New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Natural ability versus effort.

Arkady

President
Back in the 1990s there was a book by a couple conservative writers, called "The Bell Curve" that argued that intelligence is an overwhelming factor in life outcomes -- that those with high IQs were a cognitive elite who would have a much greater likelihood of socioeconomic success, while those with low IQs would be all but doomed to failure.

The argument was incredibly controversial -- partly because of shortcomings in their data and analysis, but mostly because of the political implications. Conservatives tended to like the argument, since it could be used to make a case against a generous welfare state and affirmative action (efforts that were largely wasted if the underclass was just dumb) and also against immigration from poor nations (which would be expected to bring down average IQ here). Liberals tended to hate the argument for those same reasons, but also because it lent itself to racism and eugenics.

For a while, it was a really popular book among some conservatives, but gradually the conservative movement abandoned that line of analysis. Not only was it hard to keep coming to the defense of a book that had some pretty glaring analytical problems, it was also politically difficult, in that it didn't chime well with a conservative political strategy of writing off liberals as elitist egg-heads, while conservatives were the salt of the earth. When that's your strategy, you don't want to highlight the work of some right-wing academics that insists on the importance of intelligence. Plus, ultimately, the way the book ran afoul of the taboo about talking about race and hereditary intelligence was just too much for polite conservatism.

Although I was a critic of the book, myself, I had hoped it would be an entry point into deeper and more accurate analysis of the role of intelligence in socioeconomic life. So, I'm disappointed that it was instead effectively shelved, and that whole field neglected for decades. I think there are important questions there that we should try to understand if we're going to craft good public policies.

Just to give a practical example, is a country better educating its children to develop generalized intelligence, leaving any specialization for adulthood? Or is it better identifying natural talents earlier, with greater specialization (as is common in many other countries, where there's earlier identification of professional/academic track and vocational track)? If you think that IQ (or various types of IQ, if you prefer) isn't much of a factor, and that basically anyone can be great at basically anything, and that effort is nearly all the story, there's value to delaying specialization. The longer you can delay, the more people can be exposed to lots of stuff and have the best chance of finding where their passion really lies, and that will let them have the most emotional energy for the kind of effort that will make them great. If, on the other hand, IQ (or a specific type of IQ) is a very large consideration, then you may be wasting your time giving someone a lot of education into an area he's never going to be good at, when early testing could identify his area of natural strength, for better overall returns.

That's just one example. It's hard to say all the interesting things we could learn, with serious policy implications, if we moved beyond that political taboo about discussing hereditary intelligence. I believe in the value of knowledge, and the taboo is preventing us from learning.

Anyway, here is a piece discussing the political taboo around discussing intelligence:

http://dwightmurphey-collectedwritings.info/A57-BellCrve.htm

And here's a discussion of the science of trying to assess the relative value of natural ability and hard work in the formation of expertise:

http://www.salon.com/2015/04/22/scr...oard_game_teaches_us_about_expertise_partner/

I assume we all believe that expertise is a combination of both factors. But I, for one, think that the mainstream view puts too much emphasis on work, relative to natural ability. The mainstream view is along the lines of the Malcolm Gladwell idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make anyone into a master of just about anything -- he'd argue that when you find greatness, like the music of the Beatles, it's mostly just a matter of such people having practiced more than others. But I know, from my own experience, that natural ability is the predominant factor.

I can do some mental things, effortlessly, that other people couldn't do with a lifetime of practice. For example, in law school, I could avoid going to classes all semester, pick up the textbook the night before the exam, speed read it for several hours, then do great on the test. I have the kind of brain that just soaks up that kind of information easily.... and retains it for decades. With ten hours of reading I'd retained more than most people would with a hundred hours of serious study. T o this day, I wow fellow lawyers with specific recollection of the contents of various cases we all read in law school but that I actually retained after my quick read and they forgot after their long laborious study. But, on the flip side, I'm completely middling with learning languages, and actually quite poor at learning music. I could plug away for 10,000 hours at the piano and get to the point where I have basic competence, but I'm never going to be good at it, because I'm not wired for it. And there are people who, with just 500 hours of effort, could be better than me with 10,000. I'm as developmentally disabled with music as I am gifted with some other things, and that winds up being a much bigger factor than effort, for me.
 
