New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Natural Disasters

Arkady

President
The recent tornado has had a horrifying death toll, but the truth is, it was nowhere close to one of the deadliest natural disasters in history. There have been many natural disasters that had death tolls in the hundreds of thousands -- droughts, floods, tsunamis, earthquakes, and cyclones. The deadliest tornadoes have death tolls in the many hundreds -- one killed 1300. But natural disasters have become less and less deadly in wealthy nations over time, despite growing population density that might be expected to make them more so. The reason for the improvement is important to understand.

These days, in wealthy nations, when a natural disaster hits, it usually comes with ample warning. We see hurricanes coming days before they arrive, and we usually get hours of warning about high-probability tornado conditions, so people can reach cover. That is thanks to a network of government-financed and government-run storm trackers, along with government-organized civil warning systems.

When natural disaster do hit, we're usually a lot better prepared, these days, in wealthy nations. We have strict building code regulations, for example, that prevent something like the Haiti earthquake from flattening most structures here, and which cut down on the ability of hurricanes and near-miss tornadoes to tear structures apart. Our government-crafted and government-enforced building codes help to protect people from flooding and wildfires, too.

Then there's the work of the Army Corps of Engineers, and other government groups that work directly to control the forces of nature to mitigate disasters. And, in the aftermath, you have groups like FEMA that --at least when not headed by a horse judge-- can make an enormous difference in preventing the kinds of disease, supply, and shelter problems that, in the aftermath of natural disasters in poorer countries, can multiply the death toll many times. Together with government groups like the CDC, this makes sure that the natural follow up to a flood, for us, is rebuilding, not a cholera or typhus epidemic. And we have the modern welfare state to help get hard-hit regions up and running again, rather than allowing them to linger in a rut of poverty and depressed economic fallout that could last a generation or more, in prior eras.

If you look at lists of the deadliest disasters in US history, you'll notice that most predate the era of Big Government. The Galveston Hurricane, the Dust Bowl, the Great Chicago Fire, the San Francisco Fire and Earthquake of 1906, and the Johnstown Flood are good examples. Of the 25 deadliest tornadoes in this country, only one took place in the last 50 years, and most took place before the New Deal. People of those times lived in housing unregulated by government, without the benefit of robust government disaster preparedness, warning, and response services, and that allowed storms that we'd have taken in stride to devastate them.

These things are important to remember when we talk about austerity, the sequester, and budget cuts. The government's budget didn't grow on a perverse whim. It grew, in part, because of public demand for government services that proved remarkably effective at making our lives better. Despite this country being far more densely peopled than in the past, we ride out even huge natural disasters with relatively few casualties, and much of the reason is Big Government.

This situation is reversible:

http://www.salon.com/2013/05/21/how_are_we_cutting_the_weather_service_now/

If we make cuts in the wrong places (like the National Weather Service) and remove the wrong regulations (or enforcement of such regulations, as with building codes), we can go back to the situation earlier Americans, and today's third-worlders live with, where natural disasters regularly show up and kill thousands or even hundreds of thousands of people. With growing population density and with global warming putting more energy in the atmospheric mix, we could end up even worse than that, in the future. In generations to come, we can expect more frequent and more powerful storms bearing down on more populous areas -- the only question is whether those places will be well-shielded by a modern government or not. It's our choice.
 
I notice how quickly the libertarians become "Big Gub'mint Statists" when a disaster hits.

No calls for "Leave it to the private sector....Government always fails...keep the Fed out of it." Same folks who fear a "socialist dictatorship" when it comes to providing health care to those who have lost their insurance.....happily seek "Big Government" when it comes to helping people struck with a natural disaster loss, especially if it's local.
 
I notice how quickly the libertarians become "Big Gub'mint Statists" when a disaster hits.

No calls for "Leave it to the private sector....Government always fails...keep the Fed out of it." Same folks who fear a "socialist dictatorship" when it comes to providing health care to those who have lost their insurance.....happily seek "Big Government" when it comes to helping people struck with a natural disaster loss, especially if it's local.

Inhoffe was just on explaining why he did not vote for the New Jersey bill.

He did have one point that things were tacked on that had nothing to do with the disaster.They need to expose those corrupt Politicians who add them.
 
Back
Top