New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Neat Thought Experiment

Arkady

President
Here's an article envisioning a race for president among all US presidents. If they were all magically reincarnated, in the form they were in after their first term in office, and all ran for president today, who would win?

http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/20...nts_were_alive_and_running_for_office_in.html

I think the writer is is right to throw away anyone from the 19th or 18th centuries. Their views on race and gender would almost certainly drive more than half the population away from them, today. Many held slaves, and even those who didn't would mostly have been shocked by the notion of women voting and the races being legally desegregated. Their skills could be seen as too outmoded for the challenge of leading a major 21st-century nation. Teddy Roosevelt and Abe Lincoln would be my picks for the only presidents from that earlier era with any shot, and both would be way out of their depth in understanding the implications of 20th and 21st century technological advances on the functioning of the country and the nature of our place in the world. I think they might have a strong run in the early going in a campaign, but would come to seem dangerously out-of-touch long before the vote was held.

I agree with the writer about his four contenders: Clinton, FDR, JFK, and Reagan. I'd add Eisenhower to the mix, though. With our graying, center-right demographics right now, this country is really ripe for voting Republican, if it weren't for the fact the modern GOP has reinvented itself into an extremist cult of tea-party absolutists. Bringing back a Republican war hero with plenty of charisma and a vision for the ways the government can work positively to help the American people would be very exciting for a lot of people. Ike would have some tough questions to answer on racial and gender issues, where his worldview would be quite dated, and there'd be legitimate concerns that a president today can't afford to be as "checked out" as Ike was. Plus, his weakness is the face of McCarthyism is troubling as hell. But I still think he'd have a shot.

My own vote would be for Clinton. Although I count FDR as a better president than Clinton, I'm not sure how well FDR could cope with the modern GOP in the Congress -- he had strong Democratic majorities to work with. We know Clinton fights those battles well. I also think Clinton would have a vastly stronger grasp of the modern world's challenges and the possibilities of technology, and he'd have fewer growing pains in relation to race, gender, and other modern social developments than FDR would.

If I had to guess who'd win, though, I'd guess Reagan. Although I think he was a poor-to-mediocre president, and that he'd be even worse today, he's the beneficiary of vast amounts of nostalgia on both sides of the aisle. Even Obama compared Reagan favorably to Clinton in 2008. I'm sure Obama would much prefer a Clinton presidency, but the fact he thought there was political ground to be gained by talking up Reagan tells you Reagan's status in the public consciousness. The fact he lost his mind shortly after his presidency ended and then died makes him a safe Republican for a Democrat to talk up to make himself seem bipartisan, since Reagan can't come along and use that standing to attack the Democrat, the way Clinton has been able to do when Republicans try to play the same game by talking him up over Obama. Reagan's like JFK in that way -- JFK's another one who has long been praised on both sides of the aisle because he was no longer in a position to say anything new. I think Reagan, today, would get lock-step support from almost everyone on the right (despite all the ways he'd fail the modern Tea Party acid tests), out of a sense that he could cement the conservative coalition, and I think he'd get a lot of "Reagan Democrats," who misunderstood his era or were too young to experience it themselves.

If it came down to Reagan v. FDR, FDR would look too extreme (top tax rates of 90%, court-packing efforts, vast socialization of the economy), and Reagan would win, especially with FDR having less of a grasp of how to use the modern political media to get his message across to a soundbite-addled nation. If it came down to Reagan v. Clinton it would be close, but the right would rediscover its visceral hatred of Clinton, and turn it into an ugly, scandal-ridden campaign, and Reagan would ride the resulting "Clinton fatigue" to victory.
 
But consider this...Reagan....THE template (and almost sole example) for what the Rightwing today consider to be a "good President"...

SOLD OUT the current (and even previous) Rightwing ideology in his latter years in office. Signed off tax hikes....never veto'ed or even threatened a veto of a spending bill....increased deficits and debt....appointed less-than-pure-conservative Justices to the USSC (O'Connor, Kennedy).....signed TREATIES (those "meaningless scraps of paper") with the dreaded Rooskies......SOLD WEAPONS TO IRAN....signed AMNESTY for "illegals"....etc.

So you'd have to decide "which Reagan" would be running? Especially if it was on his record as Governor of California...which would put him in the liberal DEMOCRATIC side of the aisle on many things.
 
I agree that if a Reagan came along today, he wouldn't have a snowball's chance in hell in the Tea Party-dominated GOP, given his ideological flexibility, willingness to negotiate, etc. But that's just how a Reagan would be treated if there'd never been a Reagan. If, on the other hand, Reagan were reincarnated, they'd all pretend he was the mythological figure of their collective weak memories, who fit perfectly with their nutso conservative orthodoxy. He's a cult figure for them, and any real-world evidence that conflicts with their image of him as faultless would simply be ignored, the way followers of religious wackos turn a blind eye to the hypocrisies of their leader.
 
In a way, a Reagan Reincarnated victory would be the complete OPPOSITE of what the current radical Right would imagine it to be...almost as much as a potential Romney Presidency.

To see their ideology sold out BY A REPUBLICAN PRESIDENT...thus leaving them no room to criticize (especially if it was The Gipper) due to their abject partisan loyalty to the GOP and "our guy in charge, right or wrong"....they'd be in even a WORSE bind.

