New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Nuclear War?

You mentioned testing not war in geosynchronous orbit. If you want to act like Days and Titania, fine. Talk to them.
Well, excuuuuse me, but you mentioned destroying our satellites, so I responded to your post, not his.

But, since you drag me into this, geosynchronous orbit is 22,000 miles out, while LEO for satellites is basically 700 miles out. so, how does testing in LEO tell you anything relevant about whether it will work in Clark orbit?
 
Likewise, smacking a planet with an asteroid shouldn't change the axis the planet spins on, maybe produce one doozey of a wobble

Yes, but we are thinking that what smashed into Uranus was not just some asteroid, but a planet sized body almost as large as the proto-Uranus. Think of something almost as large as Mars hitting the Earth at a glancing blow. That's what we think happened to Earth; if Theia had hit Earth dead-on, it probably would have destroyed the planet, and we wouldn't be here talking about it!

There is also the interesting idea that the Earth NEEDS the Moon to be habitable. That without the Moon, the Earth's wobble on its axis would be much more extreme, and the seasons would be WILD. I'm still not totally convinced about that, but think it wise to maintain an open mind.....
 
Well, excuuuuse me, but you mentioned destroying our satellites, so I responded to your post, not his.

But, since you drag me into this, geosynchronous orbit is 22,000 miles out, while LEO for satellites is basically 700 miles out. so, how does testing in LEO tell you anything relevant about whether it will work in Clark orbit?

That was my question, too, Days. It seems almost like testing a robotic rover on the Moon, and saying "Yup, it will work on Pluto, too!"
 
Yes, a FEW of Jupiter's and Saturn's moons are in what we call retrograde motion. Orbiting their primary in the 'wrong' direction. But these are tiny moons orbiting Jupiter and Saturn rather far out. We don't believe this is the result of any collisions, though; we believe these are captured asteroids, rocky bodies that simply got too close to Jupiter or Saturn and were captured gravitationally. And since an asteroid could approach one of these planets from almost any direction, random chance would dictate that at least some would end up orbiting in retrograde motion. But here is a MUCH more impressive example of retrograde motion: Neptune's GIANT moon, Triton, is in retrograde motion! And it is rather close to Neptune. In fact, we believe that eventually Triton will get sucked in close enough to Neptune to be ripped apart. Then Neptune will REALLY have some impressive rings.

We don't know, but it is possible that the entire Universe is rotating. How could we tell? Not easily at all! Not only that, but we don't even know if the Universe is convex. A convex polygon means that any line segment drawn between any two points inside the polygon will be completely inside the polygon. If you have a non-convex polygon, such a line segment might lie partly outside the polygon. For all we know, the Universe could be non-convex. Mind-bending stuff, to be sure. And there's a growing belief, based on some quirks we've discovered in the cosmic microwave background radiation, that our Universe may have 'bumped into' another Universe, at some point in the past.....

Magnetic forces are probably far more important in our Universe than most physicists and astronomers have realized in the past. And gravity? Gravity is the least understood force in the Universe. It is the central mystery in physics. Or I should say one of them, because we don't understand dark matter or dark energy, either. Possibly all these things are connected. We need another Einstein to help us figure it all out.....
theories of cosmology can get so far out... fairy tales become more relevant. Why would we worry about whether the universe is convex when we can't even grasp our galaxy? And certainly the galactic system is acting upon our sun, so it is relevant, but the universe?

I have this crazy idea that when a body falls into orbit with another body, the system of the two bodies in interplay brings about a dynamic of forces that is now shaping the behavior of both bodies. Kind of like living in society versus living alone in the wilderness... society becomes your life.

I'm not sure how planets are formed... some of them might be burned out stars, but certainly not all of them or even most of them. Looking at our own solar system, I doubt if any of the planets were ever stars, they are just too small. Conversely, planets seem to be so nice and round, while asteroids and comets tend to be chunks of rock, and this makes me think that being in orbit around a sun that is in orbit (?) around the galaxy... somehow all these forces are acting upon us.

