!

Group Therapy

Russia v Europe: Russia

Trump v Biden: Trump would negotiate a deal...Biden can't. 1. Biden can't negotiate, no skills. 2. The Biden's got paid from both sides and if he interferes, the truth comes out. Biden becomes non a factor.

Suggestion: Get Trump to negotiate on behalf of Biden admin.
I suspect if Trump had been re-elected, his neogtiating position might be: "Okay - we agree to prohibit Ukraine ajpplication for membership in NATO. And we won't mobilize NATO troops to counter the 190,000 Russian soldiers on Ukraine's border."

Does this actually prevent a tragedy, either now or in the future?
 
President Brandon has predicted five of the past zero Russian invasions.
Me too. I was convinced it would have happened by now.

However, a deep dive reveals that both Pentagon and CIA intelligence officials have a theory: Russia's professional military people are convinced it will take more troops to invade Ukraine than they originally mustered at the border in 2021. And they're not so keen on an invasion anyway. This could be lose-lose, career wise, for those generals.

A Russian military victory with horrific civilian casualties condemns them to history as butchers, leading to international travel restrictions, seizure of personal foreign assets (homes in London, Florida, etc., , and a miserable life for their kids in any free, post-Putin Russia. Alternatively, A Russian loss condemns them to the wrath of Putin. Thus, the ongoing calls by Russian generals for ever increasing invasion for size, in the hopes of forestalling that fork in the road.

Professional Military officers may not have broad knowledge, or enlightened souls, but they ARE well tutored on military history. The lessons of Stalingrad, D-day, and even Flanders Field during World War 1 would have been taught in every "War college" on both sides of the Iron Curtain.
 
You posed some very interesting questions... along with some statements from Trump and Biden.
There's just too much to be considered to have an easy answer for any of them, from my admittedly limited knowledge.
Those involved with the decision making sure have lots to consider, their ultimate decisions will be history making, There's little doubt about that.
I just finished a very interesting take on it by Fred Kaplan.
_______________________________________
George W. Bush Carries Some Blame for the Current Conflict With Putin
.
I get a 404 page when i click on your link. To the extent that a weak NATO and American Military failures count, I think there is blame enough to go around not only for the last 2 presidents, but Obama, Bush W, Clinton, Bush HW, LBJ, and Nixon. The only ones who might get off scott free are Reagan, JFK, Eisenhower, and Truman.
 
1. What was Kaplan's summation? Science, climate change?

None of those.

2. Does it matters who to blame outside of Russia or the Ukraine, and does putting blame on Bush fix this?

Yes, to some degree, it possibly gives some insight to what Putin has probably been thinking for a long time... Russia was screwed over.
________________________________________________________
However, there’s no question, Russia did get screwed over, and it’s perfectly reasonable to convene a summit to discuss and deal with Russia’s legitimate security interests. Bush’s Bucharest declaration was a huge mistake. George Kennan, the architect of America’s Cold War policy of the 1940s and ’50s, called NATO’s expansion “the most fateful error of American policy in the entire post-cold-war era.”

The Russian statement is also right that, just as the Charter for European Security enshrines the right of states “to freely choose or change the methods of ensuring their security, including union treaties,” it also forbids states to strengthen their position “at the expense of the security of other states.” The U.S. cites the first clause to justify allowing Ukraine to join NATO, at least in principle. Russia cites the second clause to justify its desire to forbid Ukraine from doing so. There must be a way to satisfy both positions on this score—especially since, as President Joe Biden and every other Western leader has said (and as even Zelensky is beginning to absorb), Ukraine, as a practical matter, is not going to be allowed into NATO in the foreseeable future.
snip
At that point, some leaders—even some Kremlin leaders in the past—would have looked for a face-saving way out. For a while Putin seemed to be following that course; he may do so still. At the moment, though, it seems he’s incapable of backing down; he may view doing so as an act of egregious weakness.

This crisis has unfolded as a complex mosaic of moves and countermoves, feints and bluffs, lunges and parries of counterintelligence and disinformation. (Future students of crisis management and game theory will have fertile ground for dissertations.) But fancy moves can spawn miscalculation; bluffs, if challenged, can harden into action.

Meanwhile, all of us—the players and the spectators—are in the same unsettling spot that we’ve been in since this crisis got underway: waiting, speculating, but having, really, no idea what happens next.

3. What will Biden do?
I have no idea what Biden will do.
But my thoughts are similar to Kaplan's. Give Putin an off ramp... proving Biden wrong -- by not invading Ukraine after all the declarations by Biden of an invasion being imminent.
George W. Bush carries blame for the current U.S. conflict with Putin. (slate.com)

____________________________
 
I get a 404 page when i click on your link. To the extent that a weak NATO and American Military failures count, I think there is blame enough to go around not only for the last 2 presidents, but Obama, Bush W, Clinton, Bush HW, LBJ, and Nixon. The only ones who might get off scott free are Reagan, JFK, Eisenhower, and Truman.

Sorry, the link didn't work.
I will try it again.

George W. Bush carries blame for the current U.S. conflict with Putin. (slate.com)
 
Moskva

I Live by the river!

Group Therapy

Russia v Europe: Russia

Trump v Biden: Trump would negotiate a deal...Biden can't. 1. Biden can't negotiate, no skills. 2. The Biden's got paid from both sides and if he interferes, the truth comes out. Biden becomes non a factor.

Suggestion: Get Trump to negotiate on behalf of Biden admin.
like the great deal he negoiated with the taliban? The US will quit providing support for the Afghan army...withdraw all but a few troops...release 5,000 POWs and kiss your ass. You can kill all the Afghan soldiers you want and assassinate government leaders.
Deal?
 
i think Putin's various public utterances put the onus on him. My question is, should Europe have approached this differently, right from the start? Or is the path they followed, to this violent confrontation, the best of all their possible choices?
What do you think Europe should have done?
Remember how Trump trashed NATO? Who knew he was doing it for Putin?
Biden rallied western democracies, NATO members to unite and stand against Putin's threat to democracies. What Putin is doing hasn't been done since 1939. Let's not forget that Putin has been using disinformation campaigns, cyber attacks to interfere in western democracy elections, their stability.
We can't sit back and do nothing. Calling out Putin's actions for the whole world to see is number 1. Next is threatening and imposing harsh sanctions.
 
Me too. I was convinced it would have happened by now.

However, a deep dive reveals that both Pentagon and CIA intelligence officials have a theory: Russia's professional military people are convinced it will take more troops to invade Ukraine than they originally mustered at the border in 2021. And they're not so keen on an invasion anyway. This could be lose-lose, career wise, for those generals.

A Russian military victory with horrific civilian casualties condemns them to history as butchers, leading to international travel restrictions, seizure of personal foreign assets (homes in London, Florida, etc., , and a miserable life for their kids in any free, post-Putin Russia. Alternatively, A Russian loss condemns them to the wrath of Putin. Thus, the ongoing calls by Russian generals for ever increasing invasion for size, in the hopes of forestalling that fork in the road.

Professional Military officers may not have broad knowledge, or enlightened souls, but they ARE well tutored on military history. The lessons of Stalingrad, D-day, and even Flanders Field during World War 1 would have been taught in every "War college" on both sides of the Iron Curtain.

I have a "theory" too - Putin is punking Brandon to make him look foolish and taking advantage of his incompetence to run up the price of oil. Putin may be ruthless and a killer, but he is not a dope (like Brandon).
 
Back
Top