Back in the 1990s there was a book by a couple conservative writers, called "The Bell Curve" that argued that intelligence is an overwhelming factor in life outcomes -- that those with high IQs were a cognitive elite who would have a much greater likelihood of socioeconomic success, while those with low IQs would be all but doomed to failure.

The argument was incredibly controversial -- partly because of shortcomings in their data and analysis, but mostly because of the political implications. Conservatives tended to like the argument, since it could be used to make a case against a generous welfare state and affirmative action (efforts that were largely wasted if the underclass was just dumb) and also against immigration from poor nations (which would be expected to bring down average IQ here). Liberals tended to hate the argument for those same reasons, but also because it lent itself to racism and eugenics.

For a while, it was a really popular book among some conservatives, but gradually the conservative movement abandoned that line of analysis. Not only was it hard to keep coming to the defense of a book that had some pretty glaring analytical problems, it was also politically difficult, in that it didn't chime well with a conservative political strategy of writing off liberals as elitist egg-heads, while conservatives were the salt of the earth. When that's your strategy, you don't want to highlight the work of some right-wing academics that insists on the importance of intelligence. Plus, ultimately, the way the book ran afoul of the taboo about talking about race and hereditary intelligence was just too much for polite conservatism.

Although I was a critic of the book, myself, I had hoped it would be an entry point into deeper and more accurate analysis of the role of intelligence in socioeconomic life. So, I'm disappointed that it was instead effectively shelved, and that whole field neglected for decades. I think there are important questions there that we should try to understand if we're going to craft good public policies.

Just to give a practical example, is a country better educating its children to develop generalized intelligence, leaving any specialization for adulthood? Or is it better identifying natural talents earlier, with greater specialization (as is common in many other countries, where there's earlier identification of professional/academic track and vocational track)? If you think that IQ (or various types of IQ, if you prefer) isn't much of a factor, and that basically anyone can be great at basically anything, and that effort is nearly all the story, there's value to delaying specialization. The longer you can delay, the more people can be exposed to lots of stuff and have the best chance of finding where their passion really lies, and that will let them have the most emotional energy for the kind of effort that will make them great. If, on the other hand, IQ (or a specific type of IQ) is a very large consideration, then you may be wasting your time giving someone a lot of education into an area he's never going to be good at, when early testing could identify his area of natural strength, for better overall returns.

That's just one example. It's hard to say all the interesting things we could learn, with serious policy implications, if we moved beyond that political taboo about discussing hereditary intelligence. I believe in the value of knowledge, and the taboo is preventing us from learning.

Anyway, here is a piece discussing the political taboo around discussing intelligence:

http://dwightmurphey-collectedwritings.info/A57-BellCrve.htm

And here's a discussion of the science of trying to assess the relative value of natural ability and hard work in the formation of expertise:

http://www.salon.com/2015/04/22/scr...oard_game_teaches_us_about_expertise_partner/

I assume we all believe that expertise is a combination of both factors. But I, for one, think that the mainstream view puts too much emphasis on work, relative to natural ability. The mainstream view is along the lines of the Malcolm Gladwell idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make anyone into a master of just about anything -- he'd argue that when you find greatness, like the music of the Beatles, it's mostly just a matter of such people having practiced more than others. But I know, from my own experience, that natural ability is the predominant factor.

I can do some mental things, effortlessly, that other people couldn't do with a lifetime of practice. For example, in law school, I could avoid going to classes all semester, pick up the textbook the night before the exam, speed read it for several hours, then do great on the test. I have the kind of brain that just soaks up that kind of information easily.... and retains it for decades. With ten hours of reading I'd retained more than most people would with a hundred hours of serious study. T o this day, I wow fellow lawyers with specific recollection of the contents of various cases we all read in law school but that I actually retained after my quick read and they forgot after their long laborious study. But, on the flip side, I'm completely middling with learning languages, and actually quite poor at learning music. I could plug away for 10,000 hours at the piano and get to the point where I have basic competence, but I'm never going to be good at it, because I'm not wired for it. And there are people who, with just 500 hours of effort, could be better than me with 10,000. I'm as developmentally disabled with music as I am gifted with some other things, and that winds up being a much bigger factor than effort, for me.

