Arkady
President
Back in the 1990s there was a book by a couple conservative writers, called "The Bell Curve" that argued that intelligence is an overwhelming factor in life outcomes -- that those with high IQs were a cognitive elite who would have a much greater likelihood of socioeconomic success, while those with low IQs would be all but doomed to failure.
The argument was incredibly controversial -- partly because of shortcomings in their data and analysis, but mostly because of the political implications. Conservatives tended to like the argument, since it could be used to make a case against a generous welfare state and affirmative action (efforts that were largely wasted if the underclass was just dumb) and also against immigration from poor nations (which would be expected to bring down average IQ here). Liberals tended to hate the argument for those same reasons, but also because it lent itself to racism and eugenics.
For a while, it was a really popular book among some conservatives, but gradually the conservative movement abandoned that line of analysis. Not only was it hard to keep coming to the defense of a book that had some pretty glaring analytical problems, it was also politically difficult, in that it didn't chime well with a conservative political strategy of writing off liberals as elitist egg-heads, while conservatives were the salt of the earth. When that's your strategy, you don't want to highlight the work of some right-wing academics that insists on the importance of intelligence. Plus, ultimately, the way the book ran afoul of the taboo about talking about race and hereditary intelligence was just too much for polite conservatism.
Although I was a critic of the book, myself, I had hoped it would be an entry point into deeper and more accurate analysis of the role of intelligence in socioeconomic life. So, I'm disappointed that it was instead effectively shelved, and that whole field neglected for decades. I think there are important questions there that we should try to understand if we're going to craft good public policies.
Just to give a practical example, is a country better educating its children to develop generalized intelligence, leaving any specialization for adulthood? Or is it better identifying natural talents earlier, with greater specialization (as is common in many other countries, where there's earlier identification of professional/academic track and vocational track)? If you think that IQ (or various types of IQ, if you prefer) isn't much of a factor, and that basically anyone can be great at basically anything, and that effort is nearly all the story, there's value to delaying specialization. The longer you can delay, the more people can be exposed to lots of stuff and have the best chance of finding where their passion really lies, and that will let them have the most emotional energy for the kind of effort that will make them great. If, on the other hand, IQ (or a specific type of IQ) is a very large consideration, then you may be wasting your time giving someone a lot of education into an area he's never going to be good at, when early testing could identify his area of natural strength, for better overall returns.
That's just one example. It's hard to say all the interesting things we could learn, with serious policy implications, if we moved beyond that political taboo about discussing hereditary intelligence. I believe in the value of knowledge, and the taboo is preventing us from learning.
Anyway, here is a piece discussing the political taboo around discussing intelligence:
http://dwightmurphey-collectedwritings.info/A57-BellCrve.htm
And here's a discussion of the science of trying to assess the relative value of natural ability and hard work in the formation of expertise:
http://www.salon.com/2015/04/22/scr...oard_game_teaches_us_about_expertise_partner/
I assume we all believe that expertise is a combination of both factors. But I, for one, think that the mainstream view puts too much emphasis on work, relative to natural ability. The mainstream view is along the lines of the Malcolm Gladwell idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make anyone into a master of just about anything -- he'd argue that when you find greatness, like the music of the Beatles, it's mostly just a matter of such people having practiced more than others. But I know, from my own experience, that natural ability is the predominant factor.
I can do some mental things, effortlessly, that other people couldn't do with a lifetime of practice. For example, in law school, I could avoid going to classes all semester, pick up the textbook the night before the exam, speed read it for several hours, then do great on the test. I have the kind of brain that just soaks up that kind of information easily.... and retains it for decades. With ten hours of reading I'd retained more than most people would with a hundred hours of serious study. T o this day, I wow fellow lawyers with specific recollection of the contents of various cases we all read in law school but that I actually retained after my quick read and they forgot after their long laborious study. But, on the flip side, I'm completely middling with learning languages, and actually quite poor at learning music. I could plug away for 10,000 hours at the piano and get to the point where I have basic competence, but I'm never going to be good at it, because I'm not wired for it. And there are people who, with just 500 hours of effort, could be better than me with 10,000. I'm as developmentally disabled with music as I am gifted with some other things, and that winds up being a much bigger factor than effort, for me.
