New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

not to forget that in their attempts to get american help, the french had done a fine job of convincing the mcarthyist americans that ho chi minh was a chinese pawn and that the domino theory was a real fact.

As Herb Cain would say..."I don't have facts to back this up", but......I still think that in the early 50's, the more proximate concern was France "going commie", than Indochina "going commie". Although no doubt, France's anti-communist faction, probably found a willing audience in the McCarthyites. But...I think an American "surrender-monkey" meme as regards the French, was alive and well back in the 50's and "enjoyed" considerable overlap with the McCarthyites. And therefore, they were MORE than willing to take over for the French - who apparently (in their "minds") weren't willing to defend themselves from the Soviet-commies - and "show them how real men handle these things".
 
As Herb Cain would say..."I don't have facts to back this up", but......I still think that in the early 50's, the more proximate concern was France "going commie", than Indochina "going commie". Although no doubt, France's anti-communist faction, probably found a willing audience in the McCarthyites. But...I think an American "surrender-monkey" meme as regards the French, was alive and well back in the 50's and "enjoyed" considerable overlap with the McCarthyites. And therefore, they were MORE than willing to take over for the French - who apparently (in their "minds") weren't willing to defend themselves from the Soviet-commies - and "show them how real men handle these things".

they wouldnt have felt a need to take over if they hadnt swallowed the domino theory hook line and sinker. shit, those fricken dulles brothers had everyone believing that the commies were gonna take over australia!! hahahahaahahahahahaah
 
I ould foresee one or two

IF one of the cadidates were to die.
Congress would have to make the decisions.
A national eletion has never been postponed, however a mayoral one was in 2001 when 911 occured
 
No Color. The "filibuster anything" was a GOP tactic. Remember that the Dems controlled the Senate through 1992. It was the GOP (in the form of folks like Sniely Wiplash aka Slade Gorton (R-WA)) who did things like "blue slip" judicial candidates. It was the Dems who got rid of Blue Slipping, not the GOP. The GOP only got pissed about this when Ted Kennedy basically threatend to filibuster Bork if it ever got to the nomination stage. He wasn't wrong. TO THIS DAY Bork refuses to answer the question as to whether he thinks women are legally persons under the Constitution (if you take his writings, you will see that absent an ERA, he does not see any Constitutional precedent for women being considered "persons".).
 
That was interesting thanks. Caused me to look at some other articles about Buchanan's efforts. They're all pretty much the same as to the facts but differ somewhat in the interpretation. Not much different than what we do with the facts today.

Anyway, now I'm left to wonder why historians and textbooks focus soley on Lincoln's provocation and not Buchanan's as the start of the war. I suppose it's that Sumter was abandoned and lost that time, or it could be, I don't know, that the Union ships may have fired first in the Buchanan raid which didn't fit the desired narrative that the South was the aggressor, making it easier for Licoln to get the 70,000 troops he wanted to fight the war he wanted in the first place?

Whaddya think?
 
There's an 1845 federal law that stipulates the date of federal elections. Are you saying a president can just ignore it?
 
There's an 1845 federal law that stipulates the date of federal elections. Are you saying a president can just ignore it?

That's a seperate, albeit parallel track. The Constitution "says" that only Congress may determine the election day. But...nowhere does it say that the President may NOT cancel elections on that day. And by the same token, nowhere does it say that IF elections are to be cancelled on a particular day, it can only be done by Congress.

The Constitution doesn't speak directly to the President's powers, vis a vis elections. But, I think we can rely on the various and exceedingly broad powers assumed to the executive, to conclude that IF a President wanted to cancel an election day, he could do it.

I imagine the Constitutional truth of this matter is that the President can cancel an election at his whim, but he can't establish a new election date. Congress would have to do that.
 
For your information, professional historians are in agreement with me that slavery was the PRIMARY cause of the Civil War.

A) Not all of them.

B) We weren't discussing the primary cause, and your attempt to reframe the discussion as such betrays the characteristics of a petulent sore loser.
 
A) Not all of them.

B) We weren't discussing the primary cause, and your attempt to reframe the discussion as such betrays the characteristics of a petulent sore loser.

A) Excuse me. I should have phrased it in the following way: A very large majority of professional historians are in agreement that slavery was the primary cause of the Civil War. Are you disputing that? If so, please let me know, as I should be happy to prove you wrong.

B) We certainly were discussing the primary cause of the Civil War. Go back and review the thread, starting with page one. The discussion on the Civil War began when I noted that we did not postpone the national election in 1864, despite being in the midst of a terrible Civil War, which I noted is called 'The War of Northern Aggression' by some folks in the South. And that led to a string of posters insisting that that description was just as accurate as calling it 'The Civil War'. Did you think we were only discussing the secondary and tertiary causes of the war???
 
A) Excuse me. I should have phrased it in the following way: A very large majority of professional historians are in agreement that slavery was the primary cause of the Civil War. Are you disputing that? If so, please let me know, as I should be happy to prove you wrong.

B) We certainly were discussing the primary cause of the Civil War. Go back and review the thread, starting with page one. The discussion on the Civil War began when I noted that we did not postpone the national election in 1864, despite being in the midst of a terrible Civil War, which I noted is called 'The War of Northern Aggression' by some folks in the South. And that led to a string of posters insisting that that description was just as accurate as calling it 'The Civil War'. Did you think we were only discussing the secondary and tertiary causes of the war???

You seem to be confusing me with someone else.

I merely disagreed with your fairytale notion that it was a simple case of good vs evil. And when you say that the primary motivation of the rebel solidier was to preserve the insititution of slavery, you couldn't possibly be more wrong.
 
Back
Top