New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Nuclear War?

If he had a coherent plan for Syria, I haven't discerned it. He seems to believe in fighting a war without really fighting a war. He drew red lines, and when they were crossed, he blinked.

To me, you either stay out of Syria, or you go in and fight with a clear objective of winning. You don't talk about 'containment' - that costs lives and leaves another war to fight later. If he has no stomach for war, I'm fine with that also. Then we should get out entirely; in fact, that would be the preferred option as far as I'm concerned. He wants it both ways, he can't have it, and so he puts everyone at risk and achieves nothing.

That's a muddled, and disastrous, foreign policy. It is a contributing factor to the mess in Syria. Will he fix it before the end of his term? Not likely. Step one would be admitting failure, and that will likely stop him dead in his tracks.

Winning what? Regime change and theft is the aim so far --- as usual.
 
Which one do you prefer?

For my part, I think containment is preferable to large-scale involvement, though non-intervention would be better than either, in this case.

Your criticism reminds me a lot of the rote talking points of conservatives about Clinton's engagement in Yugoslavia, in the 1990s. Outlets like the National Review couldn't decide whether to come down in favor of greater or lesser engagement in Yugoslavia than the course Clinton followed, but there was a partisan political imperative to argue that what Clinton was doing --whatever that might end up being-- was dead wrong. So, they went with the safe, vague partisan argument that his middle way was wrong. They were sure that either you go with a full-scale "boots on the ground" invasion (fight with a clear objective of winning), or you don't intervene at all. They figured that since Clinton chose a middle way, then surely that way must be doomed to failure -- mere air strikes weren't going to stop the genocide or secure Bosnia, Kosovo, and Croatia. Clinton's route surely wouldn't lead to the fall of Karadzic and Milosovic. Right?

Although I criticize Obama's foreign policy, I'm enough of a student of history that I don't fall into that mindless template of National Review talking points. I know how Clinton's limited engagement in Yugoslavia actually turned out, here in the real world. I know that for a very limited investment of US blood and treasure, and with an actual return on international prestige, we managed to intervene in a way that had large, positive, long-term consequences. I'm not terribly hopeful Obama will be as successful as that in the Middle East, but I don't rule out the possibility.


I stated my preferred option as to 'get out'. We are only in Syria because Obama put us there.

If he doesn't want to get out, he should at least fight with an objective of winning.

As for "boots on the ground", I didn't suggest that, although the President did put fifty pair there. You can do a lot with an air war, provided you do not limit yourself to 7 sorties a day (Clinton ran about 140 a day in Kosovo), you don't tell ISIS in advance when and where you plan to bomb with leaflets, and you take out oil fields, which provide a huge revenue stream for the enemy (no money = no bullets).

Get out or fight in a meaningful way. He'll do neither, and so on and on it will go, and everyone will pay.
 
I stated my preferred option as to 'get out'. We are only in Syria because Obama put us there.

If he doesn't want to get out, he should at least fight with an objective of winning.

As for "boots on the ground", I didn't suggest that, although the President did put fifty pair there. You can do a lot with an air war, provided you do not limit yourself to 7 sorties a day (Clinton ran about 140 a day in Kosovo), you don't tell ISIS in advance when and where you plan to bomb with leaflets, and you take out oil fields, which provide a huge revenue stream for the enemy (no money = no bullets).

Get out or fight in a meaningful way. He'll do neither, and so on and on it will go, and everyone will pay.
I'm agreed about getting out. We've demonstrated an incredible ability to turn whatever we touch in the Middle East to shit, and we'd be better off refraining from touching any of it. If the EU, or the Saudis, or Russia want to try their hand at screwing around with the region for a while, so be it. We have no moral standing to object, as the most active military interventionist in the world. But we should wash our hands of it and let them face the consequences of their actions. Russia, in particular, is already an incredibly active target for terrorism, and they're positioning themselves for even worse by creating Middle-East chaos and anti-Russian hatred.
 
One Democrat is sounding the alarm:

President Barack Obama is risking a nuclear war against Russian President Vladimir Putin the minute he decided to deploy American fighter jets on the border between Turkey and Syria, according to Representative Tulsi Gabbard of Hawaii.
The deployment of a specialized expeditionary targeting force announced on Tuesday and the president’s vocal objection of President Bashar al-Assad, Mr. Putin’s strong ally, could lead America into a nuclear standoff with Russia, Gabbard said.

