New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Nuclear War?

Thanks, but nothing in that link to suggest that these are being tested anywhere outside of low-Earth orbit; nothing about geosynchronous orbit....
Dude, scroll up; the tests are done in LOE to minimize debris.

In the event of war, note this paragraph in the link: "Analysts say the space threat to satellites highlights a strategic vulnerability. With as few as two dozen anti-satellite missiles, Russia or China could cripple U.S. intelligence, navigation, and communications capabilities that are critical for both military operations and civilian infrastructure."

If you worked for NASA, you should know this or at least be able to figure it out.
 
Einstein had a little help... mushroom clouds happen from explosions, doesn't have to be nuclear. Microscopic mushroom signature in 09/11 WTC dust gave away that explosives were used.

Eistrein was a plagiarist and a fraud. I still wonder about nukes ----
 
Dude, scroll up; the tests are done in LOE to minimize debris.

In the event of war, note this paragraph in the link: "Analysts say the space threat to satellites highlights a strategic vulnerability. With as few as two dozen anti-satellite missiles, Russia or China could cripple U.S. intelligence, navigation, and communications capabilities that are critical for both military operations and civilian infrastructure."

If you worked for NASA, you should know this or at least be able to figure it out.

If you were wanting to develop a satellite hunter/killer capable of taking out satellites in geosynchronous orbit, you would want to TEST it in geosynchronous orbit. Saying the tests are conducted in LEO to minimize debris does not make any sense to me. The VOLUME of space in LEO is much, MUCH less than the volume of space in geosynchronous orbit----that is just basic geometry. LEO orbit is more crowded than geosynchronous orbit!

As to your highlighted paragraph, there is utterly no doubt that this is a serious strategic vulnerability. I have heard it said: In the 19th century, sea power was paramount, and the British Navy controlled the seas, making the British Empire the superpower of the time; in the 20th century, air power was paramount, and the U.S. Air Force controlled the skies, making America the superpower of the time; while in the 21st century, the nation that controls near-Earth space (BOTH LEO and geosynchronous orbit) will be the superpower of the 21st century.

Let's hope that's US.
 
Of course it's dangerous.

But, other than carping, do you have anything to offer? What should we do instead of what we're doing?
Aren't you supposed to spout off about "Fear-mongering before an election"? And trying to scare the public into voting a certain way?

I mean, that's for sure what you'd be doing if Gabbard was a Republican.

I always enjoy a good dosage of liberal hypocrisy. Luckily, there's no end to it.
 
You're right; we're just so used to seeing a picture of the globe that way, with the equator in the middle. I've known some folks to actually get offended when you show them a map of the world, 'upside-down', with the South Pole at the top and the North Pole at the bottom....
upside down ball in space? how corny is that?

okay, professor, I got some why's...

Why do planets spin?
Why do stars spin?
Why doesn't the moon spin? (it isn't spinning)
Couldn't the earth just as easily be spinning on a million different axis than the one it is spinning on? Would if it spun on an axis perpendicular to the orbit it follows around the sun? Or is the spin of the planet determined by the gravitational radial? Or is the gravitational radial produced by the spin of the planet? (the gravitational radial produces the rings; our planet is too small to form rings, but Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune all have rings)

How many satellites are in Clark orbit? How many "slots" in that orbit does international law grant each nation? Is there a different bandwidth allotment that goes with those slots? Is the Clark orbit beyond the radiation belts? Has any of our satellites been shut down by a solar flare? Why not?

What city does Little Caesars Pizza hail from? Why can't someone build a pizza with Detroit crust and Chicago sauce?
 
Yes, and I listed the reason previously.

So why do you think the Russians and Chinese aren't actually shattering satellites in geosynchronous orbit?
Are we at war with China or Russia? Why should they be attacking satellites?
 
Why do planets spin?
Why do stars spin?
Why doesn't the moon spin? (it isn't spinning)
Couldn't the earth just as easily be spinning on a million different axis than the one it is spinning on? Would if it spun on an axis perpendicular to the orbit it follows around the sun? Or is the spin of the planet determined by the gravitational radial? Or is the gravitational radial produced by the spin of the planet? (the gravitational radial produces the rings; our planet is too small to form rings, but Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune all have rings)

Hi, Days. I can answer SOME of these questions. Though not the one about Little Caesar's pizza (which I've never liked, anyhow).