My old art teacher was more succinct so many years ago. He said that anybody could be taught to draw but they couldn't be taught to be an artist.
 
a most interesting subject. I believe there are significant differences between the races. Asian students are very good and very hard to compete with, I believe they have a genetic advantage. I believe there are some real differences between the sexes. Men's IQ span a wider range than does women, women have a narrower ban which means there are more dumb men than women and more smart men at the top than women.
There are genetic differences and I believe there are big differences caused by nutrition. If the brain isn't fed well in the early years it will never develop well.
I think hard work can really carry people a long way. I have had PhD MIT engineers work for me that didn't know how to tie their shews, yet had people self taught that could run circles around the PhD people.
There are numerous reasons why people are like they are. I was thought as being very slow in grade school because I couldn't read. I learned late in High school I was dyslexic and did things to overcome this. Within 2 years I went from being a below average student to blowing the doors off national tests and college entrance tests. I received letters from the Governor congratulating me on being in the top 1/2 of the top 1% in my scores. My condition if not spotted and given the proper attention would have probably prevented me from being an Engineer. There are many people with these type of things that make things different for them.

In general, I managed very large groups of people and the 80/20 rule was true. Twenty percent of the work force does 80% of the work, the 80% filled in the remaining 20% of the work. The key to success was finding those 20% of the work force and working to make sure they are happy and taken care of. What surprised me is how often they guy that struggled to get through school was in that top 20%. Some people are book smart and then there are the few that just grasp everything. look in the eyes!
 
a most interesting subject. I believe there are significant differences between the races. Asian students are very good and very hard to compete with, I believe they have a genetic advantage. I believe there are some real differences between the sexes. Men's IQ span a wider range than does women, women have a narrower ban which means there are more dumb men than women and more smart men at the top than women.
There are genetic differences and I believe there are big differences caused by nutrition. If the brain isn't fed well in the early years it will never develop well.
I think hard work can really carry people a long way. I have had PhD MIT engineers work for me that didn't know how to tie their shews, yet had people self taught that could run circles around the PhD people.
There are numerous reasons why people are like they are. I was thought as being very slow in grade school because I couldn't read. I learned late in High school I was dyslexic and did things to overcome this. Within 2 years I went from being a below average student to blowing the doors off national tests and college entrance tests. I received letters from the Governor congratulating me on being in the top 1/2 of the top 1% in my scores. My condition if not spotted and given the proper attention would have probably prevented me from being an Engineer. There are many people with these type of things that make things different for them.

In general, I managed very large groups of people and the 80/20 rule was true. Twenty percent of the work force does 80% of the work, the 80% filled in the remaining 20% of the work. The key to success was finding those 20% of the work force and working to make sure they are happy and taken care of. What surprised me is how often they guy that struggled to get through school was in that top 20%. Some people are book smart and then there are the few that just grasp everything. look in the eyes!
The greater IQ span among men could be due to less genetic material. The Y chromosome is much smaller than the X. With less overall code, any given gene has a bigger potential impact, in terms of percentage. So, the bell curve for women would be expected to be thicker in the middle, for height, weight, athletic prowess, natural music talent, IQ, and other multi-factor genetic outcomes.
 

In reference to your comment about diet, you are exactly right. Back in the mid 70's there was a professor at ODU who was in her 80's and pretty much allowed to do whatever she wanted. She took a group of grade schoolers who performed very poorly and came from poor families who were not able or inclined to provide good nutrition. She worked with those kids for 6 months providing proper nutrition for them. After 6 months their average IQ had increased by 10 points. I was impressed.

As for your comments about self taught people I very much agree with those also. One of my fastener customers for 20 years was a man who invented the self loading tow trucks that have become the norm today. I was in his office the day he got the patent on them and I provided most of the fasteners that were used during those years of development of the different types.

It was only after he died that I learned that along with designing those self loaders, he had also built 58 airplanes in his life. I also learned that he had only gone through 5th grade in school.

The following link will show you the type of trucks I'm talking about. FTR he didn't build the trucks themselves. He bought those in and modified them.

Wreckers - Dynamic Towing Equipment & Mfg
 
here's what I think . ..

the "mainstream" view doesn't pay enough attention to drug use, the perverse incentives of generations on welfare, crappy public schools with high dropout rates . . .

we may not all be capable of achieiving IQ scores like Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, Carly Fiorina, or Paul Allen.

But its fair to expect people to do their best, at least finish high school, and not wander through life in a drug induced stupor, even if some people are claiming that pot is some sort of "essential medicine" . . .
 
