Arkady
President
Here's an article envisioning a race for president among all US presidents. If they were all magically reincarnated, in the form they were in after their first term in office, and all ran for president today, who would win?
http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/20...nts_were_alive_and_running_for_office_in.html
I think the writer is is right to throw away anyone from the 19th or 18th centuries. Their views on race and gender would almost certainly drive more than half the population away from them, today. Many held slaves, and even those who didn't would mostly have been shocked by the notion of women voting and the races being legally desegregated. Their skills could be seen as too outmoded for the challenge of leading a major 21st-century nation. Teddy Roosevelt and Abe Lincoln would be my picks for the only presidents from that earlier era with any shot, and both would be way out of their depth in understanding the implications of 20th and 21st century technological advances on the functioning of the country and the nature of our place in the world. I think they might have a strong run in the early going in a campaign, but would come to seem dangerously out-of-touch long before the vote was held.
I agree with the writer about his four contenders: Clinton, FDR, JFK, and Reagan. I'd add Eisenhower to the mix, though. With our graying, center-right demographics right now, this country is really ripe for voting Republican, if it weren't for the fact the modern GOP has reinvented itself into an extremist cult of tea-party absolutists. Bringing back a Republican war hero with plenty of charisma and a vision for the ways the government can work positively to help the American people would be very exciting for a lot of people. Ike would have some tough questions to answer on racial and gender issues, where his worldview would be quite dated, and there'd be legitimate concerns that a president today can't afford to be as "checked out" as Ike was. Plus, his weakness is the face of McCarthyism is troubling as hell. But I still think he'd have a shot.
My own vote would be for Clinton. Although I count FDR as a better president than Clinton, I'm not sure how well FDR could cope with the modern GOP in the Congress -- he had strong Democratic majorities to work with. We know Clinton fights those battles well. I also think Clinton would have a vastly stronger grasp of the modern world's challenges and the possibilities of technology, and he'd have fewer growing pains in relation to race, gender, and other modern social developments than FDR would.
If I had to guess who'd win, though, I'd guess Reagan. Although I think he was a poor-to-mediocre president, and that he'd be even worse today, he's the beneficiary of vast amounts of nostalgia on both sides of the aisle. Even Obama compared Reagan favorably to Clinton in 2008. I'm sure Obama would much prefer a Clinton presidency, but the fact he thought there was political ground to be gained by talking up Reagan tells you Reagan's status in the public consciousness. The fact he lost his mind shortly after his presidency ended and then died makes him a safe Republican for a Democrat to talk up to make himself seem bipartisan, since Reagan can't come along and use that standing to attack the Democrat, the way Clinton has been able to do when Republicans try to play the same game by talking him up over Obama. Reagan's like JFK in that way -- JFK's another one who has long been praised on both sides of the aisle because he was no longer in a position to say anything new. I think Reagan, today, would get lock-step support from almost everyone on the right (despite all the ways he'd fail the modern Tea Party acid tests), out of a sense that he could cement the conservative coalition, and I think he'd get a lot of "Reagan Democrats," who misunderstood his era or were too young to experience it themselves.
If it came down to Reagan v. FDR, FDR would look too extreme (top tax rates of 90%, court-packing efforts, vast socialization of the economy), and Reagan would win, especially with FDR having less of a grasp of how to use the modern political media to get his message across to a soundbite-addled nation. If it came down to Reagan v. Clinton it would be close, but the right would rediscover its visceral hatred of Clinton, and turn it into an ugly, scandal-ridden campaign, and Reagan would ride the resulting "Clinton fatigue" to victory.
http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/20...nts_were_alive_and_running_for_office_in.html
I think the writer is is right to throw away anyone from the 19th or 18th centuries. Their views on race and gender would almost certainly drive more than half the population away from them, today. Many held slaves, and even those who didn't would mostly have been shocked by the notion of women voting and the races being legally desegregated. Their skills could be seen as too outmoded for the challenge of leading a major 21st-century nation. Teddy Roosevelt and Abe Lincoln would be my picks for the only presidents from that earlier era with any shot, and both would be way out of their depth in understanding the implications of 20th and 21st century technological advances on the functioning of the country and the nature of our place in the world. I think they might have a strong run in the early going in a campaign, but would come to seem dangerously out-of-touch long before the vote was held.
I agree with the writer about his four contenders: Clinton, FDR, JFK, and Reagan. I'd add Eisenhower to the mix, though. With our graying, center-right demographics right now, this country is really ripe for voting Republican, if it weren't for the fact the modern GOP has reinvented itself into an extremist cult of tea-party absolutists. Bringing back a Republican war hero with plenty of charisma and a vision for the ways the government can work positively to help the American people would be very exciting for a lot of people. Ike would have some tough questions to answer on racial and gender issues, where his worldview would be quite dated, and there'd be legitimate concerns that a president today can't afford to be as "checked out" as Ike was. Plus, his weakness is the face of McCarthyism is troubling as hell. But I still think he'd have a shot.
My own vote would be for Clinton. Although I count FDR as a better president than Clinton, I'm not sure how well FDR could cope with the modern GOP in the Congress -- he had strong Democratic majorities to work with. We know Clinton fights those battles well. I also think Clinton would have a vastly stronger grasp of the modern world's challenges and the possibilities of technology, and he'd have fewer growing pains in relation to race, gender, and other modern social developments than FDR would.
If I had to guess who'd win, though, I'd guess Reagan. Although I think he was a poor-to-mediocre president, and that he'd be even worse today, he's the beneficiary of vast amounts of nostalgia on both sides of the aisle. Even Obama compared Reagan favorably to Clinton in 2008. I'm sure Obama would much prefer a Clinton presidency, but the fact he thought there was political ground to be gained by talking up Reagan tells you Reagan's status in the public consciousness. The fact he lost his mind shortly after his presidency ended and then died makes him a safe Republican for a Democrat to talk up to make himself seem bipartisan, since Reagan can't come along and use that standing to attack the Democrat, the way Clinton has been able to do when Republicans try to play the same game by talking him up over Obama. Reagan's like JFK in that way -- JFK's another one who has long been praised on both sides of the aisle because he was no longer in a position to say anything new. I think Reagan, today, would get lock-step support from almost everyone on the right (despite all the ways he'd fail the modern Tea Party acid tests), out of a sense that he could cement the conservative coalition, and I think he'd get a lot of "Reagan Democrats," who misunderstood his era or were too young to experience it themselves.
If it came down to Reagan v. FDR, FDR would look too extreme (top tax rates of 90%, court-packing efforts, vast socialization of the economy), and Reagan would win, especially with FDR having less of a grasp of how to use the modern political media to get his message across to a soundbite-addled nation. If it came down to Reagan v. Clinton it would be close, but the right would rediscover its visceral hatred of Clinton, and turn it into an ugly, scandal-ridden campaign, and Reagan would ride the resulting "Clinton fatigue" to victory.