New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

No one notices the real problems with scripture.

Days

Commentator
Ever notice how the same themes are repeated over and over? Always, when I read your arguments against scripture, it is this personal world you live in and how you can't accept this idea or that idea, which, funny enough, always seems to be connected more to your personal world than to the scriptures.

Well, I see some problems in scripture and in the church that go beyond the personal level. I've written about Genesis and how it frames the stars as "lights in the firmament"... those lights are not in the firmament, except possibly as far as our eye is concerned; the stars are far and way beyond the firmament. Saying God put lights up in the firmament, reads like a troglodyte wrote it. The whole old testament has this problem, the God of the old testament isn't just, merciful, loving, or the least bit fair. The best advice in the old testament was "Fear God and keep his commandments" ... because the guy had a terrible temper, and loved to kill people on the spot for any tiny mistake. When Jesus came along and called him a loving father... you wonder whether he was reading the same old testament.

Then we get the New Testament and all the old commandments are nailed to the cross. I have a problem with blood sacrifice. Too much of that going on in the ancient world... the gods all demanded human sacrifice... so just by demanding another blood sacrifice, this loving father looks suspect to me. But if we get to be rid of religion, maybe it is worth it. So now that it is all by faith, what do we read? A bunch of epistles laying down more religion... after we are told to forget trying to be good, just follow the holy spirit, then we are admonished to live pure lives, fulfilling the law, and doing all these good works... so while Paul would not have us fall from grace back to the Law, where does he go? Did you know that St Paul kept the law, his whole life?

Then we have this ascension question. Now, it seems a bit silly, after all, who cares where the ascension happened? No one. But Luke takes issue with the first two gospels, that claim Jesus had the apostles return to a mountain in Galilee, and there he delivered the apostolic mission and was parted from them. Luke says, wait a minute, the apostles never returned to Galilee, they remained in Jerusalem, and the ascension happened near there. That's why Luke begins by saying, he had perfect understanding of these matters... what he is saying is, he's right, Mark and Matthew are wrong. Then John comes back with, "hey, we returned to Galilee and went fishing and Jesus appeared to us on the shore, I was there, I'm not lying." But John leaves out the ascension.

The scriptures keep pointing to an Almighty God that created all things for his glory; but then, becomes very whimsical, changes his mind, destroys it all, and starts over. And this is a pattern with this almighty God.

As Christians, we are told we will resurrect from the dead, then undergo judgement, even though judgment was nailed to the cross once and for all, but we still get judged, even though we have nothing that we didn't receive, but somehow our flesh is still accountable for how good a steward it was with the gifts that we received, even though the flesh is not capable of stewardship, but if our judgment is not of our flesh, what is it of? It can't be of our spirits, because that part is blameless, that part is joined to the Lord. Nope it is the works of the flesh that burn. I'm fine with that, but what is our stewardship all about? How is that being judged? Isn't it hypocritical to say that the works of the flesh and the works of the spirit are separate and irreconcilable, but we are still accountable for them anyway? Paul says point blank, the flesh is not capable of fulfilling the faith; so why then is it judged? See, the religion creeps back in, we are told to live by faith, which means not by works, but then we are told to keep up those good works... we are told the flesh is not capable of fulfilling the will of the Lord, but then we are told to be a good steward of the faith... as if we were capable of it. The only steward of our faith is the holy spirit, he's the only one that can lead us and guide us, why are we then told to be "good stewards" ... the scriptures tell us to feed off the tree of life and leave off the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and then in the next breath, the scriptures return right back to the matter of being good... over and over.

I wasn't raised with this faith. I raised my son with it, he has no problem with it. I have lots of problems with it. We are told to work out our own salvation with fear and trembling... after we are told that the finished work of the cross accomplished all that for us and there's nothing for us to do; except believe. What exactly am I working out with fear and trembling? Why am I scared to death of failing a stewardship if all the works come down from above and it is God that is at work, not me? How can I fail something that I am not doing? Why am I told to stop my own works, rest in his rest, let him do the work, and then work out my own salvation? makes no sense at all. In my household, we say, "whatever the Lord is doing" and "in the Lord's time" ... we don't work out our own salvation, we leave that to the holy spirit.

Well, it is bedtime. I don't have any set prayers. But I do pray, constantly. I taught my son that there are no prayer rules. If you eat your food and then remember to give thanks and ask for a blessing, go ahead and pray then. We don't let religion trip us up, our faith is the whole enchilada. I see all kinds of human faults in the scriptures, but I see God in there, too. I don't understand why God did what he did, I don't know what he is thinking, I'm not even sure he is thinking, I still haven't figured out what "in his image, after his likeness" is supposed to tell me about me, let alone about God. One thing I have learned, grace and mercy are paramount to the Christian faith, even it doesn't hurt to show those to the writers of scripture. After all, they were humans, too.
 