Back in the 1990s there was a book by a couple conservative writers, called "The Bell Curve" that argued that intelligence is an overwhelming factor in life outcomes -- that those with high IQs were a cognitive elite who would have a much greater likelihood of socioeconomic success, while those with low IQs would be all but doomed to failure.

The argument was incredibly controversial -- partly because of shortcomings in their data and analysis, but mostly because of the political implications. Conservatives tended to like the argument, since it could be used to make a case against a generous welfare state and affirmative action (efforts that were largely wasted if the underclass was just dumb) and also against immigration from poor nations (which would be expected to bring down average IQ here). Liberals tended to hate the argument for those same reasons, but also because it lent itself to racism and eugenics.

For a while, it was a really popular book among some conservatives, but gradually the conservative movement abandoned that line of analysis. Not only was it hard to keep coming to the defense of a book that had some pretty glaring analytical problems, it was also politically difficult, in that it didn't chime well with a conservative political strategy of writing off liberals as elitist egg-heads, while conservatives were the salt of the earth. When that's your strategy, you don't want to highlight the work of some right-wing academics that insists on the importance of intelligence. Plus, ultimately, the way the book ran afoul of the taboo about talking about race and hereditary intelligence was just too much for polite conservatism.

Although I was a critic of the book, myself, I had hoped it would be an entry point into deeper and more accurate analysis of the role of intelligence in socioeconomic life. So, I'm disappointed that it was instead effectively shelved, and that whole field neglected for decades. I think there are important questions there that we should try to understand if we're going to craft good public policies.

Just to give a practical example, is a country better educating its children to develop generalized intelligence, leaving any specialization for adulthood? Or is it better identifying natural talents earlier, with greater specialization (as is common in many other countries, where there's earlier identification of professional/academic track and vocational track)? If you think that IQ (or various types of IQ, if you prefer) isn't much of a factor, and that basically anyone can be great at basically anything, and that effort is nearly all the story, there's value to delaying specialization. The longer you can delay, the more people can be exposed to lots of stuff and have the best chance of finding where their passion really lies, and that will let them have the most emotional energy for the kind of effort that will make them great. If, on the other hand, IQ (or a specific type of IQ) is a very large consideration, then you may be wasting your time giving someone a lot of education into an area he's never going to be good at, when early testing could identify his area of natural strength, for better overall returns.

That's just one example. It's hard to say all the interesting things we could learn, with serious policy implications, if we moved beyond that political taboo about discussing hereditary intelligence. I believe in the value of knowledge, and the taboo is preventing us from learning.

Anyway, here is a piece discussing the political taboo around discussing intelligence:

http://dwightmurphey-collectedwritings.info/A57-BellCrve.htm

And here's a discussion of the science of trying to assess the relative value of natural ability and hard work in the formation of expertise:

http://www.salon.com/2015/04/22/scr...oard_game_teaches_us_about_expertise_partner/

I assume we all believe that expertise is a combination of both factors. But I, for one, think that the mainstream view puts too much emphasis on work, relative to natural ability. The mainstream view is along the lines of the Malcolm Gladwell idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make anyone into a master of just about anything -- he'd argue that when you find greatness, like the music of the Beatles, it's mostly just a matter of such people having practiced more than others. But I know, from my own experience, that natural ability is the predominant factor.

I can do some mental things, effortlessly, that other people couldn't do with a lifetime of practice. For example, in law school, I could avoid going to classes all semester, pick up the textbook the night before the exam, speed read it for several hours, then do great on the test. I have the kind of brain that just soaks up that kind of information easily.... and retains it for decades. With ten hours of reading I'd retained more than most people would with a hundred hours of serious study. T o this day, I wow fellow lawyers with specific recollection of the contents of various cases we all read in law school but that I actually retained after my quick read and they forgot after their long laborious study. But, on the flip side, I'm completely middling with learning languages, and actually quite poor at learning music. I could plug away for 10,000 hours at the piano and get to the point where I have basic competence, but I'm never going to be good at it, because I'm not wired for it. And there are people who, with just 500 hours of effort, could be better than me with 10,000. I'm as developmentally disabled with music as I am gifted with some other things, and that winds up being a much bigger factor than effort, for me.

