New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

No, I don't think we'll ever see a presidential election postponed. If it were to happen, the election postponement wouldn't be the story of the day because there would have to be something truly extreme happening in the nation to prompt an election postponement.
 
Not Civil War -- but our Second War For Independence

We didn't even postpone the national election in 1864, when the country was in the midst of a terrible Civil War.

[Down in the South, they call it 'The War of Northern Aggression'.]



Genereal Stonewall Jackson was right - 1861 was our Second War For Independence. A majority of voters in the eleven states voted to form a new country. I had at least 9 great grandfathers in the first War For Independence -- and not a one had the right to vote for or against forming a new country. One branch of my 'kin way back then' remain loyal to the Crown - and resettled in Nova Scotia.

Yes- I'm white. No- not for slavery. Yes- voted Obama in '08. Yes- will vote for Obama again.

But if a majority of Tennesseans vote for independence I'll stand at our borders ready to defend -but if Teaparty nuts rule a free tennbessee I would relocate.
 
If any president DID postpone an election, depending on circumstance he could be impeached for a fundimental violation of constitutional authority.

Translation: it better be one whale of a situation that only postponing could solve.
 
Genereal Stonewall Jackson was right - 1861 was our Second War For Independence. A majority of voters in the eleven states voted to form a new country. I had at least 9 great grandfathers in the first War For Independence -- and not a one had the right to vote for or against forming a new country. One branch of my 'kin way back then' remain loyal to the Crown - and resettled in Nova Scotia.

Yes- I'm white. No- not for slavery. Yes- voted Obama in '08. Yes- will vote for Obama again.

But if a majority of Tennesseans vote for independence I'll stand at our borders ready to defend -but if Teaparty nuts rule a free tennbessee I would relocate.

Even though I think the country would be better off without Tennessee, you do NOT have the right to unilaterally secede from the Union. The Supreme Court has already ruled on that question.

I had several ancestors who died in the Civil War. They were fighting to free the slaves. The rebels who killed them were fighting to preserve slavery. I know which cause was the more honorable one.
 
Since the South fired the first shots, no, I don't think 'The War of Northern Aggression' is remotely accurate. In fact, in the first few years of the war, it was Southern armies invading the North, more than Northern armies invading the South. The tide didn't turn until after Gettysburg. You do know that Gettysburg is well within Pennsylvania, right??

States do not have a right to unilaterally secede from the Union. The Supreme Court has ruled on this. On the other hand, if the state of Hawaii, say, wanted to become independent, and the rest of the country was agreeable to this, they would be allowed to do so.

I clearly stated, "Some believe the north was the aggressor, others believe the north was forced to act because of the southern initiation of war acts...", did I not?

And while battles were indeed fought on northern land the goals of the confederate government simply never included overthrowing the US government, merely to withdraw themselves from it, so sorry, the far more accepted, "Civil War", title is not even remotely accurate either.
 
I had several ancestors who died in the Civil War. They were fighting to free the slaves. The rebels who killed them were fighting to preserve slavery. I know which cause was the more honorable one.


LeRoy,

I'm surprised that you would maintain such a simplistic view of the Civil War.
 
I clearly stated, "Some believe the north was the aggressor, others believe the north was forced to act because of the southern initiation of war acts...", did I not?

Yes, you did. And then you spent the rest of your post trying to justify the use of the term 'The War of Northern Aggression'.

And while battles were indeed fought on northern land the goals of the confederate government simply never included overthrowing the US government, merely to withdraw themselves from it, so sorry, the far more accepted, "Civil War", title is not even remotely accurate either.

You are asking us to accept your definition of the term 'Civil War' as ALWAYS meaning there is a goal of overthrowing a central government. I know of no political scientist who would accept your definition.
 
Boca, as someone noted...we had a Presidential election....DURING THE CIVIL WAR.

So "short of nuclear war or a meteor approaching"....what scenario COULD be bad enough to call for a postponment?
 
LeRoy,

I'm surprised that you would maintain such a simplistic view of the Civil War.

From where I sit, the Civil War was a contest between good and evil, between right and wrong. Call that simplistic if you want. Doesn't bother me.

Abraham Lincoln: If slavery is not wrong, then nothing is wrong.
 
I clearly stated, "Some believe the north was the aggressor, others believe the north was forced to act because of the southern initiation of war acts...", did I not?

And while battles were indeed fought on northern land the goals of the confederate government simply never included overthrowing the US government, merely to withdraw themselves from it, so sorry, the far more accepted, "Civil War", title is not even remotely accurate either.

I always find those who argue the finer points of "Who was responsible for the Civil War"...against traditional thought.....to be those who think "The wrong side won".

:)
 
I had several ancestors who died in the Civil War. They were fighting to free the slaves. The rebels who killed them were fighting to preserve slavery. I know which cause was the more honorable one.

It's highly unlikely that the rebels who killed them ever owned any slaves.
 
Lincoln rope- a- doped usins

[Confederate Vice President, Alexander] Stephens identified the beginning of the war as Lincoln's order sending a "hostile fleet, styled the 'Relief Squadron'," to reinforce Fort Sumter. "The war was then and there inaugurated and begun by the authorities at Washington. General Beauregard did not open fire upon Fort Sumter until this fleet was, to his knowledge, very near the harbor of Charleston, and until he had inquired of Major Anderson . . . whether he would engage to take no part in the expected blow, then coming down upon him from the approaching fleet . . . When Major Anderson . . .would make no such promise, it became necessary for General Beauregard to strike the first blow, as he did; otherwise the forces under his command might have been exposed to two fires at the same time-- one in front, and the other in the rear." The use of force by the Confederacy , therefore, was in "self-defence," rendered necessary by the actions of the other side.

http://www.tulane.edu/~sumter/Reflections/LinWar.html
 
Boca...how did Beauregard know a fleet was coming? Satellite photography or the Confederate Air Recon units?


BTW, quoting the aggressors? I'm sure the Japanese had the same excuses for why THEY had to "strike the first blow".
 
1) Short of a nuclear war breaking out, or an approaching meteor, whatever ...under what conditions would you be comfortable with postponing a General Election?

2) Would extreme weather be one reason?

3) Who would you accept as having the authority to do so (.... a court, the Congress, etc.)?


This should be fun...by the way, does anyone know if it's ever happened?

Extreme weather could be valid justification IMO.
 
Wrong LeRoy

Even though I think the country would be better off without Tennessee, you do NOT have the right to unilaterally secede from the Union. The Supreme Court has already ruled on that question.

I had several ancestors who died in the Civil War. They were fighting to free the slaves. The rebels who killed them were fighting to preserve slavery. I know which cause was the more honorable one.



My 9 greatgrandfathersw were rebels. My great grandfather and grand uncles fought for a new country. i guess you must be one of the Tea Party nuts -- but if my state voted to leave the union it would have the right to leave. Lincoln for negroes? No way. He wanted to expell them to somewhere else. Lincoln the first Republican president charted the course for nearly all other republican presidents or would be president by being loose with the truth.

Vote Obama -- storm or no storm!
 
Drones....either that or southern sympathizers and condeferate spies who saw troops boarding the military expedition vessels at various ports. Not to mention that the Union Commander of Fort Sumter, Major Anderson, conceded as much, to General Beauregard.

You need to learn to read with comprehension Gordy.

By the way, have you checked in with an answer to the question?
 
Back
Top