BTW, part of the reason I'm not going to be particularly depressed in EITHER scenario for November 6th. If Romney wins, his total dishonesty towards the general electorate....will be more than mirrored in total dishonesty to HIS OWN BASE and a easy willingness to sell them out on everything from taxes to spending to "repealing Obamacare".

Not my "best scenario" (I want the President to win)....but not "worst" either.
 
I'd give the edge to Clinton over Reagan. Clinton left office with approvals in the high 60's. He achieved those approvals despite the "Lewinsky Pogroms" and the "visceral hatred". In fact..I'm confident that many of the very same people who so loudly and proudly indulgd in that visceral hatred publicly, would've pulled the lever for him in the privacy of the voting booth. It was all about the fact of his getting demonstrable results.

And, my intuition is that with the passage of Reagan/Clinton time, respect and nostalgia for Clinton has grown, while that for Reagan has diminshed somewhat.
 
From my own personal perspective, it wouldn't be a terrible thing if Romney won, because I'm economically in the top 2%. But I think it would be a disaster for the country, and not in any way mitigated by it being a "lesson hard learned" by the right-wing idiots who voted for him. My hope for that kind of learning moment died with Bush. If ANYTHING could have opened right-wing eyes to the ideological bankruptcy of the modern conservative movement and the idiocy of its standard bearers, it should have been 2001-2009. They got almost everything they wanted, and is was an outright catastrophe for the country and the world.... such a catastrophe that even they couldn't help but notice, to the extent that they now rule any mention of George W. Bush as out-of-bounds in our ongoing political discourse. But that didn't make them question their convictions even a little. It did nothing to immunize them against contracting the same illness again with Romney. They're ineducable. So, a Romney victory would simply be a negative for the country, with no real hope of those who made the mistakes learning anything useful from them. Even if he sells them out in ways they personally object to, they'll just find ways to blame the Democrats, just as they did with Bush on the rare occasion he deviated from the conservative orthodoxy (as when he briefly flirted with immigration reform).
 
Of all the modern presidents, Clinton had the highest approval ratings upon his exit, and you have a good point about how people might act in the privacy of the voting booth. It might be something where they think "I hate that man and everything he stands for, but he's been a good-luck charm for the country and I don't want to mess with that success." It would be a bit like having a player on your team who you can't stand, but who you'd never trade as long as the team is on a winning streak with him. But, I still think that the nostalgia for Reagan is stronger. People just seem to have forgotten what that period was really like, socially, economically, and politically.

That said, I guess another factor to think about is racial demographic. Reagan was used to running for election in a country where winning the non-hispanic white vote by any kind of margin was enough to win the overall election. These days, he'd need to appeal much more strongly to hispanics, and I'm not sure he'd have the right instincts for that.
 
Well, Arkady, I take Romney at his word....i.e. that he's lying his ass off.

One theory is, he means what he says. If he does, then he sets himself AND the GOP on the path to national political oblivion. That he WOULD pass a major tax cut and WOULD eliminate popular deductions and WOULD try to privatize Social Security/Medicare and thus see his and the Republican Party's polling go to the low 20s, due to massive public opposition to it.

The other theory is that once in office, the "Big Money Boys" in the Finance world would tell Mitt "Look, you can't pass entitlement reform....you CAN'T pass enough spending cuts...and you CAN'T cut deductions the middle class needs...so your tax plan would be a deficit buster and turn the dollar into Weimar Republican reichmarks".....and Mitt would "delay" his tax plan and hope to ride out a recovery that helped to decrease deficits while doing NOTHING....in other words continue the Obama policies, keep the OBAMA recovery going, and claim it for his own in 2016. Possbily even agree to some tax HIKES on the "jobs creators".

I think the 2nd is more likely....and more destructive to Rightwing Ideology since they would HAVE to support him and support him in a 2016 re-election bid. i.e. a repeat of HW Bush 1992.
 
Of all the modern presidents, Clinton had the highest approval ratings upon his exit, and you have a good point about how people might act in the privacy of the voting booth. It might be something where they think "I hate that man and everything he stands for, but he's been a good-luck charm for the country and I don't want to mess with that success." It would be a bit like having a player on your team who you can't stand, but who you'd never trade as long as the team is on a winning streak with him. But, I still think that the nostalgia for Reagan is stronger. People just seem to have forgotten what that period was really like, socially, economically, and politically.

That said, I guess another factor to think about is racial demographic. Reagan was used to running for election in a country where winning the non-hispanic white vote by any kind of margin was enough to win the overall election. These days, he'd need to appeal much more strongly to hispanics, and I'm not sure he'd have the right instincts for that.

The owner of the family-owned company for which I've worked all these years, is a Republican, albeit one in more of the traditional progressive Republican vein. I know that he and his family were Reagan fans. But...I was chatting with him one time - as I remember, it was in the lead up to the McCain/Obama election, and he let slip that in his opinion, Clinton "was the most conservative president we ever had".

To qualify of course, his "we ever had" went more to our lifetimes, not our entire history. And, his "conservative" went a heckuva lot more to say.....Eisenhower, than say...DeMint!
 
Back
Top