I have known some seriously brilliant people who lacked any common sense nor were they able to find a way to use their brilliance in a positive way. As such they are not even remotely successful.

So, I don't think inteligence necessarily determines "success". And, I ALSO think that despite best efforts intelligence tests are skewed to "book learning" and traditional learning experiences. I know years ago when they tested inner city kids - they scored lowere than their white counterparts. But they were judging the kids by standards that seemed familiar to white people but not black people in those situations. Like they showed a picture of a man with a briefcase - which in the 60's and the kids didn't know what he would be because they didn't every see that guy. They weren't dumb. But their experiences and learning opportunities were not the same. So, I have some doubts as to the accuracy of such tests in judging someone's true intelligence.

But, that being said, I don't know any truly dumb people who are remotely successful. I know plenty who are not learned or have not had higher formal education that are successful, but yeah.. no actual dummies who are successful. On the flip side,I have also met many people who have advanced degrees who are dumb. Like can barely read and write. And, it does make you wonder how they actually passed their classes and got those degrees.

So, I think we have to be very careful to not link education with intelligence. There are plenty of really smart people -who do not have formal educations. And, plenty who have formal educations who are idiots. But, I think in either way - if you are dumb -with or without and education... you likely will not be successful.

connie
 
But, that being said, I don't know any truly dumb people who are remotely successful

Same here. Although I know quite a few people with mediocre intelligence (combined with plenty of drive, or a ruthless willingness to step on others to get ahead) who have been successful, all the truly dumb people I know have been socioeconomic failures.

Similarly, nobody I know who is extremely smart is a particular failure, either. Even the ones who lack drive always seem to stumble into decent jobs that at least put their earnings over the median -- or, if they deliberately steer towards non-profit or artistic pursuits that doom them to low earnings, they at least tend to become successful in terms of professional prestige and rank (e.g., a fairly high-level person in a non-profit).

I would never argue that intelligence is the sole determiner of success -- much less the narrow form of intelligence and formal learning that tends to be tested in IQ tests. But I think raw intelligence matters a lot more than the average person gives it credit for. Take ten children with IQs of 140 and ten with IQs of 70 and track them through life, and there's a good chance that even the least successful of the high-IQ set will have done better than the most successful of the low-IQ set. After parental wealth, it probably the most important determiner of economic success.

And, it does make you wonder how they actually passed their classes and got those degrees.

I've particularly noticed that with people who have MBAs. A shockingly large share of them can't write a simple e-mail that makes sense, or grasp any moderately complicated idea.

I think that's in large part because there's no real quality control there. There's nothing to prevent a B-school from accepting a moron and eventually graduating him, without requiring that he learn anything. By comparison, for doctors, lawyers, CPAs, and certain others who have to pass through some rigorous professional screening (including high-stakes testing), a university is risking its reputation if it makes a habit of accepting and graduating idiots, because people actually track those stats about how their graduates do in going on to get their professional certifications. A prestigious law school that makes a habit of accepting dim-bulb aristocrats who keep failing the bar exam and screw up their stats won't be a prestigious law school for long. I think that's why I've never met a truly dim lawyer, doctor, CPA, or certified professional engineer. The dim people got screened out. With MBAs, there's just nothing to screen them.

I've also seen a lot of dim-wittedness among certain newer social sciences, which just don't seem to be terribly academically rigorous. Some humanities students are also surprisingly dumb, or maybe just poorly educated. I'm thinking of one particular example where I was trying to talk art history with a girl who had a BA in the topic, and yet she seemed ignorant of really basic stuff from her own major -- the names of major artists, movements, and styles. I was left wondering what the hell she did with her time in college.
 
Same here. Although I know quite a few people with mediocre intelligence (combined with plenty of drive, or a ruthless willingness to step on others to get ahead) who have been successful, all the truly dumb people I know have been socioeconomic failures.

Similarly, nobody I know who is extremely smart is a particular failure, either. Even the ones who lack drive always seem to stumble into decent jobs that at least put their earnings over the median -- or, if they deliberately steer towards non-profit or artistic pursuits that doom them to low earnings, they at least tend to become successful in terms of professional prestige and rank (e.g., a fairly high-level person in a non-profit).