You say that scripture has "problems". The problem may be yours - in terms of your interpretations - and not with scripture.

For instance...you allude to the "firmament" and the fact that the per the modern definition of the word, scripture uses it unscientifically. But...so what? To many of us, "scripture" stemming from whatever religion, represents simple stories or parables and is not intended to be taken literally. So...if the intent is to suggest that "God made the stars" (or whatever), what point would there be in explaining this concept to people of several millenia ago, using 21st-Century language?

So...in consideration of my premise (which you're certainly free to accept or reject!), I don't believe that the Old Testament God was the cantankerous "smiter", literal interpreters of The Bible assume he was. The Old Testament was simply "parablizing" the idea that people or peoples who acted counter to God's will, would pay a price. Times were tougher 5,000 years ago (or so), than they are today. Today, we can put the "fear of God" into someone by threatening them with 30 days in jail (with a cot and 3 squares). Back then, it was necessary to speak in terms of "smiting", in order to get the point across, even as God didn't ACTUALLY do any smiting.
 
All of those questions are why faith is important.
I have many of those same questions you asked. But the writers of scripture wrote from their own experience. They had nothing else to draw from. So we have to use that and hope we can extract what is important.

I always remember that "God is Love". I have read many life after death stories and they all have one thing in common: Love.

Love comes in lots of forms and is shown in many ways.

Love can be nurturing
Love can be admonishing
Love can be "tough"
Love can be sexual
Love can encourage
Love can instruct

So I strive to love all of God's creatures. And of course, I frequently fail. But I always hope to do better next time. There is hope in the future.

There are three things more important than anything else in this life: Faith, Hope, and Love. And the greatest of them is Love.
And that is what I believe.
Jen
 
Go outside at evening time and the firmament is still lit and the stars and the moon appear to be in the firmament. It isn't rocket science.

Did you read where King David was upset with God when he smote his best priest for steadying the cart on which the ark was riding when David was bringing the ark back to Jerusalem? David laid up the ark for an unplanned rest stop and argued with God about easing up on his priests. Eventually David returned the ark without further incident.

The bigger difference between you and I lies in our relationship with the Almighty. Mine is a personal faith, yours is a religious obligation. So we read the scriptures differently. That's to be expected.
 
The writers were human, but without God's inspiration, I doubt a bunch of fishermen from Galilee had anything meaningful to say that would have lasted 2000 years. With that inspiration, Peter warned us that the elements themselves would be set on fire... 1800 years before a nuclear chain reaction was part of mankind's scientific acumen.

Paul was a religious zealot, he was a murderer, he was a monster. He was the last guy you ever imagined would end up writing the deepest and most meaningful words ever written on what Love is and what Love does.

Most of my problems with scripture arose from my ministerial background, when I read personally, I accept flaws, I understand that the best of the prophets were flawed... look at Peter the night of Jesus torture, and later on, Paul had to stand up to his withdrawing from the gentile brethren... but when Paul had his big falling out with Barnabus, (over John Mark) it was Peter who took in John Mark. These men grew in grace and love and that's the whole lesson.

keep the faith,
Days
 
Some great books for people who are fascinated by Scripture and the elements of the sublime, awesome, or uncanny in it, but who are also inveterate doubters:

George Santayana, Interpretations of Poetry in Religion
Walter Kaufmann, Faith of a Heretic
Critique of Religion and Philosophy
 
And Paul Tillich. Nietzsche and Marx are important too, but what I like about Kaufmann especially is that he doesn't try to tell you what to think so much as how to approach these questions. He is a great admirer of Wittgenstein and employs thought-experiments reminiscent of his, but he is also steeped in the culture of existentialism (fear and trembling, if you will) that so many analytic philosophers shy away from.
 
Days---THE Paul you write about who has so much of the New Testament attributed to him was NOT the Paul, the Apostle. Paul who wrote much of the New Testament never met Jesus. He hated the early Christians (hence those who arose from the Jesus Christ guy). And that Paul, had a spiritual conversion on the road to Damascus. So, he was NOT the Paul who was one of the 12. Paul wrote in about 60 to 95CE a while after Jesus and the original 12 lived.

The name Paul was common. But definitely NOT the same Paul.

Also much of what is attributed to Paul most scholars agree was added later, like around 200-330 CE. They know this because the earliest copies (witnesses) of what became the New Testament (402 CE) did not have a lot that Paul supposedly wrote. And when you read separately the passages that Were ONLY found in the later copies it is obvious they were added to give the CHURCH more power. Please much of the New Testament was added later (200-400 CE).