We believe planetary systems form from the gravitational collapse of gas clouds. Most of these clouds would be rotating slightly to begin with, but as they collapse, the conservation of angular momentum causes the rotation to speed up. Think of an ice skater pulling his or her arms in towards them as they are spinning; they will start to spin faster! So as both the central star and the planets form, they will all be rotating. The Hubble Space Telescope has taken some mighty fine pictures of 'stellar nurseries' where this whole process appears to be playing out.

By the way, the planet Uranus DOES spin on an axis almost perpendicular to the orbit it is following around the Sun. We don't know for sure why this is, but the presumption is that something rather BIG must have smashed into the planet very early in its history, to 'knock it on its side'. By the same token, the now-consensus theory of the Moon's origin is that a Mars-sized body crashed into the early Earth, and much or most of the material thrown up by the collision eventually coalesced into the Moon. There is much evidence that supports this theory. The Mars-sized body that presumably did this has even been given a name: Theia.

Originally, the Moon was much closer to the Earth. Both the Earth and the Moon would have been spinning much more rapidly at that time. The tidal forces between the Earth and the Moon would have been MUCH larger than today. We can see evidence of this in the geological record, by the way. Those tidal forces slow down the rotation of BOTH the Earth and the Moon. At one point, the day on Earth was only some ten hours long. As I'm sure you know, it is still slowing today, with the day getting longer, albeit at a very slow rate. The Moon long ago became tidally locked to the Earth, in what we call synchronous rotation, which is why (of course) we only see one side of the Moon.

What is happening now is a very slow transfer of the rotational energy of the Earth to the orbital energy of the Moon. This is why the Moon is slowly being pushed AWAY from the Earth. You may have heard of that, too. It does run contrary to how most people imagine 'gravity' works, but that is because they don't really understand TIDAL forces.

If we had billions of years for this to play out, eventually the Earth would become tidally locked to the Moon, and anyone living on the Moon would only see one side of the Earth. At THAT point, the Moon would slowly start being dragged back TOWARDS the Earth. This will not happen, though, because before that would take place, the Sun will turn into a red giant, putting a premature end to both the Earth and the Moon.
 
Hi, Days. I can answer SOME of these questions. Though not the one about Little Caesar's pizza (which I've never liked, anyhow).

We believe planetary systems form from the gravitational collapse of gas clouds. Most of these clouds would be rotating slightly to begin with, but as they collapse, the conservation of angular momentum causes the rotation to speed up. Think of an ice skater pulling his or her arms in towards them as they are spinning; they will start to spin faster! So as both the central star and the planets form, they will all be rotating. The Hubble Space Telescope has taken some mighty fine pictures of 'stellar nurseries' where this whole process appears to be playing out.

By the way, the planet Uranus DOES spin on an axis almost perpendicular to the orbit it is following around the Sun. We don't know for sure why this is, but the presumption is that something rather BIG must have smashed into the planet very early in its history, to 'knock it on its side'. By the same token, the now-consensus theory of the Moon's origin is that a Mars-sized body crashed into the early Earth, and much or most of the material thrown up by the collision eventually coalesced into the Moon. There is much evidence that supports this theory. The Mars-sized body that presumably did this has even been given a name: Theia.

Originally, the Moon was much closer to the Earth. Both the Earth and the Moon would have been spinning much more rapidly at that time. The tidal forces between the Earth and the Moon would have been MUCH larger than today. We can see evidence of this in the geological record, by the way. Those tidal forces slow down the rotation of BOTH the Earth and the Moon. At one point, the day on Earth was only some ten hours long. As I'm sure you know, it is still slowing today, with the day getting longer, albeit at a very slow rate. The Moon long ago became tidally locked to the Earth, in what we call synchronous rotation, which is why (of course) we only see one side of the Moon.

What is happening now is a very slow transfer of the rotational energy of the Earth to the orbital energy of the Moon. This is why the Moon is slowly being pushed AWAY from the Earth. You may have heard of that, too. It does run contrary to how most people imagine 'gravity' works, but that is because they don't really understand TIDAL forces.