I would never argue that intelligence is the sole determiner of success -- much less the narrow form of intelligence and formal learning that tends to be tested in IQ tests. But I think raw intelligence matters a lot more than the average person gives it credit for. Take ten children with IQs of 140 and ten with IQs of 70 and track them through life, and there's a good chance that even the least successful of the high-IQ set will have done better than the most successful of the low-IQ set. After parental wealth, it probably the most important determiner of economic success.



I've particularly noticed that with people who have MBAs. A shockingly large share of them can't write a simple e-mail that makes sense, or grasp any moderately complicated idea.

I think that's in large part because there's no real quality control there. There's nothing to prevent a B-school from accepting a moron and eventually graduating him, without requiring that he learn anything. By comparison, for doctors, lawyers, CPAs, and certain others who have to pass through some rigorous professional screening (including high-stakes testing), a university is risking its reputation if it makes a habit of accepting and graduating idiots, because people actually track those stats about how their graduates do in going on to get their professional certifications. A prestigious law school that makes a habit of accepting dim-bulb aristocrats who keep failing the bar exam and screw up their stats won't be a prestigious law school for long. I think that's why I've never met a truly dim lawyer, doctor, CPA, or certified professional engineer. The dim people got screened out. With MBAs, there's just nothing to screen them.

I agree with your position that if you tracked a person with a 70 and a 140 - you would obviously find that the 140's are by far more successful. However, I think 70 is really low - like I think that is intellectually impaired. I think if you compared people who were more around 100 with the 140's you would see a much more even success rate.

In my personal experience with people who are off the charts smart - I think they tend to have a higher proportion of other mental health problems. I can not say they are necessarily related or causal, but the people I know who are super smart but haven't done anything - are also people who suffer from above normal bouts of depression, anxiety, etc and it is those things that hold them back. And or they are to the point that they are almost savant-esque and that basically their complete and total lack of interpersonal skills prevent them from ever being truly successful. Sometimes those people find their ways into Academia or research where they are well tolerated. But, when they try to make it in the average work world - people are not willing to put up with their oddities so much. You can have an IQ of 160 but in my line of work.... if you can't talk to the client and you can't develop relationships with other business professionals - you are no good to me. I would rather have a person in a nice solid upper intelligence around 120 or so, than have a 150 or 160 who can't function with normal people.

I agree with you on the MBA. I have met a lot of those types who I am amazed were able to graduate.

connie
 
I agree with your position that if you tracked a person with a 70 and a 140 - you would obviously find that the 140's are by far more successful. However, I think 70 is really low

Yes, admittedly, I was stacking the deck for my argument with such a wide range -- from genius to "intellectually impaired." The smaller you make that range, the more crossover there will be between the most successful dumb people and the least successful smart ones. But my guess is that the impact of IQ would be larger than your average person would expect at any given gap level. For example, I'm betting you'd find appreciable difference in outcomes between people at the 120 and 140 levels.

In my personal experience with people who are off the charts smart - I think they tend to have a higher proportion of other mental health problems.

Although I haven't seen that, first hand, it does fit a certain stereotype of the neurotic or depressive genius, so I wouldn't be surprised if you were right. Certainly there's a correlation on a regional level between higher-IQ areas and higher suicide rates:

http://www.photius.com/rankings/national_iq_scores_country_ranks.html
http://www.therichest.com/rich-list/top-10-countries-by-highest-average-iq/?view=all
http://www.iqtestforfree.net/average-IQ-by-country.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate

There's a lot of disagreement about exactly where IQs are highest and lowest, but whichever set of data you use, there's a clear tendency for the wealthier southeast Asian and Western European countries to be high in both IQ and suicide, while poor equatorial countries are low in both.

What I've definitely noticed, in my personal life (and in my own individual case) is a correlation between high intelligence and a certain variety of poor social skills -- the "on the spectrum" kind of personality that may not have been formally diagnosed as Aspergers, but definitely shares traits with that syndrome. Most of these people suck at reading non-verbal social cues, for example. They also tend to have a problem with others communicating in imprecise and non-literal ways. And they almost all share a weird pleasure in listing things.

I would rather have a person in a nice solid upper intelligence around 120 or so, than have a 150 or 160 who can't function with normal people.