The argument was incredibly controversial -- partly because of shortcomings in their data and analysis, but mostly because of the political implications. Conservatives tended to like the argument, since it could be used to make a case against a generous welfare state and affirmative action (efforts that were largely wasted if the underclass was just dumb) and also against immigration from poor nations (which would be expected to bring down average IQ here). Liberals tended to hate the argument for those same reasons, but also because it lent itself to racism and eugenics.
For a while, it was a really popular book among some conservatives, but gradually the conservative movement abandoned that line of analysis. Not only was it hard to keep coming to the defense of a book that had some pretty glaring analytical problems, it was also politically difficult, in that it didn't chime well with a conservative political strategy of writing off liberals as elitist egg-heads, while conservatives were the salt of the earth. When that's your strategy, you don't want to highlight the work of some right-wing academics that insists on the importance of intelligence. Plus, ultimately, the way the book ran afoul of the taboo about talking about race and hereditary intelligence was just too much for polite conservatism.
Although I was a critic of the book, myself, I had hoped it would be an entry point into deeper and more accurate analysis of the role of intelligence in socioeconomic life. So, I'm disappointed that it was instead effectively shelved, and that whole field neglected for decades. I think there are important questions there that we should try to understand if we're going to craft good public policies.
Just to give a practical example, is a country better educating its children to develop generalized intelligence, leaving any specialization for adulthood? Or is it better identifying natural talents earlier, with greater specialization (as is common in many other countries, where there's earlier identification of professional/academic track and vocational track)? If you think that IQ (or various types of IQ, if you prefer) isn't much of a factor, and that basically anyone can be great at basically anything, and that effort is nearly all the story, there's value to delaying specialization. The longer you can delay, the more people can be exposed to lots of stuff and have the best chance of finding where their passion really lies, and that will let them have the most emotional energy for the kind of effort that will make them great. If, on the other hand, IQ (or a specific type of IQ) is a very large consideration, then you may be wasting your time giving someone a lot of education into an area he's never going to be good at, when early testing could identify his area of natural strength, for better overall returns.
That's just one example. It's hard to say all the interesting things we could learn, with serious policy implications, if we moved beyond that political taboo about discussing hereditary intelligence. I believe in the value of knowledge, and the taboo is preventing us from learning.
Anyway, here is a piece discussing the political taboo around discussing intelligence:
http://dwightmurphey-collectedwritings.info/A57-BellCrve.htm
And here's a discussion of the science of trying to assess the relative value of natural ability and hard work in the formation of expertise:
http://www.salon.com/2015/04/22/scr...oard_game_teaches_us_about_expertise_partner/
I assume we all believe that expertise is a combination of both factors. But I, for one, think that the mainstream view puts too much emphasis on work, relative to natural ability. The mainstream view is along the lines of the Malcolm Gladwell idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make anyone into a master of just about anything -- he'd argue that when you find greatness, like the music of the Beatles, it's mostly just a matter of such people having practiced more than others. But I know, from my own experience, that natural ability is the predominant factor.
I can do some mental things, effortlessly, that other people couldn't do with a lifetime of practice. For example, in law school, I could avoid going to classes all semester, pick up the textbook the night before the exam, speed read it for several hours, then do great on the test. I have the kind of brain that just soaks up that kind of information easily.... and retains it for decades. With ten hours of reading I'd retained more than most people would with a hundred hours of serious study. T o this day, I wow fellow lawyers with specific recollection of the contents of various cases we all read in law school but that I actually retained after my quick read and they forgot after their long laborious study. But, on the flip side, I'm completely middling with learning languages, and actually quite poor at learning music. I could plug away for 10,000 hours at the piano and get to the point where I have basic competence, but I'm never going to be good at it, because I'm not wired for it. And there are people who, with just 500 hours of effort, could be better than me with 10,000. I'm as developmentally disabled with music as I am gifted with some other things, and that winds up being a much bigger factor than effort, for me.