It baffles me how so many Christians seem to NOT want to know anything about actual HISTORY or facts known about how the Scriptures that were put in the New Testament got there (and how other popular Scriptures of the early Christians also did NOT get put in what was to become The New Testament). The Dead Sea Scrolls and other finds had a lot of Scriptures that never made it to the New Testament
 
Myself, I came upon the spiritual world through the worst of portals; books written by an apprentice sorcerer of the native American Papago tribe shammans. I more or less stumbled into God and then asked him which faith I should serve him with; the reply surprised me, he said to run after the old Jesus story... I've been running after it ever since.
 
Saul of Tarsus, who took his Roman name Paul for his Christian name... there was only one of those. More books have been written on St Paul than any other human being to walk the earth (post flood). Paul changed the face of civilization. An amazing character, both brilliant and passionate... and controversial. And confusing... even in his day.
 
The writers were human, but without God's inspiration, I doubt a bunch of fishermen from Galilee had anything meaningful to say that would have lasted 2000 years. With that inspiration, Peter warned us that the elements themselves would be set on fire... 1800 years before a nuclear chain reaction was part of mankind's scientific acumen.

Paul was a religious zealot, he was a murderer, he was a monster. He was the last guy you ever imagined would end up writing the deepest and most meaningful words ever written on what Love is and what Love does.

Most of my problems with scripture arose from my ministerial background, when I read personally, I accept flaws, I understand that the best of the prophets were flawed... look at Peter the night of Jesus torture, and later on, Paul had to stand up to his withdrawing from the gentile brethren... but when Paul had his big falling out with Barnabus, (over John Mark) it was Peter who took in John Mark. These men grew in grace and love and that's the whole lesson.

keep the faith,
Days

The flaws in the Bible are because they were written by many men over the years. It is their thoughts,not God.

As you said Days, my faith is personal.It depends on no institution.The institution for me is just to share with others my faith.It is not my job to make others have faith. You can guide,not force!
 
Days---THE Paul you write about who has so much of the New Testament attributed to him was NOT the Paul, the Apostle. Paul who wrote much of the New Testament never met Jesus. He hated the early Christians (hence those who arose from the Jesus Christ guy). And that Paul, had a spiritual conversion on the road to Damascus. So, he was NOT the Paul who was one of the 12. Paul wrote in about 60 to 95CE a while after Jesus and the original 12 lived.

The name Paul was common. But definitely NOT the same Paul.

Also much of what is attributed to Paul most scholars agree was added later, like around 200-330 CE. They know this because the earliest copies (witnesses) of what became the New Testament (402 CE) did not have a lot that Paul supposedly wrote. And when you read separately the passages that Were ONLY found in the later copies it is obvious they were added to give the CHURCH more power. Please much of the New Testament was added later (200-400 CE).

It baffles me how so many Christians seem to NOT want to know anything about actual HISTORY or facts known about how the Scriptures that were put in the New Testament got there (and how other popular Scriptures of the early Christians also did NOT get put in what was to become The New Testament). The Dead Sea Scrolls and other finds had a lot of Scriptures that never made it to the New Testament

Thanks, Zoar for that. May I ask what books you suggest to give a greater understanding of how the Bible was rewritten?
 
I am very glad those men were flawed. That means there is hope for me. I am hugely flawed. I see that every single day of my life.

The writers were human, but without God's inspiration, I doubt a bunch of fishermen from Galilee had anything meaningful to say that would have lasted 2000 years. With that inspiration, Peter warned us that the elements themselves would be set on fire... 1800 years before a nuclear chain reaction was part of mankind's scientific acumen.

Paul was a religious zealot, he was a murderer, he was a monster. He was the last guy you ever imagined would end up writing the deepest and most meaningful words ever written on what Love is and what Love does.

Most of my problems with scripture arose from my ministerial background, when I read personally, I accept flaws, I understand that the best of the prophets were flawed... look at Peter the night of Jesus torture, and later on, Paul had to stand up to his withdrawing from the gentile brethren... but when Paul had his big falling out with Barnabus, (over John Mark) it was Peter who took in John Mark. These men grew in grace and love and that's the whole lesson.

keep the faith,
Days
 
Agreed, MaryAnne. My faith is personal too. An institution allows (or would allow) me to be in the presence of other people who may have similar faith and it might enable me to hear inspiring words, but my faith is my own. I can talk about it, but everyone has to find their own faith. Some find it, others do not. I'm not sure it's even a choice. I don't know enough to rule out predestination (at least to some extent).]


