While I don't know the exact books you're referring to, I suspect that they are the same or at least much like the ones that I read over 50 years ago.
My parents were not church goers but they gave me complete freedom to wander into any of my friends churches that I wanted to. I even attended Sunday School for a while.
Even as a child I kept questioning the things they were trying to teach me and I was totally unsatisfied with their 'answers'. It always came to the part where I was told there was no answer, you just had to have faith. I never did buy that one. It was in my late teens and early twenties that I really started to read everything I could find on spiritualism, reincarnation, ghosts, mediums, psychics, etc. I learned that there was much fakery involved in that pursuit, but I also learned that there were a number of 'situations' that could not be discounted by anyone.
There are quite a few examples of people being taken through past life regression using hypnosis where they have been able to come up with facts and descriptions of things that they would have absolutely no other way of knowing. So yes, I do believe in reincarnation and for the reasons that you outlined. I also believe that many of those who have gone on before us are still around us in another dimension. Because of different vibrations they are rarely able to communicate with us but occasionally they can. If it was a common thing it would defeat the whole purpose of the lessons that we need to learn on our own.
The part that I have a problem with is the "God is love" belief that people profess to have. While that may well be true, it's the directions that the acolytes have taken it in that I find hypocritical at best. If one truly believed that "God is love" then one would not tolerate the constant killing of supposed enemies. A loving God would never direct people to literally wipe out other groups of people as has occurred throughout our history and is still going on. Some of the most heinous of crimes get committed by people who profess to love God by whatever name.
Conversely, evil is just as real. We must constantly guard against the influences of the negative energies, souls that would lead us away from our whole reason for being.
My parents were very religious and came from very religious families. Not just religious in name only, they lived the life and did the best they could with the understanding they had and it was consistent and adequate. I came to the conclusion early that I could not just take their religion by heredity. I had to have my own beliefs or it would be theirs, not mine. So I have read everything possible also.
I do believe that the Soul reincarnates. If a Soul is eternal, why would it live just one life? And the Soul has memories and parts of every life it has lived. But amnesia comes to the Soul shortly before or after birth so we don't come into this life actively knowing what our Soul knows. The Soul still learns.
Just as it is rarely possible for those beings in other dimensions to converse with us, the amnesia is necessary for the learning that we are supposed to have here and now to take place. Of course, I think it's about time my amnesia goes away, but, that's just my frustration at knowing it's there but not knowing what it is .
I have some trouble sorting out Good and Evil also. Some of the books I have read discount Evil altogether. They say that the Soul of a person who has been evil in life is separated from other Souls at death, cleaned, healed........and if it can't be fixed, stripped and reworked (sort of like a computer I guess). In that theory, all Souls are good, but some are put into bodies that have such evil things happening to them from the beginning that it taints the Soul, sometimes irreparably. Those Souls cannot mix with the population of loving Souls so they are separated until they are fixed.
That sounds okay, sort of, but I wonder if, perhaps, there is a dimension where Loving Souls inhabit and another dimension where Evil Souls are. I do believe that there is a battle waging of Good vs Evil. Evil is far too prevalent for it to be just a few wayward Souls.
As for the God is Love idea, I believe that God IS Love. That's where it gets sticky. If there is a war between Good and Evil........aka Love vs Fear.... then unless Good plans to lose the battle it has to kill Evil. But killing itself is evil. So that presents a dilemma. Every idea I have on how to work this out comes to a dead end. So I don't have that answer yet. Maybe as we continue to read we will find the answer, Boltlady.
I recommend the books I named for Wahbooz. I got a lot of information just by reading the synopsis on Amazon and reading the words of the people who read them. It was enough to make me want to read the books and I'm glad I did. I have also read the book
Angels by Billy Graham twice. I might read it again now that I have read those other two. I agree that many of the books out there are trash. I try to avoid them.