New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obamacare was single payer

In effect Obamacare was a single payer program. Effectively everybody was compelled to be insured, everybody was to have a minimum prescribed coverage plan, and complete regulation including personal data transfer to the federal government paints the picture

So what if you pay $500 a month or the government taxes you and pays $500 a month for you. Obamacare WAS/IS single payer. The left lies and lies. Their slippery slope and hypocrisy never ends.

STEVE INSKEEP FROM NPR IS ON CNN TOE'ING A PARTY LINE. GUESS WHICH ONE.

NPR HAS TO GO.
 
Last edited:
In effect Obamacare was a single payer program. Effectively everybody was compelled to be insured, everybody was to have a minimum prescribed coverage plan, and complete regulation including personal data transfer to the federal government paints the picture

So what if you pay $500 a month or the government taxes you and pays $500 a month for you. Obamacare WAS/IS single payer. The left lies and lies. Their slippery slope and hypocrisy never ends.

STEVE INSKEEP FROM NPR IS ON CNN TOE'ING A PARTY LINE. GUESS WHICH ONE.

NPR HAS TO GO.
There is still a wide variety of insurance companies that are still competing against one another. They still benefit from providing the best service at the lowest cost.
 
There is still a wide variety of insurance companies that are still competing against one another. They still benefit from providing the best service at the lowest cost.
Semantics at best.

Obamacare was and is single payer in all but name and finalizing evolution. The GOP refuses to kill it and instead is trying to take credit for it. They are insipid power hungry parasites those in the governing class. We need to make them more irrelevant. We need computer voting by the people for the people on the House floor. We need more democracy in the republic.
 
Semantics at best.

Obamacare was and is single payer in all but name and finalizing evolution. The GOP refuses to kill it and instead is trying to take credit for it. They are insipid power hungry parasites those in the governing class. We need to make them more irrelevant. We need computer voting by the people for the people on the House floor. We need more democracy in the republic.
"More democracy in the republic"- You are sounding like some of my left-wing compatriots and I circa December 2016, talking about how stupid the electoral college is.
Democracy isn't the problem with healthcare. There isn't really anything government can do at this point about the cost short of price controls which are not effective.
There is a morality issue involved... which is where the government is involved. Who gets healthcare vs who doesn't its an extension who we let live and die debate. Some people think only think rich people should get it, others(including myself) think it should be more inclusive. Of course there are the practicalities of figuring out how to make healthcare more inclusive, like who pays and how much. Obamacare is best way to address it at this point, until some one comes up with something better.
 
In effect Obamacare was a single payer program. Effectively everybody was compelled to be insured, everybody was to have a minimum prescribed coverage plan, and complete regulation including personal data transfer to the federal government paints the picture

So what if you pay $500 a month or the government taxes you and pays $500 a month for you. Obamacare WAS/IS single payer. The left lies and lies. Their slippery slope and hypocrisy never ends.

STEVE INSKEEP FROM NPR IS ON CNN TOE'ING A PARTY LINE. GUESS WHICH ONE.

NPR HAS TO GO.
You misunderstand what single-payer means. A single payer system is a system under which the majority of basic care is paid for by the central government. Canada has a single-payer system. The US also has a single-payer system when it comes to military personnel and the elderly. Under Obamacare, though, the majority of basic care for the nation as a whole is paid for by multiple payers -- individual companies, employees, states and local governments, etc. Obamacare also preserved the for-profit health insurer construct, where the majority of the actual medical bills are paid for by a large number of health insurance companies.

I'm not married to the idea of single-payer, like some liberals. I'd be satisfied with something along the lines of a German or Swiss-style system, which isn't single payer but at least cuts for-profit insurers out of the business of covering basic care.
 
You misunderstand what single-payer means. A single payer system is a system under which the majority of basic care is paid for by the central government. Canada has a single-payer system. The US also has a single-payer system when it comes to military personnel and the elderly. Under Obamacare, though, the majority of basic care for the nation as a whole is paid for by multiple payers -- individual companies, employees, states and local governments, etc. Obamacare also preserved the for-profit health insurer construct, where the majority of the actual medical bills are paid for by a large number of health insurance companies.