If we had billions of years for this to play out, eventually the Earth would become tidally locked to the Moon, and anyone living on the Moon would only see one side of the Earth. At THAT point, the Moon would slowly start being dragged back TOWARDS the Earth. This will not happen, though, because before that would take place, the Sun will turn into a red giant, putting a premature end to both the Earth and the Moon.

I like Little Caesars crust, but they need to steal Rosatti's sauce.

This whole idea of what produces spin is still in the gaseous state, the theory hasn't solidified to my way of thinking. You do know that one of Jupiter's moons is spinning the opposite direction of all the other moons and Jupiter? Try reversing the spin of a moon with a collision... not so easy. Likewise, smacking a planet with an asteroid shouldn't change the axis the planet spins on, maybe produce one doozey of a wobble; but that's not the same thing. If space is infinite, are we really traveling through space? Or just spinning in space? What are we coming into contact with? In the olden days, the planets would be pushing through the ether of space, but today, it is all electromagnetic drag; the solar wind and the stellar winds. So it is an electric universe, and the magnetic winds are every whit a magnetic field we travel through. So the earth is like the armature in a very weak dynamo, but over enough time, and given that we are in free suspension, our journey through the solar winds is going to rotate the earth, it certainly is going to act upon our magnetic field. How about all those ions impacting our magnetosphere with each solar flare? That is going to push on our magnetic field. Are we sure gravity is a different force from our magnetic force? That's still not understood.

Not discounting the spinning gas collapsing into spinning stars theory, I just don't think it works as well for planets.
 
I like Little Caesars crust, but they need to steal Rosatti's sauce.

This whole idea of what produces spin is still in the gaseous state, the theory hasn't solidified to my way of thinking. You do know that one of Jupiter's moons is spinning the opposite direction of all the other moons and Jupiter? Try reversing the spin of a moon with a collision... not so easy. Likewise, smacking a planet with an asteroid shouldn't change the axis the planet spins on, maybe produce one doozey of a wobble; but that's not the same thing. If space is infinite, are we really traveling through space? Or just spinning in space? What are we coming into contact with? In the olden days, the planets would be pushing through the ether of space, but today, it is all electromagnetic drag; the solar wind and the stellar winds. So it is an electric universe, and the magnetic winds are every whit a magnetic field we travel through. So the earth is like the armature in a very weak dynamo, but over enough time, and given that we are in free suspension, our journey through the solar winds is going to rotate the earth, it certainly is going to act upon our magnetic field. How about all those ions impacting our magnetosphere with each solar flare? That is going to push on our magnetic field. Are we sure gravity is a different force from our magnetic force? That's still not understood.

Not discounting the spinning gas collapsing into spinning stars theory, I just don't think it works as well for planets.

Yes, a FEW of Jupiter's and Saturn's moons are in what we call retrograde motion. Orbiting their primary in the 'wrong' direction. But these are tiny moons orbiting Jupiter and Saturn rather far out. We don't believe this is the result of any collisions, though; we believe these are captured asteroids, rocky bodies that simply got too close to Jupiter or Saturn and were captured gravitationally. And since an asteroid could approach one of these planets from almost any direction, random chance would dictate that at least some would end up orbiting in retrograde motion. But here is a MUCH more impressive example of retrograde motion: Neptune's GIANT moon, Triton, is in retrograde motion! And it is rather close to Neptune. In fact, we believe that eventually Triton will get sucked in close enough to Neptune to be ripped apart. Then Neptune will REALLY have some impressive rings.

We don't know, but it is possible that the entire Universe is rotating. How could we tell? Not easily at all! Not only that, but we don't even know if the Universe is convex. A convex polygon means that any line segment drawn between any two points inside the polygon will be completely inside the polygon. If you have a non-convex polygon, such a line segment might lie partly outside the polygon. For all we know, the Universe could be non-convex. Mind-bending stuff, to be sure. And there's a growing belief, based on some quirks we've discovered in the cosmic microwave background radiation, that our Universe may have 'bumped into' another Universe, at some point in the past.....

Magnetic forces are probably far more important in our Universe than most physicists and astronomers have realized in the past. And gravity? Gravity is the least understood force in the Universe. It is the central mystery in physics. Or I should say one of them, because we don't understand dark matter or dark energy, either. Possibly all these things are connected. We need another Einstein to help us figure it all out.....
 
Back
Top