New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

My solution and a proposal for the Republicans.

Since rewarding people for good behavior works better than punishing them for bad behavior......

Instead of a tax or a penalty on people who can afford to buy their health insurance but don't, why not a tax credit for people who do buy their own health insurance.

In other words, if you currently don't buy health insurance you would be encouraged to do so, as you could write the cost of insurance off of you total tax bill.

If you didn't, you wouldn't get the tax credit.

That way, liberty is preserved.....but wait, THE DAMN GOVERNMENT WOULD BE OUT THE MONEY.

Proving, once again Commie Care is not about improving health care or lowering costs, it's about feeding the Leviathan.
 
NOT A CHANCE IN HELL, Sarge:

Look at what you are suggesting here: LESS money, power and authority going to the FEDZI's in the Imperial Capital, instead, flowing BACK to "the people...."

NOT A CHANCE IN HELL.

At least not until the FEDZI's in Washington once again "fear" the people.

They don't even RESPECT the people......
 
I would be curious why someone would object to people getting tax credits for buying health insurance. If the choice comes down to mandate vs incentive, why not look to the latter?
 
You know, you really need to see someone for that disorder.

So, what is your plan for your own personal financial success, other than having someone else pay for the cost of your existence?
 
It's a distinction without a difference. If you give a tax credit to those who buy insurance, you lower revenues (and thus boost deficits). So, if you want to keep tax revenues constant, then you have to hike tax rates to offset the creation of that credit. If you hike tax rates and then give most people a credit equal to the size of their hike, while only those who don't buy insurance actually pay at the new, higher effective rate, then it's functionally identical to keeping the tax rate constant and making those who don't buy insurance pay a penalty. Your solution effectively just disguises a penalty for not insuring yourself as a reward for insuring yourself.
 
It would be a useful way to confuse the stupid, but it makes no appreciable real-world difference. If you create a tax credit in a REVENUE NEUTRAL WAY, so as not to increase deficits, you need to hike taxes elsewhere. For example, you could adjust the overall tax formula so that everyone pays $5000 extra, then give a $5000 tax credit to everyone who buys his own insurance. But that would be identical in effect to not adjusting the tax formula and just imposing a $5000 penalty on those who don't buy insurance. Nothing's gained by calling it one thing and not the other, when the real-world impact is identical. The only way the real-world situation is changed is if you use it as an excuse for lowering overall revenues, and thus raising deficits. But since increased deficits are, in effect, increased future taxes (we owe that money sooner or later), you're still basically raising everyone's taxes and then lowering some people's enough to offset that, such that you may as well just have penalized the remainder.
 
If you give a tax credit to those who buy insurance, you lower revenues (and thus boost deficits).

Now wait a dern minute. Is this about Health Care or raising revenues? We have been told that the people who can buy insurance but don't are forcing all of us other people to pay their bills. This solves the problem and preserves liberty.

In addition all of the individuals that would be encouraged to purchase insurance would increase competition, result in more products being offered (Commie care orders companies what they can and can't cover).

AND it would leave health care in the hands of the individual and his doctor, not a huge government bureaucracy.


Unfortunately, Soviet Care has been tried before (how come liberals NEVER learn from history) and we know how it works.

Want to raise the cost of something, reduce the quality and availability, let government run it.....that is proven fact. Medicare, Medicaid...broke in 4 years.
 
If you choose a tax credit instead of a tax penalty, to encourage people to buy insurance, all you do is lower revenues. Lower revenues and you raise deficits. Raise deficits and you raise future taxes (when we eventually get around to paying that debt). So, in effect, you're raising everyone's long-term taxes and then offsetting that by lowering the current taxes of those who buy insurance. That's roughly equivalent to just keeping the taxes the same on those who insure themselves and penalizing those who don't. Is anyone stupid enough not to see through that?

Of course, you could counter that we should lower spending, to offset for the lower tax revenues, so that it doesn't have a deficit impact. But spending is a different question entirely, and it just muddies the waters to draw it into this discussion. Regardless of whether we raise or lower spending, the revenue-side question is the same. It makes no honest difference in whether we frame the encouragement to buy insurance as an incentive for those who do so or a penalty for those who don't. That's just window dressing.
 
This doesn't solve any problem. It just hides the ball on those too dumb to think it through. Look, I have no particular problem with the idea, even if it is a little silly. If people are dumb enough to fall for it, so be it. Anyone too stupid to see you've just created a disguised penalty deserves to be penalized. But I'd want it done in a revenue-neutral way. We already have ultra-low taxes and very high deficits, and I'm not interested in something that would raise deficits even higher by lowering effective tax rates even lower.
 
HAHAHAHAHAH...it is about the FEDZI's amassing more power, more wealth, and, more authority, centered in the Imperial Capital!

Nothing more (Although, I have no doubt that "more" is comming, if America re-elects Premier Hussein), nothing less....
 
If you choose a tax credit instead of a tax penalty, to encourage people to buy insurance, all you do is lower revenues.

Boy you sure do seem worried about the poor starving US Government.

I want to deball the US government. I want to get rid of at least 50% of the damn bureaucrats. I want to take away their power over the individual, I want to get back to a government that protects liberty, property rights and leaves us the hell alone.

They're in every damn room of my house from my bathroom to my light sockets. I have to buy their crappy mandated fuel mixture that has about as much energy as tomato juice, destroys engines, gives less mileage.

I want to go back to 110 Octane Sunoco 270 and engines with 12 to one compression. I want to be able to cut down a damn tree on my property without getting government approval. (I recently won an EPA Lawsuit against me and I'm still waiting for them to reimburse my legal fees) I want 'em to quit flying drones over private property. I want to PRIVATIZE EVERYTHING THAT CAN BE PRIVATIZED from education to social security to medicare.

If the government wants to f*uck with someone, let 'em go after the screwballs that took over Egypt and Lybia rather than giving them our money.

Give em' something to do that keeps 'em out of my hair.

And lastly I want to kick Obama's skinny ass all the way back to Kenya; Chicago ain't far enough to suit me.
 
Work hard, create wealth for my employer, retire at 65. Oh, and 20% to my 401(k).

Well, if you object to that system you could always start a business and become an employer. That is if you can get passed the regulations from OSHA, The ADA, the EPA etc. and could afford to pay for your share of your employee's payroll taxes, your share of his unemployment compensation insurance, disability insurance. workman's compensation insurance, along with your income taxes, business taxes, state and local property taxes, your utilities, your liability insurance.

I did for 25 years. It's a lot harder now.
 
It just hides the ball on those too dumb to think it through.

The definition of dumb is an Obama supporter who thinks he's in line for some free government cheese when he's really in line for Obama's gas chamber.
 
Not many are cut out to be the boss. Even fewer are cut out to be their own boss. My work, my job doesn't define my life, it's just a means to continue paying for it.
 
thats what happens when you dont study hard and have to buy a job for yourself. how is the lawn mowing business doing btw??
 
Back
Top