I'm not married to the idea of single-payer, like some liberals. I'd be satisfied with something along the lines of a German or Swiss-style system, which isn't single payer but at least cuts for-profit insurers out of the business of covering basic care.

Nope. I clearly understand what is means. You need to understand. Obamacare is effectively single payer because it starts as 80% of the definition of single payer and the natural slippery slope of it is single payer.

The left are congenital liars and hypocrites.

The internet is killing the lie. And the lie here is that the left has any good people left in it.
 
"More democracy in the republic"- You are sounding like some of my left-wing compatriots and I circa December 2016, talking about how stupid the electoral college is.
Democracy isn't the problem with healthcare. There isn't really anything government can do at this point about the cost short of price controls which are not effective.
There is a morality issue involved... which is where the government is involved. Who gets healthcare vs who doesn't its an extension who we let live and die debate. Some people think only think rich people should get it, others(including myself) think it should be more inclusive. Of course there are the practicalities of figuring out how to make healthcare more inclusive, like who pays and how much. Obamacare is best way to address it at this point, until some one comes up with something better.

No, I don't sound like you at all because the electoral college is the part of the republic that is absolutely fine and in fact is saving the country from splitting apart.

This is a crowd of people who democratically chose to perform this barbaric act.

All these Democrats by their presence alone voted to lynch these people. The lynch mob is the ultimate expression of democracy gone wrong in the many ways it can go wrong. I will live in a republic thank you very much :0)

Black-lynching.png
 
You misunderstand what single-payer means. A single payer system is a system under which the majority of basic care is paid for by the central government. Canada has a single-payer system. The US also has a single-payer system when it comes to military personnel and the elderly. Under Obamacare, though, the majority of basic care for the nation as a whole is paid for by multiple payers -- individual companies, employees, states and local governments, etc. Obamacare also preserved the for-profit health insurer construct, where the majority of the actual medical bills are paid for by a large number of health insurance companies.

I'm not married to the idea of single-payer, like some liberals. I'd be satisfied with something along the lines of a German or Swiss-style system, which isn't single payer but at least cuts for-profit insurers out of the business of covering basic care.
I don't think many people how considered the practicalities of moving to a single payer. Just crossing out the over 65 line in Medicare doesn't the fate of the insurance companies who already possess the infrastructure to insure every American.
I would like to see the government play the role of a private equity firm. I would like the government to buy up all the major insurers, they can realize synergies and cut down on costs, that way. the other cost saver would come from the leverage a single-payer would have over doctor and hospital groups when they negotiate reimbursement rates contracts. A single-payer would essentially control every paying customer that doctor/hospitals/pharmacies have. They could really play hardball and drive down the actual healthcare costs. Once the mega-mega-merger was complete then the government could IPO the giant insurance company recoup their original costs for buying up the insurance company. In private hands the insurer would still have the profit incentive which the motivation to minimize the overhead and wasteful spending.
 
Nope. I clearly understand what is means. You need to understand. Obamacare is effectively single payer because it starts as 80% of the definition of single payer and the natural slippery slope of it is single payer.

Obamacare doesn't lead inevitably to single-payer. The exchanges are already stable in most states, and shoring them up in the remainder would only require tweaks (e.g., raising the penalty for not being insured, and raising the subsidy to get insurance).

I'd argue that if there is a "slippery slope" from Obamacare, it leads not to Single Payer but to something more like the German or Swiss system (based around private non-profit insurers). Moving to single payer from Obamacare would require a full-scale overhaul, nearly as big as moving from the pre-Obamcare system to single payer. It's not somewhere you'd arrive at incrementally over time. By comparison, arriving at something like the German system, from Obamacare, by small incremental steps could happen. Basically, regulators would just gradually tinker with the cost controls in a way that forced private insurers to dedicate more of their premiums to paying for healthcare and less for advertising, executive compensation, and dividends. Gradually, those private insurers would become something a bit like traditional utilities in the US -- which are still private corporations with shareholders, etc., but which are very strictly regulated in the public interest, including the government dictating rates and limiting to an allowable rate of return, with compensation directly linked to customer satisfaction. US energy utilities look a lot like German health insurers, in the big picture, and that's where I could see Obamacare ending up in 10 or 20 years if there were a commitment to improving it, rather than trying to make it fail.
 