“Russia’s installation of their anti-aircraft missile-defense system increases that possibility of – whether it’s intentional or even an accident event – where one side may shoot down the other side’s plane. And that’s really where the potential is for devastating nuclear war,” Gabbard told Defense secretary Ashton Carter as quoted by the National Review.


http://www.morningnewsusa.com/obama-vs-putin-nuclear-war-looms-2346611.html


Well, Obama did want a legacy......



While there are some 18 wars going on right now in the world and a spark could ignite a world war I don't see the US or Russia using nukes on each other. Seems far fetched.
 
I'm agreed about getting out. We've demonstrated an incredible ability to turn whatever we touch in the Middle East to shit, and we'd be better off refraining from touching any of it. If the EU, or the Saudis, or Russia want to try their hand at screwing around with the region for a while, so be it. We have no moral standing to object, as the most active military interventionist in the world. But we should wash our hands of it and let them face the consequences of their actions. Russia, in particular, is already an incredibly active target for terrorism, and they're positioning themselves for even worse by creating Middle-East chaos and anti-Russian hatred.

I am starting to think just pulling back and letting whatever is going to happen in the Middle East may be the best strategy because at the end of the day even if we went in cleaned it all up and put a new government in place, in 10 years the same isis ideology would seep back into the middle east wherever there is a power vacuum and we would lose all that is gained.

Some people are just not capable of being ruled by anything but a dictator.
 
I'm agreed about getting out. We've demonstrated an incredible ability to turn whatever we touch in the Middle East to shit, and we'd be better off refraining from touching any of it. If the EU, or the Saudis, or Russia want to try their hand at screwing around with the region for a while, so be it. We have no moral standing to object, as the most active military interventionist in the world. But we should wash our hands of it and let them face the consequences of their actions. Russia, in particular, is already an incredibly active target for terrorism, and they're positioning themselves for even worse by creating Middle-East chaos and anti-Russian hatred.


Meanwhile, someone wants us to get involved with Boko Haram:

Rep. Frederica Wilson, D-Fla., is demanding that the Obama Administration come up with a plan for dealing with Boko Haram, the terrorist group that killed thousands of people and disrupted tens of thousands more in Nigeria.


Wilson, a member of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), introduced legislation on Mon-day that would require the Departments of Defense and State to submit a five-year plan to Congress that would help Nigeria fight the Islamic extremist group.



http://thewestsidegazette.com/dems-demand-president-obama-strategy-on-boko-haram/

Oh goody. A new war to fight......
 
While there are some 18 wars going on right now in the world and a spark could ignite a world war I don't see the US or Russia using nukes on each other. Seems far fetched.
Agreed since it would be mutual suicide. OTOH, nuclear winter would cure the global warming issue. ;)

the-road.9031.jpg
 
Last edited:
Some people are just not capable of being ruled by anything but a dictator.
I think a public mindset that allows for pluralistic democracy takes a while to develop, and it happens in small steps. We tend to forget that because we think in terms of the quick improvement in Germany following WWII -- but that was a nation with centuries of pluralism and decades of democracy under its belt, which was merely recovering from a generation-long interlude of growing totalitarianism. There were still cultural institutions for democracy and many living people with plenty of practical experience with it. Cut out the Nazi cancer, and a thriving democracy could take hold pretty quickly there.

Think of it in gardening terms. If you have fertile soil, merely weeding a garden and planting seeds may be all you need for a good crop. But fertile soil doesn't develop overnight. It consists of a whole matrix of bacteria and organic matter that accumulates over many years. Some dirt may only be able to sustain the hardiest of weeds, and if you pluck up those weeds all you get is erosion that makes the dirt even worse, making it even less suitable for anything but weeds.

I think it's important not to imagine there's something racial or even something inherent to Islam that makes pluralistic democracy impossible. It can develop. It just can't do so on our timetable. We need baby steps. And we need to realize that sometimes ripping out weeds like Saddam Hussein is counter-productive, when they're the only thing holding in place the dirt that could some day develop into something more fertile.
 
Meanwhile, someone wants us to get involved with Boko Haram:

Rep. Frederica Wilson, D-Fla., is demanding that the Obama Administration come up with a plan for dealing with Boko Haram, the terrorist group that killed thousands of people and disrupted tens of thousands more in Nigeria.