I get what you're saying, but I prefer a range, from upper-normal through super-bright. If you have a team that has people spanning that range, you can plug the right one into the right situation. The super-bright person may be worthless to you if the job involves explaining stuff in a way that dumb people can follow. That's where the "upper-normal" person will be perfect, since he or she will properly intuit where a dumber person will encounter difficulty, and will be able to communicate in a way that spans that gap. But, for other tasks, having a person who won't get lost no matter how intellectually difficult the matter gets is good, even if that means everyone has to put up with some "Aspy" social tendencies. To put it in pop cultural terms, ideally you have Inspector Lestrade, Doctor Watson, and Sherlock Holmes all working as a team.
 
Yes, admittedly, I was stacking the deck for my argument with such a wide range -- from genius to "intellectually impaired." The smaller you make that range, the more crossover there will be between the most successful dumb people and the least successful smart ones. But my guess is that the impact of IQ would be larger than your average person would expect at any given gap level. For example, I'm betting you'd find appreciable difference in outcomes between people at the 120 and 140 levels.



Although I haven't seen that, first hand, it does fit a certain stereotype of the neurotic or depressive genius, so I wouldn't be surprised if you were right. Certainly there's a correlation on a regional level between higher-IQ areas and higher suicide rates:

http://www.photius.com/rankings/national_iq_scores_country_ranks.html
http://www.therichest.com/rich-list/top-10-countries-by-highest-average-iq/?view=all
http://www.iqtestforfree.net/average-IQ-by-country.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate

There's a lot of disagreement about exactly where IQs are highest and lowest, but whichever set of data you use, there's a clear tendency for the wealthier southeast Asian and Western European countries to be high in both IQ and suicide, while poor equatorial countries are low in both.

What I've definitely noticed, in my personal life (and in my own individual case) is a correlation between high intelligence and a certain variety of poor social skills -- the "on the spectrum" kind of personality that may not have been formally diagnosed as Aspergers, but definitely shares traits with that syndrome. Most of these people suck at reading non-verbal social cues, for example. They also tend to have a problem with others communicating in imprecise and non-literal ways. And they almost all share a weird pleasure in listing things.



I get what you're saying, but I prefer a range, from upper-normal through super-bright. If you have a team that has people spanning that range, you can plug the right one into the right situation. The super-bright person may be worthless to you if the job involves explaining stuff in a way that dumb people can follow. That's where the "upper-normal" person will be perfect, since he or she will properly intuit where a dumber person will encounter difficulty, and will be able to communicate in a way that spans that gap. But, for other tasks, having a person who won't get lost no matter how intellectually difficult the matter gets is good, even if that means everyone has to put up with some "Aspy" social tendencies. To put it in pop cultural terms, ideally you have Inspector Lestrade, Doctor Watson, and Sherlock Holmes all working as a team.


Well, my job does have a lot to do with trying to dumb down concepts to people who operate on an entirely different plane. And, it depends much more on referrals and relationships. So, if you can't build those things - then you are useless. You may have GAAP memorized but if you can't communicate it in a meaningful way, its pointless. 120 is above average to most measures. There isn't much in my line or work, or most that I have encountered that a person with above average intelligence isn't able to function well.

You see I think that is where the difference is. I think you can have that person who is 160 and may get things right away, BUT - I still think that a person with solidly above average intelligence can ultimately get all those concepts, they will simply have to work harder to get them. So, I don't think you are missing out on anything by having a person with a good work ethic who is solidly above average. The social tendencies are HUGE in a business that depends entirely on social interaction and likeability. So, I would trade off raw intelligence ( and likely more neurosis) for someone who is still very bright but would maybe need to put some more effort into learning a concept. Not that those super bright people don't serve a use. We need them.. but in a lab or research facility. You can certainly be very very successful in the "real world" without being off the charts, and in fact, to some degree its preferred.
 
Well, my job does have a lot to do with trying to dumb down concepts to people who operate on an entirely different plane.

I have a wide range of clients. Those of them at the higher intellectual levels tend to love me -- especially the engineers and finance types. I struggle more with the dumber ones, though, which is why I'm glad I have a team now that I can delegate some of that lower-level work to. I just don't tend to have a good instinctive grasp of which things won't be immediately obvious to someone who isn't very bright. Because of that, I can screw up in two directions simultaneously: failing to explain stuff I thought for sure they would already understand, but which they didn't, and over-explaining something that was actually obvious to them, and thus coming across as a condescending jerk for thinking they might not know it.
 