I would dearly love to know if the galaxy has a black hole or just this mother star (that still emits light!) ... and if there really is a gravitational radial coming from a black hole that creates this pinwheel system of stars rotating around the center. And what about those rogue, wild and crazy planets? The ones that fly around the galaxy with no star attachment? Are they spinning?
 
Last edited:
Yes, but we are thinking that what smashed into Uranus was not just some asteroid, but a planet sized body almost as large as the proto-Uranus. Think of something almost as large as Mars hitting the Earth at a glancing blow. That's what we think happened to Earth; if Theia had hit Earth dead-on, it probably would have destroyed the planet, and we wouldn't be here talking about it!

There is also the interesting idea that the Earth NEEDS the Moon to be habitable. That without the Moon, the Earth's wobble on its axis would be much more extreme, and the seasons would be WILD. I'm still not totally convinced about that, but think it wise to maintain an open mind.....
Sumerian tablets tell us that earth was hit by a planet and it created our moon and I think another collision with Mars created the asteroid belt? Something nasty happened in our neck of the woods, that asteroid belt is a monster.

The moon is not spinning, it is gravitational lopsided, with the strong side constantly facing us. There's no doubt in my mind that the earth without the moon would be a dead planet, we live on the product of the two at interplay. It is symbiotic.

Neptune needs Triton... isn't that the ice moon?

Jupiter needs Tatiana... we need Tatiana, everyone needs Tatiana!

I see the bigger planets as systems that include their moons, just as I see the star as a solar system traveling around the galaxy. What I'd like to understand better is the galactic system.
 
Well, excuuuuse me, but you mentioned destroying our satellites, so I responded to your post, not his.

But, since you drag me into this, geosynchronous orbit is 22,000 miles out, while LEO for satellites is basically 700 miles out. so, how does testing in LEO tell you anything relevant about whether it will work in Clark orbit?
Because F = MA regardless of altitude or distance from the Earth. The tech is being able to "hit a bullet with another bullet". If it can be done in LEO, it can be done at any orbital distance.
 
Because F = MA regardless of altitude or distance from the Earth. The tech is being able to "hit a bullet with another bullet". If it can be done in LEO, it can be done at any orbital distance.
yeah, okay, but would if the bullet is being acted upon by x amount of gravity at 700 miles out and y amount of gravity at 22,000 miles out? And would if the target is moving 17,500 miles per hour relative to the earth at 700 miles out, while the target is stationary relative to the earth at 22,000 miles out?

Besides, doesn't it take a tad more fuel to fly the extra 21,000 miles? Isn't that a slightly different trajectory?

Couldn't be more different, Max.
 
yeah, okay, but would if the bullet is being acted upon by x amount of gravity at 700 miles out and y amount of gravity at 22,000 miles out? And would if the target is moving 17,500 miles per hour relative to the earth at 700 miles out, while the target is stationary relative to the earth at 22,000 miles out?

Besides, doesn't it take a tad more fuel to fly the extra 21,000 miles? Isn't that a slightly different trajectory?

Couldn't be more different, Max.
Ask our NASA expert. Even the Euro's managed to "hit a moving bullet" in the form of a comet.

http://www.space.com/31129-philae-comet-landing-rosetta-video.html

Yes, more fuel. What's your point? Do you really think they need to actually test the anti-sat weapon in geosynchronous orbit to make sure it works? @LeRoy_Was_Here comment?
 
Ask our NASA expert. Even the Euro's managed to "hit a moving bullet" in the form of a comet.

http://www.space.com/31129-philae-comet-landing-rosetta-video.html

Yes, more fuel. What's your point? Do you really think they need to actually test the anti-sat weapon in geosynchronous orbit to make sure it works? @LeRoy_Was_Here comment?
Only if they hope to hit a target in that orbit; isn't that the whole idea behind "testing"?

I wonder if we have lasers capable of destroying a missile flying into outer space? That would seem like a very real capability for our lasers. That might make the whole exercise moot... Like testing to see if you can steal the pink panther with the security system off.
 
Back
Top