Wilson, a member of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), introduced legislation on Mon-day that would require the Departments of Defense and State to submit a five-year plan to Congress that would help Nigeria fight the Islamic extremist group.



http://thewestsidegazette.com/dems-demand-president-obama-strategy-on-boko-haram/

Oh goody. A new war to fight......
I think the very fact she's looking to the DoD to help plan this shows she's barking up the wrong tree. A military intervention is likely just to backfire. We have to be subtler and less destructive in our approach if we want to empower the forces of anti-extremism to overcome groups like Boko Haram. If we instead just bomb the crap out of them (or finance and arm someone else to do so), we're likely to get something like Iraq, where we took out Hussein and got ISIS as our reward.
 
I think the very fact she's looking to the DoD to help plan this shows she's barking up the wrong tree. A military intervention is likely just to backfire. We have to be subtler and less destructive in our approach if we want to empower the forces of anti-extremism to overcome groups like Boko Haram. If we instead just bomb the crap out of them (or finance and arm someone else to do so), we're likely to get something like Iraq, where we took out Hussein and got ISIS as our reward.


Agreed. She either has not thought this through, or she has and wants more war anyway.

How proud her constituents must be.
 
Agreed. She either has not thought this through, or she has and wants more war anyway.

How proud her constituents must be.
I think hyper-militarism is the air we breathe in this country, which is why so many people of all political stripes reach for military solutions as a first recourse for any foreign policy problem. There's that old line about how when all you have is a hammer, everything starts to look like a nail. Well, I don't think the hammer of the military is all we have, but it is a particular big, shiny, expensive hammer, and a lot of people can't resist calling for it to be swung against anything that catches their eye.
 
I think a public mindset that allows for pluralistic democracy takes a while to develop, and it happens in small steps. We tend to forget that because we think in terms of the quick improvement in Germany following WWII -- but that was a nation with centuries of pluralism and decades of democracy under its belt, which was merely recovering from a generation-long interlude of growing totalitarianism. There were still cultural institutions for democracy and many living people with plenty of practical experience with it. Cut out the Nazi cancer, and a thriving democracy could take hold pretty quickly there.

Think of it in gardening terms. If you have fertile soil, merely weeding a garden and planting seeds may be all you need for a good crop. But fertile soil doesn't develop overnight. It consists of a whole matrix of bacteria and organic matter that accumulates over many years. Some dirt may only be able to sustain the hardiest of weeds, and if you pluck up those weeds all you get is erosion that makes the dirt even worse, making it even less suitable for anything but weeds.

I think it's important not to imagine there's something racial or even something inherent to Islam that makes pluralistic democracy impossible. It can develop. It just can't do so on our timetable. We need baby steps. And we need to realize that sometimes ripping out weeds like Saddam Hussein is counter-productive, when they're the only thing holding in place the dirt that could some day develop into something more fertile.

Interesting commentary
 
in related news, Russia this week tested a missile capable of destroying satellites (such as GPS, spy, and communication satellites) orbiting earth
Testing is one thing. It's primarily a deterrent. Using it would be another form of suicide.

The "cascade effect" shown in the movie "Gravity" could easily become a reality if nations started shattering each other's satellites. All of those geosynchronous satellites have a specific band they have to travel. If that band is littered with debris, it'd become unusable for hundreds, if not thousands, of years. It'd be akin to poisoning all water supplies just to deprive your enemy of water. Our modern world could not support 7+ billion people without technology. Kill off that technology and a lot of people will die from lack of support.
 
Testing is one thing. It's primarily a deterrent. Using it would be another form of suicide.

The "cascade effect" shown in the movie "Gravity" could easily become a reality if nations started shattering each other's satellites. All of those geosynchronous satellites have a specific band they have to travel. If that band is littered with debris, it'd become unusable for hundreds, if not thousands, of years. It'd be akin to poisoning all water supplies just to deprive your enemy of water. Our modern world could not support 7+ billion people without technology. Kill off that technology and a lot of people will die from lack of support.

Yes. As it is, we are going to have to develop satellites that can track down and collect orbiting debris----and that's even assuming there is no further development of these dangerous anti-satellite weapons.
 
Yes. As it is, we are going to have to develop satellites that can track down and collect orbiting debris----and that's even assuming there is no further development of these dangerous anti-satellite weapons.
Agreed, but that's a long way off and a lot of space to clean up. When even a paint chip can rip a hole through a suit or panel, metal shrapnel would be very hard to clean up. It might take something like nukes to vaporize entire sections of space. I don't know.

All I know is, if they used satellite killers, the satellite age would be over for our lifetime.
 
Back
Top