The greater IQ span among men could be due to less genetic material. The Y chromosome is much smaller than the X. With less overall code, any given gene has a bigger potential impact, in terms of percentage. So, the bell curve for women would be expected to be thicker in the middle, for height, weight, athletic prowess, natural music talent, IQ, and other multi-factor genetic outcomes.

if that was true - "less genetic material" - then men on average would be much less intelligent than women.

but history shows they dominate math, science, engineering, abstract though . . .

the admittedly small/partially defective Y chromosome is not directly tied to brain mass or brain developement, anyway. those elements are part of the other 41 chromosomes. the Y chromosome affects hormones and sexual development only.

genetic birth defects - men with 2 Y chromosomes instead of an X and a Y - are often violent criminals. again, this has nothing do with brain size, or even intelligence. its a hormonal thing.
 
Well, my job does have a lot to do with trying to dumb down concepts to people who operate on an entirely different plane. And, it depends much more on referrals and relationships. So, if you can't build those things - then you are useless. You may have GAAP memorized but if you can't communicate it in a meaningful way, its pointless. 120 is above average to most measures. There isn't much in my line or work, or most that I have encountered that a person with above average intelligence isn't able to function well.

You see I think that is where the difference is. I think you can have that person who is 160 and may get things right away, BUT - I still think that a person with solidly above average intelligence can ultimately get all those concepts, they will simply have to work harder to get them. So, I don't think you are missing out on anything by having a person with a good work ethic who is solidly above average. The social tendencies are HUGE in a business that depends entirely on social interaction and likeability. So, I would trade off raw intelligence ( and likely more neurosis) for someone who is still very bright but would maybe need to put some more effort into learning a concept. Not that those super bright people don't serve a use. We need them.. but in a lab or research facility. You can certainly be very very successful in the "real world" without being off the charts, and in fact, to some degree its preferred.

in most business situations raw intelligence isn't the deciding factor. its "lack of disruptive/anti-social impulses" that create success.
 
if that was true - "less genetic material" - then men on average would be much less intelligent than women.

First, it is demonstrably true that men have less genetic material than women. There's no scientific question about that:

Karyotype.png



XY (male) has less material than XX (female). Specifically, the X chromosome has 155 million DNA base pairs, versus 59 million for the Y chromosome:

http://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/chromosome/X
http://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/chromosome/Y

You can see in a photograph that the X chromosome (left) has far more material than the Y (right):

chromosome_sem.jpg


It's a non sequitur to say "if men had less genetic material - then men on average would be much less intelligent than women." Lots of species have more genetic material than humans that are dumber than us. See, for example, how much genetic material is contained in some flowering plants:

Genome_Sizes.png


Paris Japonica, a kind of flower, has 150 billion base pairs in its genome, which is about 47 times as much genetic material as in a human, and yet obviously we're not likely to be beaten at chess by it.

Anyway, here's a way to look at the X-Y problem. Picture you have a hundred women and a hundred men, and they play a game where they compete to see who can guess the result of the highest percentage of coin tosses. The women each guess 50 times. The men each guess 10 times. Is a man or woman likely to end up in first place? Last place?

The answer to that is that a man is likely to wind up in first place and another man in last place. Because women are guessing more times, the role of chance will be smaller for them. With 50 guesses each, they're all likely to be clustered very tightly around 50% correct. The men, on the other hand, have a bigger role for chance, because there's less opportunity for random streaks to be averaged out. So, some guy is likely to guess right a greater share of the time than any woman, and some other guy is likely to guess wrong a greater share of the time than any woman.

A similar phenomenon would be expected to play out with genes. The more of them you have, the less of a role any individual gene will tend to have in multi-gene characteristics like intelligence. So, if any of those intelligence-influencing genes are on the sex chromosomes, a guy is more likely to get a lucky "streak" of several "smart genes" and wind up very smart, without those results being averaged out the way they would in a bigger pool of genetic material. But a guy is also more likely to get an unlucky streak of "dumb genes" and wind up very dumb, without that averaging.

So, if we could control for cultural factors, we'd expect distributions that look something like this:

1424269208310.gif


The real distributions look more like this:
1424269006690.png

That shows the same higher clustering of women (or greater spread of men, if you prefer), as the genetic model would tell us, but with a rightward shift of men as a whole. That shift might be explained by cultural factors.
 
Back
Top