No, I don't sound like you at all because the electoral college is the part of the republic that is absolutely fine and in fact is saving the country from splitting apart.

This is a crowd of people who democratically chose to perform this barbaric act.

All these Democrats by their presence alone voted to lynch these people. The lynch mob is the ultimate expression of democracy gone wrong in the many ways it can go wrong. I will live in a republic thank you very much :0)

Black-lynching.png
The electoral college is part of the republic... you mean like elected representatives voting on the house floor?
 
In effect Obamacare was a single payer program. Effectively everybody was compelled to be insured, everybody was to have a minimum prescribed coverage plan, and complete regulation including personal data transfer to the federal government paints the picture

So what if you pay $500 a month or the government taxes you and pays $500 a month for you. Obamacare WAS/IS single payer. The left lies and lies. Their slippery slope and hypocrisy never ends.

STEVE INSKEEP FROM NPR IS ON CNN TOE'ING A PARTY LINE. GUESS WHICH ONE.

NPR HAS TO GO.

In Wingerworld, having millions of payers is "single payer."

;-)
 
No, I don't sound like you at all because the electoral college is the part of the republic that is absolutely fine and in fact is saving the country from splitting apart.

This is a crowd of people who democratically chose to perform this barbaric act.

All these Democrats by their presence alone voted to lynch these people. The lynch mob is the ultimate expression of democracy gone wrong in the many ways it can go wrong. I will live in a republic thank you very much :0)

Black-lynching.png
There's a tendency, on the right, to want to associate past atrocities like that with today's Democrats, on the basis of how the parties were aligned at the time. But back when lynchings were commonplace, the demographics of the parties were largely the opposite of today. The Democratic party was the part of the South, rural people, whites, advocates of small government and traditional family values, nativism, and states rights. The GOP was party of the big cities, ethnic minorities, academics, proponents of an activist and centralized government, the North, immigrants, etc.

For example, that picture was famously taken in Grant County, Indiana. Then, as now, it was a disproportionately white and rural county. Back in prior eras, those kinds of people might have thought of themselves as Democrats, but today they're Republicans. Specifically, Trump got two and a half votes for every vote Clinton got there.
 
There's a tendency, on the right, to want to associate past atrocities like that with today's Democrats, on the basis of how the parties were aligned at the time. But back when lynchings were commonplace, the demographics of the parties were largely the opposite of today. The Democratic party was the part of the South, rural people, whites, advocates of small government and traditional family values, nativism, and states rights. The GOP was party of the big cities, ethnic minorities, academics, proponents of an activist and centralized government, the North, immigrants, etc.

For example, that picture was famously taken in Grant County, Indiana. Then, as now, it was a disproportionately white and rural county. Back in prior eras, those kinds of people might have thought of themselves as Democrats, but today they're Republicans. Specifically, Trump got two and a half votes for every vote Clinton got there.

You concentrate on a throw away line word and miss the critique on pure democracy. It was an intelligence question and you didn't to do well. You get some credit for showing your work. :0)
 
The electoral college is part of the republic... you mean like elected representatives voting on the house floor?

Yes, you and I would go online and vote for the legislation the House prepared. You could vote on the law, proxy your vote to your representative, or abstain your vote. Then if the law passed it would go onto the Senate to vote on and then the President to sign. See how lovely that would be? It would be peaches and cream.
 
You concentrate on a throw away line word and miss the critique on pure democracy. It was an intelligence question and you didn't to do well. You get some credit for showing your work. :0)
The "throw away word" is part of an ongoing propaganda effort beloved by the conservatives, so it's worth taking issue with.

As for the electoral college, I'm not a fan of it, and never have been. However, to the extent it has ANY purpose (above what you'd get by assigning those state electors automatically by who won the state), they're meant to provide a kind of last-line-of-defense.... to make sure that some dangerous and unqualified populist ideologue doesn't take power in this country. Clearly they failed utterly in that. In fact, the electors chose to reject the will of the American people in order to elect a dangerous and unqualified populist ideologue.
 
