New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

New "Post Rating" plugin feedback needed

SW48

Administrator
Staff member
Supporting Member
How do you like the new "Post Rating" plugin?

Are there any ratings that you think should be removed?
 
I like it overall.

especially the dislike.

though i think too many....

my preference would be like, dislike, agree, disagree, and dumb. dumb rocks.
 
I like all of them, thanks. I hope we can experiment/have fun with all of them -- at least for a while.:)
 
I would say I will leave all of them up and see how it goes but I'll take recommendations for removal here in this thread.

The dislike and dumb will be abused.

Don't take that as a request for their removal, take it as a prediction based upon previous experience. Some will simply hit one of those buttons on every post made by the opposition.
 
Guarantee you they will be abused.

It's pathetic we can't have these new ratings without them being abused. I think they are a great addition if we can curb our inner child and be fair!
 
Guess I'm not sure how the ratings works. I know the number in green are our "likes"...but what are the other 2 numbers for?

I like that you have more options for ratings! I'm sure some will be abused by all of us... :)
 
Maybe the ratings rate a posters behavior. If you always get dumb or also always click dislike maybe your personal rating is bad.

I don't know, have to read up on it.
 
Maybe the ratings rate a posters behavior. If you always get dumb or also always click dislike maybe your personal rating is bad.

I don't know, have to read up on it.


I would ask people not to kneejerk, and only give "ratings" that are genuine but that wouldn't otherwise be expected. If we rubber-stamp "dumb" ratings for everyone we've traditionally disagreed with, the ratings will quickly become useless.
 
I would ask people not to kneejerk, and only give "ratings" that are genuine but that wouldn't otherwise be expected. If we rubber-stamp "dumb" ratings for everyone we've traditionally disagreed with, the ratings will quickly become useless.
That's what I meant when I guaranteed it will be abused.
 
Maybe the ratings rate a posters behavior. If you always get dumb or also always click dislike maybe your personal rating is bad.

I don't know, have to read up on it.
Likely if you get a lot of ratings of dumb it's because you make points that the 'other side' can't reply to and so resorts to clicking 'dumb' or 'dislike' as a substitute for substantive rebuttal. Frankly, I think that rating a person's post as 'dumb' or 'dislike' says more about the person doing the rating than the post being rated. If you think someone's post is dumb or you dislike it, respond to the damn post and counter it, or ignore it like I do the vast majority of posts from specific posters because there's little content and a lot of liberal or Obama bashing. I imagine there are those who feel the same way about posts from liberals bashing conservatives and similarly just scroll past them.

I like having the option to rate a post as 'like' or 'funny' but I just don't see the need to increase the negativity around here by adding insulting ratings. I got my first 'dumb' rating today. It came from a poster for whom I have absolutely no respect. Gosh, should I take it to heart and rethink my posting style? Not. Gonna. Happen.
 
How do you like the new "Post Rating" plugin?

Are there any ratings that you think should be removed?

Love it.
Thanks.
All ratings can stay...............I like options.

Is there any way that this rating ability can be added to conversations? That would be helpful too.
 
Likely if you get a lot of ratings of dumb it's because you make points that the 'other side' can't reply to and so resorts to clicking 'dumb' or 'dislike' as a substitute for substantive rebuttal. Frankly, I think that rating a person's post as 'dumb' or 'dislike' says more about the person doing the rating than the post being rated. If you think someone's post is dumb or you dislike it, respond to the damn post and counter it, or ignore it like I do the vast majority of posts from specific posters because there's little content and a lot of liberal or Obama bashing. I imagine there are those who feel the same way about posts from liberals bashing conservatives and similarly just scroll past them.

I like having the option to rate a post as 'like' or 'funny' but I just don't see the need to increase the negativity around here by adding insulting ratings. I got my first 'dumb' rating today. It came from a poster for whom I have absolutely no respect. Gosh, should I take it to heart and rethink my posting style? Not. Gonna. Happen.

I can't speak for everyone but I will not call something "dumb" just because I disagree with it. I will, however, call a post "dumb" if it is a gratuitous personal attack or if it is an attempt to derail the topic in an obviously dumb way.
 
gotta have dumb.

prediction: dumb ratings to skyrocket.....

;-)

Likely if you get a lot of ratings of dumb it's because you make points that the 'other side' can't reply to and so resorts to clicking 'dumb' or 'dislike' as a substitute for substantive rebuttal. Frankly, I think that rating a person's post as 'dumb' or 'dislike' says more about the person doing the rating than the post being rated. If you think someone's post is dumb or you dislike it, respond to the damn post and counter it, or ignore it like I do the vast majority of posts from specific posters because there's little content and a lot of liberal or Obama bashing. I imagine there are those who feel the same way about posts from liberals bashing conservatives and similarly just scroll past them.

I like having the option to rate a post as 'like' or 'funny' but I just don't see the need to increase the negativity around here by adding insulting ratings. I got my first 'dumb' rating today. It came from a poster for whom I have absolutely no respect. Gosh, should I take it to heart and rethink my posting style? Not. Gonna. Happen.

I had to agree with this.
Going through some of the threads this morning, I found one lib poster that had clicked "dumb" on almost every conservatives posts, and "like" or "agree" on every liberal post. But considering this person, I'm not surprised. Some will abuse it, but I think your statement was correct...."Likely if you get a lot of ratings of dumb it's because you make points that the 'other side' can't reply to and so resorts to clicking 'dumb' or 'dislike' as a substitute for substantive rebuttal".

I'm not saying I'll never use it myself, if I think something said IS really dumb, then I will...:) But I won't use it just because I don't care for the person posting it.
 
How do you like the new "Post Rating" plugin?

Are there any ratings that you think should be removed?
If we turn off alerts for "Likes" in Alerts Preferences,will that turn off alerts for the other ratings? The system is already being abused by some of the usual suspects.
 
Back
Top