The flaws in the Bible are because they were written by many men over the years. It is their thoughts,not God.

As you said Days, my faith is personal.It depends on no institution.The institution for me is just to share with others my faith.It is not my job to make others have faith. You can guide,not force!
 
Agreed, MaryAnne. My faith is personal too. An institution allows (or would allow) me to be in the presence of other people who may have similar faith and it might enable me to hear inspiring words, but my faith is my own. I can talk about it, but everyone has to find their own faith. Some find it, others do not. I'm not sure it's even a choice. I don't know enough to rule out predestination (at least to some extent).]

This is what most people do not understand about the contradictions in the Bible.They concentrate on that,without seeing the big picture. That is why it is impossible to explain to many who want answers.

You know it when you accept,but there is no way to explain to what many,who do not believe,and we may as well accept that.

What really strikes me is that so many who claim to not believe want to discuss over and over again. They have to be searching for answers. :eek:)

Too many accidents in life for me to believe in Predestiantion,but that is just me.I respect those who do.
The only answer I have for that is for us to try and make good come from bad.
 
Go outside at evening time and the firmament is still lit and the stars and the moon appear to be in the firmament. It isn't rocket science.

Did you read where King David was upset with God when he smote his best priest for steadying the cart on which the ark was riding when David was bringing the ark back to Jerusalem? David laid up the ark for an unplanned rest stop and argued with God about easing up on his priests. Eventually David returned the ark without further incident.

The bigger difference between you and I lies in our relationship with the Almighty. Mine is a personal faith, yours is a religious obligation. So we read the scriptures differently. That's to be expected.

You couldn't be more wrong when you ascribe my beliefs to "religious obligation". Of course...it doesn't really matter as far as I'm concerned. But...maybe the fact that you so fundamentally misperceived MY view, tells us a little about YOUR perspective? Whaddya think?
 
You say that scripture has "problems". The problem may be yours - in terms of your interpretations - and not with scripture.

For instance...you allude to the "firmament" and the fact that the per the modern definition of the word, scripture uses it unscientifically. But...so what? To many of us, "scripture" stemming from whatever religion, represents simple stories or parables and is not intended to be taken literally. So...if the intent is to suggest that "God made the stars" (or whatever), what point would there be in explaining this concept to people of several millenia ago, using 21st-Century language?

So...in consideration of my premise (which you're certainly free to accept or reject!), I don't believe that the Old Testament God was the cantankerous "smiter", literal interpreters of The Bible assume he was. The Old Testament was simply "parablizing" the idea that people or peoples who acted counter to God's will, would pay a price. Times were tougher 5,000 years ago (or so), than they are today. Today, we can put the "fear of God" into someone by threatening them with 30 days in jail (with a cot and 3 squares). Back then, it was necessary to speak in terms of "smiting", in order to get the point across, even as God didn't ACTUALLY do any smiting.

Fair, the "smiting" was done IN THE NAME OF GOD. "God" was the scapegoat used to justify the atrocities committed by the early Israelites when they were expanding their territory. Today we might be feeling the effects of that early expansion.
 
Okay, I'll let you answer for yourself... tell us about your personal relationship with Jesus.... what day were you born again? baptized? Were you called to preach? Were you called to ministry? go ahead.

I'll give my answers in advance ...

born again?
May 13, 1981

baptized?
November 27, 1981

called to preach?
Spring, 1982

called to ministry?
Spring 1984

Remember, Fair, these are your acts, not someone else acting for you. I had people pray for me before May 13, 1981, but I didn't say my own prayer asking Jesus into my heart until that evening. And I had no miracles happen with light coming into my eyes until that evening. I was baptized in the Roman Catholic Church when I was a baby, but I did not have the testimony of faith in the Lord Jesus Christ at one month old... I had that when an old man baptized me in a bathtub on November 27, 1981, and I experienced another miracle from the Holy Ghost sealing my temple (my body).

Alright, so answer with your own experiences, tell us about your personal relationship with jesus that goes beyond the religious regimen of the Catholic Church.

And if that testimony exists, let me ask you... why did you hide that candle under a bushel basket?
 
I hear ya.

What is commonly done, is cry about the imperfections and flaws in scripture as proof that there is no God... because people who do not know God, think God is some kind of absolute invisible force that knows everything and can do anything, they don't grasp ideas like Light, Love, Spirit. But the scriptures tell us God is Light, Love, and Spirit. (not perfection) And when the scriptures do speak of perfection... it would best be translated as maturity. (not infinity)

without flaws, life would suck. And Life is the whole ball game. God is a life giver, we are trees of Life, it is all about life.
 
Back
Top