The "throw away word" is part of an ongoing propaganda effort beloved by the conservatives, so it's worth taking issue with.

As for the electoral college, I'm not a fan of it, and never have been. However, to the extent it has ANY purpose (above what you'd get by assigning those state electors automatically by who won the state), they're meant to provide a kind of last-line-of-defense.... to make sure that some dangerous and unqualified populist ideologue doesn't take power in this country. Clearly they failed utterly in that. In fact, the electors chose to reject the will of the American people in order to elect a dangerous and unqualified populist ideologue.
https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/obamacare-was-single-payer.103456/#post-1910572
 
There's a tendency, on the right, to want to associate past atrocities like that with today's Democrats, on the basis of how the parties were aligned at the time. But back when lynchings were commonplace, the demographics of the parties were largely the opposite of today. The Democratic party was the part of the South, rural people, whites, advocates of small government and traditional family values, nativism, and states rights. The GOP was party of the big cities, ethnic minorities, academics, proponents of an activist and centralized government, the North, immigrants, etc.

For example, that picture was famously taken in Grant County, Indiana. Then, as now, it was a disproportionately white and rural county. Back in prior eras, those kinds of people might have thought of themselves as Democrats, but today they're Republicans. Specifically, Trump got two and a half votes for every vote Clinton got there.
Teddy Roosevelt is probably my favorite president, A Republican, but back then the Republicans were the original progressives. Teddy was anti-big business (he earned his reputation as a trust-buster). He was probably the biggest environmentalist to ever hold the office of the presidency, and countless regulatory agencies formed during his administration. Alas, 2017 and not 1905, and Republicans are not who they were 100 or 50 or 20 or even 5 years ago.
 
In effect Obamacare was a single payer program. Effectively everybody was compelled to be insured, everybody was to have a minimum prescribed coverage plan, and complete regulation including personal data transfer to the federal government paints the picture

So what if you pay $500 a month or the government taxes you and pays $500 a month for you. Obamacare WAS/IS single payer. The left lies and lies. Their slippery slope and hypocrisy never ends.

STEVE INSKEEP FROM NPR IS ON CNN TOE'ING A PARTY LINE. GUESS WHICH ONE.

NPR HAS TO GO.
fowler.png

"Former WellPoint VP Elizabeth Fowler sits behind her boss, Sen. Max Baucus, as he announces in 2009 that the health care bill will have no public option."

The public option would have been closer to single payer.

Obamacare was a corporate, for-profit endeavor created by a former vice president of a major insurance company.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/dec/05/obamacare-fowler-lobbyist-industry1
 
fowler.png

"Former WellPoint VP Elizabeth Fowler sits behind her boss, Sen. Max Baucus, as he announces in 2009 that the health care bill will have no public option."

The public option would have been closer to single payer.

Obamacare was a corporate, for-profit endeavor created by a former vice president of a major insurance company.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/dec/05/obamacare-fowler-lobbyist-industry1

Listen...

I'm forced to buy something and that something is very highly regulated and all my medical data is to be transmitted to the Federal government.

There is no difference than with the UK's NHS in coverage except I pay directly for that coverage $500/mo. The government could tax me $500/mo and buy my coverage for me making it fully single payer. The effect is the absolute same.

The elements are that say the bronze plan is the same for everybody from any provider and those providers are only allowed to take 15% of the premium for costs and profit. The farce is the illusion of shopping. My premium payment might as well be a tax payment. How do I know? Because John Roberts said it was. ha ha ha ha

You lefties forget everything.
 
There is no difference than with the UK's NHS in coverage except I pay directly for that coverage $500/mo. The government could tax me $500/mo and buy my coverage for me making it fully single payer. The effect is the absolute same.
Except the government wouldn't tax you the full $500 a month; it would be closer to $250 a month. With a for-profit insurance medical care system, you will always be over-charged. That how capitalism works.;)
 
Back
Top